If you're looking for breakfast on Sanibel, Lighthouse Cafe absolutely deserves a visit. We love breakfast, and after trying so many places over the years, it can start to feel like every menu offers the same dishes prepared the same way. Lighthouse Cafe managed to make a classic breakfast memorable. We ordered the French toast, and the portion was huge and easy to split. More importantly, it was absolutely delicious. The eggs we ordered were cooked exactly as needed, the bacon was perfectly crisp, and the cheese grits were rich, creamy, and full of flavor. We literally cleaned our plates and ate every bite despite our intentions to simple stop by for a taste. One of the biggest surprises was adding fish to breakfast. It's not something I would have ever thought to eat for breakfast, but it ended up being one of the highlights of the meal. The fish was incredibly tender and paired surprisingly well with the rest of the meal. It was such a unique addition that it changed the way I think about breakfast. We intentionally ordered some standard breakfast items because we believe that's the best way to judge a breakfast restaurant. If a place can make the classics exceptionally well, that's usually a great sign. Lighthouse Cafe exceeded our expectations across the board with their delicious plates and service. Not to mention it is nice to visit a locally owned restaurant whose owner is present and working alongside their staff. From the quality of the food to the generous portions, everything was excellent. If you're on Sanibel and want a breakfast that goes beyond the ordinary while still nailing all the classics, Lighthouse Cafe is a great place to visit. read more

See all

This establishment is definitely one of the better places on the island for a great breakfast. Dailey specials like crab cake & spinach Benedict, stuffed French toast along with typical American breakfast offerings are available. The owner, Dan greets each and everyone that walks in the door. The coffee is robust and they are quick to refill your cup. Definitely a place where you feel welcome and the service is great. read more

Lighthouse Cafe - Interior dining room area - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Sanibel, Florida

This was certainly a great place to stop for a meal. We arrived late morning between breakfast and lunch. We were able to order pretty much anything. I elected to have the sausage and Swiss omelette. It certainly did not disappoint. The food was delicious and delivered in a timely fashion. Plenty of ingredients. Service was very good. Server was friendly and personal. They had seating outside. It was beginning to warm up but it was still comfortable, besides a Minnesota resident visiting Florida in the winter will most definitely select outside seats. Place was pretty cool on the inside with tons of photos of lighthouses. A bit noisy with all the island traffic passing out front but you got to see everyone entering and leaving the island. On the must visit list. Almost forgot to mention. The potatoes are the best followed by the homemade strawberry jam. read more

Lighthouse Cafe - Sausage and Swiss omelette w/homemade strawberry jam - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Sanibel, Florida

World's best breakfast......to me it definitely is not lol. It's not bad though and I'd eat there again. Ate biscuit and gravy, wasn't that good. U can tell it's homemade tho and that's a plus. I wouldn't order it again and I'm a B&G girl. French toast was ok ‍. Potatoes were good but I think got the end of the bag lol. Service was good except they take for ever to give u the bill. And that was for everyone. read more

See all

We sat at the bar. It was busy but we were served right away. Good service. Our food.... not great. I ordered the French toast. It was dry!! The egg mixture didn't soak through. The edges and lots of the bread were dry. Thank gosh for butter and syrup. This was a special "vacation treat" for me and it was disappointing. I cut around the edges and ate the center. The bacon was good. My husband ordered waffles. They too were dry too! Overcooked. He ate half. His eggs and sausage were good. Maybe stick to the savory breakfast options read more

Lighthouse Cafe - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Sanibel, Florida

Best breakfast on the island, and they really do mean it!! The breakfast tacos were delicious, honestly some of the best I've ever had. The biscuits and gravy were great too, with a nice homemade gravy that really stood out. I also had the cranberry raisin waffle, which was a daily special. They offer rotating specials, and both of our entrées happened to be on the special menu! The coffee and juices were fresh, the service was warm and friendly, and the atmosphere felt cozy and homey. I would definitely come back!! read more

See all

Great spot for breakfast. Busy popular spot so be prepared for a wait Good food split the oceans frittata. The toast with strawberry jam .. mmmmmm good! Good service read more

Lighthouse Cafe - Frittata - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Sanibel, Florida

Food is always good and fresh, service was excelent and the place is very comfortable for big family read more

Lighthouse Cafe - Art wall - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Sanibel, Florida

We had a wonderful breakfast at Lighthouse Cafe while visiting Sanibel and it absolutely lived up to the hype. We ordered the Lighthouse Breakfast with scrambled eggs, crispy bacon, and their famous house potatoes and they really are as good as everyone says. Perfectly seasoned and cooked just right. The toast came with a homemade strawberry preserve that was incredibly fresh and flavorful, a standout touch that made the meal feel extra special. We also tried the biscuits and gravy, which were warm, comforting, and good. Everything arrived very quickly, and the staff was friendly and welcoming, making the whole experience even better. On top of great food and service, the Sanibel location and coastal atmosphere made this a perfect breakfast spot. If you're in the area, Lighthouse Cafe is a must-stop for a satisfying, classic breakfast done right. read more

amazing experience having dinner at Lighthouse Cafe's new location. The shrimp risotto and the salmon gnocchi were delicious. The ambience is really nice and it would be a great place for a cozy dinner. So happy they are serving dinner now. They change the specials and the desserts so be sure to check before you go so you aren't disappointed your favorite it's on the menu that day. We will just have to come back another evening. read more

See all

We bicycled here (Yaa, the Sanibel Causeway finally reopened to bicyclists after almost 3 years after Hurricane Ian!) from Iona not realizing that it had just opened a few weeks earlier. It was originally located near the old Lighthouse but was damaged in Hurricane Ian. This new location is only about a quarter of a mile north of the main 4-way stop (heading towards Captiva). First time visit was Friday of Memorial Day weekend at approximately 9:30am and the place was packed! We put our name on the waiting list and about 20 minutes later we were seated. Besides their regular menu, they have daily specials posted on chalkboards on each side of the room. I decided to try their Avocado Toast with 2 eggs ($14.50), and coffee, black tyvm to drink. The avocado toast was extraordinarily good, pleasantly surpassing my expectations! It had feta cheese on top and the guacamole was seriously delicious! The eggs were cooked as I had ordered and the coffee was hot and aromatic. Second visit was Tuesday morning after Memorial Day weekend and it was not nearly as busy. We were seated right away. Again I decided to try a special from their board. This time I chose their Cranberry Pistachio Waffle ($13.00). The waffle was light and good and the cranberries added a nice taste! Service was friendly and on point - checking on us throughout our meals and making sure everything was to our liking. There's outside seating as well as inside - however this time of year air conditioning feels pretty darn good! Good food, friendly and pleasant employees, and reasonable prices are reasons why I'm going with 5 stars. I definitely recommend you check them out. read more

See all

When we visit Sanibel island we always try to make it to the Lighthouse Cafe for brunch and we are always happy we do! Service and staff are excellent and the food is delicious. I highly recommend the Seafood Benedict. One of my personal favorites. read more

Lighthouse Cafe - Seafood Benedict - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Sanibel, Florida

Very nice cafe the owner welcomes you (handsome guy). We were a big group but they accommodate us in less than 30 minutes ( the place was packed). We ordered the farm omelette, eggs Benedict and I ordered a vegetable omelette superb. The coffee tasted great. Service was also very good. We recommend if you are in Sanibel. read more

See all

Stopped here for brunch. Absolutely loved the vibe, workers and food. I got a omelette which was amazing! Throw in some toast and potatoes and it was a win. Others got the grouper sandwich and they loved it. Good stop for sure. read more

See all

This is our favorite place to eat on the island... For any meal! The food is consistently good, the service is efficient, and we always feel like we are home when we are there. They also have some unique breakfast items, like the Hungry Fisherman omelette, alongside the basics: bacon and eggs, waffles, oatmeal to name a few. Our family always orders the Seafood Benedict, malted chocolate, chip pancakes, the breakfast sandwich, and there's always a special of the day that we try. read more

Amazing breakfast Brittany was a great server Homemade strawberry jelly was amazing and their own blend of coffee was delicious read more

Lighthouse is a great, fun place to go to. Local crowd, bar area has entertainment. Food and service always very good.

Had a blast... my wife and I have visited lighthouses around the world and states and were delighted to see many photos of some we have visited on walls. But, on to the food which was delightful. The server worked with us and we split a Seafood Benedict plate (without the Alfredo but additional Holandais) and it was delicious. Will order again next time we are on island. read more

Lighthouse Cafe - Seafood Benedict! - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Sanibel, Florida

Fast service quality food Would recommend the eggs Benedict with the key lime hollandaise. The ham in the eggs Benedict was substantial. read more

The service and ambiance of the light house cafe are close to the old place. Food is nothing to write home about and their bloodmary's are subpar for the price. However it's still a staple of Sanibel. read more

Lighthouse Cafe - Bloody Mary - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Sanibel, Florida

The ambience and owner's positive attitude rate 5 stars, but this was not "the world's best breakfast." We got engaged at the Outer Banks and had a seaside theme to our wedding, so we have a soft spot for lighthouses. It was cool looking at all the framed lighthouse art while waiting for our food, which however only rated 3 stars. Anticipating a tall "stack," I ordered just 2 of the raisin cinnamon French toast slices, but they were small, so I helped my husband eat his short-stack of buckwheat pancakes with blueberry sauce, since none of the flapjacks or waffles seemed to come with fruit. I paid $5 for half a grape fruit I could have cut better. We wanted to like Lighthouse Cafe more than we did, but I think we enjoyed the food at Hoot's near Marco Island more, even though the decor there was less interesting. read more

Lighthouse Cafe - Cross-stitched lighthouse hanging in the dining room - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Sanibel, Florida

See all

AMAZING !!! My wife and I are lunch there yesterday. We both had the Hungry Fisherman seafood omelet, potatoes and wheat toast. We were welcomed upon entering. Our server, Lisa, was tremendous. This was reminiscent of the seafood omelet we used to get when we traveled to Maine. The atmosphere was comfortable. Flat out, our food was delicious. read more

I ordered a cheeseburger, cooked medium. The beef was bland and mushy, it tasted like soggy water. But you know what, things happen. But if your server doesn't question a gigantic burger with one bite out of it you have to wonder. Does this happen often, or does she just not care?? My ordered a Cuban sandwich, it was bland as well. We won't stop here again! read more

We went for breakfast today. It was just ok. Service was just ok. Food was just ok. The server was not friendly but she got the job done. We were amazed by the friendly service at other restaurants on the island. We ordered a short stack of granola nut pancakes. Very skimpy on the nuts and only a few slices of bananas on top. The egg breakfast had cold potatoes, sausage and toast but warm poached eggs. The omelette had the salsa inside the omelette and just a tiny amount on top which was a bit strange? Not by any means the best breakfast in the island. Not a bad breakfast, not a great breakfast, just an ok breakfast. Also your coffee mugs are too small and the coffee does not get refilled often enough. Please get larger mugs! read more

Great little cafe! My omelette and grits were good. Good coffee too. Patrice took care of us, she was helpful though very busy (I'm sure not her fault.) It was VERY busy. And it seemed to be a place where lots of local folks hang out. Would return if visiting the area again! read more

Lighthouse Cafe - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Sanibel, Florida

See all

The food and service is great! There are many options to choose from so we are going back again. You can sit inside or outside and a great place for kids. Highly recommended! read more

Had a great breakfast! The service was excellent and I enjoyed looking through the collection of lighthouse paintings and photographs. read more

I love Sanibel and want to give them a good review, but I can't. Horrible food. Wheat pancakes are dry and no sweet taste. Scrambled eggs were incredibly average. Ice tea was tasteless and watered down. Bacon was beyond crispy and the potatoes were burnt and old. They tasted like they were the remains from 3 hours ago. Water tasted like chlorine and the air conditioning also seemed to be broken. read more

We Iove eating at Lighthouse when we're on Sanibel! We found it by accident 6 months ago...driving by and the sign said "Worlds Best Breakfast" so we stopped. Now it's a staple when we're there. Food is excellent and service is awesome! read more

Upon arrival the place is very busy. We waited about 15 minutes for a table. Service was little slow it is very very busy. I got the apple wood cheese omelet with a side of gravy and it was good. My wife got the blueberry pancakes and bacon. Our food was good. read more

Lighthouse Cafe - Apple wood cheese omelette - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Sanibel, Florida

See all

We love the new location for the Lighthouse Cafe. Still the same great food, wonderful service, we visited 3x on our last visit to the island. We've never been disappointed in 30+ years. New location is much more spacious but they still pack them in especially on Saturday morning when the new visitors for the week ahead arrive and the the previous week's visitors are on there way off Island. So glad they didn't go out of business and returned after Ian. Food, cleanliness, service fantastic as always! read more

See all

Came in for breakfast. Nobody was around stood in dinner for a few minutes. The sign said they open at 7 but could not find anybody to help me. Very disappointed. read more

Always so good here. Brings a smile to my face because everything is so yummy! Servers work as a team and do AWESOME! Love this spot, will always come back! read more

Well, wait time wasn't bad. We ate at the Over Easy Cafe the day before. I guess we were spoiled. This breakfast spot was meh. Decor was beautiful, but: My egg sandwich was served with ham instead if bacon and on a Kaiser roll. My kids Philly cheesesteak was stringy and my husband's egg breakfast was super basic. The potatoes tasted like chopped up French fries. We left in a hurry and kept saying we should've gone back to Over Easy Cafe instead or maybe try Wickies. read more

A fun, lively place with diverse menu. The blackened snapper was delicious and a pork shop and baked potato a nice change from the typical seafood restaurant menu. The service was excellent and the live music a bonus. Prices were fair. read more

Love this new location. Food and service are still outstanding. The homemade jam served with toast is excellent.

Service was fast and food was tasty. I came with two coworkers after a mtg. Two of us had the grouper sandwich and one person did the turkey benedict. read more

The food and service were awesome! I ordered the eggs Bennie lighthouse style and my husband had the omelet both were large and delicious.

Blueberry pancakes were just as good as last time! A bit dry but once you add the blueberry or regular syrup you don't notice it. Bacon is just as solid! Soooo good! Hot chocolate was superb although I accidentally got a second one from a mixup and the second scimped on most of the whipped cream and no chocolate syrup so it might depend on who makes it... Bloody Mary - NONONONONO! While it tasted just fine, there's zero add ons and even less alcohol. They should have said this was alcohol free... The jam seemed somewhat watery but still great taste (and, yes, we still bought another jar). Eggs and potatoes - sooooooooooo goooooood..... We made a special trip to come here and are still glad we did although, overall, it was a bit under 4 stars this go around. Main hostess guy is still as chill and friendly as always! read more

See all

Cecilia was our server, she made a great start to our day. Fun, attentive and never missed a beat on refills of coffee or water. Breakfast came quickly and everything as ordered. Great all the way around - Cecilia is a gem. read more