I bypassed the Lobster Ruben, had the conch ceviche and a fried hogfish sandwich, it was one of the…read morebest seafood meals of my life. Bonus points for the bar next door, and having the tartar/cocktail sauce readily available. Their prices are incredibly low for the freshness and quality they serve up. I can't wait to return to the Florida Keys again to eat here.

We stopped here after snorkeling the sombrero reef for lunch. You order at a counter and find a…read moreseat and they call your name when it's ready. You go around the corner to the bar area to order any drinks. We found a spot outside at a picnic table by the marina to eat. The food is fresh but overpriced. The lobster roll was good but had more roll than lobster. The lobster chowder was better than the lobster bisque I had at a different restaurant but still not as good as what I make at home. I tried the famous lobster Rueben. It was toasted perfectly on rye. It was fine but I think the sauerkraut over powers the lobster when the lobster needs to be the star of the sandwich. The beating I had here was probably the coconut shrimp with mango sauce. It was perfection. Deliciously crispy and the mango chutney was perfect with it. After we finished eating we went into the seafood market to check out their fresh seafood selection and grabbed a pie of key lime pie to go which comes in a little tart tin. It was really good flavored and the crust was obviously homemade. Not your typical graham cracker crust which was a nice change.

I always take my boat up to burdines and get me some grub after a long day on the water fishing or…read moresnorkeling one of my favorite spots 5 stars

This place used to be a staple to visit. I am officially crossing it off my places to visit. Too…read more many options. Sandwiches are all a carte. Mahi sandwiches over cooked and tasteless. Server didn't check in with us we had to flag him down while he was texting for water refills. My kid loved the quesadilla. Not like the old days.

This fun restaurant had live music when we went, and it was packed. The service was friendly, but…read morethe food was a little slow. They had the best fried conch of the several places where I tried it while on this trip. It was not chewy at all.

Five stars for Brutus!…read more Ambiance: The vibe and decor is beautiful! Tropical island feels! Everything is super clean and the space is bright ! Large outdoor terrace completely shaded and large trees near by for a wonderful breeze! Service: our waitress was super friendly and very fast and accommodating. She made a lot of suggestions about the menu which we appreciated. Food: what I loved the most is that everything was super fresh. We had the fish ceviche. So good!! Good portion as well. Also had the yellowtail sandwich - very fresh! Ordered the taco salad with filet mignon on top! Very good! Steak was cooked perfectly as ordered. Brutus serves breakfast daily and they have Sunday brunch! Love those options! Definitely coming back often! A gem in our neighborhood!

Our server Micheal M, went above and beyond for my family with his service and made our dining…read moreexperience the very best! We much enjoyed the food and especially the service we had while having dinner on our last night of vacation at the Keys Steak and Lobster House.

A million times yes…read more First and foremost, Brennan, the server with the upmost hospitality that was so thoughtful, attentive, informative, with great recommendations - set the bar for what service should be everywhere. Excellence all around! It was busy but we were able to find parking and were immediately seated which was a very pleasant surprise - the bread starter didn't last long enough to get pictures and they should sell that bread and butter to go While upscale with a flair, it is still very approachable and there was a variety of dress attire which made for a relaxing dining experience. Clean, well organized, good conversation white noise but not overwhelming, overall six out of five experience. From appetizers, beverages, entrees, and desserts it was worth every bit and then some. While we are trying to hit a variety of places while in the Keys, we might need to make our way back for another dinner here. Unbelievable!

our bartender, Mallory, was amazing. care of accommodating…read more we loved the restaurant! great wings!

Great place!!! We went there for the first time and the…read morefood and service was amazing....i will be going back...great local place

We came here for a late dinner and to hopefully catch the sunset. We timed it fairly spot on. They…read moresaid it would be about a 20-25 minute wait but it actually took less than 15 minutes. We got seated inside just as the sun was starting to set. Sadly all the guests that had finished eating right before us decided to walk over to the dock outside the restaurant which just so happened to be the exact viewing location for the sunset so we didn't get any really good photos of it bc there were so many people over there videoing it and taking photos. It was still nice scenery while we waited for our food though. I ordered ceviche to start us off as our appetizer and it was really good. My dinner was a pasta dish with shrimp and scallops. The sauce was supposed to be a white cream sauce but it was really runny. Even adding extra Parmesan cheese to it didn't help thicken it. It tasted ok. Not my best pick. I had a choice of soup or salad with it. I chose their she crab soup and I'm glad I did. It was great. Almost reminded me of homemade chicken and dumplings soup just with crab. I really liked it. I should have stopped with that and the ceviche. My husband got a grouper fish sandwich. He thought it was good but the prices were a bit high for what it was. His fish sandwich was $29. Although good, not worth $29. My pasta definitely not worth the $31. May be a bit of a tourist trap but the food was decent.

When my dad and I came here last year this place was great. A lot has changed. Our server was…read morehorrible, she only came to check on us once, and to give us the bill. we were seated around the bar around 1pm today. I ordered the calamari and ordered it plain without all the extras. It was so greasy and chewy. There was oil all over the plate. I sent it back. Mahi sandwich was good, but you get such a small amount of fish. It was very thin, and then I had to wait an extra five minutes after the food got there to get my side.

What a nice little stop for breakfast. The service was good and my husband loved his spicy Bloody…read moreMary . I wish I would have gotten a Mimosa they looked good. The food came out fast and delicious! Can't wait to go back.

What a cute spot with a great vibe! The music created the perfect atmosphere, and the staff was…read morefriendly, attentive, and welcoming. We stopped in for breakfast, and everything was great. The service was fast, the food was delicious, and everything came out just right. Check them out and help support the locals!

10/10 for location & Francisco! 10/10 for the Frozen Pina Colada & 2-6 happy hour. Honestly the…read morefood is mid 5/10? Not terrible. But also not great. Yellowtail Snapper catch of the day tacos, the filling was really good, nice pieces of fish, veggies were fresh & crunchy, note the sauce on the outside of taco! The tortillas were absolutely terrible! Out of cilantro. The coconut rice and black beans excellent!! So almost real good but also missed the fantastic mark. Same with the pizza, why cook the fresh basil? Easily could be much better. I would not order the pizza again. I definitely would order the tacos again knowing to avoid the tortillas maybe add some lettuce for a bowl type situation. I'm down for that fabulous slushy all day long!! The patio is absolutely lovely and Francisco is charming & fun! Not fair to drop to 3 stars but can't do 5. We did enjoy ourselves.

Burger came cold. Tacos were unseasoned and the rice was hard, crusty, cold and stale. What a…read morewaste

An absolute must go. Unique opportunity to experience locally sourced fish prepared several…read moreawesome ways. My personal favorite is wreck diver. A wide range of sushi to choose from too. Great service and cocktails and a wide variety of tap beers too.

Service was great- but the food wasn't. The two stars are for the service. The place is tucked away…read morein a yard-like area, but the restaurant itself was quite nice. We sat outside hoping to see the manatees at one point- never saw them. We ordered the lobster enchiladas, shrimp Reuben, and blackened lionfish with coleslaw and potato salad. Lobster enchiladas tasted like nothing- the shell was also oddly dry and unpleasant. I tried to drown it in the sauce, rice and beans, but honestly, almost everything on our table lacked salt and flavor. Can't believe they said Guy Fieri liked this. The bottom of the shrimp Reuben was soggy that it started falling apart. There was like 4 shrimp inside. This one was probably the most flavorful- but I still wasn't impressed. Lastly, I knew lionfish needs a lot of seasoning, and having blackened lionfish helps. But the sides (the coldslaw and the potato salad) were....so so so disappointing. A review said it felt like they were eating cafeteria food- that's exactly what I felt as well. Really appreciate the server for being so attentive and kind- they even brought over another slice of key lime pie (we only ordered one) because it was taking a while- definitely didn't expect it but appreciated the sweet gesture. For the price of it all, I paid similar for a wonderfully delicious seafood meal the other day so quite disappointed it didn't come up to par.

My wife gave the Escargot 4*, I gave it 3*. Mashed potatoes,…read more5* Duck, 3.5* Service, 3* Bananas Foster, 3*

Our favorite place to come to every time we come to the Keys. It's a must stop. Family owned the…read morefreshest fish you'll ever have. The lamb chops ought to die for and a duck is just absolutely succulent amazing. It is my father the best macaroni and cheese I've ever had in my entire life anywhere. If you want a great meal and a great atmosphere go to Baracuda you'll love this place in Marathon Florida.