John & Mary's

my husband looked up D'Agostino's PIZZERIA as it was close by where we were staying, and when you…read moreorder the nicest man answered the phone very clear well spoken, very nice and pleasant took our order we had it delivered. We had ease of putting the tip on the card and he was such a nice gentleman that came that brought us our little mini pizza Personal pizza, which was really big to us and then 10 wings. They were cooked like we asked crispy and their sauce on the pizza is delicious and they loaded it down with pepperoni. We thoroughly enjoyed it. Whenever we come to Bufalo, we will do our best to order from D'Agostino's. They have great food and great service.!!

3.5 stars. Medium wings were cooked well…read more Flavorful! Fast service! Totally understand they were very busy but even saying these were "warm" would be pushing it. I'd be willing to try once more in the future!

See all

Schifano’s Pizzeria

4.6(16 reviews)

4.0 mi

The pizza was a little thicker than I prefer and there was a lot of cheese. If you're going there…read moreto eat there are just two tables. It's more of a take out place. Wings were solid. I'd probably give this place three stars but the fact that I wasn't even asked for a tip (when nowadays counter service wants to know if you want to tip 25%) makes me inclined to give this place 4 stars.

We ordered Schifano's pizzeria delivery to our hotel the night prior to our flight home from…read moreBuffalo NY. I will say we all truly enjoyed it. The pizza had really good flavor and they pack on the toppings. The delivery service was an hour but it was understandable due to a Friday night. Schifano's is worth the wait great pizza.

See all

Small pizza-hand crafted and all fresh ingredients.

One Pie Pizza

4.4(117 reviews)

4.7 mi

Another great pizza spot for the books…read more I'm honestly surprised how different Buffalo pizza is compared to Jersey and NYC. You'd think they would be pretty similar, but Buffalo definitely has its own style. I'm a truck driver and was hauling a load from Buffalo to North Carolina, so finding a good pizza spot where I could get a 53-foot tractor-trailer close enough was a challenge. Somehow I got lucky and found a nearby no-parking bus stop for a very quick stop. If you look at my picture, you can actually see my 18-wheeler peeking out from behind the bushes. I ran inside, ordered two pepperoni slices for $10.98, and was surprised by how huge they were. I was expecting NYC-style triangles but got big rectangular slices instead. The crust was crisp underneath with a soft, chewy interior, the sauce-to-cheese ratio was really good, and the crispy cup-and-char pepperoni was easily the highlight. The sauce had a slight sweetness without being overpowering. I also asked for ranch but ended up with Bleu cheese instead, and honestly I'm glad I did because it was really good. The place was clean, the service was quick and friendly, and the pizza was excellent. If I'm ever back in Buffalo, I'd definitely stop here again.

It's been quite some time since I've allowed myself a delicious treat and pizza was on my mind…read more Not just any pizza though , pizza that hits the spot and delivers on crispy cup and char pepperoni and dough that doesn't disappoint. So one pie it was. After placing my order at the window, my slices were handed over nice and hot, knowing that I did not want a hot cheese mess in my lap while driving I went home and immediately went to work on these slices. Only being able to eat one of the two my hankering for pizza was satisfied shout out to that incredible bleu cheese for making those last few bites even more amazing. This is still top-tier elite level pizza for Buffalo.

QTR Sheet (6 slice) Steak Hoagie Pizza (Nov. 2025 Pizza of the Month)

See all

QTR Sheet (6 slice) Stuffed Banana Pepper Pizza [Pizza of the Month - 09/2024]: Perfect cook on the dough and crust

Airport Pizzeria

4.6(53 reviews)

1.9 mi

Solid pizza at a really good price. Friendly, clean, fast and probably the best slice price in…read moretown.

Stumbled upon this place as an out of state visitor, staying nearby. Cute spot, food was delicious…read moreand service was outstanding! I recommend for anyone looking for good quality pizza and wings.

Cookie platters fir corporate party.

Airport Pizzeria - Half sheet Antipasto Suprema. A hearth baked garlic crust topped with an antipasto salad, served with homemade Italian dressing.

Half sheet Antipasto Suprema. A hearth baked garlic crust topped with an antipasto salad, served with homemade Italian dressing.

See all

Half Sheet antipasto Suprema

Wally's Cafe & Pizzeria

3.9(55 reviews)

2.9 mi

Always the best need my Wally wings pizza subs only problem is online ordering with no option for…read moreplain wings with no option to add sauce on the side

My favorite ...Mae sure you get the hot honey and sweet sauce on the pizza....it's absolutely…read moreridiculous...so good i look forward to it ...

12" steak sub. Costanzo's roll. Just pain simple good.

That's the small fry.... Large enough for 3 or 4 people!

See all

Onion rings, still crisp!

Jocko's Pizza and Pasta

4.2(34 reviews)

3.8 mi

Ordered a personal Pizza here for pickup recently through the Toast App…read more Ready in about 40 minutes. the Pizza was OK, surprisingly bland vs other Chicken Finger Pizza's I've tried, not bad but not great. Better options in the area.

My orders: ciabatta bread, alfredo, lasagna…read more Pros + Parking + Service: every waitress I get is such a darling! + Unlimited soup and salad bar + Food The food here is positively scrumptious! I love their lasagna and garlic knots.

Salad Bar

See all

Salad bar

Johnny's Pizzeria & Restaurant

3.8(125 reviews)

1.6 mi

Delicious and excellent customer service. We'll be back when we're back in Buffalo for sure!read more

I grew up in Cheektowaga, but have not been to the area in many years. As soon as I checked into…read morethe hotel, I could not shake the feeling that I needed a royal sub so I get my rent a car and off I go to Johnny's. For you Non locals a royal sub is an Italian sausage patty with capicola ham on it. Johnny's is a counter service pizzeria. Everything is made fresh so it took a few extra minutes to get our order, but it was worth the wait. Jonnny' brought back memories of growing up in Cheektowaga in the early 80s. There is still Buffalo sports memorabilia in the restaurant mainly the Sabres. The royal sub is the best thank you.

Turkey Sub - One of the Best

See all

Picasso's Pizza

3.4(147 reviews)

5.7 mi

This place is fantastic. Never gets anything wrong and is on time! Great contract with this…read morecompany, can't complain. Great overall.

On Saturday Oct. 3rd 2026 my grandson who was visiting from Florida placed an order and was told 15…read moreminutes, well he was a little early and the girl who was at the checkout was very rude. Said... I told you 15 minutes. My grandson says no problem and again she says ... Well I told you 15 minutes. I will Never order from Picasso's again. Was a very good customer. Your Employee Needs A Reality Check and A Lesson On How To Talk To Customers. Lots of other good pizza places to order from!!!

Cup pepperoni

See all

Pepperoni pizza. Good.

Macy's Place

3.1(251 reviews)

1.5 mi

I really don't know how this spot doesn't have a higher rating…read more Very well may be my favorite Buffalo-style pizza. Love the thick crust (has a bit of a garlicky flavor), sweeter sauce, and not overly-cheesy. They have the craziest concoctions, like a stinger sub made that uses two pep slices instead of a roll. Genius! I do love their hot bbq sauce for fingers when in a sub, but alone, it is a bit too sweet. I do wish they made their own blue cheese - Macy's can you consider doing this? You know you'd be great at it!

Ordered large pizza with pepperoni, mushrooms. No pepperoni. Duh. Look like it got tossed aside as…read moreeverything shifted to one side. One and done, never going back. What a waste of money. Taste was fair at best. Very disappointing. Save your time and money and go to Mattia's for quality pizza that will have the toppings and taste better.

Order of 12 fingers - can split flavors

See all

Mayback's

3.7(54 reviews)

1.2 mi

The greek salad is my go to! Huge!…read more Always enough for two meals! I always add the chicken to the greek salad ( which is a good size ) portion as well! Kens dressing! Can't go wrong there!

For the Bills AFC East championship, we decided to order pizza and wings from Maybacks. The cheese…read moreand sauce ratio of this pizza, though I wish the pizza crust was more cooked. I'm glad the pizza wasnt too saucy. We both wish they had used cup and char pepperoni. The price for the pizza and wings was some of the best in the area. Also, the pizza was hot and the service was great. We ordered the bbq wings and these were some of the best wings I've had. I would definitely come back again for their wings, and maybe a pizza if I can have them make it with lesser cheese and sauce, a thinner crust, and a more crispier crust. But then again, I'm a transplant and still fond of NYC style pizza. For everyone else that likes Buffalo style pizza, this is a place to visit.

BBQ wings

Large one topping pizza. I wish they used cup & char.

See all

This is our leftovers since I was too busy to take pictures at the party, but Pepperoni pizza and barbecue wings

Why does Yelp recommend reviews?

Hundreds of millions of reviews are posted on Yelp, and our automated recommendation software works in the background to showcase the reviews that it …

1 review that is not currently recommended

The reviews below are not factored into the business's overall star rating.

Kyle R.

6 years ago

Best steak subs. Been coming here since I was a kid.

John & Mary's - pizza - Updated October 2026

People who viewed John & Mary's also viewed

Sub Delicious

3.8

(65 reviews)

Their Steak and Cheese subs are the best in Lockport BY FAR!!…read moreThe pizza is also very good. When ordering their wings, which are very good too but tend to be a little stingy with the sauce, so just make sure to ask for extra sauce on them. Curly fries were 'soggy' and under cooked, but their regular fries were very good!

Got a Large cheese & Pepperoni pizza and 20 wings before the Bills game only got there a few…read moreminutes late and only a 5 minute drive home. The food was barely warm pizza was bland and the wings were very small but for over 50 dollars I would expect better. I'll only go there for subs from now on !!'

John & Mary's

3.6

(61 reviews)

I'm fairly sure this place hasn't changed since I was a kid. And thank goodness for that. They make…read morethe best subs and they're always consistent - they will taste exactly as you expect every single time. My go to has always been the turkey sub but they're all good. They use the best rolls that's are toasted to crispy, golden perfection. The fried apps are all good too: onion rings, fries.

Not my favorite place personally, but my dad likes to stop here before Bulls games and it's his tab…read moreso his choice of course. Everything is just kind of "ok". That's the best way I can describe it. And by everything, I've only had what my dad orders which is the pizza and wings. I would definitely like my wings much crispier and a thicker sauce with more of a wow factor. Not a horrible place or anything, just not my favorite.

Sunny's Drive-In Family Restaurant

3.3

(64 reviews)

This is my favorite pizza place in Lockport. The food is amazing. Great service and a family…read moreplace. Crispy pizza slices and stingers aka beef and chicken tenders on a sub roll. Too notch. Go try it.

During lent I decided to try various fish frys to see how they were. I saw several great reviews…read morefor Sunnys and decided to give them a try. We ordered a fish fry and a double order of chicken wings. This was actually a Doordash order, so I usually include the wrapping and packaging. There is nothing more frustrating than getting a delivery and the order messy when recieved. So anyway ...the fish arrived and was beer battered. But it tasted like it was pre battered or.purchased battered. The fish was ok, but lacked any flavor or seasoning. Unfortunately when fish is frozen battered it is seldom seasoned. The fries that came with the fish were hand cut and good. Now the wings were great the flavor was good. Unfortunately I prefer a very crispy wing and these weren't that. They were packaged great so the issue wasn't the packaging, they just weren't fried the way I requested. The service was quick and the food presented well. But I can't speak for the actual location I will say for the price the piece of fish could have been a bit larger.

Submasters

3.1

(62 reviews)

Never a disappointment absolutely delicious everytime we go!! Great food, great employees, a…read morewonderful atmosphere

Everything was adequate. I ordered a stinger sub and onion rings, and the food wasn't bad... I…read moreordered it hot , and to describe it as mild would be to give it too much credit. The amount of steak was startling in how little there was. I think the photos were extremely deceiving.... I expected that a half-sub would stuff me, and have lunch for tomorrow. For $20, it barely touched my hunger. The flavor was decent; it tasted like an adequate stinger should. For the price though, I really think I should have walked away with a stronger emotion than complete indifference. At least if it were horrible, I'd feel something for the food.... It was like watching the matrix. I was hungry, I ingested calories.... I wouldn't order from them again.

Mayback's

3.7

(54 reviews)

The greek salad is my go to! Huge!…read more Always enough for two meals! I always add the chicken to the greek salad ( which is a good size ) portion as well! Kens dressing! Can't go wrong there!

LT's Old Time Pizza & Subs

3.4

(65 reviews)

Great pizza wings and subs located in the heart of West Seneca. They have daily specials. They…read moreoffer delivery or door dash

The owner of this restaurant is very personable. He's a top notch immigrant who has made a…read morewonderful job of turning a small business into a success. Their food is great, the store is clean, and the prices are what you'd expect from a pizzeria. Give them a try you won't be disappointed.

Mike's Subs - Kenmore's Original

3.6

(194 reviews)

Got their buffalo chicken tender sub. Hit the spot, got it with blue cheese and mayo and I feel…read morelike they put the perfect amount. Good amount of seating area inside and staff inside were nice and friendly. Were amenable to changing a portion of my order when I got there even though I ordered over the phone.

Every now and then that facebook algorithm turns you to a place that you didn't know existed…read more Yes I said it. I didn't know about Mikes... I had an ad pop-up for the chicken, finger, sub specials, and being in the neighborhood I thought this would be a fantastic dinner option. I placed an order for two chicken, finger subs, and a three-piece chicken finger meal. The guy who answered the phone was super polite and very helpful. Arriving at Mike's my first initial impression was this place is very well kept. Everything was clean and it had that small neighborhood feel which is exactly what I love. Within a few minutes I had my order and was on my way home to enjoy. Those chicken finger subs really hit the spot today. They were very well cooked piled high and I really appreciated the toasted bun. The little yelper loved the tenders. And despite having several snacks before dinner completely crushed all of the chicken fingers. Needless to say, there was a few additional fans made today in our house, and we will definitely make the journey out to try Mike's again .

La Hacienda Brighton

3.7

(104 reviews)

Everything was delicious! Chicken wings, chicken finger sub, pizza, and fish fry. Will definitely…read moreeat there again!!

Another order from La Hacienda Brighton. This time we ordered fish. Beer battered and broiled…read more Salad's were excellent and the fish too. Comes with fries also. Excellent fish fry.

Pizza Works Etc

4.0

(89 reviews)

For a party on Sunday, August 2, I ordered four sheet pizzas and 160 wings. They do combos so two…read morewere sheet pizzas +50 wings and two were sheet pizzas +30 wings. Everything was delicious. All of the pizzas were cooked fine with appropriate amounts of toppings. The wings were barbecue, medium and mild which they described to me as being sweet and tangy, a little different from Buffalo mild. The only problem was both the mild and medium were not sauced enough in my opinion and I'm not even someone who likes saucy wings. But given that everything was so good I decided to give them five stars instead of just four. The night before I picked up the order I learned from a public post that they will become Joey's Pizza soon. I've never been there but their reviews at their main location are pretty good so I'm hopeful that they will stay just as good as this order was.

From start to finish, this was an extremely easy process to order catering for an all-employee…read moreevent. I was able to connect with the owner fairly easily by calling and requesting to place a catering order in advance, the gentleman who anesthetized phone was very polite too! I advised what we needed and when, given a fair price for what our needs were and based on the conversation I had no worries about our pickup. Our food was hot and ready when they said it would be and staff even helped load it in our company van. Our food was clearly labeled and packaged so that we were able to set up, serve quickly and store some in our warmers. The pizza was cut into even portions and the wings were so plans juicy and sauced well! The food was delicious and we had so many coming back for 2nds. I was too busy with set up to get may pictures but we ordered 1 large veggie pizza, 1 large chicken finger pizza, 400 wings( plain, mild, medium, hot and bbq) and 7 sheets of pizza (cheese and pepperoni) and a large pan of salad.

Artone's Pizza & Subs

3.8

(53 reviews)