The greek salad is my go to! Huge! Always enough for two meals! I always add the chicken to the greek salad ( which is a good size ) portion as well! Kens dressing! Can't go wrong there! read more

For the Bills AFC East championship, we decided to order pizza and wings from Maybacks. The cheese and sauce ratio of this pizza, though I wish the pizza crust was more cooked. I'm glad the pizza wasnt too saucy. We both wish they had used cup and char pepperoni. The price for the pizza and wings was some of the best in the area. Also, the pizza was hot and the service was great. We ordered the bbq wings and these were some of the best wings I've had. I would definitely come back again for their wings, and maybe a pizza if I can have them make it with lesser cheese and sauce, a thinner crust, and a more crispier crust. But then again, I'm a transplant and still fond of NYC style pizza. For everyone else that likes Buffalo style pizza, this is a place to visit. read more

Mayback's - Large one topping pizza. I wish they used cup & char. - Pizza Near Me - Buffalo, New York

See all

Overall great: I got the fish Fry, fish was incredible and large, restaurant is clean and staff is so nice and welcoming, I felt at home. Definitely would recommend!!! read more

Well... I had ordered from here the other day. It was good. I went in tonight to pickup a pizza and there were roaches crawling on the tables and floor. read more

Mayback's - Cockroach in table - Pizza Near Me - Buffalo, New York

Always great service! Always great food! Been going here so long and even with new ownership didn't skip a beat keeping everything perfect! Will always recommend this place! The ambiance is incredible read more

We got Mayback's catering for my daughter's birthday party and we were pretty happy!! They have amazing prices. We got a deal of 3 sheet pizzas, 50 wings, and a full antipasto tray for only $160 dollars. We got it delivered and the delivery was mostly on time, so I was happy since it was for a child's birthday. There was so much food and we had so much leftover! Everything was just as ordered, and the antipasto had so many different veggies, which I was impressed by. I have had better pizza, which is the sole reason for 4 instead of 5 stars. It was still delicious, just a little less delicious than our usual pizza haunts! But definitely keep them in mind if you need catering for a party! read more

Mayback's - This is our leftovers since I was too busy to take pictures at the party, but Pepperoni pizza and barbecue wings - Pizza Near Me - Buffalo, New York

First time back in NY in 20 years. Seen local sandwich shop. Yes! Yummy NY subs. Got the sausage and pepper Sub. I was expecting a big bun with a giant sausage link covered in cheese and sauce . Got a subway sandwich with sliced..yes slices of sausage. No sauce. No yummy good cheese to burn your face. It tasted ok. Not great. Was the only one in the place and took about 20 mins to get sandwich. Not a huge amount of time but basically could have got the same thing from firehouse or Jimmy John's. read more

Mayback's - My "hot sausage sub". - Pizza Near Me - Buffalo, New York

Subs are amazing, closest thing to a cheesesteak Buffalo has honestly. Wish they were a bit closer to where I live.

We've now ordered takeout from here a few times. Food is pretty decent and reasonably priced. Chicken finger pizza was on point. The fish fry isn't the normal light and crispy beer bettered, it's a bit thicker and crunchier but still equally delicious. The wings are good but sometimes they are a bit dry. Overall it's a good go to with allot of variety read more

Mayback I'm amazed at the way you feed me all the time. Mayback I'm amazed at the way these slices fill you. Hey. I just went here. And this is crazy. But here's my review. So call them, Mayback? I enjoyed this slice a lot, I liked it slightly better than the nearby Macy's Place (not a department store), but my pizza-companion liked the Macy's one a little better. Both were very solid 4/5 slices, but I'd have to try them again to see if it can go one better and become a 5. Certainly it was delicious. The pepperoni was perfect, the cheese was generous, it was a typical Buffalo slice, easy on the sauce, not too sweet, with very juicy greasy almost-burned but delicious crust. Buffalo is full of these little family-owned pizza places, you could literally eat at a different one every night for 3-4 months, I would imagine, and still not have to leave Western NY and never have to order from a chain. And if the Bills get their act together next year, then I Mayback them to make the play offs, but then again, I maynot. read more

Mayback's - Pizza Near Me - Buffalo, New York

See all

One of the few businesses that got better during COVID. Food is fresher and the new management is hella friendly. I love this place. Absolute god tier fries! read more

We used to frequent the Mayback's on Niagara Falls Boulevard when we lived closer to it, and really enjoyed the food. We recently tried takeout from this Mayback's location, expecting a similar experience. But sadly, no, not even close. Actually, I'm not even sure if the two Mayback's are related now. We ordered a large pizza and 20 wings combo, a half cheese sub, and a falafel plate. We ordered for pickup using the DoorDash app, which was easy enough, and pickup was ready on time, with easy lot parking. But when we arrived, we were told they do not carry the falafel plate anymore. This was a downer for our vegan daughter, not sure why they don't remove it from their menu if they don't have it anymore. They replaced it with a chef salad. The salad was just basic and okay. The only food in our spread that was good was the chicken wings. My husband and son shared them, half hot and half garlic parm. They weren't huge wings, but meaty enough and cooked well. The pizza on the other hand, SO SAD! :-( Now this pizza came as part of a combo with 20 wings for $42. So we were expecting a decent quality Buffalo-style pizza for that $20+ dollar price tag. But no, it was cardboard crust, not doughy at all. It seemed like it was from frozen. Neither the crust nor the sauce had any noticeable flavor. The sauce tasted like something straight out of a can. If it was a bargain-basement ten dollar pie, fine. But way overpriced for this dud of a pizza. The half cheese sub was an overpriced fail, as well. For ten bucks, I was expecting a nicely stuffed sub. Toppings beyond lettuce, tomato, and onions are all 75-cents each additional, and I added banana peppers. But the toppings were moderate at best, even with that upcharge, and the roll was TINY! It wasn't a half sub roll, but like a steak sandwich mini-sub roll. And the sub itself wasn't a taste masterpiece, just okay and skimpy. Sadly we were mostly disappointed with our Mayback's pickup, and will not be returning anytime soon. read more

See all

We went with the medium pizza, with one topping, small wings and an order of fries and two drinks. $25 not to bad all. Tasty food, pizza was good we looked the crust, the wings were really really small. Not sure if we would return with many other choices in the area for pizza and wings. read more

Mayback's - Good taste, very crispy but very small! - Pizza Near Me - Buffalo, New York

See all

I was walking to the restaurant and I heard someone taking out the garbage, it was the cashier walking back into the store, it was only once he looked at me he took the dumpster gloves off. Then instead of washing his hands he grabbed my food from the counter. It only gets worse when I had a back and forth with said cashier about WHY he needed to wash his hands if he's going to handle food or in general after dumping garbage in the dumpster. I'm never going back there's no telling what other unsanitary things are going on there. read more

The BEST fish fry, mac salad, and potato salad!!! Fries and carrot cake are pretty good too.

Pretty good. Better than expected. Definitely will be back. Customer service was great. Which goes a long way with me.

I FINALLY FOUND THE PERFECT FISH FRY!!! Outstanding. The sides were perfect too - Mac salad, potato salad, and tartar sauce were all perfect. 10/10 read more

This place has fallen apart since original owner. I've always gone to this place since moving to SC. The chicken tender subs are garbage and always use to me by fav sub from them. The sub had more lettuce than the chicken tenders. I recommend this place to no one. read more

I was driving and saw this place, so I thought to try it. To my surprise it was quite good. As I walked in the place was quite clean and has a seating of about 20 people. The was room is locked and only for paying customer. The menu has a lot of options, I went with their specialty pizza option and got their Veggie Pizza to go. The pizza was very good and loaded with the topping they had mentioned ( green/ black olives, sweet peppers and mushrooms). The pizza was off the oven and fresh. The person at the till was very helpful and friendly. read more

See all

First time getting from Maybacks...pizza was very good. Sauce not to sweet, dough cooked well and pepperoni crisp. Will definitely be going back! read more

My first time trying this place and I am addicted! I got the chicken fingers and the size is big and the breading is light and so tasty! It reminds me exactly of the fingers I had when I was young and my mom worked as a waitress at a small diner nearby. Almost an exact replica so I'm getting hit hard by nostalgia! I also got poppers which are okay- maybe I should've gotten pizza logs instead because those were rated much better. Fries need salt but better than over salted and not soggy which is appreciated. Haven't tried their pizza yet but I will next time- which there definitely will be! Mayback's where have you been all my life? read more

Great quick lunch place. The guy at the counter is friendly and the food is quick. Great wings read more

Mayback's - Deli, wings & pizza - Pizza Near Me - Buffalo, New York

We have been going to Maybacks for years always good until the last few times . I don't know what happen the subs are horrible we asked for oil no oil asked got Mayo on the sub no Mayo you can't have people answering the phone that can't speak English we couldn't understand him at all. I was very disappointed in everything we have gotten lately from them. They are now on our don't order again read more

I was driving around for work and got hungry. I stumbled across this place close to my work. Their pizza was delicious and reasonably priced for a lunch combo. $5.50 with a can of pop. But Nicole went above and beyond and sealed my 5 star rating. She gave me an extra slice because the others were cut goofy. That's a great business owner and community star right there.I'll definitely be back read more

Very clean inside!! They carry a variety of meal & dessert selections. I requested to have all flat BBQ wings and they were able to accommodated me! The employees are very helpful and friendly. Delivery guy always arrives within reasonable time. Ordering over the phone is easy & pleasant. The cashier is very helpful on describing ingredients in several meals. Food is fresh. Price & Portion sizes are reasonable. read more

Mayback's - Grilled chicken salad - Pizza Near Me - Buffalo, New York

Delivery was very fast which was suspicious but after I had received my food from the delivery driver I had placed my hand underneath the box and had noticed right away that the box wasn't even hot like how you'd expect it to be. When I took it inside and inspected it further, half of the pizza wasn't even cooked through and was cold. Very unhappy. read more

Great combo prices! Subs are very good. Antipasto has more meats, cheese and veggies than lettuce which is good. Always pleasant people working there. Hope that they will be open on Sundays during Bills season. read more

It's ok they could have more chicken fingers on the subs and get the mushrooms orders right

Uh. Best pizza.... fish fry uh anything on their menu my husband and I found this place because we wanted something different. I'm the biggest pizza sauce snob there is. And the only complaint is that they never put enough so I always order extra sauce. The service is great! They treat you like family. If you get there and have to wait a couple minutes it's usually because you ordered fries and they pretty much drop them when you get there. The fish fry literally the best. I haven't found another I actually like. Their tartar sauce is amazing. They knew us well while I was pregnant because all I craved was their fish fry. I have no pictures but This is a hidden gem you NEED to try. You'll regret it If you don't! read more

Chicken Souvlaki sub... that is all. I discovered this gem a few years ago and have been going back since. I'm kind of ashamed to admit it but the only thing I've ever ordered is the Chicken Souvlaki sub and fries. It's that good! I drive by probably a dozen pizza/sub joints to go pick up my orders from Maybacks. It's definitely worth the extra few minutes in the car. At first I was annoyed when I'd arrive and the fries weren't done yet. Then I learned why... they cook those last to ensure that they are warm and crispy when you get them. Too many places serve up soggy fries, especially when they're to go. I tend to avoid ordering them because they're a mess when I get home. Not from Maybacks! I go about once a week to grab a sub. The food is excellent and the staff are friendly and offer great customer service. If you haven't tried Mayback's Chicken Souvlaki sub... do it tonight! I have to assume the rest of the food is good. I'm just addicted to the damn sub. (Yes, I had one last night lol) read more

I came here off a whim since I just moved down the street and got two slices of pepperoni pizza for $6. They're were fresh and really good! I told the owner (atleast I think it was the owner) how good the desserts looked in the front case looked and he said to do him a favor and try the tiramisu and to come back and tell him how it was and gave it to me for free! And it tasted so good! They make it themselves and use graham crackers instead of ladyfingers. Definitely give this place a try! And the place itself seems pretty clean and tidy with reasonable prices!! read more

A friend of mines is one of those guys that goes around to random pizzerias, & food spots to just try new food because he doesn't like ordering from the same places all the time! He stumbled upon Mayback's & called me immediately afterwards since I live around the corner.... I just tried a slice of cheese/pepperoni & it was cooked to perfection!!!! The crust was perfectly crisp, not too thick or tough to bite into. The bottoms was nice & firm, not flimsy at all. The cheese was light. The sauce was very savory, & not sweet! Then there was the pepperoni, perfectly crispy edges that just topped the entire slice off!!! Also, there was not a heavy flow of grease flowing from the pizza, nor was it a mound of it sitting onto of the slice neither.... I will be back!!!! read more

I ordered my food on the phone and went to pick it up and they gave it to the wrong person very unsatisfied never ever will I go here again

I came here through word of mouth of a friend when I used to work at HSBC. I had the hot wings which were freaking amazing!!! They were crispy, and the sauce was definitely loaded with Frank's hotsauce or something extremely close. I really have to make it a point to go here again very soon. It's a small shop with enough room to sit and eat your food. Actually, I believe my 1st experience was a dine in experience. Very delicious and affordable prices. read more

See all

After reading my fellow yelpers review, I decided to try this place for a veg pizza. I had called them and placed an order for their Veg pizza and I arrived earlier. Not sure what happened but the 20 mins took almost additional 20 mins to get the order out. The pie was piping hot, so took to our hotel room and started working on the slices..and we were disappointed with the pizzas. he toppings were green and black olives, mushrooms and sweet peppers. I don't if the peppers or the olives were in Vinegar for too long they had this our taste that did not go well. The large pizza size was pretty large compared to the large I tried in the other pizza place...but the taste was no way close to what we had from the other place. I am not sure if I wanted to go back to Mayback's again. But do definitely check out the specials that they have with the Subs and pepperoni's pizza Cheers! read more

I go on my lunch break at times to get a slice of pizza for me and my co-worker. We both like to try new places or go to places we know for good pizza. What a let down this last time. The dough does not look like real pizza dough. Looks like conveyor belt Pizza. Even the appearance was not at all appetizing. I do not see us ordering from here again. read more

This is one of my favorite places to order wings and pizza from. I like them so much because they make the wings to specification. I love extra crispy wings and they never disappoint when indicated. Delivery is pretty quick as well. Really enjoy them. read more

I've passed by this place for over a year, matter of fact I live around the corner. I finally decided to give it a try and the pizza was absolutely delicious, and the ham sub was great. The server greeted me when I walked in and was extremely helpful, it is also a deli and the place was clean, I highly recommend giving this place a try you will not be disappointed. read more

I've passed this place in the plaza countless times and every time I do, I tell myself "Next time, I'm going to try there for pizza." And of course I forget. I finally remembered it today and got a pizza. I must say it's delicious. I don't like really saucy pizza, so this one was perfect for me. Cooked perfectly as well! read more

Was driving by and was hungry, popped in just to see what they had and was instantly greeted by a warm hello and smile. From there the service only got better! The sub I had (the stinger) was the best sub i've had in a while and highly suggest the garlic parm fingers on it for added flavor. overall 5/5, Fat boy approved. read more