I always stop for a casa Italiano when I'm in the area. I love the combination of ingredients the hot/bbq "fajita" sauce, the spicy cherry peppers, pepperoni, chicken and various cheeses are just delicious. The pizza is just as good. The Western Cheddar is my favorite specialty pizza. I do wish they had coke products, but that's just my personal taste. read more

Edie's Pizza is fantastic! This is my destination pizza and worth it everytime. All of the ingredients are great and their crust is yummy - like a fresh hot loaf of baked bread with a delightful, crisp crunch and wonderful flavor. Not to thick or doughy or bland like some places. Yay Edie's for a consistent Buffalo style pizza! read more

Came in on a whim for dinner. Ordered the club salad to start, my husband ordered bacon cheeseburger sub and I got a chicken finger sub. Salad was good and he said his sub was good, but go somewhere else if you want to taste anything but bread for the chicken finger sub. 3 small, thin fingers that didn't even cover the roll. I forgot my phone so can only show you the half I brought home. Server was friendly and service was quick. Will stick with a Royal next time! read more

Edies Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Hamburg, New York

See all

Love this place! Their wings are always cooked to perfection. Their blue cheese and ranch is very delicious. The meat lovers Bambino is my favorite and don't forget the turkey sandwiches always delicious. read more

Had an amazing Chicken souvlaki sub yesterday! The chicken finger sub my gf got was delicious as well! Service was great. Lived that the younger kids working greeted us with a smile and wished us a good day on the way out. Place was really nice and clean. Plenty of seating and cool Buffalo sports memorabilia. I've had take out a few times but Dino g in was a treat! read more

I am almost certain everything I ate was thawed. Just bad all around. Also I asked for ranch and I was not provided ranch. Look, I get it when you have teenagers running the kitchen, but damn this was bad. :( read more

Order was ready on time, very hot. Wings were not soggy but still had good amount of sauce. Pizza as expected. We will return!

We order from Edie's pretty often. I will say, they could get more accurate with estimating when orders will be done. We always get there 5 minutes early compared to when they tell us our food will be done and sometimes it's already done, other times we have to wait a minute or two which is just perfect. We love the food, we're always really happy. Edie's might not be the cheapest around, but it's very consistently very good. I have gone to sit in the restaurant lots of times. It's a nice short order spot. They also keep the pick up area out of the dining area so if you need something you are not stuck in line or anything. read more

Very good pizza. Best crust around. I ordered 3 sheet pizzas, 50 wings and salad all very good. The owner or manager didn't like or think I needed help with the carry out. She even questioned my ability to need assistance. You can't always see that a person has a heart issue. Her attitude makes me question if she knows there are other great pizzas places in town. Again good food, lousy management. I will spend my $250 order elsewhere next time. read more

We stopped in to Edie's as a quick stop for me and my kids. Never heard of the place, but it was there when we needed food. Walking in, the aroma offers you a warm hug of anticipation. The host/order taker/server was extremely kind and professional. Two slice, a sub, and rings came out pretty slowly because everything seems made-to-order. Kids loved their cheese pizzas enough that I couldn't try a bite. The onion rings were filled with thick-cut Spanish onions- solid! The breading was a little too smooth for my liking, but the overall flavor of the rings were good enough to order a second time. The sausage sub was delicious, took me two meals to finish. Totally recommend coming here. read more

See all

We were nor happy with our take out fish fry yesterday. We get them often but this one had a smaller amount of coleslaw and and much smaller amount of fries . Why ??? read more

The pizza and wings are very good and always consistent!! Anytime someone has a party I recommend getting their party food from here.

I love this place. The food came out fast although the workers seemed a little young for my liking. But other than that the employees were very kind and the vibes had my aura spiking. 5/5 will come again due to the tuff food options. read more

We recently moved to Hamburg from Kenmore and have been trying the various buffalo style pizza spots and have found Edie's to be our go to here in Hamburg. They pizza is a solid choice with a nice fluffy crust and awesome crusty/crunchy crust. Their wings are also really good. We've only tried the hot, but they had a good sauce and good size wing. I wish they were just a touch more crispy. read more

The wings were HUGE! Cooked perfectly! Sauced to perfection! The veggies were large, crisp and fresh! The bleu cheese was thick and chunky! The pizza was flavorful, they remembered our side of oregano. It was tasty, but their crust is not my favorite type. It was thin and chewy, and perfectly baked. I just prefer I lighter crust with a crisp shell. It wouldn't deter me from returning. The CS was wonderful! The delivery was fast! I can't wait to try more of their menu! read more

Ordered a large cheese / pepperoni pizza to go. We had to wait when picking it up since it seemed busy but only a few minutes. The pizza was well done as we asked for and was delicious. We will absolutely order again! read more

Edies Pizza - Well done large pizza - Pizza Near Me - Hamburg, New York

Nice convenient location in Hamburg - easy in and out. Good menu with lots of choices. Dine in area available as well - but we usually do pickup. Even on a busy night they get the food out quick! read more

Shawn's Pizza Reviews REVIEW # 24 EDIE'S PIZZA & SUBS BUFFALO ST. HAMBURG, NY SCORE 7.8 Nice large pizzeria located directly on a roundabout in the town of Hamburg. Very friendly staff with a dine-in area. The pizza has a great taste. It was a bit too greasy though, pouring off the slice as I tried to eat it. I do slightly prefer Nino's which is a few blocks away, but Edie's can definitely give them a run for their money! read more

Edies Pizza - a pepperoni pizza in a box - Pizza Near Me - Hamburg, New York

i am disgusted with this worker, bri. i called to see for a delivery question and got called "babe". this was very unprofessional. i could tell i was talking to a teenager. a simple question was asked and i got nothing but attitude. i'm very disappointed with this. I have always gotten such good service at edies until this. read more

Good food although I find the prices are a little high , the pizza is good but not worth the price

We've only had the pizza at Edie's since we've moved to Hamburg so I cannot comment on the other menu items. First time it was Chicken & Spinach pizza, which was similar to a white pizza but with, you guessed it, chicken and spinach, and also feta cheese, so it had a Greek element. Very good. Second pizza was a regular old Cheese & Pepperoni, which was also very solid. We especially enjoyed the light, somewhat fluffy crust with just a light chew to it. The girls working the counter were pleasant. We'll be looking forward to more pizzas from Edie's in the near future. read more

It took over 30 minutes to get two slices of cheese pizza. No one provided an explanation.

This is our favorite pizza place. They make a great regular pizza, but also a gluten free pizza for my wife. The also take request, such as not adding cheese as my wife is also dairy sensitive. read more

enjoyed their pizza but found the quality inconsistent and on last order found hair on top of pizza

A staple pizza place in the southtowns! Service was fast and friendly, they are staying smart and strict with their Covid-19 rules. Social Distancing is created in their dining room and hand sanitizer is provided as well. Of course the food tastes amazing and they have daily specials!! I highly recommend and always bring mg out of state family here for some Buffalo Wings!! Also, the decorating each season is phenomenal and really brings me joy. read more

See all

We ordered a sub party platter and a wrap party platter it was great! It came with so many containers of toppings we loved it. It was delivered about 5 min early so the delivery man brought everything upstairs he got a good tip! We'll definitely order for a party again. read more

The quality of the food really depends on what you get. Their pizza is average, their chicken finger sub is totally really good but then their salads are absolutely awful. The other day I ordered a chicken souvlaki salad with extra chicken, cost me $14 and after a couple bites I threw the whole thing out. It was made up of white iceberg lettuce and that fake bagged chicken (you know, the kind that's slimey and feels like rubber). It was possibly the worst salad I've ever had and resulted in my need to update my review. The last time we ordered chicken finger subs they werent very good either. Idk if something is going on with this place lately but I'm less than impressed. read more

Edies Pizza - Awful chicken souvlaki - Pizza Near Me - Hamburg, New York

Their food is fairly consistent. Perhaps I am just picky, but while their food is edible, I personally prefer another pizza place down the street. Good chicken finger subs and salads. I believe they have good lunch specials too. read more

I enjoy the subs from Edie's pizza has gone downhill this used to be our number 1 place to go would order about once a week however on more than one occasion I listened to the owner talk down to his employees which was completely unnecessary and also gave my wife a attitude when she mentioned that our order was wrong the previous time we were there asking if we were looking for a handout read more

Great food great service can't go wrong here white pizza the best All around the Buffalo area read more

I was up for the summer from Florida, we had Edies Pizza twice and both times they were so good, I would say the best pizza I have ever had. Cheese was to the edge which most other places I have not had that pleasure. Wish I could bring it with me. read more

Never had beef on weck pizza before but this is the bomb! I could have eaten the whole pizza by myself. Also had delicious hot barbecued wings a couple of them were a little overdone but for the most part delicious read more

Got a slice of C&P and an order of charbroiled BBQ wings... Pizza was OK.. Pepperoni was curl and char but the wings were awful... I asked for X-crispy... They were not X-crispy and on top of that they were hardly charbroiled... They also used a ton of BBQ sauce so it made some of them soupy... Some of the wings were actually soft and mushy... Totally gross... For as much as these places charge for wings nowadays and the fact that this is a Buffalo pizzeria there is no excuse... 1 star.. I also asked the girl working if the meatballs were homemade as I was considering a meatball sub but she said she has no idea as she doesn't work in the kitchen....my guess is they are not considering how they could care less how their wings are served. read more

Edies Pizza - Supposed to be charred and X-crispy... Just the opposite. - Pizza Near Me - Hamburg, New York

See all

the pizza was very good-the antipasto salad one of the best-and I had a royal sub with mayo that was excellent! the wings were hot but not quite crispy enough! read more

I love Edie's, I've been coming here for many years, and now I basically live next door after my recent move. Their fries are fantastic, some of the best around. Battered and fried to perfection! I enjoy their pizza a lot as well, simple cheese and pepperoni tastes great, and the specialty pizzas are also top notch. I'm not a huge fan of subs/hoagies in general, never have been. However, I may have to try a couple of Edie's subs - that's apparently what they're known for. They may change my mind . The inside is a nice atmosphere, lots of local flair. I mainly do take-out since I live so close, but I did notice the dining area adheres to social distancing/requires customers to wear masks when not eating. Masks are required on the take-out side as well, 6 feet marked on the ground. read more

We Love Edies. From the pizza to the subs. Always good. But I have discovered the best yet. Cauliflower pizza crust. Have had it twice. The best Cauliflower crust pizza I have ever had. So good. You would not know it is a Cauliflower crust. Ordered it twice now. So good. read more

Pizza is amazing. And the buffalo chicken fingers are straight it still for. On those cheat days get yourself some Eddie! My go to pizza place in Hamburg. read more

Edies Pizza - Food so good it's already gone - Pizza Near Me - Hamburg, New York

Several times my orders were not ready and I had to wait over 30 minutes for my food. Even though I ordered hours ahead of time online. I seen them make my order when I came to pick it up. Don't bother with this place they are disorganized and cannot handle their volume of orders. I noticed every other person coming in picking up a take out order was waiting. Lastly, the crew working are not wearing any gloves, washing their hands or taking any sanitary measures when preparing your food. read more

Edie's pizza is located in Hamburg across from Nick Charlap's! Parking is what it is. It's not always the most safe pulling in and out of the parking lot because it's located on a roundabout, just be ware. Their service is fast and their employees are friendly and the prices are reasonable. Their pizza is cooked to perfection but I personally go there for their subs! My favorite specialty sub is the Kaleta club! Named after former Buffalo Sabers hockey player Patrick Kaleta! You gotta try it! read more

Edies Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Hamburg, New York

What a bummer. We used to love Edies but their management, quality control and lack of professionalism from their employees are Lacking for a while. Pizza is good ONLY IF they are Actually listening to what you're ordering. Lots and lots of mistakes over the years. we have LOTS of options here in Hamburg and quite frankly EXPECT MORE from a "family owned" local business. Very disappointing. read more