Not my favorite place personally, but my dad likes to stop here before Bulls games and it's his tab so his choice of course. Everything is just kind of "ok". That's the best way I can describe it. And by everything, I've only had what my dad orders which is the pizza and wings. I would definitely like my wings much crispier and a thicker sauce with more of a wow factor. Not a horrible place or anything, just not my favorite. read more

See all

Good food at reasonable price. Royal sub was really good. Friendly people and clean place.

Prices keep going up, quality keeps going down. I agree with a lot of the other reviews. They are meat skimpers. Go down the street to John's and pay the $1 more and get an actual SUB. Not a 10inch roll with hardly any meat on it. read more

This location has the worst customer service of any restaurant i've been to since covid. Their hours are inconsistent. They say open 11-close but closing is at their discretion. We walked in last night at 635pm after calling to verify they were open and the server told us that only cold items were available as they had already shut all of their equipment off. Even the phone call to inquire if they were open resulted in the owner barking at us. This is the 4th time we have had a bad experience. One time we were approaching the door and an employee looked at us, locked the door and smirked, turned around and walked away. We live around the corner, love their subs, but between the cleanliness (lack of) and service (lack of) we will not be back. read more

I'm fairly sure this place hasn't changed since I was a kid. And thank goodness for that. They make the best subs and they're always consistent - they will taste exactly as you expect every single time. My go to has always been the turkey sub but they're all good. They use the best rolls that's are toasted to crispy, golden perfection. The fried apps are all good too: onion rings, fries. read more

John & Mary's - Turkey sub with mayo. - Fast Food Near Me - Getzville, New York

LOVE THIS PLACE!! Back in the day this place used to be full. Times man. You can still find it actively busy every lunch with online orders and people sitting for lunch. Probably the best Turkey sub you can get around. If you're ever at that corner, and you're thinking BK..... change your mind and go to John and Mary's! Shop and support Local!! read more

See all

November 10th 2025, today I had a most pleasant experience. I went to John and Mary's a bomb subs for the very first time. I had a whole assorted sub. My companion had the eggplant parm sub. The construction of the sub was superb. It can only be called constructed because it was put together. Not throwing together it was neat and appearance the flavors blended nicely and there was ample amount to have made a second sub from what was there. The staff were positively fantastic. Polite, courteous, and businesslike all-in-one. And Care was taken to ensure every customer had a pleasant experience the building is well ordered. There is ample seating for those wanting to eat in, and the takeout orders we're done promptly. Music appropriate to the season was playing. The booths and table tops or clean and neat as well as pleasing to the appearance. The the restrooms were clean, stock with soap and paper towels with clean floors and no odors. We were afforded ample time to eat and our leisure and enjoy our meal. We took no beverages with our subs. Yet the amount of oil and or mayo on our selections with sufficient that a beverage was not needed. Since we were eating in, our order was on a tray which was clean. Is sufficient supply of napkins was provided for wiping of face, hands and the table top as we took so long eating and enjoying our meal that the oil from both of our subs penetrated the plate they were served on. The overall appearance was pleasing to the eye and general atmosphere enjoyable. I look forward to going back there as does my companion. Prices were in keeping with the industry, but definitely not over the top considering the amount of food that was provided. I highly recommend this business to any who fashion themselves sub sandwich aficionados! Lloyd R. Sikorski, Buffalo, New York read more

Good quick lunch! Nice people, good service, did the trick! Clean and simple seating. Plenty of seating. read more

John & Mary's - Stinger - Fast Food Near Me - Getzville, New York

A Simple Sub but simply the best! I'm a huge fan of their legendary A Bomb but the also have the best ham sub hands down. Provolone cheese, un-shredded lettuce (refreshing for a change) and old school oil and vinegar complete this beauty! Try one today and tell them that Gary Z sent you! read more

John & Mary's - Best ham sub ever! - Fast Food Near Me - Getzville, New York

See all

We always visit John & Mary's when in Buffalo! Best food and service ever! Hope to move back to Buffalo and become a regular local. Thank you for all you do and such amazing food! read more

John & Mary's - Chicken Finger Sub - Fast Food Near Me - Getzville, New York

My first dining in experience since COVID 19 started. Reasonable food prices, clean dining area, all recommended guidelines were followed. Ordered a mini turkey sub, medium loganberry, sweet potato fries. read more

John & Mary's - First Dine in lunch sweet potato fries, mini turkey, and medium loganberry. - Fast Food Near Me - Getzville, New York

The abomb was delicious with the addition of 1/2 green peppers fried with 1/2 hot peppers and exra hotsauce. Very much love John & Marys homemade hot sauce. That in itself is a reason to keep returning! Staff is always accommodating and friendly. Takeout order prepared quickly. read more

Just think of only kids running a restaurant and you pegged John and Mary's on Transit rd, Lancaster, NY This was many years ago the place to go for subs. WTH Happened to this place. Dirty, dirty dirty and food that is not that good. Wish I could say better things about John and Mary's but it's not what I was used to back in the day. read more

John and Mary were my aunt and uncle, and I grew up on John and Mary's so please excuse me for being a tiny bit biased The owners of this location are my cousins. They've taken great care to maintain the family recipes and the food tastes just as good today as it did when I was a teenager. I love our local hot sauces: Ted's. Louis'. The hot sauce here has more zing than the others. Give it a try! They have real French fries made of potatoes that weren't contaminated with MSG, strange crispy coatings or sodium levels that will make you visit your cardiac specialist. The fries are done just right on the outside, while the inside is soft, smooth, and flavorful. My only complaint is that I can't stop eating them once I get started. The Italian sausage is the wonderful Sicilian style Buffalo is used to having. It isn't the bland stuff you find in other cities. Capocollo. Fresh. Spicy. It's the real deal. Try this on your next sub. If you're Italian you'll love it. The rolls are also Buffalo style sub rolls - soft and delicious. I remember Uncle John using our family to test various pizza sauce recipes. He refused to sell any pizza until he had the recipe just right. I got to test a lot of good pizza. I think he got it right. Have some and write a review on Yelp. read more

John & Mary's - Capacollo mini with my favorite French fries. - Fast Food Near Me - Getzville, New York

John & Mary's has been my go-to sub source lately. My order is always correct and placing an order by phone is easy. Friends love the battered mushrooms, but the meatless sub (with cheese, please) is my standard order. It reminds me of how subs used to taste. It can't hurt that John & Mary's uses Costanzo's sub rolls. I'm hooked. read more

Man I love this place everyone is so nice and food is great! They work extremely fast and the food was done within seconds!!!! I highly recommend this place to everyone who asks me read more

Good food Great service food was done quick and efficiently. I would recommend going there again. read more

A great place for a very casual meal or takeout. Very reasonably priced and we have been frequenting them for years. Locally owned and operated, not a franchise. read more

Pizza here is absolute dog shit. Like cafeteria food, or a lunch-able. Cheese was bland and had no flavor, crust was dry and hard, pepperoni wasn't even cooked into the pizza. It was like they took a few pepperoni and put it on a slice of the cheese then cooked it in the microwave hoping it would stick. I also caught two or three flies swarming the inside. But I guess I shouldn't expect much from a place where the staff was all kids 16-17 years old. Never coming here again. read more

Driven past this and many other locations many times and I never had a chance to stop in and try a sub. Dad wanted to head here for lunch on Saturday so I figured let's give it a shot. I ordered a turkey and ham full size sub and it was surprisingly good for a simple sandwich. They had tasty fresh bread and yummy cold cuts and veggies. They've got a nice selection of different hot and cold sandwiches, burgers, and other grill foods. I think they even do breakfast sandwiches! Nice lunch spot, if I worked closer I'd stop in more often for something! read more

One of my favorite subs in the world. I always go to John and Marys when I visit buffalo. read more

John & Mary's - Fast Food Near Me - Getzville, New York

I stopped for lunch today to grab a couple of ham subs for lunch for my wife and I. Their subs are my favorite quick lunch to go. Any sub you want, you can build it to your liking. A word of caution: they toast the buns which brings out the superness of them. So if you are one of those au natural folks who like your buns as they came from the baker.....let them know! Picked up a pizza and wings after the game today. Take a look at the pictures this has to be one of the best pizzas I've had in western New York. It had a super nice cheesy thick yeasty crust and the sausd and cheese was great. Wings too from John & Mary's are usually very very good. Today was no exception very nice wings. Nice when they're cooked just the way you want them and they're not overcooked. read more

See all

SAD. Long time customer of J/M from different locations. Haven't been in a while because I don't live near any, but made the drive to the one on Millersport this Saturday evening. Ordered two royals and we were really sorry I took the time to go there. The subs had half slices of tomatoes, onions were difficult to see and the lettuce was just as scarce. Spent $38 with a side order also, and we were very disappointed in our choice of this place to spend our dollars. I don't know what happened to J/M but this was really disappointing. You guys were better than that. read more

I've been eating John and Marys subs since I was a kid (so now.. at least 15 years), and they are the best tasting subs I've experienced. I always make sure to get one of these when I'm in town (have now moved away from Buffalo). Their mozzarella sticks are great (and large/cheesy) too. read more

I am not a local but I have been coming to this John and Mary's since 2012. We would make it a point to order a sub every time we were visiting my husband's family. It truly feels like a warm family owned business and I do believe that the same woman has taken my order every single time. FOOD: Even though J&M's has a great selection of subs the hubby and I always get the turkey with mayo and no tomatoes. I have also tried the meatball and chicken fingers sub. If you don't eat meat I also went through a phase of marinara and cheese on a bun. The bread is delicious! I could honestly eat each of the ingredients individually. J&M's uses delicious ingredients to make the perfect sub. We also like to share an order of motzerella sticks. The batter is smooth and fried to a perfectly thin crust over a thumbs with of cheese. read more

Had a taste for a Royal sub , came with 1 thin layer of sausage worst sub I ever had from there it use to be good. I am now a fan of Jersey Mikes Subs. Ok Royal Sub read more

Web sight says open, drove all the way there and they are closed. Nothing more to say, bye bye.

I agree with the previous poster - keep driving down the road. If you want hot subs, go to Jim's Steakout. If you want pizza, go to Franco's. I visited the John and Mary's on Niagara Falls Boulevard, and it wasn't much of an improvement. My boyfriend and I have ordered subs and pizza there, which were both mistakes. The hot subs are okay, but nothing to write home about. You can get better value for the money somewhere else *cough* Jim's Steakout *cough*. The pizza isn't any better. The sauce wasn't very good, and there was way too much of it. Also, the pizza that I ordered was burned. I want my crust to be crispy, not charcoal. Their menu has a lot to offer, but every single item is overpriced. For the money John & Mary's charges, their service should be quicker. Losing the Fox News on the tv's would have helped my meal go down a little easier too. read more

Order wings from Sheridan Rd location and the Buffalo Wings were amazing. The next day went to the Millersport location and the wings were WEAK!!!! They forgot to put sauce in my wings. Who does that???? read more

John & Mary's - Weak no sauce wings!!!! - Fast Food Near Me - Getzville, New York

Quick dinner for 2 - $9 for a full sub that can easily be divided. Their tuna is simple and delicious. Friendly staff and very clean.

A dive, but this place makes the best subs on the planet. The royal with oil and mayo is pure heaven! A Buffalo must and tradition for my family!!!! read more

So if you place a lunch order for pick up because you only get 30 min for lunch, why would you have to stand in a 12 people deep line ordering food when my order was called in and sitting on the shelf getting cold! I said something and her response " we are short staffed so stand in line like everyone else". Thankfully everyone in line heard her and told me to go ahead and cash out! As I left I thanked everyone in line and told the woman her attitude sucks and she said " yeah so do you". Last time I go to John and Mary's on Millersport! read more

After all the years that I have been going to John & Mary's the subs are the same and taste great. Their super royal is fantastic. Another great item is their Friday fish fry. The fish is so big it doesn't fit on the plate. Every item is above most other restaurants read more

Decided to stop in with a friend for lunch. The lady who took my order was very nice & helpful with ordering my turkey sub. Since they don't have miracle whip I opted for their oil since the lady raved on how good it was and how flavorful it was. I waited about 5 mins for my sub. When my # was called, I went up to the counter and I was very disappointed when I saw it. It had barely anything on it! I wish I had remembered to take a picture. There was may be 2 slices of turkey on it, like 2 little scraps of lettuce and a small piece of cheese. It had no flavor either! I had to go back up and get A side vinegar. I won't be going back here again, especially since I paid $10 for a thin, empty, flavorless sub and a drink! read more

This is a solid mom&pops fast-foodish place. Came here for lunch, ordered few simple things from the menu and enjoyed most of it. Im giving this place a 3 as they totally lack any beatification and believe function-in-all approach. Another major downside is that they do not accept AMEX and do not have any signs on that. Finally tables feel like they came from 70s and average overweight american just wont be able to fit there. I'd come back if I was in the immediate area and felt like getting that belly-buster & had cashe. Other than that - go to the burrito place around the corner. read more

Had a chicken finger sub here the other week, and ordered in restaurant for take-out which I HATE because usually that means sitting around for 20 minutes. Not here, the pretty girls worked dilligently to get me my food quickly. When I ate it, I was even happier. Nicely crisp chicken fingers, good blue cheese, good sauce flavor, good roll, good price. One of the best sub places around. read more

Love this place!! They have good food and their subs are the best. Highly recommend the Royal Sub!! Staff is friendly and the wait to get food is never too long. read more

I ordered a half-size turkey sub for a quick lunch before getting back on the road, and it really hit the spot! The sandwich came on a smallish toasted roll (which was a pleasant suprise, when i felt that the sandwich was warm it was nice on a cooler day like today.) The lettuce was crispy and the tomatos were perfectly ripe. They don't really give you many options for customization, but for a quick, no-brainer kind of sandwich, John & Mary's was the perfect choice. read more

This place has terrible customer service. And when I say terrible .... I mean like I've never seen before. Today in line for lunch I witnessed the woman at the counter completely take out her frustration of being short handed on the customers. This was a real turn off. I tried calling them after to left and asked to speak with a manager.....the woman I was speaking to must have been the one who was at the counter. Ended my call with her telling me she was the owner and they have been in business so long that losing me as a customer is not really a big deal. That's just horrible. read more

Our family left Buffalo years ago. The fist food stop when we come back to town is J&M's for a Royal with Oil. My Aunt comes all the way from Hawaii! read more