Great food and friendly staff they treat you like family. The new building has so much more to offer the customers. I would highly recommend Joe's. read more

The new look of the store is absolutely BEAUTIFUL. I ordered a turkey bacon sub, a pep calzone, and loaded fries. Absolutely delicious. The aroma of the calzone filled the car as I drove home. Staff was extremely welcoming and understood my very particular sub order. So glad to have you guys back! read more

Joe's Pizza - Turkey bacon sub, calzone, and loaded fries. - Pizza Near Me - Whitehall, New York

See all

Guy making the pizzas was profusely sweating and eating handfuls of fried food over the pies.

Everything could improve before they closed we used to eat their three sometimes four nights a week and now the place is super expensive. The prices have almost doubled, and the amount of food they give you they lie to you. I ordered an order of jalapeño poppers, and they told me I would get eight I got three they told us that we would get six boneless wings. We got three a small pile of clams and four breaded mushrooms in their appetizer platter and it used to be $11 for five items now it's 19 for four and it's not even enough to feed two people. It's horrible what they've done with that place. The first night we ordered we ordered two pieces of haddock dinner. I asked the lady what the price would be. She told me it was $32 when it came to my door, it was 45. The second time we ordered they told me it would be $29 when it came to my door. It was $51. If their staff doesn't know what they're doing then they need to hire different staff. They're lying about the prices and they don't tell you the truth till they're at your door and the food's already there and you can't you can't turn it away because it's already there and then they lied to you about the amount of food you're gonna get we know Joe personally and we like Joe, but that business is going to fail if he keeps going the way he's going the only reason he's doing good right now is because everybody waited an anticipated so long for him to open but the way it's being Ran and the prices. I thought McDonald's prices went up and was expensive but honestly, I think it's cheaper for a family of four to eat at McDonald's than it is at Joe's Pizza in White Hall, New York. Even if you go to Burger King and you go online and use their coupon for $20 you get too long chicken sandwiches two cheeseburgers 24 packs of chicken McNuggets four french fries and four soft drinks and after the tax it comes to $29 I'm sadly disappointed so no I don't think I personally maybe other people in my house will order off them but me personally I'm done with them until they can get their shit together. Figure out their prices and stop lying to people about how much food you're gonna get and how much it cost then I'm not interested and I don't recommend anyone else. Go there either cause you'll be sadly disappointed their fish sandwich they had egg sandwich was disgusting. It was expensive and it said it came with chips and we never even got any chips he should just stick to selling marijuana for the government. read more

It's our first trip up to our place on northern Lake George this year, yay. After an eerily calm drive from NJ (the traffic was free flowing and the Thruway rest areas were nearly devoid of cars on a summer Saturday afternoon), we figured we'd arrive giving my sister and nephew the best gift of all: pizza! Joe's does it as well as ever. Plenty of material is applied atop the pie and at $1 for most selections, feel free to load yours up! The pie is made slightly thicker than "real" NY style but is still very good. I'm sure you could ask for it well-done if you wanted a char or more crisp in the bite. The staff is friendly and prepared the order (2 XL pies each with 3 different toppings meat/veggies) perfectly. The ratios of cheese:sauce:toppings melt together in perfect harmony for a delightful experience. Another plus: we were quoted 40 minutes time to pick up and it was finished in about 35. For COVID, everyone was masked and there's a clear "no mask, no service" sign displayed. They do have some outdoor seating and the table where you pick up is just past the front door, so you avoid going far inside. Joe's has the best pizza in town at very fair prices. $34.95 to avoid cooking and keep us satiated is a hell of a way to kick off this week of "lake life," "live love lake" and lots of other homegoods clearance aisle design platitudes. read more

See all

I always stop here before driving over the mountain on my way to the Lake. Sometimes they take awhile (even for like one slice of cheese pizza) but it's worth the wait. Sometimes the workers swear at each other trying to get me the pizza - which I find so New York and hilarious. Pizza is on point. read more

Joe's Pizza - 'One' slice of cheese pizza - Pizza Near Me - Whitehall, New York

On vacation from outside the area, we ordered a large pizza from Joe's. Surprised to say it was the best pizza I have had since I moved away from my hometown 6 years ago. We found it to be just perfect. Cooked perfect. Great amount of toppings without being too much. Very very pleased. Definitely recommend. read more

I just ordered a pistachio soft serve in a cup. The girl gives me soft serve that is 99% white and tells me it's pistachio. I told her this is vanilla and I tasted it. She didn't really help me, to the point where I just gave them back the ice cream and took the loss with my money. Will not come here again!!! read more

Best pizza around for sure !! Very big menu and they food almost never disappoints, very friendly staff just overall an awesome place

Pit-stop dinner on our way to visit camp! It's a family-owned joint that delivers yummy, very simple food. The owner was super friendly and I was chatting with him and the kitchen staff, asked for a garlic knot while we waited, and he gave me one for free :) My friends and I were pleased!! read more

Awesome pizza! My favorite, love their wings as well! Also love the deal of buy 8 lg/xlg pizzas you get one free. Enjoying my free pizza right now! read more

Joe's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Whitehall, New York

Joe has awesome pizza, wings and more. We had him cater our event at the golf course and that was awesome too. Even with all the restrictions NYS is putting on restaurants- he has stayed open and served our small community in many ways. Thanks Joe! read more

My family ordered pizza here a few years ago, it was going to lower Bellamy st in Whitehall. When we got it the one pizza was so doughy my parents couldn't eat it because of how raw the pizza was. The pizza my siblings and I had was too and I was the only one who had the 2 done pieces. It took them roughly 2 hours to deliver to us and our appetizers were a huge disappointment. Everyone got sick or felt ill other then me the night it had happened. They all ended up puking. Their pizza is so greasy you can take multiple paper towels to it and still be able to see the grease. It's disgusting. Only pizza I will eat from there was deep dish and even that is over priced and greasy and nasty. Don't eat here. Please for your sake and your family you're better going to the rail yard or having a frozen store pizza, Stewart's or going to Vermont for McDonald's. read more

While working on a movie in Hullett's Landing I had the pleasure of working with Joe's pizza and his fantastic attentive crew. I was in charge of ordering food for 70 people with a very hectic schedule and twice they provided food for us without flinching at the party size. Kayleigh was especially amazing as she would meet me halfway with these large orders. The pizza was huge and everyone raved about "upstate NY" pizza being soooo good (most people were from the city:) !! You must try the veggie pizza when you visit and I'm usually a meat lovers girl. I also ordered from their BBQ joint first day of shooting. We had pulled pork sandwiches with fresh rolls, macaroni and cheese, baked beans and broccoli crunch salad with bacon. ALL of it was delicious! Thank you for helping me feed my hungry crowd! I will be back to visit. read more

You would be better off buying a frozen pizza!!!!! The Pizza is greasy !!! I mean real bad!!!! It's the result of very cheap ingredients!!! Do not go to the run down junkyard!! And I did bring the two pizzas back and told him what I thot !!! He said he sells 600 pizzas week what a lying joke. BEWARE!!!!! read more

My family and I were having a celebration and ordered 3 dozen BONLESS wings. Once I got my order home opened it to find CHICKEN TENDERS!!!! When I called up I just assumed there was a mistake and kindly called advising and then was told no my order was correct. When I said I didn't ask for tenders the girl responded well that is what OUR boneless wings are. I said then you should have a full disclosure when someone orders the wings. She then proceeded to tell me that it wasn't HER PROBLEM that I didn't ask!!!!! Are you kidding me?!?!? She then also said that if I hadn't order there before that I should be asking.I even looked at the website and they have a picture of BONLESS WINGS with the order option complete and udder poor service with miss representation and false advertising!! I wasted 40 dollars and they will never have my service again!! read more

Awesome pizza place, handmade pies and amazing pizza rolls and party sized Stromboli. read more

Joe's Pizza - Putorti's pizza on top Joe's pizza on bottom (sides of ranch dressing) Judge for yourselves. - Pizza Near Me - Whitehall, New York

After my horrible experience with slice of pizza, i gave this joint a shit that night. The people were great, I felt welcomed and they informed me how long it would take. I order a large pizza with peppers and onions and a large wing medium. I'm a big wing person, but sadly the best ones I've tasted were my own. I only waited 20 minutes and it was a great price for both! So, my fiancée and i dove in. The sauce. .. tabby abs a bit of heat. The cheese is perfect and stringy with each bite. The dough was good and crunchy. The wings. ..i loved them. I devoured each and every one. Mind you i sometimes eat the bone. . In this case i did. Great place, also the liquor store behind them. .. They know me by heart now. Great place. read more

I have eaten pizza here twice visiting my old home town ware I grew up with Joe the owner. And this by far is the best pizza I have eaten in up state N.Y. I now live in the Boston area in MA. Every time I travel up here this is ware I always stop for dinner!! read more

Best pizza in the area! My wife and I always get the pizza, wings, calzones and or Stromboli. We moved from Whitehall but will still drive a half hour and bring it home. Joe truly knows how to make a pizza. Best in the area! read more

Best pizza in the area as well as the best service as well! My wife and I am moved here in January and are so glad that we have found this gem here in Whitehall! read more

Pizzas good. But the appetizers are just ok. My biggest issue is the customer service and the overall behavior of the staff. While waiting for our order, the workers were swearing which really doesn't create a great atmosphere even if they were in good spirits. read more

Pizza's are always burnt, delivery shows up an hour or two later unless you live in the village. I used to love this place not anymore. Now any other restaurant in town is better than Joe's. read more

We have been getting Joe's Pizza, Subs, and Calzones for years. His food is great and the atmosphere is friendly and fun. Definitely worth a stop. read more

Joe's Pizza used to be my go to Pizza Parlor in Whitehall. The last 2 times I ordered, the dough is no longer the same. It is thicker and not as good. Very disappointing. read more

I have bought wings, pizza, and subs from Joe's for many years. The food is great. I recommend the 50 wings value. Occasionally a mistake is made due to high business volume but always Joe makes things right with the customer. It can be exciting in the kitchen but that is part of the large personality Joe's Pizza delivers. read more

tried calling for hours, they quoted me an hour and a half wait time for delivery and when they showed up i received an empty pizza box, when i called the shop to talk to someone in charge i was verbally abused like it was my fault they brought an empty box... i read other reviews and i am not alone.... no thanks read more