Disappointing to say the least. Ordered the South of the Border WITH pepperoni (along with two other pizzas AND an antipasto salad); PAID for the add-on of pepperoni, but they didn't put any on the pizza. Asked for Balsamic for the Salad. They gave me Italian. Really no excuse for not getting an order correct especially since it's right there on the order. Especially when ur spending over $100 on pizza. read more

I've never eaten inside, only used take out but the pizza is OK. It's a thinner style pizza with a decent amount of pizza 'greese' on it. This wouldn't be my go-to spot for pizza since there are many other great options in the area. The mozzarella sticks here are amazing though! read more

Such a wonderful little shop in Redlands! This curious little spot is the home to some of the best pizza in town. We did have to wait a pretty long time for the raviolis and pizza BUT it was so worth it. Their pizza was so good! Raviolis were requested with an Alfredo sauce and the extra buttery bread it came with was to die for! Parking is rough but it you don't mind the walk this is the perfect little spot. Enjoy! read more

Jerseys Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Redlands, California

Delicious classic pizza. The cheese was gooey and stretchy, the crust was so good and flavorful. Nice crisp but with a chewy middle. The vibe was so retro. I felt like I was a high school kid again having a pizza date with my husband. Great place to eat. You won't regret it read more

Used to love this place. We would go sit at the bar and service was great. This time around it Took around 40-45 mins to get food and in between that time the server came up to ask if we were good one time. No refill on drinks. Looked back and seen like 3 employees chilling on their phones. Ended up just asking to get the pizza to go. Food is good but that service needs work. read more

The pizza never disappoints. The crust is perfectly cooked with generous toppings. I highly recommend read more

TERRIBLE!!! I used to LOVE Jerseys pizza. Actually, it was the best pizza I've found in my many years in California. Well, now, not so much. They recently sold and I just had my last pizza there. The recipe has ABSOLUTELY changed and the pizza is NOT EVEN CLOSE to what it was. Much less cheese, and I ordered EXTRA sauce like always and there was almost no sauce. The crust, which is very important, is different, too. The service was also bad. There were just two kids working - they looked like they were in their teens and had no business being left alone to work. I was put on hold and had to hang up and call back and put on hold again. Then, when I got there I had to wait 20 minutes longer than they said it would be. Bottom line - the pizza is NOT NEARLY the same as it was. NOT EVEN CLOSE. I'll give them a few months and I guarantee they will be closed. read more

Love the pizza and the garlic bread is outstanding. I look forward to trying their other dishes read more

Excellent pizza! Ordered takeout. 1/25/26 Spicy chicken & pepperoni. Took about 40 minutes but that is expected when it's made from scratch.

Horrible experience! Only minorities in the place and took over 20 minutes to give me NOT EVEN WHAT I ORDERED. Never offered a solution to their own problem. As a first time customer, I will NEVER be back! read more

The pasta combo came with a large garlic bread and dinner salad for $15! Pretty good amount of food! The meat sauce was delicious! So good with the garlic bread! The garlic bread had a crispy crust and soft bread! Every bite was soo good! Jersey's pizza was yummy and fluffy! I like it when there is a crisp in the crust and the dough is soft! Very fresh out of the oven! The guy at the bar as really nice! He's so friendly and upbeat! Really good service and helpful! The ambiance is very relaxing! We sat st the bar and I love that there's a raised step for our feet! read more

Jerseys Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Redlands, California

See all

The quality of their pizza was STELLAR! The service was even better. My partner and I agree, this is by far the coolest spot in downtown Redlands. GT and Chris do their best to keep the environment friendly and fresh! We appreciate how easy it was to make convo with them and feel comfortable while enjoying great eats! read more

Don't go!! A complete waste of time. Went in, sat at the bar and the bartender told us that he was leaving and Cody would come take our order. No one came, as the staff was goofing off in the back. We and a table that came in after us, were waiting. A girl, who was more interested in folding boxes and goofing on with the guys in the back finally passed by us to give menus to a group that sat at a table. When she walked by again we asked if we could place an order. She started to take our order and for things we were ordering she stated we don't have that and that. We said OK we are out. She then gave us attitude which was totally disrespectful. This place has gone to hell. They are more interested in having their own fun in the back then serving the customers who come in and pay their wages Their is no management here and they don't give a crap. Don't stay in business if you don't have an eye on your customers. Get a clue!! Don't bother getting a pizza here, go a block away to Made from Scratch for better pizza and better employees who care about their customers. read more

4.5 STARS!!! This was my first time at this location and Wow! If you are looking for thick crust pizza made WELL, this is the PLACE! I am so impressed with the flavors of my Pesto + mushroom + green pepper pizza. It was DELICIOUS!!! Now keep in mind this place is pretty pricey. A SMALL pizza w/ 2 toppings + small soda cost me $20! (they also don't offer free refills on any drinks..even fountain soda cup -that's half ice- which I think is a bit ridiculous-hence the minus 0.5 star) But for the food itself, at least the pesto pizza, FIVE STARS!!!! (Note: if you're eating alone, the small pizza can give you about 2 meals because the slices are thick Vs the mini pizza which you'll likely finish on the spot. So if you want to take pizza leftovers home, consider the small+) The ambiance is very "moody, family bar" lol which sounds kinda strange but that's the best way I can describe it. Patrons of all ages were seated within the restaurant. There were also a lot of "regulars" who the workers could call by name, so that speaks volumes in and of itself. The workers themselves (though few) are very friendly! If you're starving and want your food within 5-10 mins, this may not be the spot for you. Because due to limited workers + everything being made on the spot- It takes quite a bit of time to get your food (which makes the no free refills even more unfortunate because likely you'd have finished the drink they gave you, before your pizza ever arrives) BUT if you're willing to wait, it is WORTH IT! Will definitely be returning! read more

See all

Great pizza, great service and always good vibes. Parking is available across the street behind the old railroad station.

Well I used to love this place but new ownership is unprofessional & inconsistent. The website says open at 11:30; I show up at 12 and a cheap unprofessional cardboard sign is taped in the window saying they open at 4pm. So after driving 45 minutes I will not be back to this place. The new ownership sucks. read more

Pizza was great! Had been a long time and it had the same great taste! Love it with cashews!

Very good pizza but if u don't like a lot of cheese ask if they can put a little less. I wish the made Stromboli's though lol

How can you go wrong with pizza on a busy and cold evening? So we ordered Jersey Pizza. This evening we had the Pepperoni with Linguica sausage. This is a thinner crust pie. The sauce is tangy. The pepperoni is savory and good salty. The Linguica is milder than Italian sausage, yet still is flavorful. While the pic is a bit dark, the pie wasn't burnt or over cooked. The Zita pasta was okay. This is veggies and pasta with olive oil. The veggies were fresh. We added more olive oil which helped in texture and flavor. read more

Jerseys Pizza - Pepperoni, Linguica pizza - Pizza Near Me - Redlands, California

See all

Nice pizza place in downtown Redlands. Pizza was good and garlic bread was tasty especially with the marinara sauce. Perfect for date night/family night read more

Jerseys Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Redlands, California

This is the second time in about two weeks my family has ordered pizza under the new ownership of this Redlands staple. Their pizza is as good as ever. We always order two pizzas and half order of the cheese bread w/marinara sauce. They make a special pizza just for my son with Alfredo sauce and chicken since he is not able to eat marinara sauce due to dietary limitations. The staff is polite and courteous and willing to do what ever it takes to make your dining or takeout experience the most pleasurable they can. Please tell your friends and family to come and check out the new and improved jerseys pizza. read more

Good place to come with friends and family, service was great and food was superb. I've tried the salads and pasta but today I had just a simple Pepperoni and sausage pizza. The crust was tasty! Should have order a bigger pizza! Thank you viv for making sure my beer and pop was filled! Thank you pizza dude in the back! Will come back fersure! read more

Jerseys Pizza - Good ole mini pizza after I wrecked that salad - Pizza Near Me - Redlands, California

See all

We had a girls lunch here and loved it. We had antipasto salad and cheesebread. Outstanding. Large portions with reasonable prices Will definitely be going back read more

Seriously Jersey's! These hours are terrible! People eat pizza for lunch you know! Loved your food, but no more lunch hours is a game changer! Especially on the weekends! Sad to see others say your food has degraded as well. Maybe that's the problem. Bad food, less customers, shorter hours ... We all know what's next. read more

Pizza? Great!...Apps? Great!...Brews? Great! Perfect location and a super friendly staff!

We've been hesitant to go with ownership changes but went when we traditionally go after certain activities. We went in October and felt it tasted different but thought maybe it was just an off day. Then went again this month to give them another try now I regret my choice as it was a waste of money. we called in our order and was told 30-35 minutes. it took an hour so my husband was there an extra 30 minutes. He brought the food home to realize half of it was burnt and also gave us only garlic bread Vs garlic cheese bread I ordered. My kids starving we werent going to take it back to wait another hour. so we cut off burnt pieces to try and salvage the pizza. I tried calling the next day because they were so busy and we were so hungry I didn't feel like waiting longer. they told me I couldn't do anything even though I had photos. I tried to give them an opportunity to fix it before I posted this. read more

See all

Not sure what happened. This was the favorite pizza place in Redlands. Yesterday I picked up two pies. The pizzas were cooked but the cheese was like plastic. Possibly a lower quality cheese. It wasn't melted and remained shredded even after putting it back into the oven at home to try and get the cheese to melt. The texture & taste of the cheese was horrible. When we called about the pizzas, they said they think they may have gotten a bad batch of cheese and said they have gotten calls all day about it. Why continue to use the cheese? We've been diehards of Jerseys. Was able to get a refund. I believe there are new owners and changes have been made. read more

Jerseys Pizza - Mozzarella is supposed to melt & stretch. - Pizza Near Me - Redlands, California

I've always loved Jersey's Pizza, but when loading a Jersey's Special pizza with olives to cover up the lack of sausage doesn't score points. I practically needed a magnifying glass to see the linguica sausage that is supposed to be primary ingredient. Please stop being so stingy on the primary ingredient. I didn't pay $24 for dough, sauce and mushrooms. Let's get back to providing a quality product for the price. read more

Came here for the first time and dined in. To be clear: this is a VERY local and no frills pizza joint. If you don't like it, they could care less if you leave and go to Romanos next door. That being said, if you have the time and patience the pizza is excellent and worth a visit. It's self seating where you order at the counter and there is no hostess or menu, so you better know how it works and what they offer from word of mouth and their online menu (which is outdated as of December '22). Where the customer service severely lacks it makes up for in their pizza. We got 3 lunch specials which consists of a mini 2 topping pizza, salad, and soda all together for $25 for 3 people, so it's a great deal as the pizza is delicious and filling. Would I return? Yes. But when I'm in a hurry? Definite no. read more

Jerseys Pizza - Mini lunch pizza - Pizza Near Me - Redlands, California

See all

These prices are absolutely insane, no wonder it's always empty. $22 for a large cheese, PLUS $1.75 each topping. $29 for a large specialty pizza. When did pizza become a $60 dollar dinner for a family of 4??? read more

long time favorite. Jersey's pizza is the go-to for pizza night. Small bar is nice to keep tabs on the sports games

The best pizza every time! Fun atmosphere with good music and friendly service. Joey the manager is welcoming, attentive and makes sure our experience is always good! read more

This old crusty place is a fantastic pizza parlor a real original . Look this a true staple of downtown all the old stuff on the wall and cool sport stuff makes it genuinely a place lost in time . The service was 10/10 overall great time and good food read more

Jerseys Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Redlands, California

The pizza is great and the sauce is standout, even in a pepperoni slice. Coming back for a specialty pizza soon!

Great ingredients, not artificial. The pizza tastes great. They have been a long time supporter of city of Redlands, and community sport events. Great customer service, and a great atmosphere. Think of cheers in a pizza restaurant. Thank you Jerseys Pizza for you years of service. Psalm 103. read more

New owner...Outstanding food quality and value. A must for any Redlands foodie.the pizza is amazing.

Today, I ordered a large pepperoni and mushroom pizza for delivery and requested that the pizza be covered in mushrooms so that no pepperoni was showing and the guy on the phone confirmed that would be done by going with TRIPLE MUSHROOMS and I said "whatever it takes" and to go ahead and do it. I was charged for the extra mushrooms but when I opened the box all it had was the standard single topping amount of mushrooms (I know this because I have ordered it that way in the past). SEE PHOTO below from today for what flies for TRIPLE MUSHROOMS....just pathetic! To make matters worse I tried calling back 6 times but each time they hung up on me before any words could be said. Finally, on the 7th try, I got a hold of someone and they refused to fix their mistake and send out another pizza or offer me a refund. The best they could offer was a discount on a future order as if there was even going to be a next time ! ! ! To be fair, the pizza itself is delicious but the Customer Service STINKS NEVER EVER GOING BACK, their Customer Service is NON-EXISTENT!!! read more

Jerseys Pizza - RIPOFF - Pizza Near Me - Redlands, California

See all

Never been here before, so happy i came in off a whim! Good vibes all around from the atmosphere and crew working here! I personally never eat the crust on my pizzas, this was the first time I've ever eaten a full slice of pizza lol, absolutely love their pizza i would recommend the jersey special! Thanks chris! read more

Great atmosphere, great pizza & cold beer! This is a Redlands staple here in downtown. Joey was very helpful and was quick to assist with everything we had asked. 10/10 recommend if you're in the area. read more

Jerseys Pizza - Cold Beer! - Pizza Near Me - Redlands, California

Jersey's pizza is delicious. Pizza is cheesy and the sauce has chucks of tomato which make it tasty with their bread. The cheesy bread is good. All salads are served with a packet of dressing. read more