OK, so I've been going to this pizza joint for years now. I don't know if it's a sin to say this, but they absolutely out pizza the hut. Tonight the chicken Alfredo pizza that I received from this establishment was so beautiful that I think I need to make my first Yelp review. I've ordered many chicken Alfredo Zaas in my lifetime but this one.... I fear as if someone knew what I was going through and communicated with me through a pizza. It's not everyday you take a slice that reminds you everything going to be alright. God bless American pizza read more

American Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Highland, California

Absolutely love American pizza. It is perfect every time. Perfect sauce and cheese ratio. You can't beat the price!

First off I normally don't like to leave bad reviews but when I get lied to you, i have no choice but to speak up, a couple weeks back I ordered two large pizzas. One of them was wrong. I didn't realize it till I got home because I've ordered countless amounts of pizza from the specific place never had an issue. I drove about 20-30 minutes out of town just for this pizza because I like the quality I like the staff and it's really good fucken pizza and I rather support a Mom and pop shop then a franchise company so when I had called them to explain what had happened, the guy apologized. He gave me two options to where I can either keep the pizza and on my next order they'll credit me a discount or a coupon or something like that on my next pizza or they can remake it by that time I was ready too late I didn't want the staff staying past closing for me and I didn't feel like driving 25mins back so we took the pizza we made it work and the toppings were absolutely horrible. I just wanna say who the heck puts artichoke and pineapple on pizza that should be a crime. So when I took the offer for the coupon/discount on the pizza, the guy said that he's gonna put it under my account where all I have to do is call in and give them my phone number and it should pop up on their system. Well this is where things get me upset. I called to see if I can Claim or use that coupon/offer that they offered me in exchange for them for giving me the wrong pizza. I spoke with this Lovely girl didn't get her name and I had told her what happened she asked for my phone number. She than told me that there wasn't nothing popping up on my account or their account and I explained to her what had happened and the offer that the guy had gave me which I wish I would've got his name, but I gave them the benefit of the doubt because I truly do like this pizza and it breaks my heart that I'm doing this but when I get lied to and pretty much robbed because the pizza that I originally ordered was more expensive than the one that they gave me accidentally. I feel bad for the girl because I kinda did go off on her and I apologize for that and told her I know it wasn't her fault she probably wasn't there that night. She said if there was anything she could do if they could remake the pizza for me today and I told her no that's fine. I just won't order from you guys ever again, you guys lost a good customer and I'll make sure my family doesnt order from you guys as well. read more

Good pizza! Good cheese sticks! I always get excited when there's toppings offered that are hard to come by! To top it off the staff was great!! Overall 10/10 read more

So my husband was in the hospital for a week and we wanted food other than hospital food. So we went to pick up pizza. My husband got a small meat lovers (basically) and I got the American style. Both pizzas were good, but kinda pricey for how small it was. We also got wings which my husband said they were decent & had chicken strips which my daughter ate... she had no problem with them obviously. The service was great, they were super nice and I know there are other locations but this one doesn't have indoor seating, so it's mainly a carry out location, so there really is no ambiance. We will try again under better circumstances, but for now, it's only 4 and not five because of price & I also got a slice of cheesecake hoping it was fresh (for the price) but it was frozen and small in a generic individual wrapping. read more

See all

The quality has changed so much. They don't even bother to put pizza liners in the boxes anymore, so when you get delivery it's just a weird gummy mess. They changed the dough too, it tastes cheap. The sausage is greasy and you can taste that it's a lower grade product. We've been ordering from American pizza since 2006, when we moved to the area. And we won't be doing so again. What a bummer this place had become. read more

Great pizza and low price. sometimes too busy to answer the phone but it's all good. It's right around the corner and the web site is great ! read more

Best pizza in the valley. I drive to highland to pick it up. It's a very busy place cause their food is good. Their pizza is delicious. My only criticism I have is they don't have a dining room to sit and enjoy the food. But I do enjoy this pizza and the salad ain't that bad. My wife likes the antipasto salad ven though I am just into the pizza.. read more

The best pizza! We just get pepperoni with jalapeños or olives normally but I finally tried a Hawaiian with their white sauce and I'm hooked. But all of their pizzas are great. I haven't tried their sandwiches but while I was leaving their store the other day, a lady told me she went there specifically for their sandwiches so that's what I'll try next. Great family owned business! And they support the neighborhood so that's awesome! I love this place! They've got me as a customer for good! read more

Good pizza, salad, bread sticks, sandwiches and friendly atmosphere. I don't get here as often as I would like to but I get there once in a while. To far for delivery. Always a treat! read more

Let's start out by saying we had high hopes we've been searching for a good local pizza place. We were tired of getting Domino's, but honestly Domino's blows this place out of the water from the quality of the cheese to the dough that had no flavor. Save your Money don't order from here read more

This is probably the best pizza in the highland/redlands area. Been coming here for years and it never disappoints. If your like me and like your crust a little crispy ask for you pizza to be cooked well done. Soooo good. Toppings are excellent and the service has always been good. No place to sit, you just pick up and go, but it's our go to for Friday nights! read more

Love their Pizza they do not compare to your regular pizza places like Pizza Hut/ Domino's, their cheese is delicious. Great customer service even their driver when delivering the pizza have a great attitude, I would recommend this location you have to try it. read more

I been ordering from this location fora while now and it was great. The pizza was amazing and the service also but in May I had placed an order and I was told that it would be done in 20 min and that's ok but when it was time to pick it up my order was never put in ‍ Then yesterday 11/4 I placed an order at 7:00pm & I was told it would be ready at 9:30pm they close at 9:00pm I couldn't believe it its sad the way this location is being run. I use to recommend this location now I can't not with this service. I ended up ordering pizza from another company. read more

This place got new ownership about nine months ago and it's now July 20 25. They put you on hold for seven minutes and then you hang up and call back in a different person answers and they say how can I take your order . They mess up your order and say that it's for pick up, when it's supposed to be delivery. Pizza is old when it is finally delivered and then they offer you $10 off. What a tool. Get better management. read more

I love the food here. Best pizza in the neighborhood!!! Sometimes it is so busy you have to wait an hour, even if you do a pick up! If that is the issue, try another time or order further ahead of time. They also have delicious chicken wings cooked like real wings should be. High temp and short time. Crispy in the outside and tender and juicy on the inside. Yum, yum, yummy! No inside restaurant, just pickups or delivery. Pleasant staff, good training for local teens, strong management! Hidden in Highland at Church and Baseline. Look for their flyers in the mail. Live this place! read more

Ordered pizza and they two two hours to make. There were so many people standing outside waiting for their orders as well. Lots of laughing and workers playing around, while customers are waiting for their food. Got the pizza home and the ends are all burned. We will not order from here again. I Will go to Mountain Mikes now. We have been coming to American Pizza for years. Never again. read more

American Pizza - Burned pizza - Pizza Near Me - Highland, California

Great pizza! Definitely in my top 3 favorite pizza places in Southern California. Makes pizza hut and domino's taste like the garbage they are. read more

This is my go to for pizza. I have seen other reviews with people complaining about the pizza no being ready at the time promised. Sure that happens sometimes especially on weekends. It is a small shop so if they are slammed with orders the pizza might take longer. I have had occasions where my order was early. There are also some complaints about rude employees. That happens too but the majority of the time they are friendly. And it is nice to see some of the same faces again and again. My usual orders are pizza, pizza, and pizza. But this time I also ordered some garlic parmesan wings and they were legit fantastic. I could and will order just those for a meal. So tonight: Order early Friendly Staff Great meal Hard to ask for more. read more

Hands down one of the best pizza places that I have ever been too!!! Everything from the dough to the red sauce was good! I'm not typically a fan of Hawaiian pizza (it's my husband's fav), but even this was amazing! I also tried their Philly Cheese Steak pizza which was good, but their red sauce really sold me over! I will definitely be coming back. They also have a lot of salads to choose from! Not to mention sides! If you're going to be sharing with someone and they eat a lot of pizza, I recommend going with at least the XL. read more

American Pizza - Hawaiian Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Highland, California

Really good pizza. Had a Large Ham and Pineapple Original Crust. Very tasty, sauce and cheese was good. Toppings were fresh and crust was cooked well. Great place for pizza and wings. read more

American Pizza - Large Ham and Pineapple cooked to perfection! - Pizza Near Me - Highland, California

See all

Pizza is good and not expensive at all, it's only a few bucks more than a lil Caesar's pizza but the quality is much better.

Well, after 10 years of American Pizza's great food and excellent customer service, I experienced the new owner who refused to listen to why I was calling after not receiving my small pizza after waiting over an hour. He insulted me by calling me a tough guy as I then asked if he was a tough bitch. He then asked me to come to the store to fight him. Lol needless to see I can kick his ass and still never order from American Pizza ever again. read more

American Pizza - Proving I am not a tough guy! - Pizza Near Me - Highland, California

See all

I ordered garlic parmesan wings they sent wrong ones and the pizza was really really well done on one side almost

Pretty darn good! Generous toppings and good prices. Although for ranch they just give you a kens dressing packet lol. read more

American Pizza - The Patriot Pizza without tomatoes, sausage, or ground beef - Pizza Near Me - Highland, California

Good pizza and pasta. Service is always good. Ordered a few party size pizzas the day before a birthday party... they were available and ready for pick up exactly when we agreed upon. read more

I order frequently from American pizza. The wait times for delivery have been extremely long so I decided to pick up this time after placing order online. Three employees kept telling me my order was almost ready when in the end, the order took an extra thirty minutes after promised time. The sandwiches had burnt bread, cold bread, barely any meat and a big glob of mustard on half the sandwich. The sandwiches are obviously rushed and made very sloppy. Extremely disappointed read more

See all

Bomb If it ain't pizza co pizza, I don't want it Wings are really good as well read more

American Pizza - 12pc Buffalo Wings - Pizza Near Me - Highland, California

See all

Great pizza! We are new to the area and are very happy to have a good local pizza joint. The service is good. They delivered the pizza quickly in 40 minutes on a Friday night. It was fresh, hot and delicious. read more

We ordered pizza here because of a recommendation from a family friend. He said it was super cheesy and well priced, you can't go wrong with that! My husband ordered from their online website for pick up and it was ready within 20 minutes. We ordered the four cheese pizza and the kickin chicken. The pizzas looked amazing, and they taste even better! The four cheese pizza has a nice, thick layer of cheese which I love! Like an upgraded version of Costco pizza is the best way to describe the cheese. The crust was delicious too. I'm not one for wanting to eat the crust, but it's crispy on the outside and nice and doughy on the inside. Absolutely delicious! The kickin chicken was probably my favorite. The chicken was cooked perfectly and was super juicy. The franks red hot complimented it perfectly, and wasn't too overpowering. It was the perfect balance of heat and flavor, a super win. We will be regulars at American Pizza Company from now on and I can't wait to try what else is on the menu! read more

American Pizza - Kickin Chicken Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Highland, California

See all

Service was great. Deeonna was so sweet and helped me navigate the menu since it was my first time there. Food was absolutely amazing best pizza I had in awhile, definitely recommend this location. read more

Ordered this pizza though yelp for-filled by grub hub. Called management of American pizza. Got a not problem mentality. Felt unsupported and like management could have done more for their customer. I won't be patronizing this establishment again. I'm so upset, I've lost my appetite. The pizza is nothing to write home about anyway. read more

American Pizza - a pepperoni, mushroom, and cheese pizza - Pizza Near Me - Highland, California

See all

Super friendly! We ordered a lot of food and they were very attentive when making sure we had everything we needed! These guys made for a top-notch pizza party. read more

American Pizza - Tons of great food for the niece's birthday party! - Pizza Near Me - Highland, California

Always get great pizza and side from these guys. But today ordered pizza and pizza bread. They sent cheese pizza bread no toppings. When I called they said that it was the online service they use that messed up. No t happy the way they handled the delivery. But it is usually always good. read more

Good local business that needs to be supported the breadsticks are amazing!! The service and ambiance are both great.

Really good mushroom pizza! Got the personal size pizza. Cheese and mushrooms were delicious! Would recommend it. read more

American Pizza - Mushroom and cheese pizza - Pizza Near Me - Highland, California

Get the deep dish pepperoni and cheese, pizza, with extra cheese, so good and filling. Combination pizza was awesome. Very good definitely come back. read more

Great pizza.so happy this pizza shop is here and close to my neighborhood. Their Pizza, breadsticks and salad have been excellent every time we've ordered. Chicken Bacon Ranch Salad was so delicious under the visible toppings was a generous amount of chopped tomatoes and crumbled mozzarella. read more

See all

Owner was extremely rude. Poor staff likely has to suffer from him. The original owners were so cool, but this new guy is running this community staple into the ground. I've seen roaches in here when I pick up pizza. They've changed the recipe the pizzas not the same, and definitely for the worst. Ambiance is a walk in pizza place, there's no where to sit. I wouldn't want to sit anyways listening to the owner yell at employees all day. read more

This is what happens when you order from American pizza. Smh. Probably won't be ordering from here again. It's just a complete mess read more

American Pizza - Slop for a pizza - Pizza Near Me - Highland, California