Jeremiah's Tavern re-opened after remodeling. The menu was also revised, now definitely more like pub food. Two nights ago, on a frigid night, a friend and I went for a pint and some food. Two Guinness Stouts warm us up. Also soups, Boston Chowda (good and meaty) served with oyster crackers. So good. My friend got the Onion Soup Crock. She loved it. We shared Steak Quesadilla and Garlic Broccoli. Very satisfying meal. Service was friendly and attentive. read more

See all

If you're chasing that perfect wing-and-burger combo with a cold beer, these places deliver the kind of food that feels like bar food but tastes like a step above. Want help picking based on vibe--dive bar vs. gastropub vs. arcade bar? I've got you. read more

See all

Wings were very good-all the other food (fish fry, Reuben sandwich) was not at all good. Our server Hailey was great! read more

Jeremiah's Tavern - Fish fry ( not great) - Chicken Wings Near Me - Rochester, New York

See all

Their buffalo chicken wrap and "don't harsh with my mango man!" Beer is so good. This is a perfect place to watch football game, pit stop for lunch and just enjoy your food read more

Jeremiah's Tavern - Chicken Wings Near Me - Rochester, New York

Food was good. Service was very friendly. I met several servers and the bartender. It was fast and very efficient very clean and chic read more

Unfortunately it was temporarily closed! Didnt see that info on yelp. Bummer we were looking forward to their wings!

Wings are great service is fine. I can't stand that they don't switch back to music during commercials. Listening to commercials at full blast during the bills games is honestly completely obnoxious. Also they don't play the shout song after a bills touch down fake bills fans here. read more

I love coming here for lunch! There's so many food options, the portions are large, the prices are fair and the service is always super friendly. I especially love their wraps. The shrimp po boy and turkey bacon avocado wraps are my favorites and they are very filling. Highly recommend checking this place out as it may become your new favorite spot too. read more

Jeremiah's Tavern - Turkey Bacon Avacado Wrap and Shrimp Po-Boy Wrap, SO GOOD - Chicken Wings Near Me - Rochester, New York

See all

Food used to be excellent. It wasn't bad but it also wasn't great like I remember it about 10 years ago living on the Avenue. Ambiance is as what you would expect from a sports bar. The service was okay. My boyfriend had to stand up in order to get his water refilled. I'll try coming back for the wings to see if it's better! read more

See all

Came here with a group on a weekday. It was a strange mixture of table service and bar service (we were forgotten for about 10 minutes when we were told that someone would come right away, but there were a few people who just went up and ordered at the bar and were able to). Tried a variety of things including buffalo chicken dip (best tasting thing there), curly fries (can't go wrong) and poutine with bacon. The poutine was just okay but wasn't a standout. The group ended up going to order at the bar for various things. read more

Jeremiah's Tavern - Chicken Wings Near Me - Rochester, New York

Service via waitress at table was good, but slow. Food was delicious for bar food. Bar seemed overwhelmed and unable to handle the traffic. Unfriendly bartender. She was probably having a bad night. read more

Jeremiah's Tavern - Chicken Wings Near Me - Rochester, New York

See all

Stopped here for lunch, there are a couple of locations and this one is the original. We normally go to the one closest to our house. Parking here is either on the street or behind the restaurant. The wife had a burger and I had the Reuben sandwich with fries and a side of gravy. First her burger was cooked to perfection and her onion rings were large and crispy. My Reuben sandwich was by far the best I have had in years. I know you're saying it's a Reuben, well for those that order them, many times it comes so soggy that it is difficult to eat. This was perfect, the rye bread was toasted and it contained just the right amount of meat, kraut, and dressing. Also the gravy was to die for. Made from beef drippings and not from a powder. It was rich and so flavorful. Plenty of seating and lots of TVs, an expansive draft beer selection makes this place a go to for watching sporting events. Our waiter Josh was very attentive and made sure we were properly cared for. Can't beat this tavern if looking for a place to watch a game, have great food and an awesome beer selection. read more

I got turkey burger it had no taste kinda blah no seasoning at all . I put salt n pepper to help. Asked for extra crispy fries first time out not crispy second time still not third time finally! The fries were good after third try n dry rub wings were good at least. I don't recommend Turkey burger unless u like no flavor. Staff was friendly. read more

See all

The atmosphere was great, easy to get to and from on the local bus line. Been craving fish and chips, so I ordered them here. The batter was crispy and flavorful without being soggy, and the fish itself was flaky and perfectly cooked. Fries were well seasoned, which I always enjoy. Staff was cheerful and helpful. However, since I'm 18 I can't comment on the bar area. Overall, 5 out of 5, will come back. read more

One of my favorite restaurants. Very diverse menu and fast service. The ambience is a bit noisy, but it also can help if you're having a private conversation (can't be overheard ). Parking can be a bit difficult but there's some parking behind the building or on the streets. read more

Their menu is loaded, and have equally as positive experiences across their multiple locations. Just a top-notch establishment! Their Bee Sting sauce keeps us coming back. read more

pastrami sandwich was noo meat on it, barley sour crout ,the fries that came it was hard like cobblestone and we mentioned it to the food runner and he said i will bring a new tray with fries and guess the fries never came Horrible experience read more

Jeremiah's Tavern - Not worth it ..... drinks maybe but dont waist money on good there - Chicken Wings Near Me - Rochester, New York

I went here with a Rochester native on the recommendation that it had the best wings in town. The experience did not live up to this billing. We did get a wing platter which came with curly fries and come corn bread. The wings were boneless so essentially amounted to bite sized chicken fingers. Just meh. They were also kind of soaking in a pool of the sauce rather than having been cooked in it so the flavor was uneven. We also got a nacho platter to share and it also was kind of meh. Not much in terms of veggies or toppings, just chips bathed in cheese sauce (and some actual cheese). He waitresses also forgot to put in the order so we got them super late. This place is a local favorite so maybe they just had a down night. But in our visit the best I can say is subpar pub food. read more

Jeremiah's Tavern - Nachos with scant toppings - Chicken Wings Near Me - Rochester, New York

See all

I've been here a few times, and it's definitely hit or miss depending on what you order. The Ruben I ordered last time was good, but not amazing. This time I got the Tavern Pretzels for an appetizer, New England clam chowder as a side and the Buffalo Chicken Mac'n Cheese as my entree. - The pretzel was a bit dry and tough, but the beer cheese and honey mustard were good. - The clam chowder was good and hearty, but may have been a bit over cooked. - The Buffalo Mac'n Cheese was the big letdown. The cheese was basically velveeta with a splash of buffalo sauce that was poured over some pasta the had strips of chicken mixed in. Then they added some seasoned bread crumbs on top. For a place known for their chicken wings, I expected much more for their Bufffalo Chicken Mac. If you go here, definitely stick to the wings or bar sandwiches. read more

Jeremiah's Tavern - Buffalo Chicken Mac n Cheese - Chicken Wings Near Me - Rochester, New York

I will keep this simple and to the point. The best wings in town! The menu looks great, but when we are in town from Virginia we MUST visit here for the wings. read more

I've been here twice after a rip roaring game of kickball; once with a small group, the second with a larger group. Bar service here is pretty standard. Staff was friendly and attentive, promptly removing empty plates from the table. For my first visit I ordered Chicken Fingers and Fries. The fingers were not my speed. They tasted like store bought Tyson Chicken Tenders. The fries were good though. Crispy and fluffy. For my second visit, I ordered the 1/2 Team of wings (medium). I heard they have the best wings in Rochester so as a Buffalo native I had to try them. They were good but far from the best I've ever had. Standard wing and standard medium sauce. As per usual for me, I had to try the desserts. I split a Brownie Sundae and Warm Apple Crisp with a friend. The brownie was soft and chocolatey. The Apple Crisp was both sweet and tart. Both desserts were delicious but if I had to choose one over the other, it'd have to be the brownie. I'm not likely to return on my own but wouldn't be opposed to stop by for drinks. read more

See all

Good ambiance. The manny melt was good. The wings were good. The fish n' chips were good yummy.

Jeremiah's Tavern never disappoints! Every location delivers excellent food every time! The chicken wings are always the best and the wings platter has become my go-to at Jeremiah's. The BeeSting flavor is one of the best sauces ever invented! Washed down with one of the plenty of choices of beer on tap! Best wings in Rochester! read more

Jeremiah's Tavern - Jeremiah's Chicken Wing Platter - BeeSting with Mac Salad - Chicken Wings Near Me - Rochester, New York

If I could rate this place 0 stars I would. Do NOT come to eat here. On multiple occasions they have prepared my order completely wrong or over cooked to the point where it just wasn't edible. Not to mention the horrible customer service you'll get when calling over the phone to explain your frustration with recurring wrong orders. Spend your time and money elsewhere. read more

Jeremiah's Tavern - "Buffalo" chicken salad with no Buffalo actually on the chicken......... - Chicken Wings Near Me - Rochester, New York

I just love Jeremiah's. They have the best wings in the area IMO. The Nawleans blues sauce is outta this world! It's a combo of buffalo sauce, Cajun, and chunky blue cheese. The best. Their sandwiches are always good too, I lean towards a Rueben or French dip. Oh and their curly fries!! Yum. I've never had bad food here. The staff is always extremely friendly, at all locations. Awesome beer selections too. My only note is that during Covid prices have increased a bit, but I guess that's to be expected at a lot of places now. But I'll still pay top dollar for the best wings!!! read more

Jeremiah's Tavern - Wings and Curly Fries - Chicken Wings Near Me - Rochester, New York

Simple request TNT so I could watch a game. Now I have to sit here with my delicious food wondering if our country is winning a game. Like what am I suppose to do... how many times can I ask read more

Takeout review The kids both got wings, two different flavors, and they were both happy. Reviews said they were good here, and I guess they are (these are two kids who know good wings from bad). My wife and I each got Pork Schnitzel Sandwich, which sounded good with "lemon garlic mayo and arugula," but it turned out to be just bread, with bread-coated meat inside, no lemon, garlic, or arugula registering anywhere. I mean, we could see white stuff with green flecks in it, we just couldn't taste anything but bread and salt. $14 each. Service was friendly and prompt, and maybe we just ordered a clunker (although if something's not your best dish, maybe don't advertise it on instagram?). If we go back and order something better, I'll pack on more stars. read more

We have ordered from Jeremiah's 5-6 times, each time hoping that it will satisfy a late night burger craving. Each time we have been entirely disappointed. One of those times they totally botched our order, we called them back and they offered future dinning credit which when we tried to redeem the waitstaff said couldn't be done because the manager was not present. The sides are always skimpy-unsatisfying portions that leave us wanting more. The burgers themselves are pedestrian. The meat unseasoned, the toppings haphazardly tossed on with insufficient amounts. Safe to say we will not be making this mistake again (at least any time soon). read more

Jeremiah's went WAY downhill. It used to be my go-to great wing place from the 1980's - 2020 but no more. The Catatanic wings are now dry, bland and way overpriced. My forehead used to pleasantly sweat from the Catatonics, now a peppered butter sauce would taste better. I got stung by a bee while waiting forever for service and they were more worried about liablity than just getting me ice for the bee welts. They got my order wrong and still charged me for the mistake. The eating area feels more like an expensive McDonald's than a good old fashioned tavern, like it used to be. Good ridance, Jeremiah's after 30+ years. read more

Just had a wonderful dining experience at the Penfield location. Our server, Cal, was super attentive and great to converse with. Thanks for the service, Cal! read more

Fish fry review ONLY- an $18 disappointment. Medium sized serving of fish tossed on top of a few soggy grainy steak fries. I will say the fish was flaky and not dry which was a win. Some seasoning would have gone a long way! It certainly left one wanting more. The coleslaw has pineapple in it which gives an interesting flavor. Reminds me of pineapple cottage cheese. Tartar sauce was fine. read more

Jeremiah's Tavern - Battered Fish Fry - Chicken Wings Near Me - Rochester, New York

See all

This is my second visit and honestly I have been waiting for this for some time. The staff are very friendly and attentive. The beer selection here is excellent. Today I sampled the clam chowder. It was a heart blend of ingredients packed with clams and potatoes. The wings are incredible and I like mine hot. They are a good size and nice and crisp. The sauce is perfectly blended and spicy. Just so darn tasty. The never let you down. read more

See all

To my surprise they now charge $ .75 per takeout item. So now I just don't tip as much. Don't know of any other place in Rochester that does this. read more

My friends and I went to the Penfield Jeremiah's over the weekend, I ordered the breaded shrimp wrap and a salad with honey dijon dressing. The wrap was good, but it was tiny, with not near enough shrimp to constitute the $16 they charged. The salad was fine, dressing was tasty. Nothing special about a salad that clearly came out of a pre-made mix. Food was decent but the portions were tiny and way over priced. The place wasn't busy but service was still quite slow. read more

Nice selection of foods and beverages, but often quite busy. Service is decent but not exceptional and it is typically loud inside the restaurant. Take out is sometimes the better option. read more

My first time at Jeremiah's Tavern was about a year ago with my grandma. Then comes a night when me and my roommate are trying to find somewhere to eat. We ask some people and they recommend Jeremiah's Tavern out of a few others and I'm like I've been there it's pretty good. So we go there and I am once again reminded of how good it is. I've now order a few more times from different locations. Every time I do the food is consistently good and served by nice employees. My favorite things to order are the BBQ Pulled Pork Plate ans CHICKEN WING DIP! Being a college student I think the prices are a steal for the good quality food. I highly recommend! read more

Jeremiah's Tavern - BBQ Pulled Pork Plate with Steak Fries - Chicken Wings Near Me - Rochester, New York

See all

You can never go wrong by coming to Jeremiah's. The wings at Jeremiah's have consistently been some of the best I've had ever. The wings are the perfect size and the sauces are just packed with great flavor! I'd recommend ordering 3 sets of five wings so you can try three different sauces as there are so many great ones. The pure buffalo sauce is great if you order it hot as well as the sweet and sour sauce. The restaurant is extremely clean and a great place to go for drinks. The burgers are wonderful here as well, you really can't go wrong. read more

Jeremiah's Tavern - Chicken Wings Near Me - Rochester, New York

Great wings and food. Cozy atmosphere thats inviting. Good service and prompt. Conveniently located in the city of Rochester. read more

See all

Being from buffalo originally I'm very skeptical when people take me to places they claim have the best wings. I got a single order of wings with the garlic parmesan sauce and I was very pleasantly surprised by how good they were. We got a few other different flavors at the table as well, the nawlins blues, the mild, and the bee sting. All the flavors were good, some of which I had never tried before. Although not the best wings I've ever had, they were pretty delicious and if your in the area definitely check this place out! read more

Jeremiah's Tavern - Garlic parm wings - Chicken Wings Near Me - Rochester, New York

This place is so much fun! My server was rocking a Led Zepplen shirt. I would recommend this place to anyone down for a drink and a good time read more