It was mad busy and we had no reservation! We were still able to be seated. Had a great fish fry dinner and beer! Food & service were great great! read more

They have Heady Topper!! Came here for date night. I ordered the fish sandwich and it was very good. Wife had the Caesar salad with chicken. She said it was good. Service was good and food came out pretty fast. read more

The Sheffield - They have heady Topper!! - Bars Near Me - Rochester, New York

Good Eats at a good price. Tuesday evening is Trivia. It starts at 7:30 PM. I don't know how it turned out but the place was full. We stopped by for dinner and a beer. The "Fish Sarnie" was excellent; fresh bun, tartar sauce and fresh deep fried cod. Special. The French fries were the best I have had in ages; crisp and salty, in a large pile on the plate. The "Coronation Chicken" served on naan could be eaten open face as a salad or as a sandwich, either way it was great. Great beer selection as well. That doesn't mean they have an infinite selection of beers, it means that the beer selection is well balanced and complete. Enjoy the atmosphere and food. read more

The Sheffield is a great spot for a dependable plate of food Well cooked, simple solid menu, great beer selections Their fries are tasty! Service is friendly and professional, and happy hour specials! A perfect neighborhood place read more

See all

Waitress refused to let two older people sit in a booth instead of the bar?? The booth was 3 feet away from the bar tables. We left. We're not going to give an age-ignorant establishment our business. read more

After visiting a loved one in the hospital, we wanted food to nourish our souls as well as our bellies and this was the spot! It was clean and had beautiful wood tables, booths and bar. There was football in the other room, but it was far enough away that we were able to have a quiet conversation. Our server Whitney had only been on the job for a few weeks but was very knowledgeable and was very personable. They have a QR code for their beverages with descriptions so lovely they made you want to try each one. I only had a cider, but my companion sampled a few. Whitney also shared that on her day off she was planning on reading up on the multiple kinds of EANAB (equally attractive non-alcoholic beverages). We shared a poutine- which was large, delicious and had flavorful gravy. It could have managed a few more curds but I also think everything could do with more cheese. My companion had bangers and mash and was only able to eat one of the sausages. I had an enormous piece of fish with my fish and chips and the fish was very moist and flaky. Both entrees came with minted mushy peas- not my thing but I understand they go with the theme. We were able to pack enough leftovers to feed three people for another meal. For dessert we split sticky toffee pud and it was really delicious. I am not a local, but have already recommended it to at least two people who are. read more

See all

We were looking for a place for dinner and boy did we get lucky! The place is clean and well-furnished, and the bar is gorgeous. We wanted a little quiet so we sat on the other side - it looked like there was also outdoor seating for nicer weather. Whitney took great care of us and helped us select some delicious dinner options. The beer descriptions were also great - the QR code to a real time list is a great option and means it's always current and doesn't depend on the server to know beer. We ended up starting with a terrific plate of poutine. I might have liked a little more salt on the chips, but it was delicious. It was also huge. Two people splitting it should probably have split an entree too as we ended up taking some home. I had the bangers and mash - excellent sausages and taters, and a nice zingy mustard sauce. I can take or leave mushy peas but I have that same issue in the UK. My dinner companion had the fish and chips which were also delicious (and big). We split a sticky toffee pud and overall it was a delicious meal, and terrific service. We took home enough for another meal, so take that into consideration! read more

See all

Came here to watch the super bowl and had a great time. Bartender was friendly and welcoming. Great happy hour deals for $6 including options like burger, poutine, chicken tenders. The chicken tenders were some of the freshest juiciest chicken I've had, definitely unexpected for bar food. The special of the week was a savory puff pastry with chicken tikka. The concept was cool but the filling was a bit too acidic for my taste. Dessert was a warm skillet bake topped with ice cream, a wonderful end to the night. read more

See all

Favorite parts: - Happy hour everyday 4-6pm, which includes menu items like a happy burger (like a McD burger but 1000X better quality and much bigger), basket of fries, chicken dippies (3 piece handmade tenders). I just wish they had a printed happy hour menu (maybe they do, I just didn't see it). - Service: Nick our waiter was personable. Made sure we were well-taken care of and told a great story. Also loved the whole vibe throughout the pub/restaurant. - I highly recommend trying the Scotch egg. It's a soft boiled egg encased in a THICCKKK layer of breakfast sausage, breaded, and then deep fried. The Sheffield burger was also a favorite. The fact that the bun was spread with a garlicky butter, brought it to the next level. And I found out that I love cheese not being fully melted on the burger. Only thing that could have made it better would be making it with a homemade juicy patty. Would definitely come back when in the area. read more

See all

Excellent food - British choices are perfectly cooked, burgers went down well too. Sticky toffee pudding just delicious!! Good ambience and great service even when busy. Trivia on Tuesdays is fun for all kinds of groups. read more

Our new favorite hang! Rotating selection of beers, prosecco on tap and fantastic mashed potatoes. The Duchess approves! She say they're to die for... and the Coronation chicken sarnie fills the bill. read more

The Sheffield - Mortalis in the house! - Bars Near Me - Rochester, New York

See all

Very busy on a friday night, but they have large shared high tops in the bar so we were seated quickly. Service was good & friendly. Felt like there were many "regulars" - had a good vibe. Food was good hardy food - look forward to returning when we have more time to enjoy the atmosphere. read more

The Sheffield is a place we've been meaning to check out for several years and we've just never made it there. We've been missing out! For starters we had the whipped feta and beetroot, and Tendies and Dippies. The feta and beets were fantastic. Likewise, the Tendies and Dippies were loved. The breading and fry on the chicken was so wonderfully done -- light, flavorful, and perfectly cooked such that they were juicy. Dipping sauces were also great and we should have kept them for french fry dipping later. The fries were well seasoned and crisp. For the burgers, both of them were perfectly cooked, and the toppings and sauces were thoughtful and in just the perfect quantity. "The Sheffield" might just be among of the best burgers you can get in the Rochester area. Service was attentive. We will definitely return. read more

See all

Food was good. Service was not a priority as we had chosen to sit outside as one member of the family is immunocompromised. Multiple mistakes were made though our server handled them politely and the best she could since it was a busy Friday night. Out of town guests here for just the weekend & with other commitments limited our options. I would definitely try it again at another time. read more

Stopped here on a whim. The food menu & cocktail menu is top notch. Ordered Bangers & Mash with an Other Half West Coast IPA. read more

The Sheffield - Other Half West Coast IPA. - Bars Near Me - Rochester, New York

See all

Food and service were great! It's s really nice place with English pub food options. Definitely worth trying.

Stopped in for a late dinner. Hubby ordered bangers and mash and I had the pork schnitzel sandwich. Both dishes were delicious - I would definitely order the pork sandwich again - it was so crispy. I had a glass of Cabernet but they were out of cranberry (???) so hubby did not have his usual Ketel One and cranberry. Josh took great care of us. He checked in regularly but was not obtrusive. We also had dessert - thanks Josh for the suggestion - apple rhubarb cobbler is the best! We will be back again soon. read more

The Sheffield - House made apple rhubarb cobbler - Omgosh so good! - Bars Near Me - Rochester, New York

See all

We had a small family birthday celebration there and found the food and service both excellent. The menu is eclectic, with burgers, mains, and appetizers from all over the world. The poutine with corned beef was a great start along with some Amazing Grains bread that went well with our beers. Entrees included chicken tiki Marsala, fish and chips, bangers and mash, chicken nugs for the granddaughter, and a burger. Everyone loved what the had. Ella was attentive and accommodating. We'll certainly be back. read more

we had the coziest dinner here as a family on Friday evening. French onion soup was delicious! booth was so cozy! The happy hour menu was perfect for sharing and for kids. I can't wait to go back! read more

We live nearby and go on a regular basis. Really nice atmosphere. Personalized service from long-employed servers, good food and drink. What I really like is that the menu is varied. While it has typical bar food, it also has good selections with a nod to the owner's roots in midlands of the UK. The owner knows and values beer like few others in town. As such, the tap selection is high quality and always changing. And Tuesday night trivia is always a challenge. read more

Food was great and had a diverse menu of English and Vegan selections. Staff was very friendly and invited us to participate in the nightly activities. We will be coming back over the coming days read more

Went on Sunday night, it was quiet with lots of tables available. After chatting with our server, she said that it can get very busy some nights. Especially Tuesday for trivia! They take reservations for 4+ people. Our food was great with lots of fun options! Prices were appropriate for the portion and quality! Wing nights on Wednesdays, half off. Trivia night on Tuesday. read more

See all

What a busy far in restaurant I would recommend reservations, but they were able to accommodate us as a walk in at a high top, which was great. A great beer selection with a lot of beers on tap. Some great and interesting food fried asparagus as an appetizer was really yummy. I had the fish fry, which was using Panko breading very yummy. The service was outstanding in the food was a great value, and I thought the drink prices were very fair. Will definitely be back. read more

See all

We really enjoyed the Sheffield! Super cute inside (like a trendy pub), and lots of different types of drinks (like a large beer list). The food was really good! And I was impressed that they had some vegan options too, like vegan BLT with coconut bacon which was good! The best thing we got was the Bahn Mi but everything including the wings were very good. They have a lot of TVs too! read more

Our server Whitney was great! We really enjoyed her !!! The food was delicious! We tried the scotch egg, sausage roll, and fish & chips. The fish was enormous Had a French martini that was delicious. Dessert was the sticky toffee pudding. All 4 of us really enjoyed our experience!!! We will be back read more

The food is so good. The only thing that's been more miss than hit for me is the fish and chips. And even they're perfectly okay. In no particular order, I love: the Sheffield Burger, the Bangers and Mash, the Shepherds Pie, the Chicken Nuggies (though I'm embarrassed as an adult person to order them as such). Great place. read more

So friendly and delish. The sticky toffee pudding is a must have! Drinks are perfect, great beer selection.

Went to Sheffield's for the first time last night with a few friends. The food was great. The food came out quick and was piping hot. Wednesday is half priced wings and their wings are crispy and a nice size. They offer a few different kinds, all were good. Everything was really good. Beers were between $6 and $7 for craft pilseners and they were ice cold and also very good. The waiter was on top of everything and friendly, no complaints there. We will definitely be going back. read more

It's remarkable what the owners of the now-closed Tap & Mallet did here. In several ways it's very much how Tap & Mallet was, but even more like an English pub, and somehow the food is even higher in quality. The rotating draft list, the vegetarian options, the art on the walls, and even the decor are all reminiscent of the other place. But the food menu says, classic English pub, elevated. I've had the shepherds pie and the fish fry, and both blew me away. They didn't seem like basic standards - even the "chips" were triple-fried so that they resembled fondant potatoes. Perfect crust and batter. Flavorful and interesting mushy peas. Generous portions. And several vegetarian versions if you're not a carnivore. To cap it all, the service is fantastic. I have zero complaints. read more

See all

Had dinner here with a friend last night, and the food and service was excellent. I had the shrimp scampi appetizer as a meal, and it was the best I've ever had! The accompanying crostinis made with Amazing Grains' salt bread really topped it off! read more

The Sheffield - Shrimp Scampi Appetizer - Bars Near Me - Rochester, New York

Worth the wait for my takeout of fish and chips. Food was delicious but needs more mushy peas on the plate to make traditional. Met the owners who are kind and gracious. read more

Best fish and chips I have had! Do not sleep in them! The poutine is also solid (if not traditional) Good vibes, good draft offerings. Cool casual place. read more

So delicious, really all the food was soooo good. My favorite was the cauliflower sandwich for a veg option, the sauerbraten poutine for a meaty option. I hear the fish fry is great. Our server was super friendly, had a great sense of humor and I'd request him every time.....cause I'm definitely going back. They have a nice outdoor area to the side, in the front they had other outdoor options. read more

See all

Nice pub with good UK flare. If you miss British style food I would recommend the place. They also have a Trivia night on Tuesdays and winners get their bar tab paid covered. read more

Friendly staff. I quite enjoyed the CLT. Fries were perhaps a bit overcooked for my liking. Overall good experience. Would go again.

The last fish fry I got was terrible. The fish looked large, but was burned. The crust was hard too. When I cut the fish the piece of fish was less than an inch thick. I thought I was getting a good sized fish, but I was wrong. The crust mad it look like a nice thick piece. Wow, was I shocked! The mashed pieced was disgusting. I'll never go back! read more

We're so glad The Sheffield is open again! Living close by, we really need a solid restaurant with a vetted beer list where we can have an easy dinner out. On this visit I enjoyed the corned beef poutine. With its creamy cheese sauce and large curds, it definitely hit the mark on cheesiness. A little too much of the creamy sauce - and a little light on the corned beef cubes. And definitely light on the fries. (Although I did wind up with leftovers). My dates had the Malek burger and the fried chicken sandwich and were both satisfied. The mashed potatoes and gravy were super creamy and delicious. They are putting out some more patio furniture, so hopefully a Sheffield summer is in the future. read more

The Sheffield - Corned Beef Poutine. - Bars Near Me - Rochester, New York

Decided on the fish tacos. After a 50 minute wait, they arrived. One bite in, and the fish was scarce and super fishy( left over) and was basically just tossed with cole slaw that was more mayo than slaw , horrible. The only reason I didn't send it back was because I was with others who would have refused to continue with their meal until my new choice arrived. Very limited menu . If you go, do yourself a favor and check out the menu ti see if there is anything that appeals to you. Allow plenty of time for your visit. read more

I've dined here while in Rochester, stay at my sister's about a block away. You wouldn't know you're about to have a super meal by just looking at the exterior of the building, but the food is great. There's lots of room, and the staff was friendly. read more

Service was very friendly and helpful. The food was outstanding. FINaLLY a place that makes everything and is delicious. I had the CLT and the smoked coconut legit tasted BETTER than bacon. The french onion soup was delish as well as the dip sandwich. I want to go back on Trivia Tuesday! read more