It's hard to be me sometimes. Can you imagine trying to choose a restaurant in a city that you've never dined out in before? Can you imagine doing this while being a foodie and wanting to choose the perfect place for the occasion (even more difficult if there isn't a specific "occasion") but having almost no idea where to start? It's harrowing, friend, I tell ya. My restaurant FOMO (outdated term, sorry) is truly pathological, so sometimes I need to just pick something and deal (are we sure we're still talking about fun here). Anyway, let's get to the point, shall we? I found Iron Gate while comparing a number of different articles and listicles, and thankfully for us, it was all that we had hoped for. Romantic and charming, small plates-forward menu with fabulous, contemporary Mediterranean/Italian eats. Delicious and seasonal food, solid mixology program and a lovely selection of Greek and Italian wins. A success! 4.5 stars. I can't muster up 5, but it was pretty damn close.
Made a reservation here for 6:45pm on a Thursday night. We had everything and more go wrong on our way from Virginia to DC, so we ended up arriving more like 7:20, which is blasphemous in my book. Plus, Iron hate is usually walk-ins only between 7-9. Thankfully, we called ahead and they were more than happy to hold our table. And our table was prime real estate. Right in the middle of the main dining room which is rustic and homey, dimly-lit, romantic and features a very real, very warm (we went on a 15-degree night) fireplace. Ambiance, A++.
Our waiter, and the service overall, was delightful. He did not judge me at all for taking a quick and very unorthodox fireplace break mid-ordering due to my frostbitten hands. He was pretty much on the money when it came to choosing our damage, too.
Iron Gate has an impressive array of cocktails, beers (LOTS) and wine, with an emphasis on those from Greece and Italy. I always like to start with a cocktail, and I went with the Give Me One Resin (Barr Hill Gin, Mastiha, honey, absinthe, lemon), which was tart with some undertones of earthiness from the Mastiha (pine liquor). Nice and well-balanced. The bf tried the Rakoway Beach (Civic Vodka Giffard Pamplemousse, Rakomelo spice, lemon), which we both liked more. Sweet with a punch from the Rakomelo. Both elegant and both solid choices. With my meal, I had the Colli di Lapio despite my knowing next to nothing about Italian wine. Somewhat floral and fruity but muted enough that it went well with our food. And I'll get to that, don't worry.
Food-wise there are really only two ways to go here. Split a bunch of small plates or opt for tasting/one of the "feasts". Small plates is our go-to method of eating anyway, so it was any easy choice for us. The food was flavorful, warming and elegant. Plates were definitely on the small side, so I'd recommend 3 per person. Eats, below:
Maplebrook Farm Burrata w/ autumn squash, Asian pear, spiced pumpkin seeds: A++
Our first, and favorite, dish of the night. Sweet, rich, perfect blend of textures and flavors. The burrata was heavenly. Try to get a little bit of everything in one bite and you'll have a spiritual experience.
Brussels Sprouts Salad w/ raw cheddar, Castle Valley farro, walnut, two apples: A-
Hard to follow the burrata. This one was decent but probably our least favorite of the night. Brussels and apples done two ways, yummy fall flavors and the farro was a nice touch. Felt uninspired, though.
Spice Roasted Carrots w/ cilantro, harissa oil, pistachio, yogurt sauce: A+
A tiny plate but each morsel was delicious. I've had this roasted carrot/pistachio/yogurt combo a few different times and I've always loved it. No exception here. Carrots can be sexy, folks.
Caramelized Ricotta Gnocchi w/ Calabrian chili, pecorino, cherry tomatoes: A
I'm gluten intolerant but I made an exception here for two pieces of gnocchi, at the expense of my stomach. I love pasta but oddly have never liked gnocchi, but this was wonderful. Great texture, rich and warming flavors and not too heavy. Simple but powerful.
Grilled Tangier Oysters w/ goat butter, roasted chili, pickled shallot: A
Two each wasn't enough! Another tiny plate. But a very, very good one. Bites like these are Flavor Bombs. Nice flavor combo here with the brine and pickled shallot on one end, the butter and chili evening it out in an interesting way. A creative preparation that paid off.
Charred Octopus w/ smoked sweet potato, chicory, black garlic, mustard: A+
Octopus has been my favorite food for year and still I wish I picked something less pretentious. But the mouth wants what it wants. Though we expected slightly larger portion for the price, what we did get was delicious. Whatever they did with the mustard sauce here was magical. The sweet potatoes and garlic kept the warm vibes alive. I don't usually see a sweet flavor profile with octopus dishes, so this was a nice change of pace with excellent execution. read more