We ordered 5 pizzas including gluten free and all were delicious. We also go some Cobb salads, a Caesar salad and the pesto chicken sandwich. Everyone enjoyed the food!! We will definitely order again from them when in town read more

Easily the best pizza in McCall for the following reasons: 1- The quality of the pizza is fantastic! Great ingredients, nice thin(ish) crust, and the perfect amount of sauce. 2- The staff is just as great as the pizza. Friendly, great energy, and provide a fantastic atmosphere for enjoying pizza. 3- "The Hobbie".... hot holy damn this is easily one of the best pies I've ever had. The staff suggested I give it a go when I asked for the recommendation, and man I am so glad I did. Jalapeños, mushrooms, chicken, sausage.... damn! read more

Hometown Pizza - Pizza Near Me - McCall, Idaho

Great pizza! The best part was the gluten free crust option. The Buffalo Chicken Pizza was our favorite and the Greek was good too!

I've been there 3 times and don't understand all the glowing reviews. The crust has no flavor and the sauce doesn't compliment the toppings

Was really delicious we ordered a combo and cheese breadsticks with a side of ranch and a ceaser salad...was so good!!! read more

Hometown Pizza - Combo Pizza Large - Pizza Near Me - McCall, Idaho

See all

Friendly people, located on the edge of town near the airport. Nice family-style atmosphere. The pizza had lots of good toppings choices, but was thickish, doughy, and too heavy on the cheese, not enough tomato sauce. I wanted to like their pizza, but just wasn't excited by this style. It's a lot like a take-and-bake pizza, and not what you expect from a proper pizza joint. read more

Best Pizza in McCall Idaho! As residents we know of most of the places and this one is our favorite!

We decided to order takeout pizza for dinner on our first night in town. Hometown was a GREAT choice. We had a LARGE order for a big group of us. 2 large, 2 medium, and 1 small. They had our pizzas ready in 30 minutes, which was AMAZING to be able to feed our group of 5 adults and 6 kids back at the condo. 10/10 will be back again. *would have taken pictures... but it was so good... we couldn't wait!* read more

Great service. Pizza sizes exactly as described. Really enjoyed the Greek salad. Fun assortment of beer and wine - plus the new pub right next door where you can a wider assortment of drafts. read more

"When the owner's away the kids will play." This place is like a different restaurant when the owners are present and when they are not. Tried giving it another go. Young kid answered the phone, "hometown pizza...hold please." Left me on hold for 10 minutes before I just hung up. Could hear talking in background...he just plain forgot. Just out of curiosity I kept calling to see how long it would take them to realize...Phone was off the hook for the next 30 minutes. Ouch. Nice try guys...I'm done. read more

We really enjoyed this pizza. We did take and bake which was perfect. We will definitely order again.

We all had different (4) salads and some cheesy garlic bread sticks. It was all delicious and the Gal behind the counter was super sweet and nice.. it was perfect spot for lunch! Would definitely recommend read more

Hometown Pizza - Cobb salad with added avocado - Pizza Near Me - McCall, Idaho

Always our "go to" for take and bake pizza! They are consistently busy, so we know to call a couple of hours ahead. We're happy they continue to be in high demand, that means they have delicious food and will be around for years to come! read more

Pizza was good, different taste to the sauce. My only complaint is that the dough seemed a little undercooked...next time I may try just baking it at home to our preferred done ness. Friendly staff! read more

The wings and pizza were amazing. The wings were fresh, crispy and well seasoned. The pizzas are fantastic with fresh ingredients and cooked perfect. The staff is very polite. The patio is cute and great if you have your dog with you. Will be back again! read more

Open on Mondays! Delicious food, casual dining, great service. We had the small cheese pizza, garden vegetable pizza, BLT sandwich, and Italian salad. All delicious! read more

Love the pizza it's my favorite around McCall the crust is amazing great taste all the way around

Decent pizza and toppings visiting from out of town and thought we'd give them a try. Typical doughy crust decent amount of toppings. Nothing to write home about but good after a long day. We had an everything pizza 1/2 bbq chicken. read more

Spending the weekend in McCall and went searching for my Friday night staple- pizza. This pizza was so good! The dough was fantastic, it was thin but not dry or too crunchy. The sauce and toppings were also very good. I got the Italian favorite and would recommend to anyone looking for good, simple pizza read more

We come up to ski once a year and Hometown pizza is always a staple. We've dined in and even love their discounted take and bake at home option when we have big groups with us. This recent visit they accidentally got my lunch order wrong and went above and beyond to make it right. I told them I was fine with what they made, a buffalo chicken sandwich and ate the whole thing. They made me a buffalo chicken pizza to take home due to the mistake, and of course was the perfect breakfast before a day of skiing. Until next year Hometown! read more

This is our favorite pizza in McCall! We order a take and bake at several times a month. They are always friendly! Their wine is gear too!

This is my go to pizza shop. I'm never disappointed when I go into hometown. They have good workers that know how to make pizzas, you also feel appreciated when in the store and that's what I love read more

Pizza is amazing! Highly recommend this place. Salad was good too! They have a bbq Hawaiian pizza which is excellent! I'll eat here every time I come to McCall! read more

Shamelessly went 2x during my stay in McCall. Had the cheese sticks and oriental salad. Both were really good. Fun staff with good service. I'll definitely be back! read more

Friendly staff. Pizza was good but the antipasto salad was delicious. Small dining room and some outdoor seating, take out seems like a typical option. read more

Tried Hometown for the first time tonight. Extremely disappointed. Can't believe that no one can make a decent pizza in McCall. It tasted like a pizza from a grocery store frozen food section. Not good!! read more

At 840pm they happily made us a pizza when we arrived very late! The Idahoan was amazing with potatoes on top! Fabulous service, friendly, informative and overall amazing food and service! Thank you guys! read more

All I have to say is omg soooooo good. The sandwich's are the best. I got the veggie add pesto so good. My husband got the club he lived his as well. Kids liked the pizza. Would love to go back for their sandwich again. read more

Hometown Pizza - Club sandwich awesome - Pizza Near Me - McCall, Idaho

See all

I don't know how this place got a bad review. It's a but out of the downtown area of McCall but the food doesn't disappoint. We stopped in late on a Saturday night and were greeted by whom I assume is the owner. He was beyond friendly. It took about 20 minutes to get our pizza but it was insanely delicious and fresh. You could taste the quality, the crust was incredible. We had the Idaho pizza....bacon, potatoes ranch........I'm drooling thinking about it. I'll be back next time I'm in the area. read more

Eaten here several times while in McCall. Never a bad bite of anything. Salad, pizza, breadsticks. Oh my! Can't go wrong eating here. Friendly local place. read more

Excellent pizza! Will definitely come back the next time we are in town. Thought the crust was very unique.

Great food, excellent service. They brought our pizza right out to our car, but we were able to order inside, wearing our masks. We got the potato pizza and geek pizza-- the potato was our favorite! We always dip our pizza in ranch and the ranch was good too. Totally recommend! read more

Great pizza, ordered to go, using pics of the menu on Yelp. It was fast and easy. Ordered a Reg pep pizza for the kids, meat lovers for the dad, and garden with no cheese for the vegans. read more

Was hoping this would be great based on all the awesome reviews. But it's nothing special. Ordered the BBQ wings which had a great flavor but were soft/soggy - not crispy or caramelized at all. Similar to what you'd get at a Pizza Hut or Dominos. The Chicken Caesar salad was mediocre, and same with the pizza. Ordered the Hawaiian pizza which i'm not usually a big fan of anyway, and wasn't super impressed. read more

THE BEST GLUTEN FREE PIZZA EVER!! In my 9 years of being GF I have not come across a GF crust/pizza as good as the one I tried today at Hometown Pizza. The Garlic Chicken, Buffalo Chicken, and BBQ Chicken pizzas were all delicious and unanimously agreed upon by the whole family as the best pizza we've ever had. The staff was super nice to boot. Totally worth a stop here. read more

The food is always good and the staff is the best! Everyone I've interacted with has been friendly and dedicated to a good experience. It's McCall so weekend nights get busy and they definitely get overwhelmed so if you are patient and understanding it is worth it. Best salad selection in McCall is not an exaggeration. My children even asked to go back for lunch to have a salad. That's a win! read more

Excellent pizza! I highly recommend. Ordered a medium size pizza from Hometown this evening and we were very impressed at how good it was. They were busy, understandably so, it took about 35ish minutes before we picked up the pizza but it was well worth the wait. Looking forward to leftover pizza for lunch tomorrow read more

We arrived in town late on a Monday night very hungry after a long day on the trails, and this was one of the only places that seemed to be open and/or offering takeout. We had the Six Shooter, which was delicious, and spicy wings, which were pretty good. The service was excellent! When I arrived to pick it up I was also happy to find they carry bottles of Mexican Coke! Overall a great experience. We will be back. read more

This was a great stop on McCall! The pizza was great and the service and hospitality were even better! I especially enjoyed the antipasto salad! read more

It took about 15 calls to get through on a Sunday evening. Ordered our pizzas and one came apart in our oven as it was to heavily sauced and cheesed (buffalo chicken). I wasn't impressed with their dough but toppings were fine. read more