We are visiting McCall and looking for a pizza option... there are a few to choose from. I am happy we picked Hometown Pizza. I've read posts about other items on the menu, this rating is just based on what we ordered - pizza! Pros - great pizza! We order a large cheese and pineapple pizza for 3 kids. A medium 1/2 garden & 1/2 combo for two adults. The garden was delicious (great flavor, fresh, good veggies/ crust proportions of ingredients) -- and no complaints and full bellies for everyone else. - super quick, ordered and it was ready for pick up in under 30. - very reasonably priced $50 for two pizza that fed us and left a few slices for lunch tomorrow. Cons - the website for ordering online was a little clunky, but worked... (not bad enough to knock off a star). - while everyone else liked the crust one kid did not, it was thinner and had a different texture (less "bready") than other pizza places, e.g. Papa John's. (IMO it was good!) The place was packed at 5pm on a Wednesday so that might mean something! read more

I went here many times. The buffalo chicken pizza is heaven. It makes me mad not to see too many people in here. The people behind the counter are really nice and hospitable. The ambiance could be better, but if more people really knew about this spot, it could be a serious hit. I'm backing this up, it's good. read more

This is a nice Pizza place close to McCall airport. We had a dog with us and they had outside seating. It was the week before the 4th of July 2025. We were at Ponderosa State park but were out exploring and didn't want to cook. Everyone there was amazing. The Pizza was great and since I am moving to New Meadows I will be back. read more

Great pizza and the only one I will order as take-out to bake at hone! Wonderful selection and good selection of drinks to choose from!!!

This place is great! I thought of them as a take-and-bake, but they are much more. Their pizza is amazing, available cooked, and they have a comfy bar. Very friendly staff. I'll be back. read more

Excellent! Ordered a small Veggie, delete the red sauce and sub in the garlic olive oil... Heavenly. Also orDeRed a half doZen hot wings and they were just as good! read more

I had the buffalo chicken sandwich and it was very good. Will probably have it again. Great service.

We came in late on a Saturday and they still took our order and served us to go. Very nice staff and the pizza is quite delicious. The baconator pizza is very yummy, a great choice if you like potato bacon pizzas! Would come here again when we visit again! read more

Hometown Pizza - Baconator, pepperoni, cheese sticks - Pizza Near Me - McCall, Idaho

Got it to go. Super friendly and good pizza. Got the Greek salad, it was also good but the pizza was the star.

Came in on a wednesday and they were slammed but still polite and food was great. Would eat here again.

Our pizza was creative & good enough. There were two separate sitting areas. We sat in the family dining area but had to order alcohol at the bar. Seemed inconvenient and unnecessary. read more

Hometown Pizza is open every day of the week and for McCall standards is open late (8-9pm)! After a long day on the slopes or at the lake, nothing hits like an easy dinner that the whole family can enjoy. We called to order on a Sunday around 7 pm for a 7:20 pickup. We ordered: (1) large Lean n Green pizza (1) large cheesy garlic breadsticks with garlic sauce and ranch (2) large caesar salads with a side of anchovies and Take n Bake cookies for $5! They say that they have the largest selection of salads in the area, but they do skimp on the greens. The side of anchovies for $2 for a large was tiny, which was a disappointment because I was really hoping to top my pizza with those anchovies. The side of the ranch on the other hand was HUGE. Come here for the pizza and breadsticks, but I'd recommend stopping by the grocery store for salad mix and to buy a tin of anchovies yourself! read more

The pizza here is delicious! We had a bit of a screw up with our order, but the bartender was quick to apologize and connect with the kitchen in order to get it right. The had just recently had some turnover in staffing, so we understand the hiccups and the pizza more than made up for the error. read more

The BEST Cauliflower/Keto Crust and the BEST Gluten Free Crust that I've eaten! I was in doubt at first about a cauliflower crust being tasty, but they cooked it to perfection! The toppings are also delicious and rich. They also bake the pizzas to the perfect temperature for a small upcharge or you can take the pizzas home and bake it. The service is amazing and the wings are also good. Definitely worth taking home baked or unbaked!! read more

Hometown Pizza - Cauliflower Crust Pepperoni Pizza - Pizza Near Me - McCall, Idaho

Today was busy in my little small town home of McCall, Idaho. We had just went to another restaurant and man the manager working was a bear and not a teddy bear. We were exhausted and HOT!!! We just wanted dinner! We walked in and were VERY politely greeted by Steve the former owner who told us they were out of crust. They then made adjustments added some things 2 smalls makes a large right? We got salad and friendly service and on a busy weekend in McCall that is exactly what needed to be on the menu! The new owner gave us 10% off and a smile. I don't eat out much in McCall in the summer, but I am going to commit to come here more often just to feel welcome in my own community. read more

See all

Fantastic pizza and wings. Absolutely loved the Jalamato Spinasil pizza. The staff is extremely nice and remembered my face even though I had only been there once. Dan, who I think is the owner check on our food and made sure it was up to their standards. The pub area is extremely comfortable, it's like entering a winter cabin. read more

Hometown Pizza - a man standing at the bar - Pizza Near Me - McCall, Idaho

See all

Unfortunately, have to write this review. What was once a wonderful pizza place has succumbed with the change in ownership. Tonight's large pepperoni pizza was flat, dry, overcooked with a limited and tasteless sauce. When we opened the box, the only comment in my mind was, pathetic. We also had a small beachcomber that was overcooked and burned. The large pepperoni and small speciality cost $48. The service has also changed from great to bad. We called in a pick up order, were asked to be placed on hold (phone set down on the counter, we could hear all the background in hometown). As we watched the clock pass 12 minutes on hold, we heard someone ask why the phone was on the counter, and another person said, "hang it up". And did. When we finally got through again, the person on the phone had attitude about being called out on being hung up on. I wish it was what it used to be, but the gradual decline over the last year to today's quality, service and price is sad. This was our last visit to a once great local favorite. This review is about today's experience, but the energy to finally write this has taken visits over a year, hoping it would improve. read more

We popped in after a day of skiing and found the food and hospitality to hit the spot. The pizza was just the way I like it, thin crust that was crunchy with great toppings. I had the Lean & Green with chicken, hubby had the pepperoni with black olives. We would definitely recommend! read more

We got take out for a large group. Everything from ordering on the phone to picking it up went very smoothly and the pizza was delicious. Can't say much about ambiance since we got take out. Would definitely order from them again next time we are in town. read more

Well....I have absolutely nothing negative to say about this place. We've tried it twice now and both times the service was amazing and the food was great! There are plenty of other fun options if you're not a pizza eater. Jalapeño popper sandwich, Denver (like the omelet) sandwich, and lots of salads like an oriental chicken salad. You can create your own on just about anything. Don't just stop at your usual, read the entire menu and try something new!! The service was outstanding. All three people I dealt with were extremely nice and went out of their way to be helpful. In a time time like this when people tend to be a little more negative and sour, these guys just kept a smile and offer that hometown feel from the minute you walk in. The food was just as good. We've had pizza, wings, and sandwiches. All were better than expected. The spicy wings are pretty mild and the crust on the pizza was really good. This says a lot because I'm picky about crust. Crispy outside, soft inside, and flavorful. There is some outdoor seating available if you're not doing carry out. Bonus: They have kiddie compartment plates available which was a huge help when we brought a 2 year old! read more

Hometown Pizza - Pizza Near Me - McCall, Idaho

Very Costco pizza like. Good to fill the belly. The inside of the restaurant needs a DEEP clean, it was definitely gross.

Four of us were very pleased with two small pizzas and beer in the pub section. A Six-Shooter and a Hawaiian, the latter being made with Canadian bacon. Crust was thin , but not too thin, and crispy. They were serve hot and sliced on trays with raised bumps which kept the crust from getting soggy. Staff were friendly and efficient. The place appeared popular with the locals. read more

Great take and bake pizza! Agree with some others that salads aren't too big, but they have a great me

Very good pizza and service! Staff is very nice and friendly! We got the cheese and hobi's spicy supreme pizza, both were very good and flavorful! The owner was super nice he gave our 2 year old a free cookie after. I will be coming back when I'm in McCall again, definitely recommend! read more

We were in town for skiing and dropped in on our way out of town. We ordered cheese pizza for the kiddo, Italian sandwich, and this delicious veggie sandwich. Great looking presentation and delicious food. Keep up the good work! read more

Hometown Pizza - Veggie sandwich with chicken - Pizza Near Me - McCall, Idaho

We made a trip to McCall on August 21st and my husband HAD TO HAVE PIZZA!!! The staff are all so friendly and everything is freshly made to order, including slices. They have a wide variety of drinks (both alcoholic and non). Fun place. read more

They were very busy when we arrived but that was to be expected for a Sunday evening. Pizza was great with plenty of toppings, I would definitely come here again! read more

Hometown Pizza - Pizza Near Me - McCall, Idaho

Been here a hour and I've watched people that arrived later receive their food, and been servered, the service is great but wait time is ridiculous read more

If I could give 10 stars I would. The customer service was delightful and on point. The food was equally outstanding. As a family we highly recommend this small business in McCall!!! read more

Delicious food, beautiful people and very good service. You feel like family here. We always during come here on Christmas time and they decorate nicely and help you with orders and everything. For now, they are closed on Mondays so plan accordingly but this might change in the future so make sure to check their hours. They have clean restroom. Kitchen is clean, restaurant is clean, this is all we need when we are on vacation. Thanks again read more

The pizza here is good and there are a lot of options. Prices are reasonable. Processing customers should be more efficient. Especially handling telephone vs in person customers. Of special note is the caramel corn they sell by the counter. The best I've ever had. It's five star worthy for sure. read more

We love this place. I've never had a bad pizza, and I appreciate that they offer fresh baked, or bake at home. They keep very busy, so you will have the best luck going there directly in person, as opposed to ordering over the phone. read more

If you're in town you should eat here. We had the one with jalapeños and spinach and fresh garlic and it was delicious! read more

Hometown Pizza - a slice of pizza on a pizza pan - Pizza Near Me - McCall, Idaho

One of the best pizzas I have had in any town. Oh em eff gee. Look at that crust. (It tastes as good as it looks) read more

Hometown Pizza - a slice of pizza on a plate with a fork - Pizza Near Me - McCall, Idaho

See all

Excellent pizza. Excellent service. You can't go wrong ordering anything from here. We had wings, salad and pizza. Just awesome. read more

With a baby in tow, food is always a challenge, even pre COVID! Hometown had great pizza and salad options, both of which we took advantage of and chowed down. Their Caesar was pretty darn good especially since I'm a huge lettuce snob and require my salads to not be comprised of iceberg. Hometown had a great salad and their veggie pizza was perfect! I love they give the option of take and bake or have them cook it there, definitely a great feature. Best of all? The staff. When we ordered on the phone tons of veg which my husband explained was my fault, the gentlemen on the other end made a joke about how he assumed my husband wasn't ordering meat pizza because I was listening in and my husband answered to the affirmative! The friendliness and genuine care for the customer was clear and that goes leaps and bounds in my book. If we come back, no doubt we'll be getting pizza here! read more

We stopped by for some take-out during our stay in McCall on a Sunday night. The restaurant is nothing special on the eyes....dont let that fool you about the pizza. The service was very helpful and friendly. The restaurant was clean and simple. The seating is seat yourself and take care of yourself. They will make the pizza.....and that is about it so get ready to get the drinks and others yourself. We ordered garlic cheese bread, small pizza with pepperoni, and their special "The Greek". The cheese bread was strong with garlic...yummy. The dough is more on the thin crust side. The ingredients were good and made a tasty pizza. If you are looking for a great pizza while on McCall, definitely worth a stop. Cheers Always! read more

See all

this is some of the best PIZZA We have had in ? well forever! the crust fantastic top notch ingredients! needless to say. we will be back maybe tomorrow. The lady at the counter is as Pleasant as could be! thank You for a good meal read more

I previously posted a one star review, but I'm upping it to a 5 for the customer service. The owner got in touch with me personally and explained the situation. The place was packed that night and my pizza accidentally got made with dough that hadn't had a chance to rise before the toppings were put on. She didn't try to use this as an excuse, either. I got a very sincere apology and she refunded my money. Because of her quick response, I will definitely give this place another shot when I visit McCall again. read more

Delicious pizza, salad options and sandwiches. Never disappoints! And I love that there are options for everyone, so very easy to dine there with a group! read more