One of the best Diners around. Good price, great steak sandwich and French dip…read more Don't recommend the steak wrap. Service is great. It's got the good old, but updated ambience.

The Atlantis Diner located in Babylon is a commendable option for breakfast, lunch, or dinner…read more The Diner maintains a clean and reasonably spacious environment. The staff members are amiable, and the food quality is satisfactory. We enjoyed breakfast for dinner, and it was delightful.

Unfortunately, Peter Pan diner is now much too expensive. I'm a long time customer & was so very…read morehappy to return yesterday after it's closing due to fire. The renovations are lovely. The food is as good as ever, but now costs way too much for my return. Everything has increased by $10 to $15/item. A greek salad with grilled chicken costs $28 + tax with terrible, sweet pink dressing! Also, the waitress was nice, selling the food, but couldn't get a take out order correctly completed. The total bill came to $58 with tip for a salad & a sandwich. That's a tank of gas! Its sad, for 25 years, I really, really liked this diner.

So happy they are back. Great Cheeseburger…read more The seating arrangement however to the south (to the left when you walk in) is horrendous. Sitting on the exterior you feel like you are being watched and can hear the conversation of the table across the aisle who is literally watching you eat. Bizarre design.

My go to for brunch since forever. Team always on point, a local gem for sure! Spacious and rich…read moreoutside a boat dock, nice to sit and chill after eating your life away lol. My favorites things on the menu: * Brioche French Toast * Biscuits & Gravy * Salted Caramel Iced Latte * Loaded Homefries * Fresh Orange Juice * Brooklyn Cheesecake French Toast The new loaded homefries are amazing! That hollandaise sauce makes it go from 3 to 10. Sharing pics from Holiday 2025: Brioche French Toast & Cookies for Santa Latte (hot)

This was my second time at a Toast but the first time at this location. It was a bit nostalgic for…read moreme as the building used to house a bar my husband and I frequented many, many years ago. Needless to say even though the footprint was basically the same the interior has been changed is very open and inviting. A friend and I were there for lunch around 1:30 on a Monday. No issue getting a table and were seated immediately. Katie our server was very nice, pleasant and efficient. Drink were brought out quickly and our order taken. My friend got an omelet special with Irish bangers and cheese with home fries and rye toast. She enjoyed the omelet and I have to say the rye bread was outstanding. Don't think it's made in house but were ever they get it from is really good. I got a lunch special of Pot Roast sandwich with onions, mushrooms and cheese on thick cut bread. It was served with a au jus dipping sauce. If it's on the menu don't hesitate to get it, it was outstanding and so stuffed I could only eat half. Will absolutely be returning to Toast !

I've been meaning to try this cafe for a while, it's been recommended by a few people…read more First of all, the coffee is probably the best I've had at a cafe. I like my coffee with breakfast simple with a dash of milk and some sugar. I love that they had milk substitute specifically oat milk. I like a sweet breakfast so I ordered Nikki's Nutella crepe. I really enjoyed it. It was delicious and wasn't heavy. The service here is great there wasn't much of a wait at all for our food and our waitress kept our coffee cups full. I like that antique decorations at the entrance. I definitely want to try their other locations.

Portion size was smaller than I expected…read more I had a diner experience idea when I decided to try it. That's not totally what I got..It was more crowded/busy when the early weekday afternoon we ate there. Our server seemed overwhelmed. The food was good, the "Gatsby" decor was a nice surprise.

The drinks came fast, around 2 minutes. The food came in 5. Our waitress was extremely kind (Thank…read moreyou Elsa) And not to mention how everything tasted, I loved the wall art. Definitely come if you're in the area.

The food was absolutely delicious, everything tasted fresh and well-made…read more The place itself is super clean and decorated really cute, which makes it such a nice spot to sit and enjoy your meal. The portions are also huge, so you definitely get your money's worth. Come hungry! Overall, a great breakfast spot that I'll definitely be going back to.

A pass this establishment every single day It does have some…read morenice parking I was going to order a hamburger but ended up getting the slider lunch deal I really enjoyed it so much. It's like a real barbecue. Taste exactly what you want to taste a little bigger than a slider but not big enough to be a full-blown hamburger. Then I started smelling the area and I now ordered a pizza. I can't say enough check this place out right away. There is no lines they take care of you right away.!! The person that took care of me her name is Debbie , anything that I needed help with She explained.

Great service and love the ambience and vibe…read more I wish I had ordered the burger. I ordered the pizza with vodka sauce which had meatballs, prosciutto and crispy onions. Nice flavor but I did not like the crust. A little too doughy for me. The cauliflower app with spinach hummus was tasty. My girlfriend had the onion soup which looked pretty thick but she's had it before and presumably loved it. My other friend is a regular and is a raving fan. So I was looking forward to it. She had the pizza with the whipped ricotta and Zuchinni. She enjoyed it but was missing an app that was removed, something with blueberries. She said on paper, it didn't sound appetizing but it's a favorite of hers. All around, great experience. Next time I'm going to try a burger.

Came here with a friend for lunch. It was pretty average…read more We both ordered the new vanilla iced coffee. We agreed it was very sweet. For my meal I got the poblano omelette and my friend ordered the two egg breakfast which came with choice of meat, toast and hash-browns. Food came out in a reasonable amount of time but someone other than our waitress brought it out and then our waitress never really came back. When she finally did come back I asked for hot sauce, and she took a while to come back with it. By the time she came back with it, I was already pretty much done/full. Overall, food was alright but service needs improvement.

We were in the area for an appointment and wanted breakfast after. The plan was to try Toast, which…read morewas an equal amount of distance away from where we were. However, when we called Toast, the girl on the phone said there was a 40 minute wait and she was also rude. So we immediately opted out. It was 11:30am on a Thursday. We then decided to go to the old standby, IHOP. This location was off Sunrise Highway, around the left side of the mall. It has its own entrance from the outside and plenty of parking. We could see from the windows that there was hardly anyone inside. It was pouring rain and we were hungry. So we went against the low rated Yelp reviews and empty seats, and listened to our stomachs (and the hangry tweenager). We were kindly greeted upon entering. We asked for a booth and got seated at a clean table by the windows. Our waitress came right over to take our drink order. She was kind and efficient. An apple juice, a pot of decaf and a pot of regular coffee came to the table hot and fresh. We needed a few minutes to look over the menu and she obliged. We placed our order when she came back. We had a few questions and she answered them all with a smile. I would like to say that I had very low expectations because of our local IHOP where we live. We used to go often and it is so poorly run. The food is always wrong and always COLD! I don't get why it's always crowded. Who wants cold pancakes!? We spoke to a manager every time, who fixed the food and apologized, which is great...but it was literally EVERY. TIME. So we stopped going there. Well, this experience was the exact opposite. When the food came out, not only was it all correct, but it was also HOT! The way it's supposed to be. We were a party of 3 hungry gals and not one morsel was left on our plates. If I had to complain about anything, it would be the prices. They were pretty high and they charge you for every little thing. But that's not the fault of the restaurant. We paid $70 bucks for breakfast, for 3 people. At IHOP. We were able to take our time and enjoy our meal and each other's company. We were also given coffee cups to go for whatever was not finished from the pot. We would definitely come back again if in the area. Sorry TOAST.

We had our work holiday party here for about 60 people last week at in their upstairs space, and it…read morewas absolutely FABULOUS. I had reached out online and Nikki, the co-owner, was prompt in responding with packages and options. I had shopped around with almost every restaurant in Bay Shore and their packages were the most reasonable. Communication with Nikki was seamless and easy. Booking required an upfront deposit, headcount was due 2 weeks before the event, and rest of the payment was due 1 week beforehand. We had the buffet style and got: -Choice of 3 cold platters: chopped iceberg salad, spinach salad, and orzo salad -Choice of one vegetable: grilled vegetables with balsamic glaze -Choice of starch: garlic mashed potatoes -Choice of pasta with an add-on pasta: penne ala vodka, orecchiette with sausage and broccoli -Choice of 2 hot entrees: bulgogi beef, seafood paella with an add-on salmon -Choice of 1 dessert: seasonal bread pudding The day of, I arrived about an hour early and set up was super easy as the upstairs is already gorgeously decorated for the holidays. The wait staff were already ready and very helpful in helping me bring in items. The sound system had Christmas music on already and they had set up part of the room with extra white linen tables for our white elephant activity and a DIY photobooth (which I brought). The entire event was wonderful and our group had a wonderful time. Every dish we got was INCREDIBLE and so tasty. There isn't a single dish that wasn't perfectly cooked and seasoned. My favorites were the the bulgogi beef, paella, salads, the orecchiette (but I'm a sucker for this dish), and bread pudding. The team was also very kind with dietary restrictions, putting meat/dairy salad toppings off to the side, and making vegetarian and vegan bibimbap bowls. Of note, their korean dishes are SPECTACULAR as Nikki's mom, Helen, is korean! Can't wait for next year's party and many of my team members are now interested in hosting their own parties here! Highly highly recommend!

Love this spot for a casual lunch or dinner with family or friends. It gets busy so I recommend a…read morereservation. It's one of my favorite water spots, and perfect for the summer time. My go-to are the Ceviche, Calamari, Korean Lettuce Wraps, and the Pan-Seared Scallops. The Ceviche is always amazing! Easily one of the best apps on their menu. The Calamari is well battered and seasoned with sweet chili. I love the Pan Seared Scallops - the figs, grits, and bacon give it a well-rounded taste of sweet and savory. This is one of my favorite seafood spots in Bay Shore (there are others) and one I visit often in the summer time. I recommend popping by if you're in the area, especially when the weather is warm out!

Love everything about Tula...the food, the ambience, the vibe…read more I came her for dinner recently with a large group of girlfriends and it was excellent. The service was excellent and my app and entree were yummy. I got the Spinach Pie with Tzatziki small bites and the Forbidden Salad, which has arugula, beets, radish, feta, some kind of grain with a lemony vinaigrette. And the cocktails were so pretty and delicious. We will be back. Highly recommend.

Visited for breakfast (served until 3pm), which is a nice bonus for late risers. You place your…read moreorder at the counter, and they bring it to your table once it's ready. My husband got the Egg Sammy and really enjoyed it. I had the potato avocado egg smash, super flavorful and just the right amount of filling, especially since I wanted something without bread. The vibe is laidback and quiet a great little spot for a relaxed breakfast or brunch.