This unexpected lunch treat was a terrific experience. My shrimp parm was delicious and plentiful. My friend's shrimp scampi was tasty and generously shrimp laden. Will definitely go back. Our server was very attentive. The decor is nautically cute and pleasant to look at. Their menu is diverse. Their fish market is bonus. Yes I really liked this place. We Have a nice leftovers too. read more

My husband and i have been regular customers for many years of catfish Annies and we just found out they make lobster rolls yummy, we use to go to port Jefferson cause we know of a great place that has them.so today we ordered 2 to go that we were surprise that for $26.99 and you get either fries or their delicious seafood bisque soup we felt this was a good price. let me tell you they give you plenty of lobster and it is so delicious, i am glad to see that we have a place closer to home that we can go. Way to go!! read more

Catfish Annies - Lobster - Seafood Near Me - Commack, New York

See all

We have used catfish Annie's the last two years to cater our party. They are simply amazing. My guest go crazy for their lobster rolls especially. The staff can't be more helpful and attentive when ordering. They are more than generous with the portions and customer satisfaction is most important to them. I have heard of them for years And finally tried them. I know they have been there forever but to me they are a gem hidden away! read more

Catfish Annie's fish is always fresh, just recently had a quick lunch there, Fried Calamari with mild and hot sauce and Crab Cakes, which was very good!...Looking forward to trying to get back there to try some more.... read more

Catfish Annies - Fried Calamari and Crab Cakes - Seafood Near Me - Commack, New York

1-21-25. I actually visited Catfish Annie's a few months ago (October 2024) and I'm reviewing now because Yelp reminded me to do so. I went for lunch on a weekday with 6 other people. We ordered quite a bunch of appetizers and entrees and did a little tasting of each. Everything was very good and it was a pleasant meal overall. Ambiance is very casual and prices are reasonable for a seafood joint. Service was pretty fast and friendly. read more

Small quaint place . Bisque was very good. Linguini with white clam sauce you get like a pound of pasta my dad loved it . Fried chicken I had was crispy and tasty shrimp fra diavlo spicy and tasty . Service was good friendly and attentive. Nautical themed decor and horse racing pics in which my dad loved because we had race horses also and my dad remembers the owner from years ago in the circuit . I had pics of the food I can't find them lol read more

I ordered a dozen scallops and a half dozen baked clams on Friday January 23rd, and made them on the 25th, I didn't know until after I made them that they gave me spoiled ones because I never ordered them from a store before. Ruined my mom's birthday quite a bit because of it. :( read more

Diner food - this place is seriously for old people who have no taste buds. The fish itself seemed fresh enough but don't expect anything to be cooked well. Fisherman's platter a complete disaster, shrimp boiled down to rubber. Extremely simple 1 ingredient dishes - the baked potato literally was just a potato from the oven - dried out because it wasn't even poked with holes to let the air through. Children employed as servers, atmosphere is a sad husk of something that might have been lively in 1980. Reasonable prices and I am evaluating as a restaurant, not as a fish market. My wife took one look at the food and decided she would pass. I tried everything and crossed my fingers I would not get sick. I will not be returning. read more

Catfish Annies - Fisherman's platter - Seafood Near Me - Commack, New York

See all

Great place for some delicious seafood! We ordered a few dishes for Mother's day and we were so pleased! Calamari great flavor. Crab Cakes crunchy and tasty. Baked clams hearty and tasted wonderful. Mussels, wow generous portion and our guests truly enjoyed! Will definately order from here again! read more

service was just terrible - waitress forgot we were there, we reminded waitress we had been waiting for 30 minutes - she got our entree , forgot our soup and put it it in a bag to take home , baked potato served , no butter or sour cream offered until we asked , vegetables undercooked and hard - lobster cold - overall a "0" rating back hall to bathroom filthy dirty - amazing dept of health hasn't issued violations first and last time terrible experience - very disappointing read more

Catfish Annie's is a great place to eat.. The food is always fresh .. they have Lunch and dinner special. The restaurant part is not very big .But they also have a fish market I would recommend it read more

Pretty good food at this hidden gem. Great service and yummy food. Last time we were here we had fried fish which was to die for. Not greasy at all but full of yummyness. Have no complaints here. Plus close to home. Due to Covid haven't been back in a while. Would love to try their fresh seafood to bring home to cook as well. It always is super clean and NEVER smells fishy. read more

Solid fresh sea food. I tried the fried flounder and it was satisfyingly good. I don't eat other sea food so I can't voice an opinion on other than fish. The atmosphere was basic like that you would expect at a sea food joint on the piers. White paper covering the table, etc. All in all I am likely to return when in area. read more

Food is delicious, service is good, owner needs an attitude adjustment. Serving size is excellent

Catfish Annie's is a wonderful place to go dine in or takeout. The owner is a sweetheart as well as the workers there very friendly always smiling and helpful the Food is omg so good especially Shrimp Fried dinner, fried claims, and so many other excellent dishes oh and the soup is delicious you got to try it!! read more

Great place for a traditional, old-fashioned seafood dinner. Fresh seafood and good service. Eat in, take out or buy seafood from their display case and lobster tank. read more

Fresh tasting shrimp and stuffed sole. Friendly staff. Clean atmosphere. Nice display of assorted fresh fish. Good pricing.

My husband and I have been a part of the CatfishAnnie's family for at least 12 years. We absolutely love everything about CatfishAnnie's. We have to say, the food is delicious especially the hamburger and all types of seafood.. Our favorite food is fried shrimp , hamburgers, and my husbands is fisherman platter). All employees are super nice. We always feel so welcomed and they treat us so nicely when we come for a bite to eat. We do see regular costumers who also eat at this great restaurant which is great because now we call them our friends.. We love being a part of the CatfishAnnie's family. We highly recommend this great restaurant. read more

GREAT FOOD,prefect service, all the service staff looked for ways to make your dinner better and more enjoyable. I would recommend this restaurant to anyone who is looking for something special. Please don't hesitate to dine here the atmosphere here is amazing, Please disregard the bad reviews, they had to been written by a few sour grapes. I will Always go back to Aunt Annie's Catfish Restaurant. read more

None of the apps tasted like it was fresh or made in house, even if it was, it did not taste or feel like it. We ordered shrimp cocktail, mussels in garlic sauce & calamari as an appetizer. The shrimp was still frozen frozen in the center, the mussels tasted old, the sauce wasn't very good and the calamari as well as everything else was not seasoned at all although fried well but just tasted like oil and squid. During entrees, the fries, blackened catfish and fried fish was good. But the vegetables were not seasoned at all, the crab crakes were deep fried, not lump crab cakes and again, everything was very unseasoned. Not under but not seasoned. Even the water was not very good tbh. I honestly wouldn't recommend, not good. read more

Catfish Annies - Shrimp Cocktail - Seafood Near Me - Commack, New York

See all

Food is simple, good and the prices are fair. I'm posting this today because there was a little confusion with my pickup order and the owner came up, heard the story and just said the food was on the house. I was more than willing to pay for this simple mistake but he made it more than right. The owner is involved in every aspect of the restaurant. If the soft shell crabs look small today he will throw in another one gratis for your order. Will continue to support this restaurant. read more

Tonight we tried Catfish Annie s restaurant in Commack, it was all around great! our dinner was delicious the waitress and the rest of the staff were friendly and quick. we are already planning our next visit and are bringing family with us. read more

I had a lovely experience here. in addition to dinner, salmon, being done well. On Halloween the owner or manager gave my daughter a free dessert, which was so nice. I will go back this week for lobster. read more

Disappointed flavor was lacking all around. No seasoning. Also they put a fish sandwich on a deli Kaiser roll? Why? It definitely was not good. read more

Delicious seafood at its finest. Not a place I would necessarily go to as a young person on a date given the older feel but great for families and get togethers. Go for the real fish and seafood though, the fried stuff is usually a miss. Their New England clam chowder is one of my favorites around, and their lobster is stellar in season. read more

This was one of the better soured soft shell crab dishes I've had. The dish was overflowing with 3, yes I said 3 crabs. A mountain of veggies and corn on cob. This was a great dish. The Manhattan clam chowder was excellent. The steamers also very fresh, but cooked with just a bit to much butter for my taste anyway!! read more

Catfish Annies - Sauté soft shell crabs - Seafood Near Me - Commack, New York

Really Nice! My husband raves every time he goes there. Friendly staff know exactly what you are looking for and suggest readily. Our go to when ordering for a party or just Sunday sauce (crab). read more

Seafood is ok - the owner can be overly aggressive when asked a question. I used to go here all the time until the owner gave me attitude and sass. read more

The place is not what it use to be The restaurant appearance is very run down. I was very disappointed tonight. My husband and I went to eat there tonight. As my husband bit into his fried fillet, he found a long piece of hair seared into the batter. I informed our server. The response was they were trying to figure out whoose hair it was. Can you imagine getting a response like that??? We actually thought they would credit us for the meal but noooo. I asked why and was told the sodas were taken off the bill. I was also told that because he ate the other fish in the dish, that he ate most of the meal. Wow I have no word. The manager/owner didn't even come over. This is so sad. Let me ask anyone, would it have really put this restaurant for broke for a meal that cost $21 dollars. Very sad. Won't be going back. read more

This place is a complete joke. Takeout lobster salad at $80 per pound is bad enough but apparently Catfish Annies believes that a pound is comprised of 13 ounces. Consistently. The place does not look particularly clean either. read more

Just ate at Catfish Annie's for the first time. It was delicious !!! Crab cakes, fried shrimp, stuff sole were fresh and wonderful. Service was outstanding. Owners were very friendly as well. Fresh seafood and will definitely be back read more

Want to eat fresh seafood for lunch? Go to a place that has a restaurant in a seafood store. Whole 1 1/4 # steamed lobster with soup and French fries $18.95! Is the décor fancy? Nope. Would you take a date here? Yep. If you think to seeing each other elbow deep in a lobster carcass is sexy, absolutely! That's the test, someone who tries to eat daintily here shouldn't get another date they're not going to be good in the sack anyway. Service was friendly, the server even tied our lobster bib on us! read more

Had broiled stuffed shrimp. Excellent. So we're the veggies and service great too. First time here. Not sure about negative reviews but can make my own decisions. Good luck. Will be back. read more

Solid little hole in the wall. Always fresh, never overcooked. Had a giant tuna steak cooked black and blue just like I like it.

If there was a way to give zero stars I would give this restaurant zero. Unfortunately I had to give one star. The owner has a scam going if you use your Debit card. Either you get charged twice for your order or he says that your card didn't work. That's when I offered to pay cash. Meantime the charge went through giving a double charge. The owner is nasty when confronted and threatens to kill you. I will never ever go back to this scam restaurant. The owner is extremely nasty. I feel sorry for the people who work in the kitchen. I'm making a complaint to the Better Business Bureau. Be warned and avoid this scam place!!! read more

Had a terrible experience today. Trying to support my local small business. I went into the store today to purchase tuna steaks for a dinner party. The fish did not look like tuna (I am not a fish eater) so I questioned the owner as to what type of tuna it was. I was informed it was yellow fin. I put the fish on the grill as company was arriving. My husband took one look and asked why I bought salmon. I called the owner to explain my situation to which he responded "what would you like me to do" and he hung up the phone on me. My dinner party was ruined! My husband and I brought the fish back to the store and the owner was rude and asked us to never come back to his store! Not a problem! read more

Ordered Catfish Annie's today for the second time. Once again excellent quality entrees all around. We ordered Seafood Bisque and NE Clam Chowder to start, both soups were very good. There was a generous amount of seafood and clams respectively and great flavor too. For entrees we had the broiled salmon and the grilled swordfish. Both were prepared well and the fish was as fresh as a five star restaurant. I live 30 miles away and it is definitely worth the drive. I will absolutely be back. read more

Got a lobster roll to go...$27 and change!?!! Ok fine this better be the best lobster roll I ever had...anddd no. Unseasoned lobster salad on a straight up HOT DOG bun!? Like u buy at the grocery store..? Is this a joke..? Split buttered roll toasted is how it's supposed to go down...I've had better lobster rolls in bars..for $18 not $28! I would rather drive my ass to red hook or coney...new to Long Island I'll find a different spot if anyone has any suggestions thanks read more

I stopped in Catfish Annie's for the first time totally unplanned. So when I checked-in on my phone and saw the 1.5 star rating I was a little worried. And while my experience didn't warrant a request to speak to the manager it also won't be getting top awards. We were a party of 2 and our order consisted of fried calamari appetizer, fisherman's platter - 2 baked clams, 4 scallops, 3 shrimp, filet of sole with a double order of steamed broccoli (I opted for double veggies instead of potato). The other entree was filet of sole stuffed with crab, french fries and veggies. The entrees came with soup or salad and we both picked soup - seafood bisque and Long Island clam chowder. The clam chowder was better than the seafood bisque and the stuffed filet of sole was better than the fisherman's platter. On the platter the scallops and shrimp were a wee bit over cooked for my liking and were a little dry. Calamari appetizer was ok, clean oil and not too greasy, just would have preferred more legs - lots of rings. For dessert we shared the Spumoni Truffle which was pretty good. All and all the experience was ok - from food to service everything was ok. Nothing stood out and nothing to really call me back for more. If I could give them a 2.5 star rating that would be more accurate but because Yelp only allows us to rate in 1 star increments, I'll be positive and give them 3. read more

See all

Great hidden gem. This is a restaurant with great service & great food. Especially in this day & age when restaurant prices are skyrocketing. It's great portions & friendly family atmosphere. We will definitely come here often. It's great to help small businesses in this time especially when they keep prices affordable, with great food and do not price gouge. read more