You know it wasn't a good experience when the first thing you and your wife simultaneously say is, "Well that was disappointing!" Which it was.
We were super excited to try this place because we've been to Sanctuaria, and the food and drink there was awesome. So we figured the same would apply here, but with the BBQ. Not so, not so.
The place was decorated really neat, and has a cool outside seating area which would be great to visit on a cool summer evening. That's about where our liking of this place ended.
We started with the BBQ nacho appetizer, free if you check in on yelp, which we did. I'm glad we didn't pay for it. It was like they tried to make a nacho, pulled pork salad. There were big chunks of lettuce that made no sense in it. Not to mention we asked for the baked beans on the side, instead of in the nachos. Of course the beans still came in the nachos. The pulled pork that topped the nachos had no smoky flavor, for all I knew it was roasted in a rotisserie or in an oven. No semblance of and BBQ or smoke flavor in it. Also did not love the sparse bit of cheese they put on it was already hard and congealed by the time it made it to our table.
Which was a long time. In fact everything that we ordered took forever. We must have waited 15 minutes for our beers to arrive, and equally long for our entree's after our appetizer.
My wife ordered a burger with cheese and sides of fried potatoes and potato salad. Hey, she likes potatoes. I ordered the turkey dinner entree. Usually entree would indicate your meal comes with a side or two. Usually the term "meal" means you get a main dish and at least one side dish. Well sadly your turkey entree comes with no sides at all, you have to order them ala carte.
When my food arrived my wife actually said, "They should be ashamed to serve you an entree with no side!" And it was a just a sad little plate with a small portion of turkey on it. I ordered the large size, but was I got felt like it was the small. I can't imagine if I had ordered the small size, the plate would have looked HOOGE. So upon seeing my sad little plate of tiny turkey breast, I asked for a side of sweet potato casserole. If took another 15 minutes for that to arrive.
My turkey was just like the pulled pork. No smokey flavor, no BBQ tasty goodness. If this turkey was smoked or BBQ'd you could have fooled me! Was it juicy? Yes. Did it taste like over roasted turkey? Also yes. Even if I saw them smoke or BBQ this turkey with my own eyes, I wouldn't have believed it.
Lets talk about sides. My sweet potato casserole was fine, just fine. No strong flavors, it was very mild and borderline bland. My wife's fried potatoes were no different than what I could make at home, in fact I could definately make those at home, but better. They had very little seasoning. My wife described the potatoes in the potato salad as "Barely cooked" and "a hair away from crunchy."
My wife said her burger was fine, but not worth ever going back for, let alone you don't go to a BBQ place for a burger.
Shall I discuss the sauces? I shall. The 'sweet' sauce was sweet but it was very runny. In fact all the sauces with the exception of the 'spicy', were very runny. And they all seemed loaded with paprika. That's how it tasted to me. The spicy really wasn't very spicy and I got more paprika taste than anything. The 'house' tasted more sweet than the sweet. The 'STL' was fine. All in all they were nothing special, IMO.
It was a completely underwhelming experience, and I do realize that St. Charles doesn't have many options as far as BBQ goes, but for serious...no side dish with my entree? This isn't a Ruths Chris steak house. My wive's prediction- They won't be open long. My predication- they've got a lot of work to do to be as good as Sanctuaria. Or even Pappy's or Bogarts. read more