My wife and I love this place for winding down after work. Good food, especially the apps, fries, and burgers. Friendly service staff and good prices. Typical sports style bar but like 8I mentioned better than average food read more

Looking for something a little different for dinner last night and remembered how much I enjoyed Hamilton pubs food so I picked up the phone and placed an order. It was no surprise that as usual my food was piping, hot and delicious. Might I add, portions are large and prices are low. This is a must try! read more

Hamilton's Pub - Pub sub with fries - Pubs Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

Great bar! great atmosphere. HOWEVER, the bartender Erin was the worst. Slow service, and rude. And when she wasn't clearly faking a fake smile she had a resting bitch face on the whole time. She's apparently the manager and morning bartender most days. If you are going to come, come during the night. Harry is great and personable and funny. Always a great attitude!! I also want to point out that i personally am a bartender and have been for 15yrs now. I'm not just a someone complaining. Can someone please get Erin out of that bar read more

If it weren't for the bartender Mason, you might wait 10 minutes for a drink from the other bartenders. They seem to ignore you and rely on Mason to handle 90% of the clientele read more

The ambiance was that if a local pub with an adequate dining area. The service was great, attentive and prompt. My husband was not impressed worh their "extensive beer selections," so we settled on flat sodas. Despite being made aware of lack of carbonation, noone seemed to be bothered by it or knew how to change it. The food was very good, we both had the fish sandwich and fries. They were both fresh, hot and tasty. A good place to get a casual meal. read more

The bartenders are fantastic! Super friendly, quick and cares about their guests! The food is great, too.

The staff are the most accommodating, friendly & prompt. The music with the new speakers is a 10/10. Make sure to grab some bites too! Best bar food in NA/Gahanna! read more

Nice local spot with friendly regulars. Service is pretty good depending on which bartender you get. Food is pretty good for bar food. A no-nonsense bar with TV's for the game and music turned up pretty loud (the way I like it). TouchTunes is available. read more

Hamilton's Pub - Four Cheese Quesadilla with Crispy Chicken - Pubs Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

See all

Very nice establishment with lots of large screen TV's. There is a large dining area with high seats and tables. The staff was cordial and welcoming. The food was good, the side dish for one of us was cold (fries). The burger was good and the Rueben sandwich was above average and onion rings were lightly battered and delicious. The men's & women's bathrooms were clean. read more

See all

We have stopped in here twice so far and were able to grab two seats at the bar. I appreciate that they have Riesling and Yuengling available, and the menu is actually pretty good too. The Southwestern Chicken Wrap is very good (I've gotten it both times) and there are side options other than fries (I try to limit my intake). Always plenty of parking, a patio, and great staff! read more

Love it here. Love the fries. Love the nachos. Love the salads. Love the staff. Love the people.

Great place to watch sports, good food and service!! Fun atmosphere . Good for family also

I just relocated to the area and Hamiltons was recommended to me and my boyfriend. We really liked the atmosphere and the food was really good too. However, we were really disappointed that they let so many people use e-cigatettes and vapes. The table beside us and behind us were using. Totally ruined the evening. read more

**3.5/5 Stars** Our experience at Hamilton's Pub was pretty average for your normal bar/restaurant. It appeared like it has a very good set of regulars as the bar area was full, but the restaurant area was empty. The service was also average, our drink and food orders were taken without much fanfare and the food arrived in a timely manner. However, there were a couple issues with the food, mainly the fried items. The fries that came with my hamburger were undercooked and crunchy. The photo shows that they are cooked well on the outside, but the inside still had a raw taste. As for the burger, it was good, but lacked a little bit of seasoning. Overall, it won't be on the regular rotation, but we might try again. read more

Hamilton's Pub - All American Burger and Fries - Pubs Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

Wanted a burger for lunch and searched Yelp for one near where I was on Hamilton Rd. The photos looked good- so we stopped in and I'm glad we did. My wife had the Spicy Burger ($11 with fries) and she's particular when it comes to spicy. These jalapeños were just the right amount- covered in pepper Jack cheese and all the fixens. Nice. She was happy. I had the Thompson ($12 with fries) and it was also good. Swiss cheese, lots of crispy but not burnt bacon, sautéed mushrooms and onions on a nice sized bun. Hard pause here to talk about the fries. These were thin cut, cooked just right for my taste, and salted just enough that you liked it, but didn't feel like you just gargled saltwater. Friendly, quick service and a great afternoon stop for a burger and a beer. Photos don't do the burger justice, but you'll get the point. Good burger, good place, good price. Nice. read more

Hamilton's Pub - The Thompson Burger. Sautéed mushrooms, Swiss cheese, lots of crispy bacon with lettuce, onion & Tomato. - Pubs Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

See all

came here after the other near bars closed as this one is open later, no food was available at the time, standard bar drinks, and many tvs. Quick service. read more

Great service. Staff is friendly. Beer is cold. Don't trust the other review that said the egg rolls are bad. I almost didn't order them because of it but I'm glad I did. Egg rolls are fire. read more

I really loved the atmosphere of this place. Food was good and was quick. Our waitress Sam was always checking on us and making sure we were good on food and drinks. I've traveled from coast to coast for work and haven't found a place that was more fun and had better service than Hamilton's. Sam was amazing she chatted with us through out the night made jokes and it was just what we needed after a long day at work on a Monday. read more

Hamilton's Pub - Chili dog was pretty decent. The tater tots were on point!! - Pubs Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

went on a friday night with some friends, vibes were great! loved the music being played. drinks were cheap and yummy. our bartender was super kind and made my drink correct. read more

This is a great place for some basic bar fare done well. I've been coming here for many years as I used to be a manager of the bounce house that was right behind it before it closed a few years ago. We'd walk over after closing quite often for some snacks and drinks. My favorite thing here is the cheese quesadilla add crispy chicken. It sounds basic - and it is - but it's done so right. Lots of melty cheese and with the chicken it is just so indulgent and delicious. I also tried their new fried zucchini on my recent trip and while I enjoyed them, I think $10 is a bit steep consider there's only about 1 zucchini's worth of chips in the basket and zucchini isn't very pricey of a vegetable. I'd also prefer them in sticks as opposed to the chips they went with. But they were battered and cooked well and served with ranch for a good dip. I have and will definitely be back! read more

See all

Good was ok. Southwest egg rolls had little to no chicken. Bartender attentive. Drinks good.

My husband and I have been coming here for years. We bring guests here a lot. Food is good, service and servers excellent. They know what we drink and bring our drinks as soon as we sit down. Nice well maintained sports bar. Only down side for us, being in the older (in our 80's) generation is noise. In the evenings or game days it gets pretty loud and our hearing isn't the best. That shouldn't be a deterrent for the younger crowd it's a fun inviting atmosphere. read more

Won't be back. Been here three times and food was okay. We stopped today at 12:45 to have a beer and look at our errands list, only to walk in at a young lady with her leg propped up on a chair at the bar. We went and sat at the other side of the bar. She was our bartender. She came around the bar and gave us our drinks. Socially engaging with another patron about accepting shots at another bar she works at, but not here. Yet, not professionally dressed or acting like any other bartenders we've had before there. A couple walked out while we tried to pay our tab of one beer. I always tip, love to give second chances and give benefit of the doubt. But NO, won't be back, no tip, she needs an etiquette course in service industry behavior before midnight. read more

This is my second time at Hamilton's. This seat yourself bar/restaurant has plenty of seating and visibility to a lot of TVs. You can expect to wait a little longer for your food as the past times we have been there are not a lot of servers and they also work the bar. I got the Nashville hot chicken sandwich, when it came out the sauce was very dark like BBQ, when I took a bite it tasted and smelt more like a sweet/tangy BBQ not Nashville. I asked the server to make sure it was Nashville sauce and she brought me out a sample of the Nashville sauce to see if they tasted the same and they did. If you're wanting a true Nashville Hot tasting sandwich I do not recommend this one. My boyfriend loved his Jacks Favorite Quesadilla. Their french fries also remind me of fair fries. We will be back! read more

Be careful how the servers ring up your drinks. We went yesterday and I didn't catch this until today, but they rang up our bucket of Mich Ultra as import; which is an additional $5 to a bucket. read more

Hamilton's Pub - the receipt for the restaurant - Pubs Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

There are a lot of reasons Hamilton's is a favorite amongst my friends and I. A good selection of craft beers, solid bar food, very efficient staff, keno, dog friendly patio, and 1/2 price wing Wednesday. On this particular visit my boyfriend and I had lunch on the patio. Kendra, our server was awesome! She was on top of it, and really personable. We ordered boneless wings, cheeseburger sliders, and pretzel bites. The food is good, but don't expect to be blown away. I do really like their wing sauces, especially Flamethrower ( not unbearably hot, but spicy ) and Jim Beam BBQ ( sweet and smoky ). If you just need a drink and a snack you will be pleasantly surprised by Hamilton's. read more

Hamilton's Pub - 1/2 order Flamethrower boneless wings ( these are smaller than usual) and pretzel bites - Pubs Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

See all

We found this place sort of by accident. Great food! Great variety! Extremely cool bar atmosphere! Servers and bar tenders are top notch! read more

Great service and wonderful regulars. The number of screens make it always possible to see "your game" as you imbibe.

Neat little pub right of the main drag in New Albany. First time here, but heard good reviews from a friend. I walked in and was impressed. great seating options, great atmosphere. Multiple TV's to catch any type of sports or a variety of other media. Nice solid sturdy tables and socially distant. We arrived, they weren't very busy, we got a table and the bartender came over and got our drink order. She did a very good job of keeping my drink full. As the night progressed it became much busier. We decided to order an appetizer, we waited, and waited, finally decided we should order food as the frequency of our servers visits were getting longer and longer. Our food arrived and no appetizer. we asked, and she admitted that she forgot to put it in, it came later. The chicken egg rolls were okay, soft wrap and good flavor from the filling. I would have preferred a different dipping sauce other than ranch. The buffalo chicken sliders were standard bar food. Chicken chunks in buffalo sauce with blue cheese crumbles. I was excited about the shoe string fries, but they were a big letdown. They were soggy and under cooked. Overall a nice spot to have drink and watch the game. read more

See all

Not a bad place to grab a beer or a quick dinner. We live pretty close to here so its really easy for us to pop over when we want. The food is nothing impressive in my opinion, however they do have half off wings wednesdays which is a pretty sweet deal! They offer boneless and bone-in. Both are good! They also have some beer specials occasionally. Our favorite thing about this place is that they host trivia (by sporkle) on Wednesday nights. Free to play! You just have to be able to snag a table. Parking is easy -- large lot surounds the place. It's well-kept. The bathrooms are clean and I've never had a problem with them lacking toilet paper. I call that a win in any Pub. Friendly service. Thanks for being a great place for wings! read more

Good place for work happy hour. Not a good place for family especially if you have older people or children. Food was average pub style. Pizza was peculiar... the thin crust was extremely thin to the point that it couldn't support the cheese or loaded sauce. The flavor was decent and familiar until I realized it tasted exactly like the cheap $1 Torino's pizza you at as a kid only instead of paying 1-2 bucks your paying $12-14 for a sloppy pie. Service was okay. Got same drink 3 times and was presented and tasted different all 3 times. Good just inconsistent. read more

See all

Went on a Friday night around 630pm and sat outside on the patio. Live music started around 730/8, band (3 guys) were good. Has the buffalo chicken dip and the chips that came with it were AMAZING - not a low fat dish. I had the pub blue burger and fries with vinegar and it was great! Large portions overall! Great beer specials especially if you drink yuengling light. Plenty of seating both in and outside. Parking not an issue. Our waiter was Zack- he was fantastic!!! read more

This little hole in the wall has become a favorite spot for my family. Their food is average, their prices are what you'd guess them to be, and the atmosphere is like any old bar. However, their WINGS. Their wings are everything. They are giant. Jumbo. And they are fried to perfection-- providing the perfect crunch followed by tender, juicy bites of meat. The sauces are delicious as well. Especially the bourbon and the garlic parm. My husband asks to go every time we are in the area. Normally I'd give a place like this a 3.5/4. But with wings this good, I can't give less than a 5. Hamilton's Pub knows what they are doing with wings. read more

So my buddy used to come here after golf, but he couldn't remember the name of it until one day when we went to Mezze, and he instantly recognized it. According to him the place had some awesome wings, but he wasn't sure how great, since it was after golf and a few drinks. Well, we eventually made it here for lunch this week. Long story short: the wings are awesome. In fact, the wings themselves are some of the best I've ever had. They have a super crispy coating but not a super thick batter which is almost perfect in my mind. The chicken was juicy, and the wings were pretty big. I tried the flamethrower (which is the hottest) and I think the other flavor was Sweet Thai or something like that. Either way, they were both delicious, and the flamethrower was pretty damn hot but not enough to make them not enjoyable. The pricing is OK at $11 for 10 large wings, but if you come after 5 pm on Wednesdays, they're half price, and that's a good deal. Also, the shoestring fries we ordered with them were great as well with a nice seasoning to make them very flavorful. I can't say anything about the rest of the food, but we weren't really there for that. The place is a pretty divey bar, and it was empty when we were there, but I'm told there's a good crowd towards dinner time. They have tons of TVs, so you'd be able to go there and watch any game you want I would assume. Finding a good wing place is pretty dangerous when you're trying to cut some pounds (bye bye diet), but I'm sure we'll be back pretty soon. read more

Hamilton's Pub - Full order of wings with fries - Pubs Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

For a glorified suburban publican house this place really does shine as a lunch destination, and dinner too in a pinch. The beer is cold, the service is prompt, and the food - while definitely and firmly planted in the scope of bar cuisine - is warm, fresh, and in your face alongside a tall glass of "whatever you're having" that evening. Ironically enough I'd highly recommend their salads if you're of a healthier mindset, and if not, the buffalo chicken offerings rival that of some of the other beer-slingers in the area, even the chains. Another big plus is parking and elbow room. It's part of a broader shopping complex so there's ample space to drop anchor in your sedan or crossover beast. On the inside, there's a variety of tabletop solutions to choose from that accommodate party sizes both large and intimate. I particularly enjoy using some of the larger curvy tables designed to facilitate, I imagine, the convenient consumption of food and booze. There is only one or two of them, but they have really interesting curves to their shape for a larger group of folks to congregate around. It's definitely a place I drove by many times before finally going in, but I'm glad I did. Odds are you may encounter the same feeling. read more

I'm a sucker for pubs. If a business has the word pub in it, I'm there. I'm always reeled in by that mysterious force that makes me check out any food establishment with the name "pub" in it. I dread driving past one called The Colonoscopy Pub. No! Well, um, erm, OK... But seriously. It's a decent enough typical suburban sports bar. It's not really the type of place that I'd normally hang out in, but it's alright. There's plenty of seating, seems like lots of regulars, everyone is pretty friendly. Guinness in a can ( eh? ), at $4.75. There are plenty of big screens around to watch. Add in Keno, a jukebox, pool table, patio and enough seating for about 80 or so. I didn't try their food but previous reviews seem to think it's decent bar food. Maybe again if I were in the area. read more

Nice bar room with plenty of seating and 15 TVs. A musician was setting up and must have started at 8:00. They also have s large outdoor seating area. I had the pizza sub and fries. Average. The average age was over 40. Nice clean group All of the waitress and bar tender were wearing tank tops and blue jeans. All looked unfinished. Take the pub up a couple of notches by supplying nice tops. 9-7-18 update. Went for a Friday night dinner. 40% busy. 7:00 pm. Music loud, customers had to yell. Sandwich barely warm. Fries barely warm. Interesting there is a sign in the kitchen that says "Good customer service is good business " Won't be returning read more

The fajita quesadilla is a great portion size and extremely filling. The flavors were all there and nothing was dry nor over seasoned. The ambiance of the place is chill and relaxing and service was friendly and quick. I'll definitely be back and try other items. read more

Hamilton's Pub - Fajita quesadilla - Pubs Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

Great bar, good drinks and very clean! I didn't get a chance to try there food because I thought it was half off wings Wednesday but with the pandemic it hit them hard so there not doing the deal right now. The drinks was great and a good price though. I will definitely return and recommend others to go here an support them. read more

Updating my review because the patio is gorgeous with the new renovations and social distancing. Decor is on trend and the drinks are done right. The bartenders are a great crew anytime I've been there. After 10 years, it's still awesome! read more