This review is solely based on delivery via seamless! My boyfriend and I ordered for delivery and we didn't have high expectations at all because of previous experiences with delivery but we really didn't want to go out or cook haha (we've all had one of those days!) The price was kind of expensive for everything ($69) but we were quite content on our orders. Although we got our delivery in 30 minutes, the food managed to be warm and in tact (what kind of sorcery is that?!) We ordered the loaded kitchen sink fries, tater tots, mac n cheese jalapeño poppers, a portobello burger, and a Gnarly burger. Everything was delicious! My boyfriend enjoyed the loaded kitchen sink fries the most and he said it honestly could have been one order lmao. I enjoyed my portobello burger and loved the mac n cheese jalapeño poppers that was warm, slight crisp, and wasn't overly cheesy inside. We were definitely amazed at how good the food was. Hopefully we can give Gnarly a try by dining in as food is better fresh from the kitchen! read more

Gnarly Eats - Mac and Cheese Jalapeno Poppers! - Burgers Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

Their Fried Chicken Sandwich is better than Mekelburg's, which has been featured in a bunch if publications as one of the best chicken sandwiches in NYC. Do those people know about this place!?!?Because Holy $@&! Absolutely amazing. And their Pulled Pork Sliders are equally as amazing. Like would make a nun swear amazing. Craziest part is I ordered delivery! So both these things taste even better dining-in? My brain & tastebuds can't even begin to compute that. Also love how they offer (and encourage) to deliver menu items unassembled. You can tell they REALLY take pride in their product and want it to be almost as good as if you were dining in. Again, something I just can't compute because again Holy $@&! - but can't wait to find out next time I'm in the neighborhood! read more

Staff was nice and food was great, definitely very fried but that's what we were after. There's only one or two tables inside so it may be designed more for takeout, but the tiny brick interior and decor was casual but cool! read more

Great vegan burger. Better fries. American food with some options for the non meat eaters. Enjoyed. read more

Really cute decor, never dined inside but would love to once dine in is reopened. Probably the best fried chicken sandwich in this part of Brooklyn and generous and amazing hand cut fries also. Five star! read more

Hmm... i am conflicted. The sandwich was definitely good but they have a bizarre way of packaging take-out. They package everything separately so you have to essentially make the sandwich yourself. The reason is because people probably have complained that the bread gets soggy if it is in the plastic wrap. Word of advice: do your thing gnarly eats. People will either love it or hate it. Either way they will find a flaw in something if they are looking for one. Overall, the sandwiches were good. The fried chicken was a little bready (too much coating). The brisket was ok but i didnt get the full experience bc i had to make the sandwich myself. This might have been a 3.5 but i gave the benefit of the doubt to the place since they care enough about the customer that they do take out like that. read more

Gnarly Eats - Decor - Burgers Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

We ordered delivery from here and we've done it. We have discovered the best delivery burger in Brooklyn, MAYBE the world. First of all, they offer to package the burger unassembled so you don't end up with a soggy mess by the time the burger arrives. Second, they freshly grind their meat every day and it shows. It is a juicy, tender, but not crumbly or falling-apart patty with the right amount of fat to keep it from drying out. The red cabbage is super flavorful and makes the burger in my opinion - it's garlicky and not too crunchy or too limp. Perfect bite to it. The burger also comes with lettuce, tomato, and pickles on the side. There are caramelized onions on top that, again, add lots of flavor to the burger and that I loved. I liked their special sauce too (basically a tartar sauce). We also got fries, tots, Buffalo wings, and mac and cheese jalapeno poppers. The fries were ok, not super crispy but tasted really good. The tots were great and we'd probably order those next time. The order of fries and tots were also each HUGE so one order can easily be shared among two to three people. The Buffalo wings were ok - the sauce didn't feel like a true Buffalo with the hot sauce and butter mixed into a sauce. It felt more like purely hot sauce. Tasty but not what I'd want if I'm craving proper Buffalo wings. The wings were juicy though, so I'm intrigued to try their other wing flavor next time. The mac and cheese poppers are a must-have here though! They were so good, perfectly fried, super crispy on the outside (even after delivery), flavorful with the jalapeno, and creamy on the inside from the cheese. It came with a spicy mayo for dipping that was really tasty too. This is DEFINITELY our new burger delivery spot from now on. read more

This has become our go-to burger place because everything we had here is amazing. The burgers are fantastic, even better is the portobello burger. Recently we tried the pulled pork sliders the first time and those are in my family's vier the very best. People are friendly, orders don't take too long. Try it. It's amazing!! read more

nice chickenburger and juicy also pinklemonade is good mighty wing is crispy sweet potato is sweet

I'm one of those people who either cooks or goes out. No grey areas of delivery or takeout for me. But the other night, a literal and figurative perfect storm, that included ominous looking weather, no food in the fridge and the fact that hubby and kid were on their way home from Park Slope, colluded so I heard myself saying the following words: "Honey, why don't you just pick up some takeout from that new Burger place on 7th. Avenue?" Classic Burger: Two Words: Soggy Bun. Gummy, even. Plus the beef patty was dry and overcooked. Buttermilk Fried Chicken Sandwich: I managed to steal a bite from the kid and really liked the Chicken component. Major potential there. Juicy and surprisingly crispy given the challenges that takeout presents. But again with the inedible, soggy bun. Portobello Burger: Hubby was not very enthusiastic about this, mostly because he didn't realize it was fried and he had been trying to make a healthier choice. His bad, but maybe offering a lighter, more virtuous vegetarian sandwich alternative on the menu would broaden the appeal of this spot? Tater Tots: Happily, these stayed crispy on the short ride home. Unhappily, they were SUPER greasy. In fact, I bit into one and oil oozed out of it. This sealed it for me, leaving me with a deep and frankly, sick feeling of regret over eating any of this in the first place. Now I have a suspicion that had we dined in and eaten the Fried Chicken Sandwich immediately, it would have tasted pretty good. Not too sure that applies to the rest of our meal. ps Lately, I've noticed a trend of sorts, with restaurateurs opening spots in tiny, minimalist spaces due, I'm assuming, to the prohibitive costs of operating a food business in NYC. The resulting lack of comfortable seating and ambiance then lead to lots of takeout and delivery orders. Meanwhile, the menu is almost perversely heavy in its inclusion of items that are challenging to package to-go, while still maintaining their integrity. Talk about making it hard on yourself. read more

Gnarly Eats - "Take nothing on its looks; take everything on evidence. There's no better rule." I had great expectations for this Classic Burger. - Burgers Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

Little hole in the wall with great burgers and chicken. Friendly and helpful staff. Only 3 small tables... I would come again! read more

The food here is so good! I'm obsessed with the buttermilk fried chicken sandwich (I always want another one). Also the mighty wings are very scrumptious. I also tried the Texas beef brisket sandwich, very good as well and the hand cut fries. Prickly Pear Lemonade is very refreshing!!! It has mint leaves in the beverage. I always forget to take pics of the food, I will update! read more

Gnarly Eats - The inside, very small and cute. I usually take it to go! - Burgers Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

This is a tiny place with seating for, maybe 10. The server was super sweet, polite and the whole ambiance of the place is lovely. Everything you want a hole-in-the-wall place to be. I ordered the Gnarly burger, in hindsight I should of gone for the highly recommended fried Chicken burger instead. The burger was sufficiently sized with a leaky fried egg on top. I was a bit disappointed with the taste of the thing. It felt slightly lacking in flavor, I'm not sure how to put my finger on it. Maybe it was just lacking in salt, but everything felt a bit underwhelming. I would want to go back and try them again, but this experience was neither here nor there. read more

Gnarly Eats - Gnarly Burger - Burgers Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Gnarly Eats has hands down the best Chicken Sandwich in Brooklyn. Their quality is consistent and their staff is friendly and nice. Truly a great little spot in Park Slope. read more

I'd give them five stars solely for their buttermilk fried chicken sandwich. It was TOO good! The place is small, but they do have seats for about 10 people. They started out as a rolled ice cream place, and they expanded their hot menu as if got colder out. They do plan on bringing the rolled ice cream back when it gets warmer though! I'll definitely be back for that. As I said, the buttermilk fried chicken sandwich is a must. The classic burger was solid, and I love that they came on potato buns. It just made everything taste so classic. The double fried wings were also a solid appetizer, just know that these take a big longer to make. They also have shakes! read more

See all

Great restaurant when you'd like a quick delivery of burgers and fries. I like how you can assemble it when you choose delivery because then the bun is not soggy! read more

Great food, friendly staff, good vibe. Will be coming back to try the rest of the menu!

I had a craving for burgers and fries so my girlfriend and I decided to browse the park slope area until we stumbled upon this small gem. The lack of space is made up by the abundance of flavor! We ordered the gnarly burger, fried chicken sandwich, onion rings and hand cut fries. The burger topped with a runny egg, onions(perfectly cooked-raw onions are the worst), and two thick slabs of bacon was exactly what I needed to satisfy my burger craving. The fried chicken sandwich with the slaw and mayo was so darn good, I almost ordered a second one. The fries and rings were great as well but to be honest the burger and chicken sandwich was so freaking good, I forgot about everything else. The staff was friendly and inviting when we entered, our server Lisa was super chill. To put things simple, this place was totally Gnarly! Can't wait to come back for another burger and chicken sandwich. read more

See all

Delish. This restaurant is a quaint little place on 7th, but the food packs a flavor that is larger than life. My first experience with Gnarly was via Seamless and a horribly incompetent Seamless driver. The driver brought us the wrong order and by the time we discovered the error, the restaurant was set to close and the driver ignored our efforts to contact him. Swayed by the positive reviews and determined not to give up, I used Seamless to order from Gnarly again but this time opted for pick-up. Best choice, best food. I highly recommend the incredibly juicy and flavorful pulled-pork sliders​ and some tater tots, which is more than enough food for two. I am determined to try the buttermilk fried chicken burger when I can finally fit back into my pants. read more

The buttermilk fried chicken sandwich is certainly the BEST fried chicken sandwich I've had to this date. Seriously it was immaculate. The most important part (the chicken, duh...) was juicy and seasoned really well. The red cabbage/slaw were great complements, but the spicy mayo sauce stole the show. Shoot the potato bun was tasty too. The sandwich became sloppy after a while but this didn't bother me one bit. I asked for a spoon to sop up all the goodness that fell on the tray. The space was small but cute and inviting. I found the sign suggesting patrons eat the food to stay amusing. Moreover, the young lady at the front was pleasant and provided stellar service. I'm a fan and cant wait to try other items. read more

Gnarly Eats - Burgers Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Gnarly Eats is your quintessential hole-in-the-wall joint, with fantastic food, a great atmosphere, and friendly staff. I had The Beetles (the chicken sandwich) with the Kitchen Sink Fries, and I ate to the point of bursting. Oh, and the house-made lemonade was unbelievably fresh. read more

I WAS NOT SATISFIED!!! Not with the one chicken sandwich I ordered. That sandwich was designed, not made; juicy, flavored chicken with coleslaw and a mildly spiced mayo sauce; I never had that combo before but that one time got me hooked. The prickly lemonade was on the house just for checking in on Yelp... this too is another story; a fusion that I can't explain..it's a refreshing drink no one will dislike. read more

Gnarly Eats - Burgers Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

I've gotten them twice for delivery. So far I've had the classic burger, the buttermilk fried chicken burger, the hand-cut fries, and the sweet potato fries. All were delicious. The portions are not real huge, so I'd suggest maybe ordering more than one burger--or something else to accompany it--if you're really hungry. But as for the food itself, definitely recommend. read more

David and Barbie who own and run Gnarly Eats are so nice that even if the food was not great - which it is and even if the prices were not reasonable for "the Slope" - which they are, you would still want to go back to support their venture! I had the Gnarly burger which includes a runny fried egg and bacon. Both the bacon (well done) and burger (medium rare) were cooked exactly to my request. I washed it down with a free (thanks to the Yelp check-in offer) Organic Prickly Pear Lemonade. The meat was full of flavor but I would have paid a bit more to have it be a bit bigger. They have a nice collection of hot sauces but the food was so tasty, that I didn't want to mask the flavor in spite of my love of hot sauces! My friend had the Buttermilk fried chicken sandwich and potato tots. I tried both of course and was impressed at how light the flavor was for fried food. To be as decadent as possible, we finished our meal with one of their humungous donuts! The restaurant is in a very small space. We were lucky that we visited on a weekday night in the pouring rain when most of their business was take out because their eating area is very limited. That said, they have done a great job decorating and are working on different configurations to maximize their eating area. Their location on 16th street is just outside of the heavy foot traffic area on 7th Avenue, but well worth the short walk to try them out! read more

See all

A great addition to the neighborhood. Went for the first time today and had the classic burger while my husband had the chicken sandwich and we shared a side of fries. Everything was cooked perfectly and very tasty. I loved the addition of red cabbage to give the burger some crunch. The chicken sandwich was quite spicy so be warned! The place is small but welcoming. We chatted with the owner briefly and he was very friendly. Looking forward to trying their rolled ice cream when the weather is warmer. read more

Gnarly Eats - The Classic Burger + Tater Tots - Burgers Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

I had the The BUTTERMILK CHICKEN BURGER (spicy) Buttermilk Fry chicken marinated in buttermilk with herbs and spices, homemade pickled cabbage, coleslaw with homemade spicy mayo and house sauce on it salt Gary potato bun. (Thigh Meat)! This sandwich is the BEST CHICKEN SANDWICH THAT I HAVE HAD IN A LONG TIME! I'm in heaven! I love the plates! I LOVE THE FOOD! I will be back! read more

Gnarly Eats - BUTTERMILK CHICKEN BURGER! - Burgers Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

It's my cheat day and I just HAD to go back here for a few reasons. #1 the food is delicious. This time I ordered their tots and the chicken wings. Tots are my fave and hit home. The wings were perfect! Perfect balance of sweetness! Their iced tea was very refreshing. #2 I just love visiting Barbie and Dave. They're so fun and caring! They really make you feel at home when you're there. #3 I love supporting small businesses. One of the reasons I love living in this neighborhood is because of all the small businesses. My money isn't going towards another vacation home for a CEO, but towards sending their child to dance class or to college. Hell, even to take a day off to spend with their family! I mean I can't imagine working 7 days a week like they do. For that, I'll support them any day I can. read more

Gnarly Eats - Tots! - Burgers Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

The mighty wings were amazing. Perfectly crunchy plumped with chicken. That buttermilk burger was good too - granted the spices mayo sauce made it worth the while after awhile. The presentation made my mouth water. There's this Thai teas?! It's basically ice-cream I'm a liquid form - so delicious!!! I don't have the photo of it, but it is pretty and sweet. Throw in some sweet potato fries - need I say more? read more

Gnarly Eats - Mighty Wings - Burgers Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

First off I am torn between 3.5 and 4 stars. I went with four because the chicken wings are phenomenal. Let's start with the good shall we? Beautiful open concept where you can eat right at the bar while sitting outside. Cool Polaroid camera to take flicks with you and your "good good" girlfriends and post on their wall of funky hipster photos. Did I mention the wings? Chicken sandwich is great! (Pickled cabbage could be cut into thinner slices but I guess that is a personal preference. They make everything in house and nothing is frozen. Fries, burger patties, chicken ... all fresh and made in house. The bad ... *dum dum dum! The server lied and said they served beer and when me and my mates began to order we quickly learned that the server was referring to root beer (I hate root beer) so I asked, "Is it hard root beer?" It wasn't. "We have shots! Of wheatgrass!!"- I digress ... Good food small space and no liquor. read more

Gnarly Eats - Burgers Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

This is a great little spot in BK. The customer service was immaculate, and the slushy was amazing. Highly recommend the wings, fries and drinks. read more

YUMMO YUMMO YUMMO - super cute vibe and every item on the menu is perfection! The staff is always friendly and have great conversation while you wait for your food! Gnarly Eats is a must! read more

The burger and wings are delicious. Highly recommend this! My to go place in Brooklyn

We really liked Gnarly Eats. Great burgers, though the variety is limited if you are looking for something more customizable. The timing of the food was really off - came in with two kids and our burgers were served about 10 minutes before their food was ready. Our fries came out about 15 minutes after we finished our burgers. The kitchen sink fries were good, but I would have preferred pickled jalapeno over fresh, and given how delayed they were, I was surprised that the cheese was already somewhat cold and the fries a bit limp when they arrived. They were very kind and accommodating, though, and even though there is no seating to speak of (6 stools...it's a really small space so don't plan to come with a group or hang out here), we'd probably return for another visit. I can't imagine making it all the way home, though, with the runny egg on the burger not spoiling the whole works, so perhaps if they manage to get a sidewalk table or two, that might be the best time for our next visit. read more

If you want raw chicken in your chicken sandwich this is the place. This was my second order from them. I ordered from them before and it was great. My second order was very disappointing. Whoever takes the calls wasn't very helpful after I called them about it. I called to let them know about the raw meat my friend and I had in both of our chicken sandwiches and her response was "that's impossible"! No it's not impossible. It could happen!!! They refuse to give us back a refund or send another order over. So I had to contact Grubhub to get my refund. I won't ever order from them again after this experience. My friend and I both got sick after eating couple bites of our sandwiches before realizing it was raw. read more

Gnarly Eats - DON'T ORDER FROM HERE!!!! BOTH MY CHICKEN SANDWICHES HAD RAAAAAAAW CHICKEN. - Burgers Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

This tiny place was a giant surprise! I loved the kitchen sink fries and the mandarin orange slush. The customer service was a delight as well. I highly recommend trying this small neighborhood gem out! read more

Gnarly Eats - Burgers Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

I live in the neighborhood. I was walking home from work and noticed a new restaurant opening up. I spoke with the owner who laid out his vision for a place where you can get delicious burgers, fries and a drink for under $15. Right up my alley. At first they only offered their signature "Roll'n'Chill" ice cream, but I returned today (after trying every ice cream flavor) to eat their buttermilk chicken sandwich. The quality of the chicken meat was really great and looked to be mostly dark meat instead of white meat which can be more flavorful. They gave me two paddies stacked on top of each other, which was very filling. Definitely a great value!! I look forward to working my way through every permutation of the menu! read more

Gnarly Eats - Buttermilk chicken sandwich - Burgers Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

Awesome amazing juicy tasty delicious burgers! I had the Grateful Dead burger. My wife had a spicy fried chicken sandwich. Both were delicious. Great attention to detail. The place is tiny so best for 2-4 ppl at most. read more

See all

Small & quaint burger joint with a delicious burger! It was nice to sit outside & enjoy the great Spring weather- finally & enjoy this meal. The server also gave me a complimentary lemonade for waiting which wasn't long. Quality meat & really juicy! I wish I had a picture but true left my phone at home. If you're in the prospect park & Windsor terrace area come here for burger! read more

I was a bit upset after hearing all the rave reviews about it, I was expecting something next level. I'm all about supporting local businesses in the area and I would like to keep my reviews very honest. My friend stated that he really enjoyed his burger, to the contrary I had the mushroom burger. I think the fact that the mushroom was fried takes away from the freshness and earthiness of the Portabella mushroom, it wasn't bad it was just oily. I think a simple portobello with a fresh cheese and aioli would be a great replacement for vegetarians. So I guess if you're judging simply based on the regular burgers they are A-OK but I would avoid the fried Portabella burger unless you really love fried food. The tater tot's are really good. It's a really cute place small and has a few seats available to sit inside, there is not a big seating area. It was cold inside because it was Cold out and people were opening the door into the place which meant we were getting a cold breeze which was annoying. Cash and credit excepted. The staff is very sweet and kind. I told the lady behind the counter that they should include a portobello mushroom burger that is not fried on their menu and she said maybe so I would hope they would include that in the new menu and I would go back and try it. Their menu is nice and simple. I just had better burgers, and I was expecting more. Lots of metered parking outside the restaurant. read more

See all

I wrote a one star review a few months back as I felt I was treated poorly at gnarly eats. The owner kindly wrote back to me asking me to come give it another shot, so I did. I went in as a regular customer and didn't let the owner know that it was me because I wanted to pay for my food rather than have it on the house. I must say, I have changed my mind. The owner and his wife were working the day i went back. They were both super kind and he was talking to me about how his vision for the restaurant came to life, without knowing it was me who wrote the bad review. The food was very good. I ordered the chicken sandwich again and the loaded sink fries with the pear lemonade. Everything was so good, and I was happily stuffed afterwards. Ever since I've order four or five times. I'm happy I gave gnarly eats another shot. Just to be clear the first time the food was very good. The review was only due to customer service* read more

Gnarly Eats - Pear lemonade and the amazing chicken sandwich - Burgers Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all