If you're in the plaza, just follow your nose! Get Caked smells like heaven and tastes even better!!! Everyone there is super friendly, making the whole experience 10/10. I was tempted to buy more, but I had to control myself lol Can't wait for my next visit!!!! read more

Get Caked - Bakeries Near Me - Rochester, New York

Stopped by here to tag along with a friend who was picking up her son's birthday cake. Anyways, the lady working was super friendly. Very nice and personable. To be honest, I was a bit underwhelmed with the cake design. It was a plain 10" cake with white icing and printed out images stuck on top with a printed out image as a ribbon along the bottom edge. THAT'S IT. For what she told me paid for it, I just thought it was a bit high for the caliber of the decoration. The cake lady did ask if my friend wanted anything else added to the cake but honestly, I don't know what could have been added in a couple minutes to make up for the lackluster design. Maybe I'm biased because I have done cakes, highly detailed cakes. I'm sure to have a highly detailed cake here, my friend would have paid double or more than what she paid. Needless to say, my friend RAVES about how delicious the cakes are and I wish I was in town a day longer so I could comment but I'll trust her word that the cakes here taste awesome. Was tempted to buy a cupcake in the display case so I could get a sample of their cakes but I didn't. read more

Come here for their amazing assortment of gluten free and vegan options, which also exclude a lot of food allergens!! Their cakes/cupcakes are all delicious and the gluten free do not taste weird like a lot of them do elsewhere. My daughter has a peanut allergy and I can order her a specialty cake with no worries. Love the staff and their work is always beautiful! read more

Best Bakery ever. We go here for everything. They have delicious cookies, cakes, and cupcakes. Every time we are in the area we stop in. Love the staff and the owners are top notch We have ordered custom cakes and they have always been perfect. And disappear so quickly. read more

Amazing bakery! Friendly staff and quality baked goods. Store is clean and smells like one would expect - warm baked goods out of the oven. Staff has made cakes for local charities that were showpieces and raised money for the community. Highly recommend! read more

Kelly and her team are absolutely amazing! The cakes are delicious I have used them for several of my kids birthday's!!! Will be going here again!!! read more

Get Caked - Ombre cake with purple sprinkles! Fruity pebble cake is to die for! - Bakeries Near Me - Rochester, New York

My husband got my birthday cake from here. He sent a picture of me when I was little with my favorite bike and yellow helmet. It was a chocolate vegan cake with buttercream frosting and it was decorated with my infamous yellow helmet. All of my friends and family absolutely raved about how the cake looked and tasted. My husband said it was super easy to order and the staff were very accommodating. Can't wait to get more sweet treats from them! read more

Adorable cake! Tasted delicious! Everybody loved it at the event, especially the people that I got the cake for! Excellent customer service! Cute aesthetic in the cake shop with variety of cupcakes! Their Strawberry crunch bar cupcakes SLAP( they're good)!! Thank you Get Caked for your service!! Your cake was Awesome!!! read more

Get Caked - Garden Cake - Bakeries Near Me - Rochester, New York

See all

macaroons are very good and so are the cookies. The cupcakes are hit or miss. Sometimes they are moist and sometimes they are dry. Also the reward program doesn't work well. Every time I hit 10 stars they tell me I'd get a discount and it never comes off my tab or I never get the "free cookie" they offer. Just a waste of a reward system. Twice without receiving said "discount" or free cookie. read more

The service is always friendly and the display case of cupcakes is inviting and beyond delicious looking. These have been my favorite cupcakes in town for over a decade! Have ordered cupcakes here for weddings, events and just casual eating. read more

Yummy sweet treats! Helpful and friendly customer service -- which is important to me. Give them a try. You won't be disappointed!

Love Get Caked so much! Such amazing cookies and cupcakes, especially the toffee, molasses, lemon, and blueberry oatmeal!!!

Get Caked made a cake for a birthday and it was outstanding! We even froze what was left over and it thawed out as moist and delicious as the day we bought it!! read more

Absolutely delicious and beautiful cake. My fiancé ordered the cake a month in advance and it looked exactly the way he requested. We never went inside, but the service for curbside was quick and friendly. Overall, we are so happy to find a delicious dessert location that's affordable and presents lovely. read more

Get Caked - Bakeries Near Me - Rochester, New York

See all

I ordered cupcakes and cookies for my daughter's graduation party. The staff at get caked were great to work with. Our order needed to be nut free, with some gluten free items as well. I felt confident that they would handle our items carefully. Everything was packaged and labeled clearly. The curbside pick up was so convenient. And the best part was that everyone at the party was RAVING about how delicious everything was. I'm still getting texts asking where I got the cupcakes from. People agreed they were the best they have ever had. My new go to bakery! read more

Home of consistently delicious and interesting cupcakes and cookies. We've been coming here for years -- either after a meal at a NOTA/Village Gate restaurant or to pickup for special occasions. They always have amazing flavors and some way out there awesome combos. They also specialize in quite a variety of dietary specific needs. It's great because everyone is able to get something and feel special. For cupcakes, our favorites are the chai ones and strawberry ones. Our very favorite cookie (not pictured) is the Blueberry. It sounds odd but it tastes fantastic. Our extended family loves it enough that when we've served them at holidays, people almost started a physical fight over who would eat the last of a particular flavor. (Yes, really! Grown adults in their 40s through 70s!) read more

See all

They nailed it! Barbell plate inspired cake i like how they give suggestions to make the cake better. They care about the quality of the final product. This is my second custom cake order, so fun! read more

I LOVE THE BLUEBERRY OATMEAL COOKIES SO MUCH!!!!!! I'm addicted to them. They were at my uncles wedding and I swear I'm going to visit this place the first chance I get! read more

Such a solid collection of vegan cupcakes. I was here to visit my sister who's also vegan and comes here once a month and is love with the cupcakes. I got a carrot cake cupcake this time and enjoyed it. It's good. My sister said they also had vegan sugar cookies on Valentine's Day and they were super good. She's been checking back every now and then for more but it sounds like they only bring them out for holidays. Hopefully we get to see more of their creations added to the normal offerings. I'd highly recommend. As a vegan from California, I was seriously blown away by the quantity of vegan cupcakes offered, given that this isn't even a fully vegan place. I haven't found anything comparable in the Bay Area yet. Enjoy! read more

Get Caked - Vegan Cupcakes - Bakeries Near Me - Rochester, New York

This was my first time here creating, ordering, and purchasing a cake here. They have many different designs of cakes they can create. I was hoping this cake would be very very good, especially for the price of it. I recommend giving it a try at least if you are looking at trying something new and different. read more

See all

I came here on Valentine's Day and it was a cute little bakery it was kinda hard to find but we managed to find it ! I love the fact that they were vegan friendly as well ... actually that's the only reason I chose them lol but I kinda wish they had seating but it wasn't a big deal ! The lady that took our order was some what friendly being that it started to get crowded as we were checking out . Overall the cupcakes were moist and delicious I would recommend and I'd go back ! read more

Get Caked - Oreo cupcake and vanilla cupcake - Bakeries Near Me - Rochester, New York

My husband and I used Get Caked for our wedding cake and it was an incredible experience. Kelly was so sweet, the cake was delicious, and it was so beautifully decorated with flowers, eucalyptus and lavender. We were so happy we used them. Also, we got their vegan cookies for the guests with dietary restrictions and they were a hit! Thank you for making it all so easy and memorable! read more

I love Get Caked SO MUCH! Amazing community partners to so many local businesses? Check. Some of the best cupcakes I've ever had? Check. Vegan/GF options? Check! Not to mention their staff is crazy friendly. I've used Get Caked on a number of occasions, including my sisters baby shower and as a very frequent bad day pick me up. I've eaten way too many of their vegan brownies and have also found myself absolutely smitten with their seasonal offerings. The blueberry cookies that come on a tray are always a hit at any party. I will say if you have a large order, I still haven't found the best place to park to easily get your large order into your car with haste. I've had a few near misses, so I would recommend just asking when you place your order or are about to head out. I can't wait until my next trip to Get Caked and can't say enough about how amazing their work is! read more

The truffle chocolate cupcakes are moist, flavorful and rich...will return for a couple more soon.

I won a gift card to Get Caked last year, and used it to order a birthday cake for my niece's first birthday. It was beautiful and delicious, and I was impressed. This year I hosted a very involved dessert baby shower for one of my closest friends, and Get Caked worked with me every step of the way. Email was easier for me than the phone - especially when I got the flu and lost my voice for a week right before the party - and they were very accommodating. They gracefully managed a change shortly before the event, and for everything that we received, the cost was reasonable. The goodies were delivered the morning of the shower by one of the owners, and they were picture-perfect, "in theme" (and we had a very unique theme - baby as political candidate campaigning), and oh so tasty. So many of the party compliments were about Get Caked's desserts, and I'm now very quick to tell people to run, not walk, to Get Caked! read more

See all

always friendly and helpful. their cupcakes are amazing. i need to add more characters to hit the minimum so just go and get some treats already. read more

We are trying bakeries with Gluten free baked goods to try to decide on what to use for our wedding, and we thing Get Caked is a great contender! We retired their strawberry lemon and vanilla espresso cupcakes and they were both great and very flavorful read more

Get Caked - Gluten free free lemon strawberry and vanilla espresso cupcakes - Bakeries Near Me - Rochester, New York

You should be ashamed for selling this cake to us. It doesn't even look like the picture I sent. Never asked for fuchsia colored frosting or for that matter for the whole entire cake, even the writing, to be in fuchsia. How ridiculous. Not to mention the cake was dry, barely any lemon filling, and the frosting was cracked. I got a call at the 12th hour saying they used vanilla frosting instead of chi. Is that okay? No, I want what I ordered. They redid the cake with a frozen dried out cake and made it look like a disaster to be served at my daughters baby shower. I'm requesting a full refund for this anomaly you call a cake. Below is the picture I sent asking for the cake to look just like that one except with pink dots and a pink pumpkin where the M was. I never once mentioned I want the whole cake in Fuchsia even the writing. Would you accept this if it were you. Everybody was laughing and asking what happened to the cake and OMG Where Did You Get It? Get Caked. Never again. Extremely disappointed and reviews will be written. read more

Get Caked - Cake I ordered. Only changes were pink dots instead of blue and a pink pumpkin where the M is. - Bakeries Near Me - Rochester, New York

See all

I was craving a vegan cupcake, and Red Fern is closed on Mondays so I went over to Get Caked to check out their selection. I wasn't familiar with the building it was located in so it was very difficult for me to find it. I was looking for it on the outside, but the store is located inside a building. The interior of the store was gloomy and dark. It wasn't very welcoming. I got boston creme, chocolate and twist cupcakes while my husband got the pumpkin chai. I liked the cake part of the cupcake; it was soft and moist and not too sweet. I normally don't like frosting, and I didn't like the frosting on these cupcakes either. They're overly sweet and stiff. I don't like the texture of the sprinkles and frosting against the soft and comforting texture of the cake part. The chocolate cupcake was delicious. The twist wasn't my favorite but I liked it. The boston creme was really yummy, although the filling was a little bit too sweet for me. I didn't enjoy the frosting on any of them but the cake part was really delicious. The cupcakes were heavy and filling, and I couldn't eat more than 1 in a sitting; That's not a bad thing though. The cupcakes were pretty basic and I didn't feel like they were worth the $11 I paid for them. I enjoyed the cupcakes but I'm not really a cupcake person. I'm hoping to try the cookies next time. I was happy that there were so many vegan options to choose from. read more

Get Caked - Boston creme, pumpkin chai, chocolate and twist cupcakes - Bakeries Near Me - Rochester, New York

I was just a walk-in , didn't buy a whole cake. I was not especially impressed. The cake slice was ok, moist and nice enough, but the chocolate flavor could have been richer, and it wasn't special. The M&M cookie was ok, but Java's has better. The brownie was remarkably bad, just sort of fell apart and lacked taste. I admit they might be the best place around for those with specific dietary needs, but I wasn't impressed on taste. read more

My newest teenager turned 13 last week and wanted to bring cupcakes to school. However, they had to be labeled as peanut free. After a quick google search, Yelp search and asking friends. I ended up speaking to someone from Get Caked on the phone. The order was placed and a few days later, we picked up these beauties. My daughter said they tasted good. I did not get one but we did have some of their cookies and those were yummy. I'd definitely go back to them for baked goods in the future. read more

Get Caked - Vanilla cupcakes with vanilla filling. Treenut free! - Bakeries Near Me - Rochester, New York

This is a place where we got things for events or I'd stop in because of my husband's office was right in that area. I found the cupcakes pretty good and they are nicely displayed. It's inside of village gate and yes you have to look for it inside. Unfortunately I can't tell you which items blew me away.. the were good just not memorable. They share Village Gate parking read more

I brought my daughter and her husband here because they are dairy and gluten free. They were pumped to have sweets that accommodated their restrictions. It was a Saturday afternoon. We purchased a six pack of cupcakes and a few cookies. The cookies we ate on the way home. They were ok, but not great. The cupcakes on the other hand were hard dry and stale by dessert time after dinner that day. For some the frosting was OK, but the cake was not up to the standards, I would have expected. We went way out of our way to go there and were very disappointed. After checking out the first 4 we never bothered to taste the last 2. It's too bad because the kids had looked forward to this expierence, we will not be back. read more

We LOVE Get Caked - they are the best! I called and needed a birthday cake for my toddler's birthday party (after the one I had ordered fell through), and they were extremely helpful, accommodating, and friendly. I loved what they pulled together for us, and in such a short time - it matched my vision exactly! Looks aside, the FLAVOR of the cake was amazing - I have a dairy intolerance, and they were able to make us a dairy free cake that was better than anything I'd had before, dairy or otherwise! So moist and fresh and yummy with great flavor, even as leftovers in the few days after our party. I'm so glad we found them, and will order all of our cakes from Get Caked from now on. Thank you so much! read more

Get Caked - the COOLEST dairy-free birthday cake for our construction themed toddler party - thank you so much! - Bakeries Near Me - Rochester, New York

Got a wonderful cookie cake that I loved. I tend to love their cookies here more than cake/cupcakes but that might just be because I love cookies. I highly recommend the toffee crisp cookies. If you don't try those you are missing out! read more

I live in NYC but wanted to send some gluten free cupcakes as a thank you to a friend living in Rochester. I ordered a dozen online, all different flavors, to be picked up. (Although they do offer delivery for a $10 charge). The cupcakes were ready to go at the requested time and the reviews from the group that actually got to eat them are stellar!! Even the people that aren't generally GF! They have such a great selection of flavors in so many different dietary options, and i only got the cupcakes!!!! read more

I know this place is considered a cake shop. It's in the name. But i like the cookies best. The cupcakes are fine.

The $1 sugar cookie for a Yelp check-in at GC lured me in. When we finally found this cute little bakery shop located within the Village Gate, I proceeded to check-in so I could redeem my offer. I was ready to Get Caked, but I was about to Get Faked. I wanted that $1 sugar cookie but unfortunately they were all out. So, I asked for a substitute for the sugar cookie check-in offer. A reasonable request, I thought, since I'm just asking to pay $1 for a different cookie. I'm pretty sure that a sugar cookie substitute shouldn't cost much more than $1 or so. That's when I learned that the offer expired "a long time ago." And, furthermore no, I could not get a substitute cookie. Do not pass go, do not collect a sugar cookie substitute, proceed to check-in offer jail. Sure enough, I noticed after checking in that the offer was only valid for a single day in 2013. Okay, you got me. Yes, there is a date listed before checking in but no, that's not just the beginning date of the promo. Apparently, after checking in you learn that 12/14/2013 is the beginning *and* the end of the $1 sugar cookie promo. The alpha and the omega of the $1 sugar cookie. The first and last date of availability for the check-in offer. Maybe it's time to take that "check-in offer" off the Yelp business page? I recovered from my sugar cookie loss and then decided to purchase some cookies anyway. We selected several different kinds, cut them into bite-sized pieces, and shared them with a group of 7 or so. After sampling, I decided that I would probably forgive GC for the expired check-in offer and make a return trip just for the molasses. The perfectly baked molasses cookie was slightly crisp on the outside but thick, soft and chewy on the inside. Great texture and thickness. Just enough sweetness. It was heavenly. My favorite. The gluten free blueberry oatmeal seemed to be the group favorite. Soft and chewy with just a hint of blueberry. The red velvet cookie was okay. One person in our group really liked it but no one raved over it. It's a beautiful red color but methinks red velvet should have a little cream cheese frosting, even if it is only a cookie and not a cake. We tried two different chocolate chip cookies. The gluten free was crisper but a little sweeter than the regular chocolate chip. Both tasty but I was really wishing we had picked up a few more molasses instead. Overall, GC is a cute local bakery with some very tasty cookies. If I'm in the area again, I may swing by for some molasses cookies and perhaps try a cupcake or two. Maybe by then I will be lucky enough to score a one day deal on a killer molasses cookie. read more

See all

Inaccessible location, limited store and pick up options but attractive display of options and friendly staff. plan ahead. they need lots of time and are slow to communicate about custom orders. I purchased a completely unusable cake that the baker mistakenly put Bavarian cream in when I had ordered raspberry filling. When I picked up the cake nothing was said. when I returned home they telephoned me with the information and expressed that they wanted me to be happy but the only solution to the mistake made was for me to drive back down to the bakery location so they could "remove the cream and replace it with raspberry filling" I am not sure how that works! I gave the cake away to someone who probably likes Bavarian cream, but was left without a birthday cake for my friend. read more

Get Caked is a cool bakery. They have a variety of vegan and dairy desserts. Reviews for Get Caked are all over the map. I think this is a result of a couple of key things... #1 VEGAN: The one thing that makes this bakery unique is that it has many vegan desserts. How awesome is that? Unfortunately, (let's be honest here) those who aren't vegan may find that their taste buds may not quite welcome the taste of some of the vegan items. #2 DESSERTS: The variety is small. What you order here is hit or miss. If we would have only ordered one or two things, we certainly wouldn't have returned. We tried a variety of their cupcakes and a half dozen cookies. So if this is your first time going, make sure you get plenty to try. Luckily, I really liked their peanut butter cookies, which happened to be vegan, and were probably the best peanut butter cookies that I've ever had. Great location and I would totally return for a couple of desserts when hanging out at Village Gate. read more

Get Caked - Front entrance - Bakeries Near Me - Rochester, New York

See all