I ordered a pie for my husband's birthday and it was AMAZING, the crust is perfect. It was delivered to my house, fresh out of the oven! I will be using JonJohn's again! read more

Gotta love this small speciality pastry pop up shop. The items they have are fresh and not mass produced. This allows them to focus in quality and not if they can make 100 dozen of something. The staff is always polite and friendly. Make a stop down at the Brighton farmers market and treat yourself to one of their treats. read more

JonJohn's Bakery - Forgot the name of this slice but a call it the million layer slice - Bakeries Near Me - Rochester, New York

Saw JonJohn's bakery stand at Brighton Farmers Market. They had many types of muffins, cookies and chocolate cake - all of which looked so great and tempting but I went with the peach cobbler. $5 for a very large container - 2-3 servings which was a great deal. The peaches were so fresh but I overall found the cobbler a little bland. I am used to a Southern style cobbler - extra sweet with lots of butter. Their cobbler is a little less rich but I did like the freshness of the peaches. Really looking forward to returning and trying some of their other bakery items especially their chocolate cake and blueberry muffins. read more

JonJohn's Bakery - Peach cobbler $5.... Brighton Market - Sunday's 9a - 1p - Bakeries Near Me - Rochester, New York

Ok can someone stop me from eating these amazing delicious cookies because I can't stop the best I ever had. Love in every bite read more

See all

Probably THE best products from a local baker I've had. Always happy to seen them at the Christmas market in canandaigua in November. Always personable, laughing and smiling which makes the experience so much more fun... love the peanut butter balls. Extraordinarily delicious, worth the drive and calories! read more

My first time having Jon John's anything was today at the Brighton Farmers Market. I have hear and read about them for a bit and was pretty excited to try them out today. I purchased a strawberry rhubarb cobbler (small for $8.50) and their everything brownie (1 square for $8.50). The prices are a bit steep. The strawberry rhubarb cobbler was disappointing. The dough on top was not all the way cooked, the raw parts were unappealing to say the least. Very raw flour taste. The filling was good...so we ate that. It's not something I would purchase again. So, let's talk brownie. It was good, nothing spectacular. As I was talking with a good friend that I was about to toss out the most overpriced brownie I've ever bought...she asked me were it was from. I told her, she asked me to save it for her. She absolutely loves these brownies. So, for me its wasn't something I was impressed with. The items didnt live up to the cost. BUT, they have a fan base and everyone should try them...like my friend who adores them and is getting that brownie. read more

JonJohn's is the BEST! I love everything they make especially the chocolate peanut butter balls! And this pumpkin cheesecake is amazing! read more

JonJohn's Bakery - Bakeries Near Me - Rochester, New York

I'm hit or miss with going to the various farmer's markets we have. Between working late and not being an early riser, I have a tendency to miss out on some local market weekends. If you're like me and you wonder if going to a market is worth it after all the produce has been picked through? Do yourself a favor and go if JonJohn's is there. Typically they come with several staples including muffins (the berry ones are my favorite), the famous beyond chocolate cake (probably the best chocolate cake I've ever had), cookies (oatmeal craisin may be my favorite cookie...but I've never had a bad one), and my favorite: the peanut butter balls (dark chocolate, rice crisps, peanut butter, and chocolate chips). Depending on the market and the weekend, they offer other things too. From seasonal goodies like strawberry lemonade (perfect and not overly sweet!), to hot dogs and chili, it's worth looking at their Facebook page to see what they are going to offer. And the other big selling point? Jon and John are really, really nice. I've been dropping by on and off for the past 3 years, and they still know who I am...even if I go awhile without making it. All of their employees are friendly, so if you drop by for the first time - don't be shy. Ask them what they recommend! In the summer, catch JohnJon's at the West Side, Brighton, and Wedge Markets. If you're overwhelmed with the choices, I suggest starting with the peanut butter balls. Just don't buy them all out before I get there. :) read more

JonJohn's Bakery - Goodies from JonJohn's from today's Brighton Market: zucchini bread and a peanut butter ball. - Bakeries Near Me - Rochester, New York

Even with all the competing treats in the Brighton Farmers Market, JonJohn's remains our absolute go-to. The portions are huge and the blueberry muffins and chocolate cake are not to be missed. Despite how tasty the treats are, the real draw of this shop are the owners. Their joyous smiles and kind words for their customers raise the spirits of everyone that passes. I'm very excited to hear that they added Sunday dinners to their offerings, and look forward to trying that out this summer! read more

What to say about JonJohn's? That he is one of the kindest, most creative, and amazing baker there is? No way does that do him justice. Ever since moving to Rochester, all visiting friends and family make it a priority to see JonJohn and get their baked goods before leaving. (I like to think I am a close second reason for their visit but who am I kidding?) Thanks for all the love and deliciousness!! read more

Treat yourself to takeout of JonJohn's Bakery now. Had an amazing dinner brought to my door with amazing pasta, meatballs, salad and desert. Cannot wait to visit in person after we get past this COVID crisis. Delicious & unique. Thank you! read more

I can't say enough fabulous things about everything I tried from here!!! From their sweet potato pie...to their muffins to their peanut butter balls?!? All AMAZING!!! I love stopping by the Brighton Market to see what treats they have!! It's such a nice treat when I'm used to not being able to have so many wonderful gluten free options!!! I just can't say enough about their sweet treats to their lovely personalities!!! Definitely worth making an extra stop for these goodies!!! Enjoy!! read more

JonJohn's Bakery is by far the best bakery in all of Rochester! This is not an exaggeration, try the Grandmas Breakfast Cake, Carrot Cake, Muffins, Cookies... I drive to the Brighton Market every Sunday from Brockport because JonJohns is that Amazing! read more

I was visiting Rochester and happened to sample a few of Jon John's baked goods. The carrot cake was huge and rich, and the cream cheese frosting was on point. It had marvelous pecans on top. Cheesecake was dense and covered in both strawberry and chocolate. Too good. The brownies were fudge and studded with those same giant pecans. Oreo cheesecake with a brownie bottom...beyond words. And for something a little lighter, I had a bite of berry coffee cake. It was a sweet pound cake with just a hint of almond in the glaze. The fresh berries set it off perfectly. I'm glad we don't have Jon John's in Houston because I'd never fit into my clothes...Try it if you get a chance! Next year, I'm getting peanut butter balls and something lemony. read more

This set of bakers - John and Jon - are as sweet and lovely as their baked goods. Grandma's Breakfast Cake is a favorite but with so many other scrumptious cakes, cookies and sweets to choose from its hard to leave with just one item. The peanut butter balls are addicting and you really can't eat just one. Peach cobbler and blueberry cake are seasonal favorites that are a welcomed sight on a warm summer day. Truly wonderful baked goods all made with fresh, quality ingredients with great care and a heaping spoonful of love. read more

Visited their stand at the Brighton Market this morning... i have gotten muffins there before and remember them being delicious. Both items I got today were delicious as well, and I've only one complaint. It is a bit of a sticker shock to be told the total was $15 for a a slice of cake and a chocolate ball. It is my fault for not asking, but I think maybe it would help to have prices marked. The cake slice was a specialty cake, and it was huge. There were two kinds of balls available (think cake pop size)... I inquired as to what they were and was told one was peanut butter and the others were bourbon, and warned that it did contain a real shot of bourbon... that would have been a good time to mention that they are more expensive than the prices listed on website. I'm really not sure how much they were, because as I mentioned no prices listed. As I mentioned, both items were delicious and high quality, so this is not meant to be a negative review, just maybe a suggestion. read more

Amazing is an understatement. I have never had treats from them i wouldnt recommend. Everything from cookies to cakes is made from scratch from family recipes. Apple and pumpkin pies i ordered for thanksgiving where such a hit that a family fight almost occurred over who was going to get the last piece. Carrot cake is my fave, a perfect blend of sweet and creamy. The peanut butter balls are the hubby's favorite, rich and filling, he's not a big sweets person,but if i come home with a JonJohn's container i better have something for him. Love this local bakery that really does bake their love into every single item. read more

The brownies were the best and the carrot cake was sooooooo delicious. Everything I have had from JonJohn's bakery has exceeded my expectations read more

I went to the Farmer's market and got a slice of the lemon dream cake, chocolate cake, and carrot cake. Little did I know I just bought the most delicious cake I have ever tasted in my LIFE! First of all, both Jon and John are such kind people and answered my onslaught of "what's this" questions. I thought I was getting a slice but the portion was HUGE! It was very generous and filled the square clam shell box from edge to edge. I shared all the cakes with friends and family and they were all impressed. The lemon cake was all kinds of amazing with the smoothness from the lemon pudding and the creaminess from the whipped cream. The chocolate cake was so moist but not too sweet or heavy. The carrot cake was perfectly pair with the best cream cheese frosting I have ever tasted and each bite had a burst of sweet raisin. I am a huge dessert fan and JonJohn's cakes are at the top of my list. I sent a friend to bring back a lemon dream cake and dream pie, which I can not wait to try. I went on vacation and forgot to place my cake order ahead of time, but they were kind enough to rush my order. Thank you guys so much! You're the best! read more

I ordered a cake from JonJohns this weekend for a party and my experience working with these guys was fantastic. They are super friendly and accommodating -- always makes for a nice experience! I ordered an 8" Red Velvet cake for 8 people. It was huge (2 gigantic layers), and absolutely delicious. Would certainly recommend them for any special occasions. read more

The german chocolate cake is like a little slice of heaven. The brownies and breakfast cake are amazing as well. Both Johns are always friendly and happy to interact with the Rochester community. They have a bakery out of their house and you can order cakes to pick up at any of the local markets. If you haven't tried their baked goods yet, you are missing out. read more