I've tried to go here with my daughter twice during their posted open hours but they were closed both times. This was 2 different days of the week. Neither time was a sign posted saying sorry which makes me think this a regular thing. Good luck! read more

We have tried KMC previously at Schutt's apple farm and loved the Smores bars. We hadn't been to their shop yet, but took a ride out there this week. Their shop was easy to find on Ridge Rd, with plenty of parking. I had an ice cream cookie sandwich with Funfetti Ice Cream and a Funfetti and Golden Dough Cookie. The cookies were so fresh, flavorful and amazing!! I would have to say the yellow cake batter flavor of golden dough is my favorite. Their ice creams taste like cookie dough whipped with some cream - amazing! My husband had the Butterfinger and golden dough ice creams and they were so rich and wonderful. We also picked up a smores bar, as they are cravingly good, a traditional chocolate chip and Butterfinger cookie. They also have cupcakes, some with liquor infusions. They obviously have numerous flavors of fresh cookies and decorated cookie pizzas. A handful of ice cream flavors available, and having tried most of them, I can tell you they are amazing. They had many local items to purchase such as Finger Lakes Coffee Roasters. They take credit and the owner popped out to say Hi and Thank you, which is always nice. Stop in and get some fresh cookies and ice cream, you will be so happy you did. read more

See all

I've been here twice in 2 weeks, so I may have a problem! First was for the Yelp event, and I came back for more! It smells so good in here!!! And the funfetti cookie seriously may be the best cookie I've ever eaten!!! Sooooo good! I also got some cupcakes because I can't see cupcakes and not get some, lol. I had the funfetti and the Margarita one. Great frosting on both. I preferred the Margarita one. And so cute that they added the umbrella! My mom had a chocolate cupcake and cookie dough and loved them both! I mainly came back to try the Oreo filled cookie and a frosting filled cookie. I actually was a little disappointed in these. The display one with the frosting had a lot of frosting in the middle. What I had was more like frosting throughout it, and mixed in. I'm a frosting girl, so I was hoping for a lot a frosting. And the Oreo one was good. Just the first cookie I had here was amazing, so these were just good. I'd get a regular cookie again next time because they're incredible! And there's so many to pick from! I'm already planning to come back here for my birthday for a cupcake and a cookie. I love it here! read more

See all

I wish I lived closer to this cute little shop, although I'm sure my wallet and scale are happy I don't! This is everything I want in a bakery! Friendly people, variety, delicious baked goods, and local products. There's a lot packed into that little store. Now what you really want to know... I tried a lot of sweets. Ice cream, cookies and cupcakes, oh my! Everything was delicious! I recommend the yin/yang cookie and the salted caramel cookie. Any cookie really. The golden dough ice cream was also very good. I then ordered cupcakes to take home because they were infused with alcohol (twist my arm). I tried the fireball and the orange dreamsicle. They were quite good! My only critique is that the frosting was a little too sweet for me. I ended up taking some off of the cupcake... but then I just ended up eating it later haha, did I mention it's a good thing I don't live nearby? This is a great place if you're craving something sweet or if you need to pick up a gift for something. read more

Kiss Me Cookie - Orange dreamsicle and fireball cupcakes - Bakeries Near Me - Webster, New York

I am here to make a really big deal about these COOKIES! Saying that the cookie I ate in my car today after leaving the store is "the best cookie I've ever had" is the understatement of the year. The cookies Kiss Me Cookie sells are perfection for those of us that love a soft, pull apart, smooshy, doughy, sugary, flavorful cookie. I sampled the funfetti chocolate chip cookie on my way home, prior to stuffing these bad boys into Yelpies bags, and I was utterly shocked. How could cookies BE this perfect? How have I gone 27 years without eating one? I doubt I'll ever purchase cookies from anywhere else. The experience I had placing my order, adjusting my order, and picking up my order was friendly, seamless, and filled with care and consideration. They are conveniently located (8 minutes from me DANGER) in Webster in a plaza with ample parking. Order ahead during the COVID times for easy pick up - I was in the store for a total of maybe 45 seconds? Snap pics, grab bags, slide card into square reader, and see ya! It couldn't have been easier. I can't wait to use Kiss Me Cookies for every party, event, and gathering when we're allowed to have those again some day. The flavor list goes from your basic favorites to innovative new ideas. I can't wait to try every single one, waistline be damned! Thanks for making the day of this Yelper, Kiss Me Cookie! read more

See all

So excited to try this place with the yelp elites. So many options. They have ice cream, milk shakes, cookies, cupcakes, cookie cake etc. I opted for the golden cookie with golden ice per request of my five year old. It was delicious, it tasted like cookie batter in the best way imaginable. I also bought a few more cookies because why not.. and who doesn't love cookies. We chose chocolate chip, butterfinger and funfetti. Each cookie was really tasty. My husband preferred the chocolate chip, my son loved the funfetti and I couldn't quite decide. Employee was super friendly and nice. It was a great experience and I will return when in the area read more

See all

Okay- they got me. I came home and told 3 different friends about this place. I'm really not sure what they do different when making their cookies, but whatever it is- it's good. Really. Really. Good. We got a peanut butter cup pizza cookie and split it- I already want to go back for another. We also got some cupcakes for the next day and the frosting is great. Not too sweet but also sweet enough to do its job. You know, as frosting does. The cupcake itself was fluffy, so that gets a thumbs up as well. My husband had the Funfetti ice cream in a waffle cone - on our way home he said he was glad we didn't stop at Abbott's because the line is longer and the ice cream just wouldn't have been as good. That's high praise coming from that guy. So go support a small, local business and be prepared to be impressed read more

See all

We had an opportunity to try their cookies stuffed with alcohol infused frosting tonight during the June City Walk. I highly recommend you visit their store in Webster. These cookies were exceptional. read more

Kiss Me Cookie - Owner - Bakeries Near Me - Webster, New York

See all

If you are watching your sugar, turn back now. Only the strong may enter. Confectionary best describes this cute little shop. I tried several different ice creams, cookies, and cupcakes (not all in one sitting). The 1st cookie sandwich had a double chocolate cookie, a s'mores cookies, with chocolate ice cream in the center. Together, it was a lot and I mean a lot of sweetness all at once. Ideally, I think the ice cream, though good on its own, took away from the flavor of the cookies. Best to enjoy them separately. The 2nd cookie sandwich had a red velvet cookie, a salted caramel cookie with golden dough ice cream (tastes like cake batter with chocolate chips). Again, it's sugar on sugar on sugar. I knew it would be sweet but exceeded my expectations. A note for the salted caramel cookie, it was too salty.i know I know, I'm never happy. Too sweet and now too salty. Suggestion for patrons - Have milk with the salted caramel cookie. Bet that would balance the salt with the sweet. Now for the cupcakes... The Piña Colada cupcake had both coconut and pineapple flavors. Believe there were some coconut slices and pineapple pieces in the cake. I know the frosting was rum flavored, but it was just sweet IMHO. The vanilla cupcake. Vanilla cake with vanilla frosting. It was good but wasn't different from other vanilla cupcakes out there. I think what could elevate this cupcake to differentiate it above others is to use a bourbon based vanilla extract (instead of the vodka based versions) to add depth of flavor. Also, use a vanilla bean buttercream frosting. More expensive to accomplish, the pops of flavor the vanilla bean brings makes a world of a difference. Overall, definetly will visit again. Though this time, I'll eat ice cream on a cone while there, get a few cookies and cupcakes to go, then call it a day. read more

Kiss Me Cookie - Red velvet cookie, salted caramel cookie, with golden dough ice cream (cake batter ice cream with chocolate chips) - Bakeries Near Me - Webster, New York

See all

How sweet it is to have one conveniently located place to treat yourself and your family to luxuriously creamy ice cream, home made cookies, and cupcakes for all age groups (i.e. boozy flavors available now for us grown kids). Being able to customize your own ice cream sandwich is so much fun. It's a chance to take a childhood favorite up a notch. Get CRAZY! Your cookies can even be different flavors. One tip, especially on a hot day, maybe grab a bowl because that ice cream might squish out. The vanilla ice cream was outstanding and I will be thinking about it for days! I tried the boozy pina colada cupcake which was fruity, moist, and definitely packed a punch. My boyfriend enjoyed his very rich peanut butter chocolate (non-alcoholic) cupcake. I'm curious about their Buttery Nipple flavor and would love to check out their hot chocolate bar. A dessert pizza would make a great surprise to bring to a kids party or family celebration. read more

See all

I've been here a couple times and am unsure what all the hype is about. I have yet to have one cookie I have enjoyed. I even tried the ice cream one day and while accurate in flavor, most were just far too sugary. read more

It's fun to find a place outside your own town! The family and we're thrilled for our adventure to Kiss Me Cookie! We ordered a butterfinger cone, vanilla cone, chocolate chip cookie sandwich and double chocolate chip sandwich! They were so good and the sandwiches were made to order! Totally worth the adventure and we look forward to visiting again! read more

The name speaks for itself! The cookies are bursting with original flavors that takes you down memory lane.The cookies make you want to order a Dozen! I ordered a red velvet cookie and Oatmeal Raisin! And because of the gifts of being a Yelper, I got a Butterfinger Ice-cream on a Butter finger cookie ! Definitely check this place out... the ice cream is AMAZING! And Steve and Pam are so sweet and welcoming! read more

See all

Their cookies are so good! My favorites are funfetti chocolate chip and red velvet. The cookies are SO soft and big. The prices are great for what you get. There's a lot of parking available and the space is clean. read more

Kiss Me Cookie - Salted caramel, red velvet, golden dough, hot cocoa - highly recommend getting a bunch of flavors! - Bakeries Near Me - Webster, New York

Really awesome staff/owner who was very friendly in explaining how the ordering process works and what various flavors of cookie and ice cream there was. Also a lot of other products sold like chocolate, caramel popcorn, coffee, etc in case you're feeling something else! read more

I had a chocolate cookie from Kiss Me Cookie and it was really good! I was impressed how good it was after having had it for 2 days. Usually, cookies go off really quickly, but I very much enjoyed the cookie I had. I would definitely go and look at what other flavors they offer! read more

They opened a store! These cookies rate 10 out of 10! Today i had the yin/yang and a chocolate chip cookie with an Oreo center- out of this world- check it out will not be disappointed.. read more

If you're looking to order some delicious cookies, you've come to the right place. I've enjoyed both individual cookies and a custom order for a wedding. All of the cookies we've had so far have been outstanding. Custom ordering was great, we talked with Pam and Steve about what we were looking for and tried a couple of samples. They were willing to make whatever we were looking for, and suggested some recipes. We ordered cookies from both Kiss Me and from a well known specialty bakery and party guests enjoyed the Kiss Me cookies far more. I've tried the peanut butter crunch, the double chocolate and the golden dough cookie. The standout by far is the golden dough. It tastes like a combo between a yellow cake and a chocolate chip cookie, it's crazy that no one came up with this before! I'm glad that Kiss Me Cookies figured this out first. Next time you need cookies check out Kiss Me Cookies! Support a great local start up! read more

Not only are they delicious cookies but they are made by some of the nicest people. It's nice to get treats during the last year but it's even nicer to get them from the kind of businesses you want to support. read more

The cookies were very hard (stale?) Maybe we caught them on a bad day. They were recommended on a Webster FB group so we tried them today. "Salted caramel" read more

I ran into Pam and Steve, owners of Kiss Me Cookie, at Mark's Pizzeria in Webster. I saw "free tasting" and figured I would stop. It happened to be my daughters birthday so after tasting some excellent fudge and some cookie flavors, I asked if I could buy the display cookie cake made with butterfinger!! Happens to be Daughter's favorite candy. After Steve explained it was display and I promised to be lenient in my expectations, they let me buy it. It was great!! I haven't told them yet, so "great job!" Pam and Steve! I'm always happy to support start-up businesses. I see some fundraiser potential here, too. After sampling, I also ordered fudge for Thanksgiving which was just nicely dropped off to my home!!! I actually forgot I ordered it!! What a surprise! A lb of peppermint bark fudge, 1/2 lb of Oreo cookie and 1/4 lb of dark chocolate! We will share this on Thanksgiving and I'll update after tasting! Great couple, great customer service and can't wait to have the family taste the fudge! Thanks to Pam and Steve and good luck!! I'm sure I'll be in touch to order some Chriatmas fudge! Fantastic pricing!! read more