Love this coffee shop! I make a point to come here whenever I'm in town. It's super nice and cozy inside, with plenty of seating, though it's usually full, which just shows how much the locals love it. The latte is delicious, as is the breakfast food. I tried the generously portioned egg bites and the sausage, egg, and cheese sandwich, and they were excellent. read more

See all

I finally decided to check out this location today after driving by many times and I'm so happy I did. The staff was incredibly kind and it had a very cozy interior. I loved the chalkboard artwork and they had an extensive menu of food and drinks. The caramel brûlée latte is easily one of my favorites and this was one of the BEST ones I've had read more

See all

This was my first time trying their coffee and it was fantastic! I ordered their Masala Chia latte and asked they make it dirty. It was amazing and delightful surprising. The staff was super friendly and helpful as well. I highly recommend stopping it when your in the Geist area! read more

Geist Coffee - Seasonal Masala Chai Latte, dirty. - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Fishers, Indiana

New favorite coffee spot unlocked! My husband and I stopped by Geist Coffee for the first time this morning since moving to the area, and I'm officially obsessed. Hands down the best coffee shop around, with so many tempting options to choose from. I went for the Blackberry White Mocha Iced Latte--perfectly balanced in flavor--while my husband enjoyed the Go Green smoothie, which was just as refreshing and delicious (and such a gorgeous color!). The shop itself is adorable, with plenty of cozy seating both inside and out. I can't wait to make this a regular stop and work my way through their menu. Service was outstanding--thank you, Geist Coffee Co.! read more

See all

It's a cute little place to hang out with friends or alone. It is always busy but they keep it clean. The food and drinks are always a great variety and taste great also. read more

Such a warm and welcoming place to meet friends for a chat. Service is consistently good and coffee choices are tasty.

First things first!! The ambiance, just wow. How beautiful this place is! Upon entering and getting in line, I noticed the dining area and how they have string lights and lanterns hanging from a wooden shed-like structure. It's a very dreamy, warm, and aesthetic space! I love it! Great for studying. In terms of service, the service is very simple and easy. The baristas and cashier are kind and polite. It's a very "quick order and pay" experience but not in a rushed way. I got a hot caramel macchiato and it's balanced in flavor, the good coffee beans, and they gave it to me within a temperature where I could drink it and not burn my tongue but still call it hot. It's not overly sweet but I will say that it could use a bit more "kick" to it. Overall: very pleasant and aesthetically appealing experience! Nothing too special about the coffee tho. read more

See all

This coffee shop offers you a different kind of experience. It's had a cabin feel when you walk in and feels very warm and cozy, the perfect place to have coffee or tea. They have a wide variety of choices with all the diff kinds of milk options. There is plenty of seating both inside and out. The patio is dog friendly and the day I was there, there were several. Everyone is very nice and since it was my first time they took their time to go over some of the customer favorites. Nice addition to this plaza! read more

See all

Found this cute coffee house while visiting the area. Coffee was amazing. Service and vibe was awesome too. Enjoyed sitting by the gas fireplace. The area has a Minnesota or Michigan vibe. Loved it. read more

This is THE coffee spot in Geist! You'll know the moment you walk in because everyone and their mama will be trying to get their Java fix! This place stays packed and for good reason. The ownership and staff are super friendly and work diligently to make sure each order is exactly how the customer wants it. The atmosphere is warm and everyone feels like a regular. There's a business deal happening in one corner, a Bible study happening in another, a student working on a paper by the window, and friends just catching up by the checker table. Life is just happening. My morning go-to is the Naranja Blanco! It only comes in the small size, but it perfectly blends the combo of orange and coffee to feel like a warm good morning! My sandwich of choice is a sausage, egg, and cheese on a jalapeño cheddar bagel (add avocado and sriracha). It's always on point! My only knock is that sometimes it's too packed and you can't find an open table. However, it's worth the wait! Can't wait until it warms up and the outdoor seating is an option. read more

The breakfast bagel was the best I have had in Indy! Great service and I met the owner. Looking forward to trying sooo many more things. The vibe was way different than I expected. Super chill read more

Geist Coffee - Omg!!!!! So delicious! I even the owner. They have a flight that I am sooo excited to try. - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Fishers, Indiana

Very slow, waited for over 25 minutes for an iced espresso after placing an order and still didn't get it

I stopped in Geist Coffee while running errands nearby and needing to do some work and loved it. The breakfast sandwich was freshly made and their coffee was great. The atmosphere was quiet and the staff were welcoming making it a great place to get work done or meet a friend for coffee. I truly wished I lived closer to make it my regular local coffee shop but will surely return whenever I'm in the area! read more

Geist Coffee - Egg, sausage, and cheese breakfast sandwich and white chocolate latte - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Fishers, Indiana

What an immaculate coffee shop that's easily accessible by vehicle or bike. Several drink options and a light food menu are available. We split a gluten-free Snickerdoodle cookie that was soft and gooey, and you could not believe there was no gluten in it. The service was quick and friendly, and you ordered from the counter. read more

I love coming to Geist Coffee! Whether you are there to work, talk with friends, or read a book, there is a place for you. The cozy inside and beautiful shaded outdoor area are perfect for whatever you want to do. Their staff are always welcoming and help you with recommendations. Their coffee is great! I had an iced vanilla latte. Espresso tasted pretty average and the latte was a little less sweet than typical. I would maybe get an extra pump next time since I like my coffee on the sweeter side! read more

Geist Coffee - Iced Vanilla Latte - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Fishers, Indiana

I've been coming here for around 7 (ish) years now and always visit when I'm in town. The atmosphere makes it the perfect spot to sit down and do some work, or meet up with friends for coffee. Their seasonal drinks are always delicious and if they have coffee cake in the pastry case, don't pass it up. The staff is always so polite and welcoming too. Just beware, seating fills up quickly on the weekends! read more

I love stopping here every time I walk the fall creek trail. It's a celebration of passing the half way mark of my 10 mile journey. Today I stopped with my two boys and sprung for a treat. Archer (8) got a hot chocolate with whipped cream and Oliver (11) got a Carmel macchiato. Both boys very much enjoyed their drinks. I had a nitro cold brew with a shot of vanilla. It was lite and creamy and was very enjoyable. The staff here is always patient and friendly, and the atmosphere is calm and relaxed. A great place to take a load off for a spell. read more

Geist Coffee - Nitro cold brew with a shot of vanilla, lite and creamy. - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Fishers, Indiana

So excited to visit again after some time and find new menu items. An "espresso flight" ! Say what?!?! I'll have to get that next time! read more

I got a hot chai latte and it was amazing! The girl at the counter was super friendly too. Great atmosphere to meet with friends and chat.

An excellent little coffee shop. Lots of seasonal drinks and house specials, one of which I tried -- namely, the red cappuccino. I guess the drink has its origins in South Africa, but it was new to me. Very tasty, with a rich flavor profile. I appreciated the barista's willingness to explain some of these different drinks to me, to assist in my order. Notably, Geist has ample seating and rustic decor. We sat very comfortably for two hours. Next time I'm in the area, I'd gladly return. read more

Great service. Hearty breakfast sandwiches. Nice atmosphere and comfy chairs by a fireplace. What more could you ask for on a frigid winter morning? read more

I just get Chai latte from here. It's not as good as Big Train of course haha but I luv me some good chai read more

Geist Coffee - Chai latte - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Fishers, Indiana

I wish they had dark roast coffee and just little surprised by the paper plates.. Taste good though. read more

Geist Coffee - Avocado toast with black coffee - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Fishers, Indiana

See all

I've always enjoyed coming to Geist Coffee ever since one of my friends suggested we try it. It has a very homey feel, which is expected from a family-owned business. The seasonal drinks are always very great creations. I personally love the blackberry white mocha latte from the summer seasonal drinks and I also recommend the house specialty naranja blanco which has a little kick to it (cayenne)! Everyone is always so nice when taking my order and gives good recommendations when I'm in the mood to try something different. Definitely recommend checking this cute coffee shop out! read more

Nice little place out in Fishers, IN. Lots of locals hanging out. Coffee was great..latte with coconut milk flavors with mocha and vanilla.. smooth! Apple fritter was large, filled with apple and baked by local bakery! read more

Geist Coffee - Entrance to Geist coffee - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Fishers, Indiana

Snickerdoodle cookies as thick as a hockey puck, I tell ya! A delicious, chewy, cakey, cinnamony, perfectly baked hockey puck. I know I'm not making these cookies sound very good by comparing them to a hockey puck, but just go with me here as I construct this shoddy simile. These cookies are thick. Geist Coffee sells other cookies, but frankly, when snickerdoodles are on the menu, no other cookies exist in my mind. Though I'm pretty sure I saw some chocolate chip cookies in the display case, if you're into non-snickerdoodle options. We also got a cranberry orange muffin, which was delicious, as well. Even my children thought it was great -- they devoured more of it than I did. You never can tell what a child will like, especially when it comes to non-traditional muffin flavors like cranberry orange, but they loved it and I loved that they loved it. The coffee is great, too -- we got it black, and it was perfectly roasted and not at all bitter. They sell a wide selection of Nelson's Tea, too. Chai is one of my favorites from Nelson's, and they sell it here! It's loose leaf tea and they scoop it into little tea bags. I got all of my food and drinks to go, but I wish I would have stayed a while because the dining room is super cozy. Like another reviewer said, it looks like a cabin in there. It's a very warm and inviting place to sit and have some coffee. read more

If you're looking for a cozy, local spot to be a regular at, this is the place! Plus their coffee is top notch and they make a great breakfast burrito. I have yet to have a bad experience there and look forward to grabbing a latte most Saturday mornings from Giest! read more

Seriously the best coffee in the Fishers area. They serve Utopian beans (a roaster from Fort Wayne) which has fantastic single origins and blends. The baristas are all really excellent at what they do. Geist coffee takes coffee seriously and doesn't just serve sugary drinks. Love this place! It has a cozy neighborhood vibe that I love. read more

This was a very chill coffee shop, when I came it wasn't very busy. I got the spring special; honey lavender latte. It was sooooo good!! They had several seasonal drinks to choose from, which I love!! A rose shaken espresso sounds amazing! I got a small cinnamon sugar donut, it was good but I would try another delicious looking muffin next time. Also, I love how they have 3 sizes of coffee The barista took care while making it, which makes me happy. I will be back again soon! read more

I stopped by Geist Coffee on my way home from a quick trip to the reservoir for a little rest and renewal after work. Geist rests on the corner of a popular spot at the corner of Brooks School Road and Fall Creek Road right off Geist Reservoir. Geist Coffee has a warm interior that is nicely situated for pandemic relaxation, though they also have a very nice patio as the weather gets warmer. While I've been inside once, on this particular day I decided to try out the drive-thru that I'd never noticed before but actually existed pre-pandemic. It's kind of an awkward drive-thru as you have to drive around the back of the building via the Detour American Grille side and that will wind you over to the Geist Coffee window. This is a fairly casual window - you pull up to the window, ring the bell, place your order, and it's delivered to you fairly quickly. They were clearly monitoring the window as I did not ring the bell because I'm, well, a bit of a doofus. They have a menu at the window. I didn't see iced coffee, but upon inquiry was told they have it. I don't recall that they had prices on the menu, but Geist is the kind of area where if you live there you can probably afford coffee. I ordered a large iced coffee and it came in at about $4.50. It struck me as a bit high for the serving size (I don't live at Geist. These things matter). However, it was smooth and tasty and I have no regrets. The two employees who I met with briefly were helpful and friendly. Both were masked. Geist Coffee is noted as having farmer direct, locally roasted and handcrafted products. It's locally and family owned. Prior to the pandemic, it was certainly a gathering place for the area and I have no doubt will return to being so once things calm down. My understanding is they will also serve up pup cups, though I have no pup so I needed no cups. With the pandemic still influencing behavior, I've really started to take note of those places offering drive-thru. While this drive-thru is a bit odd, it's convenient and the employees are friendly. There's no doubt I'll return when I'm in the area. read more

This place just feels average to me. I wouldn't go out of my way to come here. I decided to try the flying pig and the carmilla latte. The sandwich I got on their jalapeño bagel which wasn't anything special. The sandwich was just okay, the latte was terrible their espresso had a very bitter flavor. The fireplace is a nice touch so I could see coming and enjoying that maybe just try the coffee next time. One covid related issue is they never wiped tables after guest left, I would imagine that should be protocol so be careful! read more

This is my go-to coffee shop when I want to indulge in quality coffee and concoctions! The ambiance inside is very warm and cozy, think cabin somewhere out West. The have a drive-up which is great for moms like myself that cannot take four boys under four inside. Now, onto why I had to knock off a star. The service is hit or miss. It's very very inconsistent which is frustrating at times because I would love to keep supporting a small biz. I used to go 3x a week here but the service just became so bad. No one seems to know what's going on and I have had to sit waiting for one coffee for 35 minutes. I love the owners they are ridiculously sweet people but some of their staff (managers especially) are not delivering on the service front. With all that said, it was a great cup of coffee and hope they work out the kinks! read more

Geist Coffee - Fun fact: we loved this shop so much we did family photos there! - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Fishers, Indiana

See all

It is hard for a coffee shop to keep a strong ambiance during COVID. They've done a great job of keeping a relaxed environment that still keeps customers safety first. Great latte. Fun menu to explore new coffee options and a VERY friendly staff. I can finally finish my screenplay. read more

Geist Coffee - Médium latte - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Fishers, Indiana

Stopped for a mocha and was not disappointed. This is a cute little coffee shop with great ambiance and staff. Will definitely stop by again next time I'm in the area! read more

Very cute and cozy coffee spot! Baristas were very kind and inviting. It felt like I was in a cabin in the woods, well mostly just the fireplace. After a lot of deliberating I decided on the cinnamon white mocha and a side of gluten free toast. The coffee was good, not too sweet. I did order it with half pumps. But the toast!!! This was some of the best gluten free bread I've had in a while!! I went for the coffee but I'd stay for the bread. What a gem?! read more

Geist Coffee - Cinnamon white mocha and gluten free toast - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Fishers, Indiana

Wow. What a busy place! We walked in and every table was filled, it was such a lively coffee shop!! We were greeted immediately and even though it was busy, they didn't rush us, which was very nice! I knew I wanted to try the Naranja Blanco, which is an orange oil white mocha with cayenne. It was probably the most interesting drink I've ever tried. read more

See all

My first time here and it was great. Who knew there was such a cute locally owned coffee shop within walking distance from my house. I had the lavender London fog tea and it was delicious. I love the cozy ambiance and nice friendly staff. I love the comfy seats and fireplace- i could sit here all day and just relax or work on my laptop. read more

Geist Coffee - Interior lighting with pergola - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Fishers, Indiana

See all

Latte was amazing however it took way to long to get my two lattes not even a sorry about your wait so kinda rude but coffee was good

I stopped in for a quick cup of coffee late in the afternoon and was very pleased. Not only did the shop have plenty of free parking outside their door, but inside, the place looked inviting and well kept. Very quiet vibe so that if you wanted to spend a little time working here, it seemed like you could go undisturbed. Although they offer a lot of pastries (and sandwiches until 3 pm), I simply wanted a nice black coffee that was drinkable without burning my tongue or tasting bitter. I received a really fine tasting coffee that was hot, but ready to drink and I was happy! The man behind the counter was friendly and we chatted while he got my coffee for me. So nice to have baristas who can make a customer feel welcome. If you are in the Geist area, make this your quick stop for a good cup of coffee. Review #3672 read more

See all

This cafe will transport you to a sweet, little log cabin where you can enjoy your latte by the fire. Geist has plenty of seating, string lights, free Wifi, and a great menu. What more could you need in a coffee shop? I've been here a couple times now and the staff is always super friendly! They know the menu like the back of their hand and they're willing to joke around with me when I order. I particularly enjoy the unique menu items. They experiment with your everyday cafe beverages and make fun combinations out of them. I've ordered the maple macchiato and cinnamon white mocha and both were great! The espresso isn't very strong, but it pairs well with the sweetness of the drinks. There are many more drinks on the menu I am excited to try. The food I ordered was also pretty good! Standard, but done well. It's a comfortable spot to sit and get work done for a few hours. read more

Geist Coffee - Flying pig sandwich, sausage egg and cheese sandwich, cinnamon white mocha latte, turmeric latte - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Fishers, Indiana