An absolute must-try!! I was so excited to finally check out Dark Side Coffee House, especially after seeing their incredible summer menu. But the moment I spotted the 32 oz coffee bucket...I was sold. I've been searching for a coffee shop that serves coffee buckets, so this instantly became a must-order. Not only was the bucket such a fun experience, but the coffee itself was perfectly balanced despite the larger size. Plus, I was thrilled to take the bucket home--I already know I'll be reusing it! I can't wait to come back and work my way through the seasonal menu. The atmosphere is just as impressive as the coffee. From the relaxed, cozy vibe to the fun Star Wars theme, it's a place that's easy to love. The service was phenomenal, and I only wish I lived closer because this would absolutely become one of my regular coffee stops. I'm so glad I finally got to experience Dark Side Coffee House, and I can't wait to bring my friends and family here to enjoy it too! read more

See all

Friendly service and yummy drinks. I got their special seasonal blueberry breeze matcha, and my husband got the iced cold brew with vanilla. Both were very good and the service was friendly and quick. read more

Dark Side Coffee House - Blueberry breeze matcha - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Cicero, Indiana

Neat little coffee shop. Our respective coffee orders were very good. Prices are about what you'd expect to pay. We also ate breakfast. The yogurt was good and the breakfast sandwich was ok. The gals behind the counter were very nice and quick to deliver our orders. Glad we found a good coffee spot. read more

Oh! What a beautiful beautiful cozy coffee shop! I have been meaning to visit Dark side coffee house for a while now and I finally got the chance today! The vibe is relaxed and the service is so good and quick. My best part was having a slice of spinach quiche. The base was fresh and layered crunchiness and the keto cookie was from a different world! The coffee was delicious and freshly brewed! Cicero is a small town with really stylish and friendly customers and I so enjoyed interacting with every one of them. They have a delicious array of baked goods so be sure to try each one of those! read more

See all

This was our first trip up to this cozy coffee shop. I was very surprised to find that we had never heard of it and it's been there for 4 years. The espresso was very smooth and they had a nice drink menu with seasonal specials that looked refreshing. My next trip up I want to try their cold brew or Nitro but as my GOTO test of a coffee shop I did a Cappuccino which was made very well! The staff was really nice, chatty, and fun to talk to. Plenty of seating to sit, chat, and enjoy your cup or take to go. My only con and it wasn't worth a star was the steps to get into the building. They are a little steep and not ADA. With that said they may have another entrance around the corner that is ADA but I didn't notice it when I glanced. read more

Love the ambiance, food & most of their drinks. The staff is friendly & quick. However, I got a cup of reg coffee & it was very bitter & not that good which was disappointing read more

Cute little coffee shop. Yummy fall drinks. Big comfy couch! Girls were helpful with drinks and super nice. read more

Dark Side Coffee House - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Cicero, Indiana

Cicero is the cutest, most quaint little town, just north of Noblesville. I was looking to go off the beaten path, so this was the perfect place for a little adventure. I'm always delighted and surprised to find the coolest places in tiny towns like this! Get here now! The vibe is super cute and modern, with exposed brick and cool subway tiles. The tables are cool and there are cozy leather couches for relaxing. The barista was extremely helpful! He was able to answer my many questions about the holiday menu and helped me choose the best drink--and then he went a step further and made adjustments to my latte, making it extra special and perfect for me. I ended up with an iced oat milk gingerbread latte (with 3 pumps of gingerbread and a pump of cinnamon--if you're like me, searching for a replacement to the discontinued Starbucks GBL, this one is great!). My boyfriend ordered a peppermint mocha and it was also good (the mocha is really rich and dark and delicious). Highly recommend! This place is a hidden gem. read more

Dark Side Coffee House - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Cicero, Indiana

See all

Coffee was amazing, the staff is super sweet and gave me a great drink recommendation! The aesthetic of the shop is super cute too!

Dark Side is our favorite small town coffee shop. The location is great, the coffee is always hot & delicious, and there is a huge variety of baked goods and sandwiches to choose from. Charming atmosphere, great service and a terrific place to meet up with a friend. read more

I moved here last Friday and I swear I have been to this coffee shop every single day. Everything I've had is fantastic. Great breakfast burrito, amazing coffee. I just wish they had a loyalty program to get a couple free coffees by now read more

Glad to have a coffee shop like this in Cicero. I was already delighted when Remnant opened up in Arcadia, and while I prefer Remnant to Dark Side by a slight margin, it's a nice little treat to have this so close to home. It definitely beats driving to Noblesville for a good iced coffee when I can grab one just down the street here. I've tried several of their drinks and a simple vanilla or caramel iced latte (though they also have cinnamon, which is a top-tier flavor to add to any iced drink in my oponion) is my go-to for sure. I will say that they are not typically super cold, since they're obviously adding hot coffee to it, so maybe ask for extra ice if the temperature of it will bother you. Definitely worth a stop and a good addition to Cicero's growing downtown business scene. I suspect more things like this are to come with the way the town has grown in the past few years. read more

Dark Side Coffee House - This was an interesting apple cider freeze thing they had back in the fall - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Cicero, Indiana

Food is excellent! Love the breakfast croissant ! Service is accommodating Ambiance is chill and trendy read more

disappointing experience at this coffee shop. While the coffee itself was okay at best, the management was a mess. It was clear that there was a lack of leadership. read more

Had heard great things about this coffee shop, stopped by on a beautiful fall morning and it did not disappoint! Super cute cafe, stuff was really nice & lots of choices! I couldn't decide between a few coffees and they let me try their cold brew on tap & gave recommendations. I tried a popular choice, white mocha & cinnamon latte...SO GOOD. Lots of fun bakery options like rainbow bagels and Halloween themed baked goods. read more

See all

Nice and cozy atmosphere. Coffee was good and the breakfast croissant was really good and the maple pecan scone was good but needed more flavor and more butter. They were very busy but the 3 ladies were quick and very efficient. read more

Great little coffee shop to go to when passing through. Cold brew was so good! Love visiting local coffee shops when out traveling! read more

Dark Side Coffee House - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Cicero, Indiana

It was a nice coffee shop in the middle of town. The place was neat and clean and the people were friendly with good coffee.

Cute place, the inside is adorable, and they even have things to buy that match the Star Wars theme, which is really cute! It's nice to have another coffee shop around. I got a white mocha, two Macarons, and my boyfriend got the blueberry redbull drink. The total came up to $18. The coffee and pastries were really good! My only complaint is that the service was not the best and the prices are a little steep. That being said, I'd still recommend it! read more

Delicious coffee!! It was not overly sweet. We were visiting from out of town and they took time to chat with us to make sure we got what we wanted. Very friendly staff. Would definitely recommend. read more

What a great addition to Cicero! I have had their dark roast and an iced latte--both delish. The baked goods look amazing, but I haven't had the chance to try any yet. All are made in house except their bagels which they bring in from NY. I mean- that's the way to do it! Staff was so helpful and kind. I'll stop here for coffee (and maybe a treat) anytime I'm in the neighborhood. read more

Every time I have visited Dark Side its been a great experience. I'm a fan of their seasonal drinks and TOP NOTCH pastries! Not to mention the shops atmosphere is a total vibe! I love supporting local businesses like Dark Side. read more

See all

Amazing local coffee shop located downtown Cicero. I love their iced lattes and their fresh pastries! Staff is also very friendly. Can't wait to return read more

Dark Side Coffee House - Caramel Macchiato - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Cicero, Indiana

See all

The atmosphere of this new little coffee shop is clean and crisp. I really appreciate what they were going for! They seem to have all the staples for a coffee shop and even do drips and pour-overs which is refreshing for the area. All three drinks that our group had were very good and we will be trying it out again soon! read more

Dark Side Coffee House - a man sitting at the bar - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Cicero, Indiana

Absolutely love this coffee shop!! Their drinks are amazing and they have incredible Gluten free and Keto cookies. Their Star Wars theme is the icing on the cake of this adorable coffee shop! read more

What a great experience! Lovely little spot with delicious coffee... the girls working were friendly and helpful and I'm loving my seasonal pick of the caramel apple blonde latte - something I wouldn't normally pick, but they managed to make it delicious. And the coffee has a very nice and clean caffeine hit. This is my kind of coffee :) read more

Great people, good beverages, and awesome value for your dollar. They're there only "coffee house" we go to locally now. Not that others aren't good, but bang for the buck is important. read more

Cute store, friendly staff, delicious food, and the best coffee I've ever had anywhere in Hamilton County!

My Family and I absolutely love this coffeehouse. Fantastic service, food, and the drinks are top notch!

Dark Side Roasters has been roasting great coffee locally (and generating quite the fan following!) in northern Hamilton County for a couple of years now, but recently added a coffee shop to their line up. Fantastic move, Dark Side! The coffee options are on point, and they've also some added bakery items, breakfast choices and other nice treats. Given how delicious their roast coffee is, it's not unexpected they would do a great job with the coffee shop. And, they have! Well done. read more

Friendly staff. Regular patrons seem to know each other. Comfortable space to enjoy a delicious coffee.

Amazing coffee, baked goods, bagels, breakfast burritos! Love the friendly staff and the excellent coffee! Gluten free options also available! read more

See all

Super friendly and helpful staff. Owner was on site and able to help with suggestions. She even turned my daughter onto liking coffee.... Never thought I would see the day. Super cute shop that is clean. Love to get a chance to support a small business who cares about their customers. read more

i got an iced caramel latte. a basic but very tasty. they have alternative milk options which is always nice as i can't have dairy milk. will be stopping back in when i'm in the area! read more