It's might seem like another stall in the mall, but this is one of the best coffee I've ever had. Turkish coffee with its cardamom flavor hits like nothing else, and the homemade treats--particularly the baklava--are a must. Endorse this shop and the sweet owner as much as you can. Best local coffee in the Castleton area! read more

I'm so glad I discovered Cath Coffee & Tea House at Castleton Square Mall. From the moment I walked in, the experience was wonderful. The owner was incredibly kind and welcoming. I tried the regular iced vanilla latte and the iced Biscoff latte. Both were delicious, but the Biscoff latte completely stole the show. It was so smooth, flavorful, and unlike anything I've had before. It was one of those drinks that makes you immediately want to come back for another. Everything on their menu looked amazing, and I'm already looking forward to coming back and trying more. If you're in the area and looking for great coffee, matcha, tea, or a sweet treat, definitely check this place out. read more

See all

First of all: Cath Coffee is located inside Castleton Square Mall! It's not a coffee shop, per se, but more like a coffee stall by Macy's that specializes in caffeinated beverages and desserts. So, if you want to visit Cath Coffee, you will need to enter the mall. I didn't need a coffee shop to hang out in, just a place to get a drink to give me an edge. I needed my wits about me on this afternoon, because I was buying a kettle bell at the nearby Dick's Sporting Goods, and I needed to determine which weight was the right fit for me. Important stuff! But this is neither here nor there. At Cath Coffee, I ordered a black iced coffee. Haters will say that my order was pedestrian, considering the abundance of coffee options on the Cath menu. I coulda got a chai latte! Or a lavender lemonade! Or a toasted marshmallow hot chocolate! But I wanted just pure caffeine with the least amount of calories. Black coffee fits that description, and I chose iced because it was a relatively warm day. My iced coffee was ready lickety split, and it tasted great. It's hard to eff up an iced black coffee, and luckily, Cath Coffee did not do that. They have a lot of pastries and desserts, including baklava and macarons. They also have Dubai chocolate bars! read more

DELICIOUS! My mother and I ordered the caramel macchiato. My brother ordered a lemonade. All three drinks were delicious. Not overly sweet and they didn't taste artificial. The espresso was so smooth. The lemonade was refreshing. The service was top tier. He was so kind and even stirred our macchiatos for us. He demanded (jokingly) that we try it and tell him how it was because he didn't want us to leave unsatisfied. Such an amazing little coffee shop in the mall with even more amazing service ! Note- he even has non dairy whipped cream which is great for the non dairy latte lovers ! read more

The most expensive latte I have ever purchased does seem awkward to be from a mall stall! Phenomenal staff, engaging and inviting, ensured I selected everything convinced me to put in 4 shots to my large soy Irish cream latte. He mentioned he offers coffee forward, not as sweet, which is fine however for adding up to over twelve dollars there's no espresso that can dance on tastebuds well enough! I'm sure some would try persuading me of single origin specialty roast yet once the milk and sugar syrup is pumped out of plastic. Well. I recommend 7 Brew, Dutch Bros, and even the Wendy's cold brew offering the same overall conclusion for half the cost! read more

Cath Coffee - Bar - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

See all

Turkish coffee in the castelton mall! Such a hidden gem for coffee in Indianapolis. The iced latte is delicious. I got marshmallow this time from the seasonal menu, but they have ton of flavor choices and sugar free options too. My mom got a bourbon macchiato again. She got that last time and loved it so much wanted it again! There are lots of pastry options too. Plenty of comfy seats right next to it or can stroll around the mall while you drink. If you have kids the food court has an indoor play area that I recommend grabbing a coffee before hand and relaxing there. Cath coffee is in front of Macys if you are trying to find it! read more

Cath Coffee - Iced latte - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

Great customer service. I wasn't a fan of my drink. It was clean. I noticed the bakery items were from Costco. If I went back, I'd try something else. The coffee is located in the middle of the mall near Macy's. Make sure to check them out. read more

See all

Stopped by here while at the mall for a quick drink. It was pretty warm so while I love a hot coffee, I wanted something more refreshing. I've been loving matcha for the health benefits and non-jittery caffeine boost so when I saw matcha lemonade, which is harder to find since Dutch Bros removed it from their menu, I was sold. The owners were in such good moods, especially the male owner. Just naturally good energy, someone who clearly cares a lot about good products and great customer service. The female told me lavender and strawberry were the top flavors to add to the matcha lemonade. I went with lavender and it was amazing! They made sure I loved it before I walked away, which I appreciated. They have lots of desserts here too, the pistachio cake looked amazing. They make the baklava and Dubai bars in-house. My husband had a slice of blueberry cake loaf, which was warmed up - it was pretty good and he loved it. For my large drink and his slice, it was $13. My friend also loved her coffee beverage. We will definitely be back!! read more

Cath Coffee - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

Great location for consistent business but wish they had a stand alone because I am NOT A FAN of the mall anymore .... Thankful I stumbled across this place though. They took over the old Starbucks location right across from the LEGO store in castleton mall. I got the pistachio latte, great flavor & perfect temp! read more

Cath Coffee - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

See all

We were in the mall for some business and after our meeting, I grabbed a mocha from their kiosk. The guy there was the nicest guy ever, he was genuinely happy we were there. Coffee was great too! I had a large hot mocha with an extra shot and it was great! read more

Cath Coffee - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

Coffee kiosk in Castleton Square mall right outside of Macy's. The kiosk offers a wide variety of flavors to mix and match. I ordered an iced white mocha with Carmel Bourbon and oat milk. The barista was nice and asked questions before preparing the drink to get the appropriate amount of sweetness that matched my taste. read more

Cath Coffee - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

See all

I was at the mall running some errand and was in need for a coffee. I've always seen Cath Coffee pop up when search for coffee shops but never had a chance to make my way there so what perfect time to try. It's a little stall in the mall right outside Macy's. The owner Atif was extremely nice from the moment we walked up. Unsure what to order he gave some recommendations and I got the Nutty Irishman and my friend for ordered an almond milk latte. We asked Atif if the coffees were sweet & he assured us they will be just perfect. Not too sweet & not too bitter and he was correct. It was one of the best coffees I've had in the Indianapolis area. Atif was the most friendly person and very passionate about his coffee and I definitely will be returning. read more

See all

Incredible service, fantastic coffee, ordered a mocha latte. Highly recommend this place.

Not bad. We got a large decaf latte, which was served a tad cooler than I like and seemed to have the coffee to milk ratio a little off. But it was ok. The baklava was really good. And the owner seems very friendly. The counter's clean and seems well maintained. Not the best around, but better than the Starbucks in Macy's. read more

See all

I had errands to preform in the Castleton Mall. I don't know the last time I was in the mall but thought I would get a coffee while there. I noticed Starbucks was in Macy's but thought I would prefer a non corporate shop. That is when I noticed Cath's coffee and teas. Signage indicated it was an "international" coffee shop. We each bought black American coffee. The coffee was prepared individually in a drip cone. It was really good. It could be drunk black without a bitter after taste Once we had ordered our coffee we noticed that he sold Turkish coffee, something we enjoy. Next time! The owner pointed out he had fresh, homemade baklava as well as an Egyptian dessert. They looked so good we had to try them. They were good. Another customer ordered a cookie, latte, milkshake. It looked good and I commented on it. The owner gave me a taste. It was good and offered me more but I had to decline as the desserts were big and impossible to eat more. Although there is nowhere to sit in the coffee shop, there is a grouping of comfortable mall chairs a few feet from the coffee shop. This business is to the right when you leave Macy's and for my money very good and more reasonable than Starbucks. The owner was friendly, helpful, generous and welcoming and if I am in the mall again I will go back. read more

Replaced the Starbucks coffee shop at castleton mall, loveeeed the coffee we had there! I got a Turkish coffee and my husband a gingerbread flavored coffee and both were fantastic. Service was friendly and I appreciate their multiple questions/warnings about Turkish coffee (it's fair because can be thick/sludgy to those not familiar with it). Would definitely go back if/when I shop again in the mall! read more

Best baklava Ive ever had! Awesome owner and great quality ingredient. the coffee was strong and tasted great. we will be coming back inside the mall just to get the baklava read more

I am constantly finding excuses to drive up north just to get this karak, it's absolutely delicious and one of the best chai spots in the city read more

Meandered through the mall with my spouse and met the most dedicated and kind shopkeeper I've ever met. Great quality food and drink!

this place is awesome! i got an iced salted caramel white mocha in the smallest size, with one shot of espresso, and it was the perfect amount of coffee and milk/flavorings together. she was super nice and sweet and explained things to me. she's so awesome! love it!!!! 10/10 would come here again if i'm in Indianapolis! read more

It's great to see this long time coffee spot that operated in City Market downtown take over a former Starbucks kiosk in Castleton Mall. This locally owned small business offers traditional coffee drinks and pastries as well as Turkish coffee and a few other drinks with international inspiration. The owners and friendly and welcoming. read more

Cath Coffee - Side of the kiosk as you exit Macy's into the mall - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

See all

Wonderful coffee great company! Thank you!! Thank you!! Really took the time to decorate and attention to detail. Made a great product read more

Cath Coffee - Yummy - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

Amazing and fast service, delicious drinks, variety of great pastries! Definitely recommend

The owner was very friendly they have amazing coffee drinks especially the Turkish coffee :)

phenomenal coffee and it's family owned definitely should try it when you come to the castleton mall! read more

Cath Coffee - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

Lovely place! Good coffee, fast service, nice people! I liked all of the options they had including the turkish coffee latte.

The nicest service ever!!!!! That alone would make be come back, but the drinks are so good as well! I got a strawberry refresher and it was so fresh and good! read more

Such great service! Workers are helpful in helping you decide what you would like. Super great coffee and sweet treats

Coffee was amazing and the barista was super helpful, very knowledgeable about his coffee, and great bakery items.

Great coffee, glad to see it replaced Starbucks. The guy running the stand is very professional and sincere.