What can I say about this staple restaurant? It's our family's dependable middle ground, where the food is consistently fantastic, time after time. We've celebrated birthdays and more in its always-cozy atmosphere, which feels special enough to require reservations and on some days, it truly does--yet they somehow always make room for us. A word to the wise: if you're driving, pace yourself with their legendary pineapple drink; it has a sneaky way of catching up to you! Now, for the food: the duck wings are a must, and the crab cakes are always fresh. The rolls are perpetually on point, but the star is undoubtedly the steak. It's so perfectly juicy that I'm almost disappointed to have leftovers, though it makes for a spectacular next-day breakfast with eggs. This place will always be my go-to for a deliciously fancy dinner and excellent drinks. read more

Gages Steak House - Steak cooked twice potatoes - Steakhouses Near Me - Guthrie, Oklahoma

This was our second visit and the food and service were exceptional. I had the seafood stuffed snapper and my husband had the special - 16 oz ribeye with shrimp. So delicious. Our friends enjoyed their meals as well. Worth the drive from OKC. Love this place. Well priced too. We will be back. read more

Gages Steak House - Ribeye and shrimp special - Steakhouses Near Me - Guthrie, Oklahoma

See all

Nice restaurant located in the historic Guthrie rail depot. Food was good and the staff knowledgeable and polite.

Harry Potter is not the only one able to access a concealed platform in a railway station. Gages has a life of its own hidden inside of a beautiful, historic train depot. Embraced by cowboy-hat wearing locals, Gages is a guarantee for a great evening complete with well-prepared steaks, delicious mashed potatoes, and handmade desserts. They also have a special event space. Guthrie is a small town with a handful of good restaurants. Gages came highly recommended by locals and I'm pleased I took their advice. Protips: 1)reserve a table on yelp! They get very busy! 2) The portion size of the Delmonico steak is very large. For $6 extra, you can split a main dish with family and get an additional two-sides. Well worth it. read more

Gages Steak House - Steakhouses Near Me - Guthrie, Oklahoma

This was a really good restaurant. The artichoke dip we ordered was underwhelming, but that doesn't hurt the entree score. We had the Chicken Fried Steak, the Country Fried Pork Chop head, and the Cobb Salad. The main course was some of the best we have had. They start with different cuts of meat that are better than normal beef, they use beef tenderloin and the pork was a pork loin. They breaded it with perfection ingredients. The white and brown gravy were delicious additions that accented the potato and green beans. Next time, we will skip appetizers and get dessert! The service was great as well and no issues with running out of drinks. Yesterday, was a rodeo event at the Lazy E so it was packed! Definitely need to make reservations at the time you wish to eat. Showing late, you may not get a seat. The restaurant is housed in the old railroad depot. Very cool old building! read more

Gages Steak House - Country-Fried Pork Chop! - Steakhouses Near Me - Guthrie, Oklahoma

The only thing that went well was the service. Everyone was so friendly and kind. That's why I did not give them one star. The food is not worth the price. We had the artichoke dip and it had a weird taste and color. The burger was huge, but lacked seasoning. Fries were okay, but soggy. My husband had a steak with potatoes and he said it was alright, but needed salt and the potato was not finished cooking. They cooked the steak to the right temp though. The crème brûlée was water and did not taste good. All you really had was burnt sugar. The restaurant is in an historic train station. They should really buy into and invest to bring it back to life and make it an experience like back in the day. Honoring the station and it's history instead of cheap tables and bare walls. read more

Gages Steak House - Burger - Steakhouses Near Me - Guthrie, Oklahoma

See all

I have been there twice. Food was good both times. I will be eating there again. I kinda get a feeling of sprits......

We had an excellent meal!!! Our waiter, Brandon was awesome! He knew the menu well and was great in helping us choose a wine. We drove 30 minutes to Guthrie and found this outstanding restaurant. All the waitstaff were pleasant and so welcoming. Great atmosphere, too! Rick and Cam read more

The food was delicious. We all had the 3/4 pound burger. Wow! So yummy. Gages is a great place to eat in an historic building! Perfect service too read more

We loved our visit to Gages Steak House. They have done a great job with the old depot building. The staff was friendly and polite and took great care of us. The food was very good. The steak was very nice. The cut was good, and the flavor and grill of the meat was done nicely. We will definitely be back. read more

Great selection, outstanding service, and delicious. Comfortable atmosphere in a rustic setting.

Manager was very kind and helpful. Waitress did a great job. Shrimp cocktail was great. Took my 92 year old mother for her birthday. Great setting in old train station. Prices were fair. read more

Amazing food and service. Steaks are outstanding. Charming decor and ambiance in an old railroad depot in the center of downtown Guthrie.

The staff was very attentive without being obtrusive. The food was excellent. Kudos to the chef. The atmosphere being in the old train station was very imaginative. If we had one more day we would go again. Highly recommend read more

I have been about 6 times to Gages in Guthrie Oklahoma. The last couple of times have been below par. Last nite I went. And I gave the waitress my order. Got a salad with cheese. Ordered it with. Asked for more rolls never got them. When the gm brought what was suppose to be my meal. Well it wasn't. I order a filet med well with mash potatoes. What she brought me was a steak, lobster and asparagus. And then had me cut into the steak even tho I told her it wasn't mine. I finally just said I would pay for my drink and forget about the rest. The gm said no I didn't have to pay for the drink. The time before that last week. I ordered my steak when I got it it was burnt. And I again paid for my drink and left. Last nite I went on the restaurants messenger and asked for the gm which at the time I didn't realize that it was the one there. And I was told I wasn't allowed back there. And then today I get a message on messenger from somebody telling me I wasn't going to be allowed to come back. Haha. So I guess if you want substandard food for very expensive prices then go to Gages in Guthrie Oklahoma. Most of the wait staff is very good but there are some who are only interested in the big tables. I usual tip very good. Christmas we tipped over $150 .​ read more

I like to give 5s. I met with a group of friends for dinner. We were able to visit for 2 1/2 hours. The chicken fried steak was delicious. The New York strip was delicious and cooked perfectly but a bit of gristle along the edge and tip. The lava cake is tasty but I think I have had the torte in the past. The waitress was welcoming and friendly. It seems like the Delmonico is not a wider cut of meat with sauce but the same cut as the New York strip. read more

Food excellent Service outstanding Reservation is always on time Enjoy when a train goes through read more

Gage's Steak House was really good! We've been to Guthrie many times for events at Lazy E but this was our first time here. It came highly recommended by a friend. We got in with no wait. The server was excellent. Rolls were excellent. I had the pork chop, my husband had a steak and we had 3 teenage girls with us who got a variety of things. No complaints. We will return on our next trip to the Lazy E for sure!! read more

See all

The food was great and the location is very unique. We enjoyed the restored train depot - it has so much charm and character.

Such a cool experience eating at this old train depot as trains go by! The food and service were superb! I highly recommend.

Great steaks and seafood. Consistent quality. It can be busy on weekends. It's a favorite of mine.

Service was quick!! As was the food. We went during the Victorian walk in Guthrie and they had ample parking. A great meal read more

It is the place to go for a night out and good food. Highly recommend the steaks and the service is great!!!

Hostess not friendly. Felt very rushed. Small table with little room. Very loud. Service was friendly. Steak cold, potatoes cold and very dry. Dessert so so at best. Not a great experience- will not be returning. read more

Busy early Friday night. Great atmosphere. Sat at the bar and had an excellent pineapple margarita (although the bartender added salt w/o asking). We ordered the surf and turf. It had. 3 big tasty shrimp but the steak medallions were way too salty!! Could not even eat them. Potatoes were also heavily salted! Salad was swimming in too much dressing and nothing to write home about. read more

My wife and I favorite spot in Guthrie. Makes for a solid dinner on date night! The service is nice and quick. The food is very good. We always go here for our date night. read more

The food is usually quite meh and the service is hit or miss. It is exceptionally loud inside the restaurant.

This restaurant has the best ribeye (and most affordable) that I have ever had in my life. I am not exaggerating when I say this. The food is phenomenal. The service is also fantastic. The chef, bartenders, and servers all treat you so well. I would move to Guthrie, OK just so I could eat dinner here every night. read more

Great food service and atmosphere. Got right in without a reservation, but it is recommended to have.

First off, the train came thru twice! Can't script a great dinner at a historical train depot and a train comes by. Next, my blackened ribeye was absolutely delicious. Yummy! read more

A great little secret in Guthrie! Steaks were delicious. Great atmosphere Service was nice. We will go back

The front desk clerk recommended this restaurant and I'm glad she did. While the steaks are indeed expensive, there are a variety of excellent menu choices starting at $10-14. The food variety seemed to offer something for everyone. I had the pecan crusted rainbow trout which came on a bed of risotto and asparagus. The server was light hearted and attentive. I'd definitely come back. read more

Gages Steak House - Pecan crusted rainbow trout over a bed of risotto and asparagus. - Steakhouses Near Me - Guthrie, Oklahoma

I'll start with why I took off two stars. We had a reservation at 6:45, and the host/hostess let us know we had to wait for a table to empty. Which was fine with us. We asked if we could wait in the bar, they told us that was fine. The two at the hostess stand proceeded to whisper to each other like two teenagers.... It was very awkward and they continued to do that to other people who were patiently waiting. The bartenders were amazing! We really enjoyed our drinks... we tried to check a couple of times on our table and the host/hostess were not at their stand, they were all gathered around another table discussing something with the waiter/waitress both times. Finally at 7:45 pm, we decided to place our order at the bar because we didn't have all night. Almost a minute after we ordered the host/hostess came over and said our table was ready... a full hour after our reservation, we said no thanks we ordered at the bar due to the wait. The food was amazing and service at the bar! Steaks cooked perfectly! We will return, but I'm hoping someone addresses the employees at the front hostess station. Good help is so difficult to find. read more

Food is outstanding and staff is great. Their Tuesday night burger special is the best at a excellent price. This place is a good choice for a family night out or special event. read more

The food was great. I suggest the blackened ribeye with the blue cheese butter- absolutely delicious. I suggest you a reservation, it can get busy on Friday or Saturday nights. read more

My husband and I usually eat dinner here twice a year. The filet is amazing! We do not care for the twice baked potato, so we order the garlic mashed potatoes instead. read more

Good food, great atmosphere in an old train depot, great service. Make reservations through Yelp.

On an overnight visit for a girls weekend, we needed a good place for dinner. This was about the only option from the looks of what is open in Guthrie. There just aren't that many options. We had an enjoyable dinner. I would normally give 4 stars but we had great service, good drinks, and good food for the money. The fact that this place was open and we got right in on a busy Saturday night is worth an additional star. My mom enjoyed her ribeye. It was cooked medium, just like she ordered it and it was a huge piece of meat. The carrots, asparagus, and twice baked potatoes were nice. My stuffed salmon with Boursin sauce was great. It had a crunchy edge along the bottom and was cooked perfectly. It was not over cooked, which I was thrilled about! It was juicy and flavorful. I'd have this again. If I'm ever in Guthrie again, I'd eat here for sure. read more

Very nice place in an old train station. Unassuming until you have the steak au poivre or the crab stuffed salmon... Second best au poivre I've had on my life, and I've had a LOT... Salmon was fantastic. Bread was so-so. Staff was nice but could be more professional. (At one point the busboy just "plopped" the bread onto the table)... Service was laid-back but the Old Fashions were above average. Plenty of parking and casual to semi romantic ambiance. Overall, worth the time, effort and cost. read more

Gages Steak House - Crab topped Salmon - Steakhouses Near Me - Guthrie, Oklahoma

See all

Service is always great and the group are so friendly. Food is great, perfect for a dinner for 2 or a group.