I thought this place was a sit-down pizza place, but the bestie and I were pleasantly surprised when it's one where you order at the counter, sit down, and they bring your food out to you. We arrived here around 4 on a Saturday and were able to walk up to the counter without any line. We ordered the dill pickle pizza and the aloha (minus the spam). Both were delicious! We loved the airy, fluffy crust that wasn't hard or crunchy at all. The dill on the pizza was fresh and potent, and the buttermilk dressing was super creamy. The Hawaiian pizza was my favorite out of the two (while the dill pickle was my friend's favorite). I loved how the teriyaki sauce was sweet on the aloha, and the cheese on both pizzas was very tasty. My only complaint would be the long hair I found EMBEDDED underneath the toppings inside the crust on my piece of the aloha pizza. I kept tearing off chunks of the crust hoping I'd find an end to the strand... and it wasn't until most of the slice was demolished was I able to confidently say my piece was hair-free. Still giving this place a 5-star rating here, but just know in my heart, it's truly a 4.5/5 star rating. The dill pizza came out first and the aloha came out several minutes later, but both were fairly quick. The staff was super nice and I'd definitely love to go again to try out some of their other specialty pizzas. read more

Fire and Brimstone - Aloha Pizza (minus spam) - Pizza Near Me - Gilbert, Arizona

See all

SO GOOD. Will be coming back again! :) Limited seating inside but there are also outside seats as well! read more

Fire and Brimstone - The Fire and Brimstone Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Gilbert, Arizona

Came here to celebrate my last day of college ever. We were craving pizza and Fire and Brimstone truly satisfied our craving. It looked crowded at first and the line was long but in reality it took less than 5 minutes. When we got to the counter, the cashier was very nice and sweet. Even with the long line and crowd, the enthusiasm radiates from her and is definitely appreciated. I ordered the carnivore pizza and my girlfriend got the vegetarian pizza and we got an appetizer of pita and hummus. When we got up, we were able to find a spot to sit. The wait time that the restaurant has is based on the wait time of the bar for those who want food and alcohol. But we didn't want any so again we were able to find a comfy seat. Only thing preventing me from giving it a 5 star for a perfect dining experience is that the tables need to be wiped down more often. We had some crumbs in our table and felt uneasy from how unclean it felt. When we got the pita, it was great. The hummus was of amazing quality and the pita was fresh. And the wait time was very short for the appetizer. After a few more minutes, we got our pizzas. The carnivore pizza was amazing and my girlfriend loved the vegetarian pizza. Great quality and freshness as always. We didn't finish our food and I walked up and asked the staff if I could take the empty pizza boxes for takeouts, the staff let us know the pizza boxes were for take out and were very chill. With short wait times, good fresh food, and an amazing and chill staff. I would recommend people to come to this place. read more

See all

The dill pickle pizza is the bomb! I know it sounds a bit crazy but it's great! We also ordered a pepperoni (just in case), it too was yummy! read more

There were an unique selection of personal sized handmade brick oven pizza to choose from. I got the prosciutto and fig pizza and the classic fire and brimstone pizza. The prosciutto and fig had a very unique taste because it blended two different taste profiles into a single pizza. I'm not sure if I enjoyed the fig jam with the tomato sauce, but it was very different to say the least. A blend of savory and sweet. The service was pretty good as they would find you in the crowds between the brewery next door and the patio. It had a very chill vibes ambience, there were outdoor music playing during some nights as well. Perfect for date night or casual hang out. read more

See all

Where do I start! Brought family from out of state to eat before we walked through Agritopia Christmas lights. 2 of us went to order for our group and were told they were out of Bolagnese, so I looked for something else and we ordered a Reuben and out of that. Finally decided on 2 Italian sandwiches, a smash burger n a pizza. 2 other people who were with us ordered just ahead of our group. We were all told an hour and a half. Their order came first then the pizza. It was 20-25 min later and we were nearly done and the rest of the food was still not there. Why the pizza came and not the rest of the food? I will add by the time our friends got their order they were out of rice that went with her salmon. Thankfully she got a refund for that. I went back to see why we were still waiting and was told they were plating so I stayed to wait. A runner went and took the sandwiches and I was still waiting for the smash burger plate and I took it myself. Seriously disappointing and embarrassing to be out of things when there is a huge planned holiday event happening next door and not be prepared for higher volume on a Monday. Big miss. Will not be back. read more

Pizza is close to 5 stars, service & experience was terrible though. On a Tuesday, we placed a togo order. Ordered a pizza, a half salad, and the smoked olives & Marcona almonds. Ordered at 6:38 pm. Email receipt shows we were quoted to pickup at 7:23. We go in at that time and nothing is ready. So much for 45 mins and order will be ready. Pizza comes out at about 7:28. We ask and they say wait for our text alert. Almonds/olives finally gets boxed up at 7:40. We then ask again and say they are waiting for the salad. Finally get the salad done at about 7:50. Pizza was cold. Flavor was good. Salad was okay. Almonds/olives were good. There is no way they make the in-house customers wait almost 1 hr & 15 mins to complete an order. We won't order from here again. read more

YUM!!! We were starving and I had heard on Go Gilbert that Fire & Brimstone is highly recommended, so we ordered take out and drove there to pick it up. The order was correct and still hot, which is a rarity when picking up food. We ordered the Italian Salad, and 4 pizzas. We ordered the Margherita Pizza, the BBQ Brisket Pizza, the Carnivore Pizza, and a Pepperoni Pizza. The BBQ Brisket Pizza was easily one of the best pizzas I have ever tried in my entire life. Which is saying something, because I love and eat pizza quite often. It was piled with yummy and tender brisket with a delicious BBQ sauce. It was seriously addicting. The other 3 pizzas were also quite delicious. We enjoyed the Carnivore Pizza quite a bit. The pizzas all tasted incredibly fresh and unique in their own ways. The Italian Salad was also fresh and refreshing to pair with the spiciness of the BBQ Pizza. Overall, Fire & Brimstone blew me away for my first ever time trying them. Everything was quite reasonably priced for the quality. I'm sure I'll be back-- and try some new items next time. read more

See all

Ambience, and Brisket Pizza was just "Fire" recommended even with the GF Crust. Enjoyed and got a non gluten free first and easily switched with gf quick read more

Fire and Brimstone - Pizza Near Me - Gilbert, Arizona

Had a great experience at Fire and Brimstone. When we went to order we were told it would be about an hour wait for the pizza. It was dinner time on a Friday night so no surprise it was busy but I really appreciated the heads up. We said that was fine and ordered. We sat at W Brewing across the hall since that was the only place with indoor seating left and it was cold out. The pizza came out pretty much exactly an hour later but we were enjoying drinks from W brewing in the meantime. It's cool they let you bring food and drinks (unopened) back and forth between the two. Fire and Brimstone even lets you bring drinks from home as long as they're unopened which is so cool! I ordered The Big Dill. I wasn't sure how it would be since it's pretty weird for a pizza but I love ranch and pickles so I figured I'd give it a try. Omg was it so good!!! I'd say this place is worth checking out just to try this. I've never seen anything like it on a menu anywhere else. read more

Fire and Brimstone - The Big Dill - Pizza Near Me - Gilbert, Arizona

For starters it's in Gilbert in a barn with people who probably don't eat carbs but,,,, not my vibe but pizza was pizza

Pizza is amazing. Could have to wait a bit as they get busy and it's a smaller size restaurant. But quality and taste of food is one of our local favs. While you wait, you can walk 10 steps to the brewery and then sit outside and enjoy the patio vibes. read more

Truly one of the best pizza spots in the East Valley, we LOVE Fire & Brimstone. Located right next to 12 West in Barnone, it's the perfect place to spend an evening. Pizza and beer, what's better than that? We love all their pizzas but tend to always go for the Fire & Brimstone (with the fried egg!). We also love their specialty pizza of the week, it's always something fun and unique. Staff is always great, food can take awhile during busier times but they're very upfront about how long it will take. The merch is SO good, you have to grab a T-shirt while you're there. Plenty of seating, especially outdoors on the patio, and lots of parking available as well. We have not been since the renovation but are looking forward to trying out the new menu! See you soon F&B! read more

If you are a pickle lover, the Pickle pizza is a must! By far the best I've ever had! Their menu includes a variety of unique pizzas, you'll want to try them all! Best place to go to cure your pizza craving! read more

Fire and Brimstone - Pickle pizza - Pizza Near Me - Gilbert, Arizona

See all

This review is based solely on 1 slice of pizza. I got a NY slice. It was very floppy, with little flavor. Staff were not very friendly. Pass read more

Great wood fired pizza, not as crispy as I prefer it but definitely worth it. Nice to be able to order from neighboring spots to drink and relax. Went during the lunch hour and it wasn't crazy. Knowing the area I would avoid high traffic times I can only assume this place has a decent wait on food during the weekends and peak times. Planning to go back to try some of the more unique options. We did also have a cheese pizza that didn't make the photos, we ate it too fast! Props to the owner for the overall experience, I didn't meet them but the staff and food are a great reflection. read more

Fire and Brimstone - Dill pizza - Pizza Near Me - Gilbert, Arizona

See all

Great little pizza place! We love coming here for the unique wood fired pizzas and atmosphere. They're right next to 12 West so you can enjoy a beer with your food. Workers were super nice and attentive. read more

Fire and Brimstone - Prosciutto and Fig Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Gilbert, Arizona

See all

We go to F&B a lot because our 8 yr old loves the pizza, the dog watching and the outdoor patio. The Shrimp Salad and Smash Burger highly recommended as well. read more

One of the very few places I've found that offers pickle pizza. As an artisan pizza and pickle lover, even I was skeptical of the combo. Located inside Barn One, there's very limited seating for this place alone. However, they offer the option of bringing your food to you at the bar just across from them if you're planning on grabbing a beer there. I didn't see the option on the menu, but noticed another family order single slices so good to know you're not settled down with a whole pie. I decided on half prosciutto with fig and half big dill. I definitely see the potential in the fun options they offer, but I wasn't wowed with the flavors. I won't be running back, but would like to try more from the menu if we find ourselves back here! read more

See all

Love their pizza, only issue is that they're so busy :( I will be back one day. The bbq chicken pizza is really good and im hoping to try the pickle one read more

Amazing food and I'm not just talking about the pizza. It's a scratch kitchen so you know you are getting the best. Wonderful staff and a great place to eat. read more

Just really mid. The service was good but jeez man I think it was bingo night or something because the inside was so loud with some annoying lady talking on the speaker. Pizza was meh. Not horrible but also not excellent, especially for the price. We got a pickle pizza and the prosciutto and fig along with the beet salad. $64. The salad was really bland and felt like it was missing something, also way too much dressing it was almost soggy. The pickle pizza was not great, super wet because it was covered in ranch, cool concept but it missed. The prosciutto and fig one was alright too, it was a little too sweet because it had so much fig jam it was almost all you could taste. All in all just not very good, you could find way better in the valley for a better price. read more

Fire and Brimstone - Pickle pizza and Prosciutto and Fig Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Gilbert, Arizona

The pizza is delicious! Love the vegan options. They have some ingredients from uprooted kitchen which really elevate the experience.

We've eaten at nearby spots nearly a dozen times (maybe more), we finally had to give Fire and Brimstone a shot. Located inside Barone, this is a very casual pizza place. You order at the counter and can then grab a table, either in the restaurant side or bar side if you're also getting a drink. It was surprisingly busy when we went there on a Thursday afternoon, but we were able to get our order placed quickly and found a table. We ordered two pizzas: The Fire and Brimstone with a fried egg as well as the Prosciutto & Fig pizza. The first pizza was quite tasty; it came with spicy tomato sauce, fresh mozzarella, jalapeños, house-made merguez sausage, and cilantro. Definitely had a bit of a bite with the jalapeños on top .. overall, quite satisfying especially with a beer to wash it down! The second pizza was topped with prosciutto, fig, arugula, whipped ricotta, balsamic reduction, and tomato sauce. I'm kind of a sucker for prosciutto & fig pizzas .. whenever I see them on the menu, it's a must-order for me. This did not disappoint at all! The flavor combos were spot on, I really enjoyed this pizza. Overall, I'd definitely recommend this restaurant. They have a good number of pizza with various unique toppings; quite a few of them intrigued me so I'll be going back to try them! read more

Fire and Brimstone - The Fire and Brimstone Pizza with fried egg - Pizza Near Me - Gilbert, Arizona

See all

Gluten free and dairy light eater. The atmosphere is really relaxed. A barn with several little shops and bars. Minimal sitting inside and decent space outside. Nothing here has a huge footprint. We ordered the gluten free fire and brimstone pizza and polenta with meatballs. There was cheese on the pizza and in the polenta. It was too much dairy for me, but my rating isn't based on that. I've never had a gf pizza like this. It crisped up well. The flavor was decent, but didn't pop out for me. The topping was a bit dry. Cilantro was good. And the bite of the fresh jalapeño was good. The polenta and meatballs were good but a bit bland. It needed another dimension of flavor. Meatballs were pretty good. Overall the place was good but we probably won't come back. Nothing stood out to us. read more

Update to say the owner reached out to me and empathized with the situation and informed me he addressed it with his staff. I appreciate him taking the review seriously and attempting to remedy it. read more

Fire and Brimstone - Italian sandwich - Pizza Near Me - Gilbert, Arizona

I did not know the Barnone concept existed or that it was so close to my place! It's nice to see local business collaboration like this in Gilbert compared to the strip malls and chains in the suburbs. They all get their produce from the Agritopia farm as well, which is really cool. We got the fig and prosciutto pizza and the fire and brimstone pizza. Both were delicious! And you can't forget the skillet cookie. It was nice to be able to place the order, grab a beer at 12 West, then grab a seat at the patio. read more

This was some of the best pizza I've ever had! I highly recommend the fire and brimstone pizza if you like a little bit of heat! The prosciutto and fig was alright, but I realized I'm not the biggest fig on pizza person. If you want to make a night of it, hope over to the bar next door with your pizza and enjoy a good beverage! There was seating in the restaurant area and lots more if you're willing to grab a drink at the bar! Will for sure be going back to this yummy spot. read more

Pizza was taste, quick service. Fair prices good help. Just a little hot inside building.

Fast, friendly, and great service, are words that I would use to describe Fire and Brimstone. My family loves to go to Joe's Farm Grill in Gilbert, AZ. So, we were going to go over the weekend and discovered something, a lot of other people love going there too. As I was parking on the other side of the lot I had to walk through Barn One where Fire and Brimstone are located. Had some business to it but not like Joe's where it looked out to the road. So I said let's go here, and I am so glad that I did! I love pizza. I mean if I could I would eat it every day. But the reality is I can't but when I do I make sure it is good and I like it. Let me tell you this is good. I am a fan of Grimaldi's Pizza because it is a coal-fired pizza. This is exactly what it says, wood Fire and Brimstone, and let me tell you that flavor of wood is in the pie. It gives that dough a ton of extra crispiness and flavor. I had the Buffalo Chicken pizza. Surprisingly the sauce was not over-powerful to where you can't eat it but there and it gave it the right kick. The ranch is sweet but a little runny. Added the Parmesan cheese to the pie for that more cheesy goodness and it was great. The kiddo had a pepperoni pie and it was just like you would expect. The wife's pizza was the Margarita pizza as it is her favorite. I had a bit of both and they were good. Even better 4 days later for lunch. On the way out I wanted to see about a Chicken, Bacon, and Ranch Pizza. Apparently that is not a big thing in Arizona but they were willing to accommodate me and made one. I had it for dinner and I regret to say that I didn't get a picture of it but I ate every last bit to make sure it was the same taste and it was great. If you like pizza like this I know there is MOD, Blaze, and a few others that are chains. These guys are a mom and pop joint and I'll tell you what they are good and worth it. They are a friendly group and takek care of the customer. Ask if they had water and the guy who brought our food out told us that he would bring them and did. Didn't have to but that was great of him to do and then welcomed us and made us feel good to be there. The only major downside is that they only have bottled pop (yes I said pop because I am from PA). But to makeup for that fact they have a Bar right next to it. Literally, there is a bar on the other side of the room and their beer is next on my must tries. Another is seating. Very limited inside by the oven and then a little bit more out side, but they share patios with the bar so it really isn't a down side it is just a little confusing. In short, if Joe's is what you are looking for but don't want to wait in line for an hour and a half, head over to Fire and Brimstone for a pizza and a beer. You will not be disappointed!! read more

See all

We were having a couple of beers at 12 West Brewing and decided it was time for some thing to eat. We decided on a Southwest Pacific which had black forest ham, pineapple, pickled jalapeños and mozzarella. I was actually very impressed. We took our beers and sat on the patio which had big trees that provided shade and misters to keep us cool. When our pizza was ready they brought it to us outside. The menu was bigger than I expected and can't wait to come back and try some of the other things that were offered. read more

Fire and Brimstone - Pizza Near Me - Gilbert, Arizona

Great Pizza. Located in shared building with other businesses, it was nice to find it and enjoy some good food. One pie is good for two people. Everyone was friendly and quick. read more

See all

Amazing pizza selection. Likes: - The crust is soft, puffy, and chewy. - Mediterranean (top of first photo). That Za'atar seasoning was amazing - Great ambience. Friendly staff. Music is perfect volume and you can have a conversation with a group of friends without yelling over the table. Dislikes: - The Fire and Brimstone pizza (bottom of first photo). It's basically a taco on pizza dough and it just didn't seem to work. read more

Fire and Brimstone - Mediterranean (top) The Fire and Brimstone (bottom) - Pizza Near Me - Gilbert, Arizona

See all

Been here many times and the pizzas are always unique and awesome the service is impeccable and they'll do anything they can to make your visit a good experience I will definitely be back read more

Best pizza ever!!!! I got the pep and pineapple and it was amazing. The crust was crunchy and it was cooked all of the way thru the middle. I also got the half shaved salad and all of the fresh shaved veggies were very refreshing and a perfect pair with the pizza. read more

Fire and Brimstone - Pizza Near Me - Gilbert, Arizona

The pizza-hot The cooks-hotter The oven-on fire Super cute and vibey location with plenty of seating indoors and out (even tho it looks small there's actually a lot of seats even some barstools hidden right where the pizza is made so you can watch!) Also the BEST gf pizza crust I've had. Love that it was thin crust style and the vegan cheese option was a game changer. I will be back probably tomorrow, and the next day, and the next, and do y'all have a rewards program? read more

Fire and Brimstone - Gluten free crust for the Romanoff (vegan with plant-based cheese tempeh sausage)! - Pizza Near Me - Gilbert, Arizona

Cute little joint! It's tucked into the corner of the Barnone building, so don't blink, or you'll miss it. Walk up and order, then sit on their dog-friendly patio under the Roman shades... not a bad spot for a casual lunch on a nice day! We had the meatball sandwich and the Carne-vore pizza. The pizza was good. The crust was very good, if you like NY style pizza crust. The sauce was very plain, and quite scant, but still wasn't bad. The meatballs were very good, and the bread for the sandwich was also yummy, but it was luke-warm on arrival. The sandwich came with a side of Ruffles potato chips. Service was friendly and inviting. I'd say this place is a solid 3.5 stars; nothing spectacular and nothing bad; no complaints. read more

Fire and Brimstone - Meatball Sandwich - Pizza Near Me - Gilbert, Arizona

See all

If you're craving pizza that's worth the heat, Fire and Brimstone is where you should fan the flames of your appetite. This place takes the art of fire oven pizza to sinful levels of deliciousness. The crust is crispy with just the right amount of char, the toppings are fresh, and the cheese melts in a way that feels almost indecent. The inferno of flavors will have you praying for more. So, whether you're looking to indulge in a bit of culinary mischief or simply want to taste a slice of heaven, Fire and Brimstone delivers both in every bite. read more

The pizza was good. I really liked the baked potato pizza - unique concept and it went over well even as leftovers. The Mediterranean was also great. It made our revisit list - just wish there was more seating. read more

As a winter visitor I love a mile away from here. Was disappointed in Nov when it was closed as we really liked the pizzas in the past. Went after the re-opening and a bit disappointed. To be fair I will give them another chance as I think the expanded menu is maybe causing too much to balance. It's very different. We got 3 pizzas Potato/mushroom with Labneh Noodle salad Hummus Pizzas were not hot. Potato/mushroom dish not warm potatoes and mushrooms tough. Noodle salad recipient rated as okay Hummus was great It feels like the kitchen may not be dialed right now. I wonder if we only got pizzas if it was be better. Staff was kind as always friendly environment. During summer the sitting outside will be great. Hope it improves and will be back to Hopefully improve this review. read more