Food was mediocre, lacked flavor. Service was decent. Food came out quickly. Very, very warm inside made it slightly uncomfortable.

I really love this diner, the food is good and the staff friendly. There is also some nostalgia sprinkled in on my fondness of this particular diner that I've been coming to for a few decades despite living on the west coast. The food is always good, hearty portions and prices good. My club this visit was delish and my husbands Black Russian was tasty! read more

See all

The staff here were very nice, but the food unfortunately fell short of expectations. The bacon was mediocre, just some thin pieces of overpriced bacon. chocolate milk was wayyyyy too sweet. Then lastly, the pancakes were alright. Good fluffy pancakes, but sort of reminded me of hot cakes from McDonald's. read more

There is always an adventure and new food destination when visiting New York. Upon entering you are greeted and seated very quickly. I loved the vast selection of food choices. I chose the Eldorado burger and it was so delicious and juicy. I tried to walk past the desserts but the cheesecake could not be passed up. The thickness and flavor of it didn't disappoint. I loved the ambiance and friendliness of the staff. It's a great feeling to leave an establishment full, content and sharing a laugh. read more

See all

I was really craving a breakfast burrito (and I'm always craving pancakes) and this breakfast burrito was very cheese heavy in a way that was just very off balance. It didn't feel like there were any eggs in there at all. The pancakes also didn't have that buttery savory yet sweet flavor that I was craving unfortunately. I did enjoy the waffle fries though. I've been to this diner before haven't particularly enjoyed anything in a major way so I think this is just one of those last resort diners, but at least it's not as bad as the Port Chester Coach Diner and Mamaroneck Diner... read more

Eldorado Diner - chocolate chip pancakes - Diners Near Me - Elmsford, New York

See all

We spontaneously came here for lunch. It's a pretty standard diner. The kid menu was pretty robust, and the pasta and hot dog with fries did the trick. Our wraps were ok, though all the contents sort of spilled out. More could be done to keep the ingredients inside the wrap. The frappe was ok. I like that it wasn't too sweet, but I needed a little bit more of a caffeine buzz that morning. read more

Eldorado Diner - Part of gourmet chicken wrap. Ok but pretty much all fell out - Diners Near Me - Elmsford, New York

See all

Incredibly old old school. It's 24 7 which is a lot. The food is not cheap like 15 dollars for chicken fingers but it's 1 am and the service is great. Nice people. read more

Decent diner on the Elmsford/Tarrytown border. I was looking for a quick meal after a really long day and was seated right away. Staff members were nice and accommodating. I spotted a single page in the overwhelming menu filled with too many choices highlighting Mexican tacos. That was exactly what I wanted. Taco choices were beef, pork, chicken and blackened fish. I went with the chicken (though I would have preferred to mix and match-that wasn't an option). Chicken was a little dry and a smidge salty but tasty enough. Green sauce was moderately spicy and the corn tortillas were good. The cilantro and onions were very mild-almost oddly tasteless. Rice and beans were Ok. Three tacos were inhaled by yours truly and I had no room for anything else. Again-decent diner. read more

Eldorado Diner - Tacos-chicken w/rice and beans - Diners Near Me - Elmsford, New York

Worst experience ever - a fly in a clam chowder soup resulted in insults by the manager on site (Adolfo if I recall correctly) the evening of 8/21/2026. His attitude was one of 'well, deal with it'. I do not write reviews often but this one is for the ages. I do get it. Mistkes happen. But instead of profusely apologizing, and doing anything possible to remedy the unfortunate event, he proceeded to lob insults and threatened to call the police (Frankly, i was too tired, but was a tempting offer, wonder why he did not) when I told him he should be ashamed to even be charging for anything and apologize profusely instead. His behaviour as a manager was unacceptable. He should not even have charged for the 5 soups we had ' consumed' at that stage (we were gagging after seeing the fly). As usual, the reaction and (lack of) customer service is worse than the unfortunate event. Not sure what this says about management if they have such a site manager in place. I have been to this 'establishment' before. NEVER AGAIN. Additionally, place looks run down (leaks indoors, bad ome the moement we walked in). Terrible experience. Lack of empathy, lack of customer service, disrespect. Bad business management!! read more

Eldorado Diner - Pic of the fly. - Diners Near Me - Elmsford, New York

We went there late last night after an event in the city. They are open 24/7, which is very convenient. The food we ordered - Greek salad and tuna club sandwich- was good. The desserts -lemon cake and rice pudding - were also good. The service was acceptable. No complaints. The place is clean and tidy. If we're ever in the area, we will go back. read more

See all

Well we had take out everything good ,order was perfect and the person taking the order was also good like I said before this is good diner. There's Eldorado 3 which not no where near this diner don't go to that dinerstick ro this one read more

Services great, food over priced. Kids meals are all over 10 for simplest items . Tasteless. read more

This place looks and feels legit, and the service is excellent and friendly, but it is PRICEY and the food ain't what it used to be. We returned an egg dish on sight; it was blanketed in some dreadful-looking cheese; no one would touch it. And we ordered a bag of egg sandwiches for a group road trip that were so disappointing- the rolls were cheap & tasteless, sausage barely cooked. Shouldn't an egg sandwiches be a specialty? read more

Stopped at this place after a long day of driving. My hotel was nearby. Very solid diner food! The house bread was good, salad was nothing special, but the blue cheese dressing was awesome. The chopped steak was really good and a huge portion. I couldn't finish it. Nice job! read more

I have service dog and this restaurant seated us far away in an empty room. My dog has manners and easily sits under our table. He was not a nuisance. Then the service was rude when we asked to be moved into the main dining room. NEVER GO TO THIS RESTAURANT. They said it would make patrons uncomfortable. read more

Been coming to this diner irregularly for 15 years. It's always been decent, but today's Fathers Day visit was far from perfect. Diner wasn't busy, but service was indifferent, my order took nearly a 1/2 hour to come out (a sandwich), and when it finally arrived the fries were lukewarm, and the sandwich was meager, so much so, that I called the manager over to complain. $17.99 for a turkey sandwich, and $1.50 extra for 2 slices of tomato, which IMHO should come with the sandwich gratis. The manager put some more turkey on the sandwich, but honestly it was completely MID, tasted like processed turkey, not fresh. I don't know what's going on in this place, but they've got to do better than this, especially for a $50 bill for a sandwich and a turkey burger. I'd rather eat at Subway. read more

We were so looking forward to diner food! Unfortunately everything was disappointing. The burger was terrible, - old bun not tasty. The roast beef panini was dry, unflavorful, and tough, fries smelled and tasted like old oil. The server was overwhelmed. Left with upset stomachs. read more

Rushed service and misleading information on the Menu. I was asked 3 times within 5 minutes if I was ready to order (I was not due to some confusion about the menu). I ended up ordering from their Breakfast Menu a Texas Avocado Toast (French Toast with Avocado, Mixed Greens, Chopped Tomato, Olive Oil & Sunny Side Egg) and I was given dry Texas toast with eggs over it and a salad with balsamic dressing of the side. This item was in the Breakfast section of the Menu (next to the pancakes). When I went up to discuss the restaurant's vision for the sandwich, they shut me down. I did not ask for a discount or to have the item removed from my bill, I was just looking for clarification of what this item was actually supposed to look/ taste like. I gave the wait staff person a 20% tip regardless. Very discouraging treatment and quality of the food. Do not recommend. read more

Eldorado Diner - Diners Near Me - Elmsford, New York

We love a good diner and we're very happy that Eldorado Diner was within walking distance of The Marriott hotel. We got the turkey club and the Eggs Benedict Florentine. Got the coke slaw with a pickle as the side for the Turkey Club. I got the iced coffee to drink and it was perfect! The food was good. The poached eggs were cooked perfectly. The turkey club was a huge hit with the coleslaw. As others have stated - the potatoes were not hot and not seasoned. Service was great. As soon as we walked in, we knew we were in a diner - the perfect vibe! If we would have still been hungry, we would have tried a dessert. They looked amazing. read more

Eldorado Diner - Eggs Benedict Florentine with potatoes and Turkey Club with a side of Cole slaw. - Diners Near Me - Elmsford, New York

See all

We had early 4 am cravings and were happy this place is open 24 hours. We both had breakfast. My omelet was big and super delicious; fluffy pancakes and great staff at that time. Good coffee and hot chocolate. read more

See all

Old fashion style Dinner. Great food, great prices, great service! A step back into the past.

It's 24 hours which is rare but the screwed most of my order up for basic breakfast sandwiches which was repeated over the phone the sandwiches were ok for a drive I prefer 6 brothers not open 24 hours but better service and food.. this place still has 24 hours which no one has . read more

Pleasant staff. Terrible food. Never again. Meatloaf was not edible. Margaritas was without tequila. read more

Eldorado Diner - Meatloaf? - Diners Near Me - Elmsford, New York

Food was delicious, decaf coffee was just a bit warm and watery... other than the banana being WHOLE on the plate and funny... We were very pleased with our meal. Servers were very attentive! read more

Eldorado Diner - Corned Beef Hash and home fries with 2 fried eggs Banana French Toast with eggs and pork sausage. - Diners Near Me - Elmsford, New York

Came here with a larger group on a Saturday night and very grateful this was 24/7 and across the street from our hotel. Maybe poor planning but we walked along the highway to get here. Service was great - even though we were a polite bunch, managing 12 people is still a large task. The attention to our needs were great and the food was lighting fast. I had a chicken salad sandwich and it was every bit of a deli style sandwich that I wanted and needed. Every person really enjoyed there food and even when we were done, we were not rushed out even though it became a little busier towards the end of the night. Good place with solid service and food. read more

Eldorado Diner - Diners Near Me - Elmsford, New York

The food tasted... umm... different... The corn beef hash was well done like I asked. The potatoes had no flavor so make sure you grab salt pepper and ketchup... if you like that sort of thing ! It is literally the only thing open late at night (after 12AM so if you absolutely positively cannot wait until morning... try it! (PSST... don't say I didn't warn you) read more

This was an Uber order. The meatloaf tasted like it was a meat substitute with a really weird texture. I ate 3 bites hoping it would get better but I had to throw it out after that. read more

We are in town a couple times a year and we always make it a point to eat at a diner, and Eldorado is one of our favorites. This trip we went for breakfast and had a good experience. Our server, I wish I remembered his name, was friendly and very attentive. He was always checking on us and refilling our water. I went with the Corned Beef Hash & Eggs, which comes with Home Fries and also ordered a Bagel. My meal was delicious, exactly what I expected. My BF got an omelette and he said it was great. We look forward to our next visit. read more

Eldorado Diner - Corned Beef Hash and 2 Eggs- yummy! - Diners Near Me - Elmsford, New York

Went for dessert and coffee Cake was stale. Could have chipped your tooth. Service Q a smile though!

I felt conflicted about my rating for this diner. Truly, I think it sits somewhere at a 3.5 for overall experience. First off, the food was actually pretty good and was ready in like 5-10 mins. It was kind of unheard of, how quickly the food was ready on a bustling Saturday morning. I think that impressed me the most. We were on a time restraint and I didn't feel like things took a long time at all. That's a big plus. Plus, I was starving. On another note, the diner was a bit outdated and the service kind of fell flat. I've had better service elsewhere. Our server wasn't bad, just not very personable. He popped in and out. Got to the point. If the customer service were maybe a tad bit better, I think I would have given a better rating. Overall not too bad though. And it's right near the highway so it's super accessible. read more

See all

Excellent and friendly service. Excellent food and portions at a fair price. Excellent prime rib and Greek salad. read more

See all

El Dorado is my go to late night dining near Marriott Westchester. Nothing fancy, very traditional diner, but always reliable. My normal order? French toast, hard to go wrong. read more

The chicken tenders were amazing. The servers were very nice. The food took a bit long though. Very nice would recommend. The chicken soup is also good read more

Classic NY diner with the typically extensive menu and attentive service. I had a falafel salad and fries and my wife had coffee and a pita wrap. We filled up on half of our order and took the other half home. I like too, that the takeout containers are aluminum - no leaking, and easy to reuse or recycle. read more

The diner is vegetarian friendly as well. I ordered a Cheese Quesadilla with Jalepenjos and beans. They called us up to make sure there was no meat in it. Now that's excellent service! read more

I gave it a try and was pleased. Was a bit hesitant with the negative reviews on here. Typical diner fare. Had an avocado, feta, and tomato omelet. Food came out fast and taste and presentation as expected. Server promptly refilled my coffee and was attentive. Interior was clean. They also had quite a good selection of boozy, milkshakes and drinks. I did not order one, but I wanted to. read more

Never going again! cakes had mold. Staff refused to serve us because we complained about the cake. Horrible customer service.

Ordered eggs and corned beef hash, a few potatoes were overdone but the eggs were so much better than how I do them at home, and the staff was so good. Maybe the best at keeping my cup of coffee topped up. Intrigued enough to try coming back for lunch! read more

delicious spaghetti with meatballs & matzoh ball soup! kept my order simple, and great tasting for the price too. Good portion sizes for under $30 after tip read more

Eldorado Diner - Diners Near Me - Elmsford, New York

A jaw-dropping number of folks could give two shiits about this place. But low ratings and all, this El Dorado Diner in Elmsford, has always been in our view- ESPECIALLY for those 4am cravings after dancing House Music. Grilled Cheese is nice. Their Spanakopita is actually nice too. Then again, I can't think of anywhere else in the immediate area that makes a decent one. But their Chocolate Shakes (the last I remember) is what I gravitate to. When we've dined in, all we say to our waiter is, "extra thick and super chocolatey"- and they've delivered. And if we're calling it in, same requests. Haven't been here recently for a chocolate shake- so can't tell you if things have/haven't changed. For basic Greek diner fare, El Dorado is good. read more

See all