Quality control has been going down hill. It's a shame. This order, the pizza was fine, but my wings looked like they had been picked on or something . I've never seen anything like it. Do better, please read more

Donatos Pizza - Wings..... exactly how they came. - Pizza Near Me - Delaware, Ohio

this place is awful. Before Covid it was the best pizza place in Delaware but after Covid, it's the worst pizza place in Delaware. I think Donatos's Pizza owner decided to freeze all their pizzas and send them to the stores and sell them to the customers but the pizza taste terrible. read more

Donatos Pizza - three boxes of pizza on a counter - Pizza Near Me - Delaware, Ohio

I was here for my lunch today at 1:10 PM (time on the register receipt). I ordered a sub, chips, and soda for DINE IN (also on receipt). After paying I had to continue to stand at the counter to get my chips and the woman said "Oh, you want to eat your chips while you wait?" I said yes. At 1:40 I walked and still had not received my sub. THIRTY MINUTES waiting for a sub while on my lunch break was way too long. As I left I gave my receipt to a customer that had walked in and told him he could have a free sub and that I had already waited 1/2 hour and couldn't wait any longer. What is a reasonable time for a sub to be prepared and brought to the table - for me, 30 minutes is more than adequate. I WON"T BE BACK!! read more

I never write reviews and I saw 2.5 and was like how can donatos be that bad. This place is horrible our pizza was cold and hardly done. Our chicken bacon ranch sub had Italian dressing on it.... Do not order from here read more

Pizza was cold, cheese solid and pepperoni not crisp. Obviously been sitting a while. Lettuce in salad had been frozen and tomato's mushy. From order to pickup less than 40 minutes with a 8 minute drive home. DO NOT RECOMMEND! read more

My current choice for delivery pizza, and, at the moment, my preferred national chain pizza. That aside, were I to find myself in Brooklyn, I would probably sample the wares of a local pizza place recommended by locals. Short of that, Donato's fits the bill. read more

I wish I could say something about the food. My wife and I walked in. I viewed one employee with her butt against a table looking at her phone. I viewed 6 or 7 other employees in the back, 3 of which looked me in the eye. After standing there looking for a menu and wondering what to do for what seemed like forever, we walked out. What a shame. read more

Great location with great service. There are two prime Donato's around Columbus that make the best Hot Chicken Pizza; Dublin and this location read more

Ordered on Christmas Eve. Understandably very backed up. The two young men out front stayed calm, professional and polite in spite of the customers in the lobby not being polite. Was very impressed. Good food as well and didn't wait long for a holiday when everything else was closed. read more

Ordered a large pepperoni extra cheese low sauce pizza as a Delaware Ohio location to Donatos I had it delivered to me when I received it was completely burnt! I called and they sent me a new pizza but it was the idea this is the second month in a row that I have had problems with this Donatos I'm giving it a one-star I would give it less than that if I could but the manager didn't make it right so one star to him! read more

Donatos Pizza - Large BURNT Pepperoni extra cheese no sauce - Pizza Near Me - Delaware, Ohio

Don't bother. Food was ordered at 9. 10:20 still no delivery. Called and they had not started making and didn't have my order?

Never disappoints. I HIGHY recommend the hot chicken pizza!! I promise you will not regret it.

This location smells like they use the same Mop in the bathroom as they do in the dining area. The last time we ordered take out, our pizza was burned on the bottom nearly inedible. read more

We visited this Donatos location on the 4th of July. They were very busy. Our group of 14 ordered several pizzas, subs, salads and breadsticks. The food came out as ordered and in less than 10 minutes. The restaurant was clean and the staff was friendly. We couldn't have asked for a better experience. read more

Not sure what's going on here but won't ever bother trying to order from this place again. Judging by some of the reviews I most likely dodged a bullet. I placed an order tonight and never received it. No explanation from Donatos staff just a bunch of stuttering and placed on hold/disconnected from call. What a let down for our family read more

For the first time, I tried the cauliflower crust half veggies every thg no olives and half pepperoni with a lil extra sauce bc I don't like my pizza dry. I found out that it only comes in small, but that's really all I needed... hands down... it's a 5 STAR!!! It was hot and fresh... just the way I like it!! I don't know if it will still taste good if "reheated"..., but I guess I will find out later! The service here at 2181 Mr. Vernon was also very professional... " Shayley" is her name. She was very knowledgeable of the products they offered. The pizza was prepared in a reasonable amount of time... thank goodness bc I was starving...lol! Thanks Donatoes for a grt food experience!! Most def will be back!!!! read more

Donatos Pizza - Half veggies with every thg no olives half pepperoni cheese with a lil extra sauce. - Pizza Near Me - Delaware, Ohio

We had some problems with our delivery several weeks ago and the manager promised to make it right on our next order. When I called and order this weekend, he remembered our situation and made everything right for us. Carried through with his promises and the pizza was great as well as quick and pleasant delivery. Anybody can make a mistake, but a business that makes up for it and cares makes all the difference. read more

I do not recommend ordering via call, because I'm unsure that this location even has a phone. When I called, I ordered a cheese pizza and they said that it would be ready at this location. Yet when I went there, they told me my order did not exist and that I never even ordered it. I felt gaslit. They asked me what I ordered and started making it, which I appreciated. But when I tried to express my confusion on why this whole fiasco happened in the first place, i quickly got turned down. I felt ignored. The pizza was good in the end, but getting it was a long time coming read more

Donatos is not a pizza place I order from often but when I do I always wonder, "Why don't I eat here more often?" I like the thin crispy crust. The sauce has a great flavor. I had the hot chicken pizza and trio of sausage, pepperoni, and mushroom. Without the jalapeños on the hot chicken pizza it wasn't really hot which was perfect. Compared to other pizza places I'd say they're on the more expensive size but we had a coupon. Ordered delivery online and it came just a little later than expected. I appreciated they also sent plates, napkins, parmesan cheese, and red pepper flakes. The delivery driver was also very friendly. I'd definitely order from here again. read more

Donatos Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Delaware, Ohio

One of the best pizzas ever from this store, maybe the best I've had? Yes, the crew knocked it out of the park. Perfect pizza for sure. Thin crust , EZ sauce, mushrooms, onion, sausage & bacon, yum! I could eat this one everyday and never get tired of it, or at least I would like to try. I would submit a picture but their isn't any left. read more

Lived in Delaware for 16 yrs and always had great carryout and delivery. We moved away 2 yrs ago and was driving thru town and decided to stop. Ate inside for the first time and was very disappointed. Son and I each got 6 piece boneless wings (more like very small chicken nuggets) His were BBQ and mine were supposed to be spicy garlic. Mine had no sauce. I requested more and the guy in the kitchen was having attitude about it. The cashier grabbed the sauce and stated that in fact there was no sauce on them. I also orded a small hawaiian pizza. Not very good. It was too brown on the bottom and had burnt edges. We also had 2 drinks. Total of $20. We won't be back. Its not the same. Shawn, this location needs some serious help. The smell in there was also bad... I assume from other comments was coming from the restroom. Ewwwww!! read more

See all

I've had more bad pizza'd from this location lately than any other pizza place ever before. Management, ownership, employees?!?! Who knows but lately the pizza is 100% inedible. It goes straight in the trash after I have a piece or two. I'd rather get little caesars. THAT IS NOT A KNOCK ON THEM NOR IS IT A JOKE. Thank god we have Massey's in town. Oh n not to mention my order is always super late. They only apologize. read more

Funny to not put orders in the system apparently. I won't be back. Tired of these restaurants who don't take carry out seriously. Just standing around on phones. Must be more important than customers. read more

Sent the wrong item. When I called I then never got the other part I was owed. Waited a long time and no one contacted me.

Have a vet fond memory of Donatos as it was the place I took my first date way back in 1993 in Newark. Sadly, this location has become too inconsistent in a town with lots of options that are better. read more

I really don't mind waiting a little bit for call in carry out but 50 minutes for cold pizza is a bit much. The cashier told me for 35 minutes it was coming out of the oven then gave me a few coupons for future use. The manager gave me a credit for future use and a 2 liter which was great but when I got home with it, it was cold (10 minute drive). I'll give them one more try but that will be 3 strikes if not good. read more

Just ordered a chicken caprese salad. NO WHERE in the description does it mention bacon. I drove out of town to eat and opened the bowl to find it covered in pig bits. I for health reasons do not eat red meat. Very disappointed that whoever made this salad decided it need to be rendered virtually inedible. Follow the recipe not your own sims. read more

I've been boycotting this particular Donato's for the last few years. The first bad incident happened when I was in college at OWU. My friend offered to buy pizza to celebrate my birthday. I told the order taker at least three times on the phone that I would pick up the order. After ordering the food over the phone and giving them a coupon code, I went to go get the order. As I pulled in the parking lot they called me to ask me what the address was--he was already out trying to delivery my order to me. The second incident happened before work one break. We stopped in about an hour before I had to be there (I still had to run home and get my uniform before my shift) and they said it would be 15 minutes tops for our order to come off the line. 30 minutes later, I asked where my pizza was (we waited in the shop) and they said that the dough needed to thaw and they were making it now. When I pointed out that they should have said something to me about it when they realized there was a problem, they acted like I was crazy. I was late to work over pizza and poor communication. Management has zero interest in improving the quality or responsibility of their employees. read more

Only came in for a Diet Pepsi. It took like 20 minutes for them to give me it. When they finally came up, I got a regular Pepsi. Disappointed. Very disappointed. I told them clearly I didn't order that, I strictly said diet. They apologized but didn't give me my Diet Pepsi. They said I've already paid and had to take it. I was furious. I walked out with nothing in my hands. I absolutely hate this place. read more

3 hours for delivery.... Just say it's gonna take that long. Papa Johns is always one time with no issues. Not ordering from Domino's again ... Thanks for narrowing down my choices in Delaware! read more

In the last 20 years since I've lived in Delaware, this location has gone from good to bad to worse to awful. We had been ordering from Romeos since they came to town but decided to change it up tonight. Pizza left the building at 7:13 and didn't arrive until 7:47. We live 5 minutes away. Pizza was literally cold! read more

ordered a veggie sub. came burnt. after calling and waiting on the phone for 7 mins after an answer to speak to manager; I called back and got hung up on. Called again and spoke with the mgr and told him what the issue was and stated there was supposed to be extra cheese( my fault I didn't make sure it was on there before processing the order)Manager goes ahead n asked for the burnt sub back... . manager gonna call back and charge me for the extra chz... ok that's fine. He then tells me to wait another 25mins. so 25 mins come around and I give the burnt sub back and I get the new sub how I ordered it with a receipt that states" make sure it's not burnt" there no done right. cheese wasn't even melted. the veggies on it was cold and not to mention the lettuce that comes on it wasn't even there!!!!! never tf again! hope the money was worth it for you cause for me and the wait and quality. It was trash!!!!! read more

Waited an hour and a half for order after getting a confirmation number, called and was told the order was not processed waited another hour plus before the order showed up. Terrible service. Terrible experience. read more

I'm kinda confused...does Donatos advertise "hand -tossed " pizza dough??? I'm just saying fresh dough and hand tossed are 2 different things!!! That being said... the Delaware Donatos has always provided our family with fantastic pizzas and subs!!!As an added note... yes, no one is perfect.. but ANY issues have always been addressed and taken care of immediately!!! They have a very conscientious manager staff that really puts customers first!!! DELAWARE DONATOS...YOU ARE AWESOME!!! read more

When I ordered on the phone for a delivery. They couldn't break my hundred dollar bill apparently and they were very rude when I ordered a pizza and some wings I called them a few times to cancel my order and the delivery guy goes ahead and shows up anyway expecting me to pay for the pizza 2 hours later when I canceled it so I told him and he storms away muttering to himself. That was ridiculous and I'm never ordering from Donatos again facts they're fucking dicks. read more

Very friendly staff. Had to wait a few minutes for an order I called in, but the staff was very nice and apologetic and I really appreciated it. read more

I like Donatos, always have since moving to Ohio in HS. With that being said ... I am repulsed by the Delaware branch! They have delivered the wrong pizza to my home on more than 4 different occasions in a years time. The last time I asked the delivery driver to show me the pizza before I signed the receipt and when he opened it (instead of handing it to me so I could handle my own food that I had already paid for) half of the pizza was stuck to the top of the box. He looked at me and said "What, you don't want it because of that?".. ... Never again will I order from Donatos Delaware!! read more

I've given the Delaware location chance after chance to get it right, but have been let down every time. I love donatos pizza itself, so I'm super disappointed. We've done delivery.. driver was an hour and a half late and the order was wrong, and then we received attitude when we told her we were already on the phone with the store manager. We tried pick up. Always wait at least 20 minutes after pick up time. This time, I waited for 25 minutes & was told our pizza was in the oven coming out now. When I got to the car, I noticed our pizza was COLD. Wings were too. So our food more than likely just sat back there while the employees ran around like chickens with their heads cut off. There's an obvious lack of management and communication within this store and someone needs to step up! read more

Love the pizza, but don't love the prices. Deliveries always forget items; especially any extra sauces ordered.

So we ordered the pizza and thatwas pretty good but we also ordered the Apple pie dessert and it came burnt, we called and then they sent another one that still tasted burnt. It has a horrible, burnt taste and I won't tell anyone to try it. read more