Placed an order for one pizza & said order would be ready in 25 minutes, got there 25 minutes later & was told my order would be ready in 25-30 minutes Very disappointing customer service. read more

Order was 30 minutes later than promised pick up time. (Got our text saying order was ready) Sat outside and watched our car get bumped by uber driver and an old guy. No real damage, but everyone just drove away! Girls running pick up were confused, overwhelmed, busy answering phones, ignoring guests in front of them, and unwilling to figure out our order. Ok, but. Bottom line roasty had cheese, asked for no cheese. Too bad Guess we'll avoid weekends. read more

Cardinal Pizza - Propa pie - Pizza Near Me - Westerville, Ohio

Awesome Columbus style, service, and beer options. The option for both NY and Columbus style is awesome,

We ordered takeout, and this was the worst pizza we've ever had. Somehow, even though I ordered it only 45 min before we ate it, it arrived cold and tasted like it had been sitting out for hours. The Columbus style crust tasted as if there was no yeast in it and stale. I also found an eyelash under the cheese. For the first time in our lives, we threw away pizza. read more

Where My Tribe Feasted and My Heart Was Pizza'd Let me tell you about the time I walked into both entrances of Cardinal Pizza like I was on a food quest from Skyrim. One side says, "Takeout." The other says, "Dine In." I said, "Yes." I dined in like a civilized human, devouring a Pizza My Heart -- which, let's be honest, was not thick... but she had flavor, attitude, and left me with commitment issues. I'm still thinking about her. But I wasn't alone in this tale. My tribe awaited at home, hungry and dramatic. So I did what any pizza warlord would do: I brought home Meatballs and Spaghetti, Garlic Bread with Cheese, a New York-style Pepperoni & Sausage pizza, and for dessert -- a pizza-pie-apple-strudel-type-thing that defied dessert categories and tasted like cinnamon wrapped itself in a hug. Final verdict? I loved my pizza. The tribe devoured their haul like it was a deleted scene from "Vikings." No complaints. No leftovers. Just sauce-stained smiles and a solid reminder that Cardinal Pizza is the two-door gateway to happy bellies. read more

Cardinal Pizza - A 10 inch A Pizza my Heart - - I housed it like I was in a good competition - Pizza Near Me - Westerville, Ohio

Cardinal Pizza is a phenomenal stop by as one walks through Uptown Westerville the pizza slices are well made and fresh and probably the best I have had in a while. Happy people work here and the food comes out fast. It's a chill environment and a great Happy Hour deal with all the libations. Thank you for your welcome atmosphere and kind staff they can draw tigers on their signage really really well. Roar! read more

Always love the pizza I get here. The pepperoni and banana peppers as well as your house salad. Service is always great and your staff members are all super friendly and helpful. I wish you had more seating though. Keep up the amazing service and food - A Westerville favorite! read more

Cardinal is our favorite place in Westerville for pizza! The takeout and delivery options are excellent, but you can also grab a pizza there and enjoy some drinks. It's a great addition to our little uptown area! read more

Service is going down hill. I've seen customers leaving due to the seating process in the dining room or lack there of I suppose. Twice now I've seen customers treated poorly. I sat there for 20 minutes waiting for my order only to find out it had been in the warmer the whole time. Other customers, while I waited, received incorrect orders and a couple folks were sure to check their order because of past mistakes. Not sure what's going on but the pizza deserves better. . If it weren't for Kirby's kindness probably wouldn't be going back. read more

I love this place in uptown Westerville . I always get the NY crust with the tower toppings and it never disappoints. Bartenders are helpful and friendly . It gets crowded so you might have to wait .. but if it's on the weekend grab a Dora cup and walk around . It's a dark old bar which is part of its charm . Highly recommend stopping in . read more

Cardinal Pizza - New York crust tower toppings - Pizza Near Me - Westerville, Ohio

Delicious local spot. Small quant location but worth the wait for their food! Staff is friendly and pizzas are fairly quick.

Ummmm. Delivery took an additional 15 min. Ok. But it's a small thing-no silverware in a delivery order and no sald dressing. Food is expensive-why was putting Togo silverware and sald dressing in an order so hard? Idk. read more

So they're AI agent has a really sexy voice and she got my order completely accurate. But the fact that she tells everyone their order will be ready in 30 minutes when that's not true is kind of a bummer. read more

This is my favorite pizza shop in Columbus. Why? First I love the vibe. Its a small shop and I mean right now its small and truly, I love that. However, its in the process of acquiring/modifying the space next door so it will get bigger. Im sure I will still love bigger as it eill be easier to get seating. Currently it has four tables and a bar that seats 7-8. Everything is made in house except the cauliflower crust, boneless chicken and one other thing, which I dont get, so I forgot what it is. The salads are great. The dressings are made in-house, their ranch is my favorite. The bar is fun to sit at and very comfortable. they hire great people that are always fun to talk to. They have two types of crust: NY Style and Columbus style. Both are good but I prefer the NY style. They have two sauces, spicy and regular. The spicy is amazing. The regular is sweeter than the spicy (imo) My go to here is the NY style Taylors favorite.. omit sausage on half and "a Propa-Pie, add sausage to entire pie. The pepperoni is the type that curls upward and their sausage is good sized. The mushrooms are so fresh. Yum. Thanks Mel (one of the owners) for always making us feel like regulars even tho we come in sporadically and always sending us home happy and full! read more

See all

Very good pizza but lacks consistency. Although they've all tasted good, it's probably been the same pie 20% of the time. Give em a try!

Ended up going here to grab a pizza for the Browns vs Cardinals game. Ironic, isn't it? But, unlike the Cardinals football team, this pizza is not slouch. When we pulled up, I noticed that they were Browns supporters, so I knew I was in for a treat. The cashier was very welcoming and friendly. We ordered the Proper Pie to go, and this pizza featured Old World Pepperoni, which is my favorite! The pizza looked and smelled phenomenal when we got into the car. My wife was not in the mood for pizza, so she ordered one of their meatball subs. When we got home, we dug in. The pizza had a thinner crust, and the flavors were amazing. The pepp was cripsy and bold! The cheese had a nice pull, and the sauce was very complimentary. I drizzled a little ranch on a slice, and it enhanced the pie even more. The crust had a nice crunch to it as well. My wife said that she enjoyed her meatball sub and the slice of pie she tried. I would give this place another go, and I would like to try another one of their specialty pizzas. The Proper Pie Pizza 1-5=4.5! Customer Service 1-5=5! read more

See all

Friends recommended trying this pizza. I can honestly say it's the best in Westerville. I ordered a build your own 14 inch NY style with pepperoni, pineapple, and red onions... yes I put pineapple on 1/2 the pizza. I do appreciate that they use real pineapple. I ordered online and liked that they texted you when it was ready. The girl working was super friendly. Its a small place. I give the pizza a solid 4/5. I would come back and order the pizza. I do wish they offered bigger sizes. As for the small salad... a total scam! 12 pieces of spinach for $5.25... Don't make the same mistake I did. :( read more

Cardinal Pizza - Small Fancy Pants Salad - Pizza Near Me - Westerville, Ohio

See all

My favorite place for pizza in Westerville. Their New York style pizzas are superb in every way. The crust is soft and pliable, original sauce is delicious, and toppings (especially the sausage) are stand out. read more

Cardinal Pizza has always been one of my favorite spots in uptown Westerville, and the food was just as amazing as always during our recent visit. However, I did want to share what happened while my family and I were there. While we were dining, I believe a delivery driver or cook became extremely aggressive--raising his voice, using profanity, and getting into arguments with the female bartender and a young employee. It created an uncomfortable atmosphere for everyone around. Ultimately, he stormed out while still swearing. Despite how stressful and unnecessary the situation was, the female bartender who I believe is named Emma, handled everything with professionalism and kept her head high. She truly did an incredible job managing something that should never have been allowed to escalate in the first place. I'm disappointed that no manager or person in charge stepped in to intervene. That said, we'll absolutely be back. We love Cardinal Pizza, and the staff who were working that night deserve a lot of credit for keeping things together during a situation completely out of their control. read more

We ordered takeout, and both the pizza and the buffalo chicken wrap were very good! The service was quick.

placed an order by phone for delivery. I was told it would be 50 minutes, I was fine with that, planned accordingly. 2 hours later no delivery, called the store and they said that it must have been delivered to the wrong address.... I was asked if i wanted a refund, yes. however the person that I gave my cc number to could charge me but was not authorized to give a refund.... I was told that I would have to call back tomorrow and ask for Emma to get a refund, Ridiculous!! I love to support local, but not this business ever again! read more

This was my first visit here. It's a small place with great NY-style pizza. Our order: Margarita pizza was the best we had in Ohio. I'll be definitely back soon. I highly recommend this establishment. And thank you for the "Nextdoor" app and neighbors recommendation... read more

We finally had the chance to check out Cardinal Pizza shop on Saturday and I'm so glad we did! We had a large NY style cheese pizza, breadsticks, a thin crust banana pepper pizza, and meatballs. Everything was amazing. Although the breadsticks were my absolute favorite! The crust is a little sweet and there is plenty of delicious cheese. The order was prompt and the prices are great for the quality! Everyone there was super friendly and the ambiance is really cool too. Definitely a must if you're in the Westerville area! read more

See all

We love cardinal pizza it is one of our favorite ones in Westerville, but the problem is even when they say your pizza will be ready in 45 minutes. It's over an hour and a half every time tonight we ordered a pizza and waited an hour and a half and called to make sure our pizza was still being made and she said oh your pizza is ready. They said they would send a text when it's ready. We live two minutes away and can be right down to pick up the pizza. She said I'm sorry we're having a problem tonight. We asked her. What problem are you having the fact that you can't get your pizza done when you tell us you're going to or the fact that you didn't text us when it was done and she hung up on us. I know their pizza always takes a little longer and it is great pizza but when you lie about when it's going to be done and you can't bother to text us when it is done, it makes me question whether I want to keep ordering from them. my husband is picking the pizza up now so we haven't tasted it yet, but I am giving them two stars for their customer service and the fact we had to wait so long. read more

The sauce was good but the crust was burnt not lightly charred but seriously burnt on the New York Style crust.

There pizza and staff are amazing. I love there NY style pizza. Currently on the Columbus crusts now.

First impression visit. Good pizza. Ample public parking. Convenient texting when carryout is ready. 5 dine in tables with an expansion in the future. 10 seat bar with limited selection, but yet plenty of desirable choices. Fair prices. Quality ingredients and recipe. Red sauce is semi sweet. Crust is ok without the crackery flaking, and more of a chewy texture. #UpCloseSavor read more

See all

YUM YUM YUM!!!! Found this place one afternoon and ordered carry out. We got a small order of medium wings which came with six (good sized wings) and were really tasty, a medium bbq chicken pizza that we loved and the buffalo chicken dip appetizer which was the best buffalo chicken dip I've had in a long time and came with chips. This will now we our regular spot! Inside was a small but loved the cozy atmosphere and there is lots of public parking around. Employees were so kind. Prices were so reasonable and the prices were more than fair!!! Couldn't recommend more!!!! read more

Great pizza in Westerville, a must order on pizza night. We've ordered many pies and only had one issue which was promptly corrected. Great business for our community. read more

Great pizza! We love the New York crust. Ingredients are good and plentiful. Their new delivery service sucks. Toast is awful.

New favorite pizza place. Stopped in one night on the way to my parents and it's VERY tiny inside so social distancing is kind of hard. There are a couple of hightop tables and a bar. Check out their happy hour specials for food and drinks. We had both the pizza and wings. Wings were decent, came back a second time for the pizza. I love the crust! read more

Cardinal Pizza - Wings - Pizza Near Me - Westerville, Ohio

See all

Great pizza! Had not tried before but will be back! Love the thin crust and the bake was perfect. Had it delivered and was right on time.

Had a gluten free pepperoni pizza delivered with regular sauce and extra pep. I have ceiac and did NOT get sick Good job! It was really good! Delivery driver was so kind and polite. Great experience! read more

With such a large pool of pizza joints in the Cbus area it's not that difficult to find those that fit your pizza profile. Cardinal is tucked away down a one way street in Uptown Westerville. They have a great NY style. The thing that draws us back are the great flavors and how the pizza is just simply the perfect pie! We've only had the pizza the Red Bird Special and the Hawaiian. read more

Cardinal Pizza - Interesting decor - Pizza Near Me - Westerville, Ohio

Walked in, sat down and was soon satisfied. There are two types of pies: NY and Columbus. Columbus has more of a Donatos style thin, square cut crust where the NY is your large, triangle slices you'd expect to find from a traditional pie. But the sauce... that's what makes it! A full, semi-sweet sauce that highlights the pepperoni, dos t distract or hide it. There are plenty of specials they offer on food and your favorite local OH adult beverages. I have a new haunt, and they will soon know me by name- and my order! read more

Cardinal Pizza - Red Bird Special Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Westerville, Ohio

See all

Excellent pizza! Great seasoning! Awesome service! This was my second time visiting Cardinal Pizza although I had tasted it before and I must say that they are consistently delicious. And it's ready when they say it'll be ready. I highly recommend! read more

We love Cardinal Pizza! We get the Columbus crust and it is always so good. The pepperonis are always so crisp. It is a local place with a down home feel. Meatballs are excellent as well. They also make good margaritas. Wait staff is always friendly. read more

The Pizza is very authentic. I love the vibe and service in the restaurant. it's fun to watch sports and overall the best pizza in town. You can't beat it! Also there delivery is unusually fast read more

2 hours for a pizza. Horrible service. Always want to support the local guys but if they can't get an order done not worth coming back to it. If you don't get there before 5pm, don't wanted your time. read more

Amazing. Definitely one of the best pizza shops in the Columbus area. They also have amazing happy hour specials. read more

Cardinal Pizza - Taylor's Favorite. - Pizza Near Me - Westerville, Ohio