I'd followed this bakery on social media for a long time and they posted the cutest cutout cookies…read moreso I stopped in and bought a dozen +1 for me--the dozen being for a meeting I was attending later. They had a great inventory and I was waited on quickly. I got in the car and broke into the bag with the single cookie...big bite and OMG, this is perhaps the worst cookie I have ever tasted. I spit the bite out into the bag and deposited the dozen in my trash as I went in my house to find another treat to take to my meeting. I'll never go back.

Beautiful and delectable treats from this locally owned business! Our go-to for every special…read moreoccasion. The cake and cupcakes for our son's wedding were beautiful and delicious! Some favorites: Pumpkin Pie Cupcakes (okay - ALL the cupcakes!) Cake pops almost too cute to eat Cinnamon rolls like Grandma made The most perfect buttercream frosting.

I want to like this bakery so much, but twice it has fallen very short. Why?…read more I'd read a review about cakes--this must have been a comment about custom cakes because there were no cakes, cupcakes or anything like that there In fact, their total inventory included a few donuts, scones and cookies. I bought a few of each and none tasted particularly fresh (my visits have been in the afternoon) The second time the person at the counter was super friendly, so this is a plus. I do not believe I've met the owner. I'd be hard pressed to go back--just nothing really here to buy.

This place is SO good! There hasn't been one thing I haven't liked…read more FYI, it is hard to find. I went there yesterday and missed it and then went there again this morning and missed it again. Lol. The sign is small and it is in a lot with other businesses. They have coffee and various specialty drinks. They make custom cakes, cupcakes, and then have an assortment of pastries. I believe each week she has a different assortment of pastries available. I ordered a variety of donuts, chocolate pecan scones, a monster cookie, and she had two different kinds of cinnamon rolls. The monster cookie was delicious (there was only one left when I was there unfortunately). The chocolate pecan scones were awesome! There was an iced cinnamon roll and a maple icing cinnamon roll. I LOVED both the cinnamon rolls. They were both very soft and just right. I'm not a huge donut person but the donuts were very good! Stop and try this place!

I was visiting Newark, staying at Cherry Valley Inn with my husband while he was attending his work…read moreconference. I had the mornings and afternoons on my own. I always try to find coffee shops when I'm somewhere different. I googled and found this gem!! Not only great coffee but, the BEST cinnamon roll I have ever had!!! Took part of it back to my husband because I couldn't finish the huge thing! He really is the cinnamon roll guy and loved every bite!!! Didn't look for a different place the next morning, just went straight to Rolls By The Pound!!! Thanks for pleasing an out of towner!!!!

The baked goods and coffee are the best in the area! Reasonably priced and family owned…read more Expedient friendly service every single time. I stop any time I am nearby; and sometimes when I am not. Worth the drive. Items of note aside from the obvious cinnamon rolls - maple long johns - chocolate chip muffins And that iced caramel macchiato are all top notch!

WOW...what a great find. A hole in the wall donut place that is well worth looking for and buying…read morein. My wife and I stopped it and it did not disappoint. Fresh cookies and cakes and unbelievable donuts. The staff was plentiful and very helpful. Too many to choose from. I ended up getting standard glazed donut (they had just sold the last of their blueberry cake to the guy in front of me ) and a maple frosted vanilla cream filled stick. Oh man...the glazed donut was 10 out of 10. I waited to have the second donut until later in the day and man...that maple frosted was amazing! Totally worth stopping. Fantastic place. Fantastic staff. Fantastic donuts. They have been making donuts for a long time and with them being this good...I understand why they have been successful at doing it.

Amazing bakery. Cinnamon rolls are absolutely delicious…read more And try the piña colada cake is absolutely amazing and delicious. Friendly staff.

Y'all! You gotta check this place out even if you're not gluten free, vegan, egg free, or dairy…read morefree! It's that good. And shout out to the young lady running this place, your baking is amazing! My wife and I were referred here by the staff at River Road Coffee House (check out my review over there too!), and I'm doing the same for you. I'm gluten free, and my wife is gluten, dairy, and egg free so we plan as though we are on our own in the small towns we love to visit so much. Boy we're we wrong in Newark, OH! Madelyn's is a treasure. We tried the cinnamon roll bar (stocked at River Road Coffee), two different kinds of muffins, a jalapeño "cheese" focaccia, and homemade oatmeal crème pies. My only complaint was that the focaccia was a little dry. The oatmeal crème pies were so good! I'm sure they're even better when fresh. The shop is warm and inviting, and the staff were very friendly and helpful! Again, another place in central Ohio that we will be back to!

First time visiting but not the first time trying Madelyn's. Parking is conveniently located behind…read morethe bakery. Was sadly empty when we visited on a Saturday with a lot of goodies available. Preordered just in case. Really enjoyed the March special of a mint chocolate Bundt cake. Also their almond muffins were just like the almond croissants. Tasted incredible heated up a little! Great option for those who need to enjoy gluten free and vegan.

Delicious! My husband and I ordered a donut, macaron, coffee, and some almond/raspberry bars…read more Everything was so good and the owner was very sweet! If we are ever in the area again, we will definitely be back.

Great baked goods and the staff are extremely helpful. And no I'm not just saying this because my…read moremom is the owner

Quality food and ingredients, easy and good service, small comfortable inside seating and outdoor…read moreseating.

One of the best breakfast sandwiches around, their classic folded egg, cheese spread with pickled…read moreonion, arugula on a perfectly toasted ciabatta add bacon is the BOMB!! Breakfast potato bowl is Al's delicious with their signature seasoned crispy potato's topped with peppers, cheese and eggs "your way" is packed with flavor. Good coffees, matcha and more... worth a try, we also picked up a loaf of fresh sourdough. They have a baked goods section along with some pre made quick eats including overnight oats, wraps, yogurt parfait and more.. the service is great and they made the little space to my have work great. Fantastic outdoor space with planet of seating.

Definitely a hidden gem as it's not on any main road but I feel like you should make this a…read moredestination if you're from out of the area because it's a real Amish bakery! I feel like there is something for everyone here! My husband thought the Dutch apple pie was out of this world. I thought it was different because it was chopped oats. We were not a huge fan of the chocolate chip cookies, the texture kinda got me, and the chocolate chips were an interesting flavor. My mom thought the pecan tarts were so yummy. I could literally taste how fresh and homemade that dough was, I thought it was very good as well, but probably would try something else instead next time. The cinnamon roll was interesting because I thought it was a lot more Joey than we used to and it had an icing on top. I actually really liked it. I am not someone that likes the super glazed sweet stuff so this was the right amount for me. My husband and I were not huge fans of the Fry pies. They were glazed, which is a personal preference. But the filling was just too much for me, I like more writing than filling, especially in the middle. It was a little overwhelming. I also felt like they were filled with more of the canned stuff rather than fresh bc of the consistency. The fresh sourdough bread was out of this world. I'd definitely recommend getting a bread loaf!!!

This is a hidden gem off the beaten path, if you didn't know it was there you would never know it…read moreis there. It is very authentic and rustic. Get there early!!!!!! We have tried many baked goods in the area and I have to say the glazed donuts were one of the best I have had. So light, pillowy and full of flavor. I was not so much a fan of the chocolate chip cookies, but my family loved the molasses and ginger cookies.

A tiny, classic bakery. Lots of fresh donuts and other pastries at 9am. I asked for a Bavarian…read morecreme one, and they made one right then, with a fresh donut. Shot some pudding in, and I enjoyed it at the counter and in my car. Coffee is from a Keurig. Several flavors and sweeteners available. Super friendly service. Very reasonable prices. They had Danishes and buckeyes and other tempting things, but sadly I was running around for the day and they would not have kept in the car. Small lot right there; be careful pulling in and out.

Great baked goods! Super friendly people working there. The donuts are some of the best I've had…read moreanywhere. I strongly suggest this bakery!