Y'all! You gotta check this place out even if you're not gluten free, vegan, egg free, or dairy free! It's that good. And shout out to the young lady running this place, your baking is amazing!
My wife and I were referred here by the staff at River Road Coffee House (check out my review over there too!), and I'm doing the same for you. I'm gluten free, and my wife is gluten, dairy, and egg free so we plan as though we are on our own in the small towns we love to visit so much. Boy we're we wrong in Newark, OH! Madelyn's is a treasure.
We tried the cinnamon roll bar (stocked at River Road Coffee), two different kinds of muffins, a jalapeño "cheese" focaccia, and homemade oatmeal crème pies. My only complaint was that the focaccia was a little dry. The oatmeal crème pies were so good! I'm sure they're even better when fresh.
The shop is warm and inviting, and the staff were very friendly and helpful! Again, another place in central Ohio that we will be back to! read more