OMG!!! This is a gem located in the middle of this residential area. They have plenty of options…read moreavailable. Their service is good. They helped explain their menu. They are good for sit-down and take out. They also have outdoor seating. It is good for family friendly and business casual. There is a huge parking space right in front of this ice cream place.

| Johnson's Real Ice Cream - New Albany, OH 160 W Main St,…read moreNew Albany, OH 43054 Visited: Aug 3, 2025 | Takeout -- What we ordered: * Jr. Scoop (Butterscotch Toffee) - Sugar Cone - $4.25 * Single Scoop split 1/2 Butter Pecan + 1/2 Butterscotch Toffee - Sugar Cone - $4.75 We asked for cups on the side -- these were two-handed cones, no question. -- Flavor notes: * Butterscotch Toffee: Buttery, smooth, with soft bits of toffee that didn't overtake the bite * Butter Pecan: Heavier on the pecans than the flavor. The base leaned a little plain -- almost watery in taste -- but it was full of nuts and held texture well. Melt-wise, it held up just long enough to enjoy without rushing -- not that artificial stuff that sits like wax, but not soft-serve-level meltdown either. You've got a comfortable few minutes before it starts sliding. -- Total: $10.98 (with tip) -- Quick info: * Wait time: 5-10 min * Parking: 1-hour signs closest to storefront; rest of the lot is unmarked and free * Seating: benches + brick ledge outside * Noise: chill, steady foot traffic * Accessibility: Yes * Allergy info: clearly posted * Dairy-free: Yes (coconut-based and sorbet) -- Would I come back? Absolutely. The ice cream was good, the scoops were serious, and the side cup wasn't extra -- but it was essential.

I love anything that comes from this kitchen! When a plain vanilla cupcake is the best you've ever…read morehad.. THEN you get to taste the key lime and you think you'll swoon? You know you're in heaven. Highly rec for events, gifts, parties, happy hours, you name it :) Andrea will work with whatever creative idea you may have.

This wasn't either of our first weddings which meant we were looking for a different approach than…read moreusually required by first timers. It helped that we knew what we wanted too. Because of the location for our wedding we had chosen, there were certain things we had to take into consideration, among the most important, time. Time for set up, time for the event, and time for clean up. From the very beginning, we had envisioned not going the traditional route of a tiered wedding cake, but that of a tiered cupcake tree with a small topper for the traditional cake cutting. This helped by eliminating the need to spend time in cutting and plating cake for 100 people. My now wife found the Royal Cupcakery using a local site and the fun began. When we met to discuss the wedding and their offerings, they brought us a couple of samples. OMG! We sat and reviewed their website which listed what seemed to be an endless choice of cakes, frostings, and presentations. Luckily, we knew what we wanted ahead of time or making the choices would have taken a really long time. We chose four different cupcakes: devil's food with cinnamon infused chocolate frosting (my fav), carrot cake, traditional white cake, and a key lime cake with lemon frosting tinted green to match our colors. All were dusted with sparkles because, well, because it was a wedding. The stand we chose was solid and fit perfectly with the decor and the style of the room. For $25, they provided a dozen cupcakes so that we could sample our flavor choices. Can you imagine being on a sugar high for a whole week? It was heaven! On the day of the wedding, they arrived right on schedule and set up the tree, cupcakes, and topper cake so that it looked just like all of the pictures. Everyone was professional from day one. Their pricing was better than reasonable and the service was exceptional. And the cupcakes? Even though about 80% of those invited and planned for made it, there were only 12 left over.

Oh Libby Lou's what a place!! This place is every child's dream come true, so many options and so…read moremany sweet treats. They are right by Studio 35 in a small location Service can be slow as they make everything fresh to order like waffles and crepes We enjoyed the S'mores Waffles which was simply delectable and delicious. They have several options for you to mix and match You can choose from various variations of ice creams to toppings to crepes or waffles Place is tiny and quaint so nothing fancy about it. Definitely amazing experience for anyone who loves a good dessert

Fantastic spot to come to. Be careful if you're on a diet! You'll ruin it once you walk in…read more We got the ice cream nachos, and it was amazing. I'm not sure what to get next time because everything looks so good!

Grabbing cookies. They have the best tiny fig cookies. They almost taste like they have a tiny…read morebit of anise in them. Mmmmmmmm. Today they had so many cakes and brownie selections. All looked amazing. As we came in two other couples popped in too. For a tiny little bakery its pretty popular! Come try it! Mmmmmmm. So good!

I was looking forward to visiting this place since I liked the restaurant and thought I'd try their…read moretiramisu. Unfortunately, all the pieces looked small and deflated for the price of about $8. It was a weekday, so maybe that was why their selection was slim. The shop itself is small and the parking lot is cramped. The employees were attentive but looked bored.

My husband and had an errand in Gahanna today and since it was Valentine's Day we decided to look…read moreup a local bakery. We purchased two peanut butter cupcakes, two red velvet and he chose a Boston cream while I chose strawberry shortcake. Just ate the strawberry and Boston and they were absolute perfection. The crumb was light as air and oh so moist. The strawberry filling was perfect and the strawberry buttercream was light and fluffy. All the components came came together for the most perfect amount of sweetness. Hubby agreed when describing the components of his Boston. We don't make it up to Gahanna very often but the next time we do, Smallcakes will be our first stop.

Delicious high priced cupcakes which have high fructose corn syringe chocolate frosting. At these…read moreprices premium ingredients should be standard.

We were visiting from Hawaii and in New Albany for a concert at the McCoy Center when my daughter…read moreand I decided to look for a sweet treat during our two-hour break. A family member recommended *Witt's Frozen Custard*, and I'm so glad we stopped by! The shop is adorable, and the selection was so good that my daughter had a hard time deciding what to get. I'm more of a simple person, so I went with the plain vanilla custard--delicious! My daughter opted for one with gummy worms, which she loved. We enjoyed it so much that I made the drive back from Westerville a second time with my husband before we left Ohio. Can't wait to come back!

Whit's in New Albany is my absolute favorite place to get a sundae. They have so many wonderful…read morechoices there but my go-to is the New Albany Gem!!! I love the vanilla ice cream with caramel and hot fudge drizzle and of course, those wonderful fresh pecan halves. This is an absolutely to-die-for experience. Yuummmmm!!!! Perfecto!!!

Great drinks, great food, and great service! Their egg sandwich is one of my absolute favorites…read more The ambience is a perfect balance of coffee shop and fun vibes. https://www.tiktok.com/t/ZTh2Wr8rL/

Fox in the Snow is a Columbus staple. The pastries and breakfast sandwich are amazing always. I…read moredon't love the coffee here, I believe there are many other coffee shops in the area that have a leg up on Fox in the Snow. But the pastries are hard to beat, and I frequent for that reason! Ambiance & service are also great always.

They really do have "nothing but" the BEST bundt cakes here!…read more Oh, but they actually also sell party supplies too, haha!

I have used nothing Bundt cakes, several times for birthday orders, and I have never been…read moredisappointed. Every single flavor I've ever tried to scrumptious and moist. You really get a lot of cake even though it doesn't look like you do. I can never pass up the bundtlets when people bring them to work. It's actually a problem. I prefer this cake over every cake, ever!