LOVE this place! I'm not a big fan of ice cream in general unless it's actually good quality, and…read morethis stuff was creamy, fresh, and didn't make my stomach hurt the way the lower quality ice creams do. My favorite part about this place is their homemade doggy icecream biscuits made with peanut butter! Both of my dogs loved them!! It's nice that they had outdoor seating so we could enjoy our frozen treats with our dog.

No shade on Mr. Gs and Cone Sweet Cone, but Half Pint Creamery is in a different league…read more The flavor choices are incredible. There had to be 20+. Add in the special toppings on top of the Gelato bases the aesthetics were incredible! We used to live in York and I would go here frequently because they make dog ice cream treats! They are awesome and our German Shepherd loves them! I got a 6 pack yesterday! I got a 2 scoop dish! Fluffernutter and Peanut Butter Egg! Incredible! They even place a waffle cone chip in your dish! No seating indoors at the Gettysburg location, but they had a few tables outside to sit at! The two girls serving up ice cream were phenomenal! Asked us about free samples, gave us recommendations, and we're very good at their jobs! The portions are definitely generous!

Virtually no line compared to other area ice cream shops. All flavors were delicious. Cool variety…read moreof candy inside as well. Walk up window on the side of the building for handicap and pet owner customers. Seating areas on the side of the building and front porch. Within the main downtown. Friendly staff. Great find.

Had the pleasure of stopping into this wonderful shop on our trip to Gettysburg. I loved the…read morewelcoming feel inside from the owner who let us know of the different flavors of ice cream he had available that day. I chose chocolate as a pretty basic treat however; it was extremely creamy and delicious! An additional bonus is the front porch is shaded for nice place to sit and enjoy a moment in the historical town. I will be back again on our next trip the battlefield.

Our family stopped in for some delicious ice cream on a hot summer day. The ice cream was great --…read morerich, creamy, and perfect for cooling off -- though the prices seemed a bit inflated, likely due to the location within the historical Gettysburg area. The shop itself was cute, but maybe a bit crowded since they're tight on space. It was fun to watch the workers making peanut brittle right in front of us, and we couldn't help but admire the other tempting goodies on display, from fudge to candied caramel apples. Overall, a sweet stop in the heart of Gettysburg -- just be ready to pay a little extra for the prime location.

We absolutely love Kilwans !…read more It doesn't matter the location. It's always spot on whether you're stopping for ice cream or a sundae or freshly prepared candy. We stopped here in Gettysburg yesterday and purchased the Turtle Sundae which was really good. Service was very friendly and prompt and the inside was basically spotless. The candy section the caramel apples and their selections. Everything was well presented. If you're in the area, we highly recommend stopping in here. Be careful on the parking because Gettysburg has parking meters that you need to be aware of so you don't get a ticket.

Really good creamy ice cream for a reasonable price. The flavor is really good. The girl working…read morethere was very nice and keep multiple samples. We definitely come back here. It's connected to Upper Crust and Borough BBQ. Indoor and outdoor seating available

The ice cream was terrible, it had that freezer burnt taste, the cones were so stale made me…read morequestion how long they sat out. Service was socially awkward, not nice and bubbly like an old ice cream shop should be. The place it self is old looking, (cool looking) rather empty though. NOT the "finest"

2 ice cream places right next to each other? Tourist confusion! Checked into our tour and our guide…read moresaid Sunset! He told us they make their ice cream and the other uses Hershey. So we went into Sunset. Awesome Wednesday deal, buy one waffle cone, get one free. My daughter ordered watermelon and I had the chocolate peanut butter. My Cousin tried like 4 flavors and the girls were really friendly and helpful. The watermelon is not as sweet as others which is great! Huge chunks of the peanut butter and chocolate wasnt as dark so i ejoyed it. Overall nice place.

Stopped in for a little snack. There are numerous flavors to choose from. My wife had Banana and…read moreChocolate Chip. I had the Black Rasberry. Both tasted really good. We ate inside where the place was cool. There were many folks sitting outside enjoying the warm weather and ice cream. We would highly recommend this ice cream shop for a little taste of heaven.

I got the 5-layer gelati, which is a party of flavor and texture: 2 layers of refreshing Italian…read moreice wedge between 3 layers of velvety smooth vanilla custard. It's impossible to go wrong with any flavor combo. They also offer other treat options, such as sundae, milkshake, and many more.

Rita's!!! I love it. This location is run by a nice guy and it opened this year on March 1. Still…read morekind of cold but I of course had to get some. I love trying all the varieties of ice. I would come here first over other similar options.

We had the BLT and Happy Ending sundae on the senior menu. Delicious, affordable, and such a fun…read moreand cheerful atmosphere. Great server, and great clientele

After two exhausting tours we decided on an early dinner and spotted the Friendly's sign. Since…read moreit's been years since we have been in one, we decided to take a chance. With ice cream for dessert, how bad could it be? Since we weren't overly hungry, we ordered a club sandwich and grilled cheese from the senior menu that included a free small sundae. Everything was great and we left quite satisfied.

Been there a few times now. Had breakfast, and dinner. Took my son who is a bug eater. He was well…read moresatisfied. They also can do some modification because I was eating a Keto diet plan. I was happy. Waiting staff was friendly and fast. Had no problems.

So we stayed at the hotel over the weekend. Great hotel!! The restaurant not so good we got the…read morefish and chips. The fries were perfect, fish tasted like trash. Very expensive food. Save yourself the disappointment and head into town for a meal. We paid $101 for 2 fish and chip meals and a couple drinks... went to Appalachian brewing and spent the same amount and got 3 appetizers, 2 delicious meals, 3 bar drinks and a dessert for $101.