Virtually no line compared to other area ice cream shops. All flavors were delicious. Cool variety of candy inside as well. Walk up window on the side of the building for handicap and pet owner customers. [[HIGHLIGHT]]Seating areas on the side of the building and front porch.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] Within the main downtown. Friendly staff. Great find. read more

See all

Had the pleasure of stopping into this wonderful shop on our trip to Gettysburg. I loved the welcoming feel inside from the owner who let us know of the different flavors of ice cream he had available that day. I chose chocolate as a pretty basic treat however; it was extremely creamy and delicious! [[HIGHLIGHT]]An additional bonus is the front porch is shaded for nice place to sit and enjoy a moment in the historical town.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] I will be back again on our next trip the battlefield. read more

Cone Sweet Cone was a special little spot. Loved all of their dairy free options and the Cherry Coke sherbet really hit the spot! read more

Cone Sweet Cone - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Gettysburg, Pennsylvania

Best ice cream hands down! The owner makes his own ice cream. The raspberry was incredible! We also tried the salted caramel, mint chip, almond joy, and coconut. Every flavor was outstanding. [[HIGHLIGHT]]The enjoyment was enhanced by the great music and sitting on the porch while we ate our desserts.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] We enjoyed it so much, we brought our friends back for dessert two days later! read more

Absolutely amazing! Family oriented business where they're all nice and the ice cream is home made. [[HIGHLIGHT]]Nice amount of sitting outside and you can walk in the shop, unlike other ice cream shops[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] read more

See all

The ice cream was pretty decent, the service was nice, and it was cool that they had a little things to buy. I wish that they had more options, or I wish that the ice cream tasted more homemade. Next time I really wanna try other places, but this is a really good place to just stop in and grab ice cream. read more

This wasn't our favorite ice cream place in Gettysburg but it was still very good. A little pricy but good ice cream with a number of interesting flavors. The shop is cute with souvenirs and old-fashioned candy, which was fun. They don't do shakes, which is a bummer, but they do have a number of dairy-free options for the lactose intolerant. Pleasant servers. read more

We really loved this ice cream shop! The staff were so sweet and friendly to my kids. [[HIGHLIGHT]]There's some seating inside but we enjoyed ours out in the front porch.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] All the flavors we got were delicious! We have a child with a cashew and pistachio allergy and they were able to tell us that he was safe to eat anything which was so helpful! We absolutely recommend this shop! read more

There are so many I've cream spots in town. It was hard to choose. The locals recommended this spot. The ice cream was so delicious! It was nice to support a local business! You can tell the LOVE is in the craft of their homemade small batch ice cream! [[HIGHLIGHT]]It's such a cute little shop![[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] read more

Loved the ice cream!! Almost better than the ice cream was the service. Friendly and kind and helpful people took and order and brought out the cones to the pick up window on the side of the building. We didn't have to go inside at all. The ice cream maker even came to check on our "salted caramel connoisseur " daughter to see how she liked it. She loves it of course and they gave her a sticker. Right on the main drag in downtown Gettysburg it's a great place to stop. read more

Stopped in here during a food tour. Plenty of homemade flavors. The price was reasonable and the serving size was nice. We'll definitely be back! read more

See all

They have candy cigarettes here (now candy sticks)!!!! If you remember them, they're not exactly easy to find. I love the decor. They have a porch you can sit in that reminded me of the glider we had at my house when I was really little. I got the chocolate ice cream (which is homemade) and was definitely pleased with the chocolatey goodness. If you're in downtown Gettysburg, I highly recommend you stop in here especially if you're a nostalgia freak. read more

We went to the popular neighboring ice cream co one day and this one - Cone Sweet Cone IS where it's at!!!!! High recommend this place - one of the best damn ice cream I've ever had! read more

Cone Sweet Cone - a woman holding a child - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Gettysburg, Pennsylvania

Excellent flavors of homemade ice cream, peaches from a local orchard being cooked down in the back for some peach ice cream, and really tasty vegan ice cream flavors (made from almond milk). It's also in a really great walking neighborhood of historic Gettysburg. read more

Cone Sweet Cone - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Gettysburg, Pennsylvania

Super cute little house that's like a hidden treasure. Ice cream was delicious and the server was so sweet and personal! Definitely recommend to skip the line at the place across the street!! read more

Don't freeze your cone off going to Mr G's across the street. This place has a good selection of flavors and is indoors. pumpkin cheesecake was on point. Not too much pumpkin flavor and just enough spice. read more

The ice cream was very creamy and smooth; the salted caramel had a wonderful flavor. The only parking is street parking that fills up quickly. read more

Cone Sweet Cone - Salted caramel - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Gettysburg, Pennsylvania

See all

Saw the line at Mr. G's and made the decision to come here. We didn't know anything about either place, but I'm really glad we came here. The father and son duo working the store were incredibly nice and got our ice cream cups and cones to us quickly. They even had Vegan ice cream selections! We ate our ice cream on the porch and convinced another large group walking by to give this place a shot. They did and they were glad they listened to us. Make sure to stop in here and check it out. They even have a walk up window! read more

The ice cream was amazing. They had great vegan ice cream that I really enjoyed. The owner was very friendly. It was a very cute place.

Wonderful homemade ice cream and very friendly owners! The best ice cream in Gettysburg!

Still amazing, no line! I had mint cookie gelato, the cookie was thin mints! So good.

GO TRY THEIR DELISH ICE CREAM AND GELATO!! Was in town visiting the Gettysburg sites, and decided to grab some ice cream after dinner. I looked up ice cream places on yelp, and made note of a few of them. This place had a note saying no line, compared to Mr. G's or whatever the place is. As I was driving, I noticed a huge line out the door of that place, and decided to continue on 1/2-1 block to try this place, were there was a much smaller line. Based off the page on Yelp,I thought that it was more of soft serve place, but I the photos are deceiving; It is homemade ice cream and gelato. My initial instinct as usual is to try and true and trusted flavor, but one of the owners convinced me to try a flavor outside of my normal selection, Black Walnut Gelato. IT WAS AMAZING! It was so good. I am so glad that he mentioned it, and that I took the leap of faith. The family that runs the place is really really nice, and I am glad that I was able to end my day with such a delicious sweet treat. Took my ice cream, and ate it on the front porch. Glad that I decided that I didn't want to wait in line like everyone else and gave this place a try. read more

Fantastic ice cream, fantastic costumer service, we left Mr. Gs because the line was so long and not moving and we're very impressed! 10/10 recommend coming here for ice cream and some old school shopping in their gift shop! read more

Not sure why more people aren't coming here but I'm glad it wasn't crowded. I had caramel latte ice cream in a waffle cone, and my partner had s'mores ice cream in a regular cone. Both were really good but the s'mores was actually my favorite. Cute antique shop with gifts and art works. Porch to hang out on. Perfect! read more

Very very good . Their two scoops are big. The icecream was amazing. Definitely would come back

Ice cream texture was not good or smooth. Flavors were also bland and did not have that satisfying feel that homemade ice cream generally has. read more

This place is somewhat hidden. They have many flavors and I am sure one will find something of their choosing. This is a nice stop and the front porch is a nice spot to enjoy one's ice cream. read more

We thoroughly enjoyed this shop! The ice cream was delicious. This is definitely a place to check out. They have an impressive variety of flavors and the owner makes all of the ice cream himself. read more

Good ice scream. I've had their chocolate peanut butter cup, as well as their strawberry cheesecake. Their selection may not be as big as other shops, but it's a thoughtful mix of flavors. They also have several gelatos available. My sister had their tiramisu gelato, and really liked it. Service was a bit rushed, even though there was only a couple people behind us. And indoor seating is limited, so anticipate sitting outside. Overall I would recommend checking it out. read more

Cute place with a really nice small business feel. Pretty good prices too, I got a small vanilla custard for $3 and for a small it was a pretty big portion. Nice place to stop when you're passing through town on Baltimore St read more

Spent 15 dollars on ice cream water and soda and asked for small cup of ice for my dog. They charged me a dollar for a cup of ice. Really?

We had the s'mores ice cream & pistachio gelato - both were amazing and the place is inexpensive - you'd be crazy to stand in that line across the street! read more

Can definitely say that this is the best ice cream that we've had in a very long time! Tried the peanut butter swirl gelato, chocolate peanut butter and the cake batter. All were delicious! Highly recommend this ice cream shop. read more

Barbara and Steve are so precious, and their store is a sweet gem! They serve Italian ice, cream ice and gelato in wonderful flavors. We had orange cream ice which was like sunshine and billowy clouds and a perfect combination of ice and cream -- but better than ice cream. We also had Italian ice blue raspberry, root beer cream ice, mocha toffee gelato and malted chocolate chip. Yum! Don't delay and treat yourself! read more

Support a true Mom and Pop space and enjoy amazing ice cream at Cone Sweet Cone. Excellent selection of ice creams, gelato, and truly flavorful vegan ice cream. Enjoy the front porch and watch the world go by! read more

Delicious Ice cream and gelato! Very impressive selection of homemade ice cream. Every flavor we tried was amazing (particularly the coconut cream pie, peanut butter chocolate, and mocha chip). Owner was very friendly and knowledgeable about ice cream. Highly recommend for a treat!! read more

Great homemade ice cream. The selection isn't huge, but the flavor and quality is excellent. The prices are low for the portion sizes. They could easily charge more for the quality of the ice cream. I highly recommend trying the cream ice. The cherry chocolate chip was amazing. Great place for dessert. read more

Ice cream is wonderful! A delicious after dinner treat. They do have a $10 minimum for credit though, so come prepared or hungry. read more

Stopped in here for the first time yesterday and I am happy to say my friend & I were pleasantly surprised! When we first stepped in the whole shop smelled fantastic, and both of the owners thanked us for coming! Talk about amazing service!! I got the vegan Mocha Chip flavor and let me tell you, any type of store bought ice cream is no match for this stuff. I'm usually not a chocolate lover but my scoop was so delicious, it may have just converted me! After getting your ice cream sitting on the porch outside is wonderful and allows you to enjoy your scoop to the fullest. This place is well worth forgoing your normal ice cream spot to check out! read more

Tried the Italian lemon ice and wasn't impressed. People seemed to like the ice cream.