I've got a couple of 'not perfect' pizzas from here. One arrived very COLD, another had sparse ingredient even though I paid extra and asked for 3x Mushroom To their credit, I called to inform them at least they offered to make me another one(I declined the offer. I just want them to work to improve the consistency) On the UPSIDE. When it arrives HOT and made as I ordered it...This is REALLY good NY style PIZZA. They need to add a very fine TIRAMISU and Carrot Cake to the menu. read more

Driver who drove to Boulder Valley Family Practice today 01/23/20 at 12:35pm hit my car with his door fairly hard when getting out the car. No apology and the nerve to make eye contact twice on the way back out with no consideration and respect to say something. read more

Amazing. Super welcoming even at late night meals. Gluten free crust is I haven't had pizza this good in years. Everything always falls short. read more

I eat at cosmos about once a week, and when I eat there, it's good every time. Unfortunately, the past couple of times that I have ordered delivery I've been pretty disappointed. The first time the pizza took more than two hours and was pretty marginal quality, the second time the person who answered the phone was extremely rude and the pizza was also marginal quality again. Definitely not worth the 20 dollars to get delivery. read more

A true Boulder staple! Always fantastic eats (ever tried their garden salad? It's great. The staff are polite, fast, and I've never had an order be incorrect. Much more than just your average pizza joint. read more

Pizza was mediocre however we went in with about 7 people and within seconds the employee was rude and disrespectful quote on quote, "Hurry the fuck up and order". Not helpful to any of our needs and when giving us the wrong slice the man said "just choose a slice man". Never experienced such disrespect from a place. Really disappointed read more

So good! Definitely a good choice for delivery on a cold/lazy night. Wish they had wings or something though. It's always good to have options. read more

Absolutely horrible service. Pizza is passable enough to keep doors open (that and the forced consumer base across the street at the dorms). Don't go here, unless you're drunk out of your mind. read more

Delivery was so delayed and I don't appreciate my food coming 25-30min late past the original time

This is one of our favorite places to stop in when we are in Boulder! One slice counts as a meal and the kids love getting a piece bigger than their face! (They'll even cute the pizza special for your little ones if you ask) The spicy ranch adds the perfect final touch to whatever toppings you choose!! read more

Late night pizza after Rockies game hit the spot. I've lived in NY and NYC for 45 years and glad to find a local Boulder place open late and with solid food. Customer service very good as well. read more

Pizza by the slice or by the pie. Quick, cheap, and easy. Thin crust. HUGE slices. Pretty delicious NY-style pizza.

First bite of my 16 inch cheese pizza from cosmos... 4 Why? It's was cold... It tasted like rubber 1 out of 5 people said they would eat there again Cosmos really? Can't we be a little bit more original with the name read more

Cosmo's Pizza - The only guy that actually enjoyed the pizza (we're no longer friends) - Pizza Near Me - Boulder, Colorado

I'm very frustrated because i I asked the cosmos lady to put the meat on the pizza in the shape of 19 for my friends birthday, and they failed to do that. Thank you. read more

Cosmo gives new meaning to the phrase, LOUSY PIZZA. My $25 all meat pizza is not as good as a Walmart $9 grocery pizza, Little meat and very little sauce. Zero cheese, Pitiful. I bought some Prego sauce to put on the balance of the remains of this junk-ola pizza. I have visited twice, my first and LAST time. Go anywhere else. It will be better. Unfortunate I could not give it ZERO stars. Second day later, I put on 1/2 bottle of Prego sauce from the grocery. Crust now tough and they did not even provide plastic anti-crush device. Good reviews are BOGUS for this place. Makes Mountain Mike's fit for a king, in comparison. Even fake cheese, is better than NO CHEESE. I cannot get over how the good reviews contradict my visit. Negative star, minus 1, is more accurate. JUST SIMPLY AWFUL!!! read more

Cosmos Pizza has been and will forever be.. MY JAM. I ordered 10 XL pizza's with 6 jars of spicy ranch to show up at my wedding reception at midnight. I placed my order weeks in advance and have to say I was a little worried "my party trick" might not work. However, I learned a very valuable lesson -- COSMOS ALWAYS COMES THROUGH! They showed up at midnight on the dot and I could have an entire album named -- Cosmo smiles -- because everyone had the biggest smile and couldn't have been more pumped for the midnight snack. Thank you to Cosmos for always showing up and being delicious Also, I introduced my Dutch friends to your Ranch - They LOVED IT! read more

Cosmo's Pizza: excellent. The chefs salad was fresh but lacking in some meats. We ordered delivery on a Holiday weekend Saturday night and it took a while: maybe it was an hour and a half but that was to be expected. We really were not disappoint and the the delivery guy was pleasantly friendly. We had spent quite a bit of time even finding a pizza place that was open and delivered so, when we happen upon Cosmo's, our expectations were not high. We definitely would order pizza from Cosmo's again; and again, and again. See you there! read more

Cosmo's Pizza - Not much left for breakfast! - Pizza Near Me - Boulder, Colorado

Site asks you to download the Cosmo's App for a discount. I did, but the coupons were limited to only pizzas with one topping. I tried to order anyway through the app. It didn't work and told me to call. I called several times letting it ring and ring. No one answered. Tried the App again. Still didn't work. Called again. Still no answer. Poor service. I couldn't even order. read more

Won't be going back here! Exceedingly rude staff and manager Cody is rude and unpleasant. Go for pizza elsewhere!

This location will not be getting my business again, and it certainly should not get yours either. The blatant health code violations on display made me throw my food out after purchasing it. There were about five employees behind the counter, each performing various roles. There were zero gloves in use, which is fine, as long as people are very careful about proper hand washing, basic sanitary habits, and not doing things like taking money and preparing food in the same act. Apparently Cosmos employees are not the careful type. At least four of the employees were eating while preparing the meals and dough. Hands were going into mouths to shove in gummy worms, and employees were chewing over the buckets that they were stirring. At one point I thought a gummy worm was going to drop into the food. One employee was checking her phone and then returning directly to the line, while two employees were using a dubious technique of holding paper towels over their mouths to protect them from flour (I'm guessing). It's convenient having a paper towel over your mouth when you have the sniffles, as this allows you to cough liberally into your hand and towel without interrupting your work flow. One girl in particular was taking advantage of this, much to my dismay. After witnessing this orgy of health violations, I threw my pizza in the trash. I eat pizza at a minimum 15 days a month. Throwing out pizza goes against everything I believe in - I would eat pizza off the floor of Dominos before eating a slice that came across that counter. If there was a manager on duty, he or she should be fired, and all employees should be required to attend Servsafe classes. This is how illness spreads. The responsibility falls directly on management, since literally every employee on shift was in open violation of some health code. You could not pay me to eat here. read more

I visited Cosmo's Pizza and the cashier charged me a price higher than that posted on the menu for a slice of pizza. The cashier looked at another employee who overheard this exchange and they smiled at each other. I did not immediately realize what was going on, but the customer behind me ordered the exact same slice and was charged the correct amount. I asked the cashier to explain the discrepancy between the price I paid and the price the second customer paid (which was equal to the menu price), and he looked at me as if I were speaking to him in a foreign language. I dumbed it down and said something to the effect of "Hey bro. You charged me extra. What's up?" Without apologizing or explaining himself, he refunded the extra money that he fraudulently charged. On top of that, the pizza is very mediocre. I shouldn't have been surprised, given the appearance of the restaurant and the fact that the employees almost exclusively had long hair that was not tied up... I won't be returning. read more

Pizza is pretty good but never get delivery. I live 1.5 miles away and usually they get lost on the way and call for directions. Guaranteed it will take over an hour to show up as well. Save yourself the headache and maybe pick up. read more

My son and i went to cosmos because he heard what a great place this is. The slices came and there were cockroach droppings on the pizza . I know this because I buy old homes and have seen this a lot. I let them know but they did not care. They actually ignored me. DO NOT SUPPPORT THIS SHIT HOLE !!!! read more

Ordered a pizza at 6:35pm & was promised delivery in 60 minutes. It didn't arrive for 1 hour & 15 minutes & then I wasn't even offered a discount for the 3 cold pizzas that were delivered. I couldn't even tell that they pizzas had been sliced as they were fused back together. I do NOT recommend this place & feel ripped off. If they can't deliver in the time they allot, then change your promise or lower the price. There are options that would have delivered in time. read more

I try to have a good time here, but the only person working hard seems to be the manager! Trash overflowing and the slice usually burned or raw... If you order multiple slices they come out randomly and cooked to differet textures, no way they are keeping track of what is what. Also they just set them up on the dirty counter and drunk kids will take your slice after they just ordered 3 seconds ago... The worst experience I have had here was with this girl having her nasty gut hanging out and she was so rude... Manager guy in the black hat- you are always working hard and trying to get these kids to stop f-ing off I can tell im sorry ... read more

The pizza is decent, but they have a bunch of stoner butthole bros answering the phone. Completely rude, get orders wrong on a consistent basis, and have no basic communication skills. Plenty of other good pizza in Boulder, so I'm happy to take my business elsewhere. I'd take a DiGiorno pizza any day of the week over this joint. At least the microwave doesn't mouth off and screw up the pizza! read more

First off, the pizza is great! The best part is it ALWAYS is great, which is more than the other pizza spots around town can say. The main reason why I felt compelled to write this review is because of the customer service. I am a dumb stoner who had the music too loud and didn't hear the door or the phone. They showed up nice and early! They repeatedly called me and sent me a text explaining that they showed up but nobody answered. I then called back and the delivery driver said he would head right back. He was back really fast with my za and was really nice. Overall, you guys rock and I appreciate your good pizza and great service! Zack. read more

Always a solid choice, make sure to get the spicy ranch. Makes the pizza so much better. The actual store isn't as well kept and definitely could be cleaner and nicer. read more

Awful crust, sauce, and toppings. Save yourself the trip and microwave a frozen pizza.

4 star pizza for sure, I order about once or twice a week because I hate cooking and pizza is a main food group. Will not be ordering from here anymore. FIRE the chick you mistakenly hired to answer your phones. Today marks the third time I have called and spoken to the same impatient, rude, generally unfriendly person and got off the phone without ordering. Don't get me wrong, I work 3 jobs where I answer phones, make reservations, similar shit. I get people have a bad day, but this chick doesn't seem to have a good one. There's no reason for her to talk to customer's that way or be permitted to work in a customer service job when I'm sure there's someone without a personality disorder looking for a job. It's too bad because otherwise the service is really good and when I've gone in the people that work here seem really nice in general. read more

Good place to go to for late night munchies, especially for the college students living in Will Vill across the way

This place used to put out a decent pie, but no longer. Just stopped in today and was served some of the worst couple of slices I've had in a while. Dough was undercooked and sauce was pasty and old tasting. It's too bad because Colorado is lacking good pizza. No luck here. read more

cosmos pizza is great and the staff are very friendly! i love that they are open until midnight for college students and always have slices cooked fast read more

The best pizza slices ever. And super huge pizzas. They still have the "back in the day" prices. But high quality ingredients. And they allow dogs to eat in. They gave my dog free pepperonis. Their slices are like 2 in 1. Great pizza and staff. read more

Saying I'm obsess with cosmos pizzas is an understatement. The Calzones are sooooo delicious, I crave them every day. Also they are open late, making them also my favorite midnight snack. read more

Honestly the worst pizza I have ever had and I have been forced by friends to try it many times, it is like they literally do not season anything. Cheese is sparse and low quality, sauce is completely flavorless and barely there, and the crust is dry and hard. Nothing about this pizza makes me ever craze Cosmos. read more

my boyfriend called to place a delivery order a couple weeks ago and the employee who answered the phone said "are you my dad?" and kept acting like my boyfriend was his dad and then hung up. it was pretty weird but we called back and successfully placed our order with another employee. the pizza's always good at least! read more

Cosmos 'used to' make great NY style pizza. These days, their pizza can best be described as couple notches above your average grocery store brand frozen pizza that your bring home and throw in the oven.. read more

Cosmo's is my go-to in Boulder for a quick lunch when I'm riding around on my motorcycle. I can get a big ass slice of pizza and some spicy ranch for under 4 bones and I know I'm going to leave satisfied and without a major dent in my wallet. read more

I used to really like Cosmos pizza, especially because I always consumed it at 1AM after a night of drinking. And it's pretty delicious at 1AM. On a sober night of ordering calzones, however, it is not so much. The calzones had waaaay too much ricotta in them, and no sauce. Each calzone also took up a medium sized pizza box -- so I'm pretty sure they just folded a sauceless pizza in half and stuffed it with cheese. Never ordering those again, but the pizza is still alright. Plus there is spicy ranch. Never underestimate spicy ranch. read more