Overhyped and overrated.
My first impression walking in on a hot July evening was it was warm inside. Uncomfortably warm like the AC couldn't keep up. There was an odd smell. Not necessary offensive but, not what you would expect given that there is an open grill. You would think you would smell delicious food cooking.
We were seated quickly and the table was nicely prepared. Our waiter was quick to greet us and attentive but didn't take our drink order until he came back to take our food order. They did give us water served at room temperature. I guess that is okay if that is your thing but I prefer my water to be ice cold.
Our waiter explained that their food was family style and that each portion was plenty for two. It was broken down into 4 categories, starters, proteins, starches and vegetables. He recommended we pick one item from each group and it would be plenty for us.
My wife is not a fan of anything that comes from the ocean and the starter and protein choices were very limited. For a starter we settled for their "garden gurus shoots, snuck farm cress, heirloom tomatoes, watermelon, ricotta salata" for $15. First thing I noticed was this $15 salad had about $1.00 worth of food in it. It was spread out on a platter but if I were to put it into a standard salad bowl for one, I doubt it would have filled it up. My wife didn't care for the taste of it. I really didn't either but it wasn't terrible and I was very hungry, so I ate it along with the tough and chewy dinner rolls.
We ordered the "succotash, edamame, local corn, asparagus, chive" for our vegetable. Again, my wife didn't care for it, but as far as the food goes, I thought it was good. Again the portion was small. A bit larger than I would have liked for one, but certainly not enough for two.
The "communal mashed potatoes" were tasty but nothing special. This past week, my wife had served some "Idahoan Roasted Garlic" instant mashed potatoes she bought at the grocery store for a dollar that were just as good, if not better, and you got twice as much. Again the portion wasn't as large as it should have been. I mean, really how much do instant mashed potatoes cost. For $8 you should at least be able to fill up on the potatoes.
Our protein was the biggest disappointment. The "niman ranch prime flat iron steak, roasted shishito peppers, avocado puree" had very little flavor. I am usually very disappointed in restaurant steaks and this was no exception. It was a very nice cut of meat that was poorly prepared. It was a 10 to 12 oz. cut of meat--not nearly enough for two. It was not seasoned at all. the avocado puree also didn't seem to have any seasonings in it and had very little flavor.
The steak had been pan seared but not, in my opinion properly cooked. I like my steaks medium rare which means the internal temperature should be 135 degrees. Fine steak houses will sear a steak and then put it in the oven until the internal temp. is right. I do the same with my steaks at home in the reverse order, using a smoker at low heat to cook the steak to a proper temperature and then sear it at a very high temperature. This results in a evenly cooked steak with the perfect internal temperature and nice seared outside taste.
The steak we were served as not 135 degrees in the middle. It was cooked rare. The outside was blackened, which normally gives a nice flavor, but you have to season a steak to get that nice flavor. Even the best cuts of meat need at least a little salt and pepper on the outside before you cook them. The result was a flavorless cut of meat that was a bit chewy.
Our waiter was attentive but twice mixed up our drinks, giving my wife my diet pepsi and me her Dr. Pepper. Rather than ask, "how is everything?" he would say, "delicious, isn't it?" forcing us to disagree with him if we chose to complain. Their was no salt and pepper at the table and my wife got "the look" from the waiter when we she asked for some.
We left $80 poorer, still hungry but wise enough to know we weren't coming back. read more