Comella's is a go-to for us in Winchester, Their slices are huge (the equivalent of 2 slices) and they take under 5 minutes to heat in their ovens. Whether we order online or call in pizza orders already of time, Comella's is quick and always has our food ready to go and on time. The guys working there are very friendly and helpful, too. There are plenty of tables to sit at if you'd like to eat there, or it's easy to take your food to go as well. read more

Finally a great veal Parm! As well as many other menu items. It smelled awesome as soon as I walked in. Been back a few more times. Still great! read more

Service is good took a little while but that's fine. Food was great best pizza in town I my opinion. But I went after school got out and it was a half day so kids were hungry and they came here but still great. 5 stars read more

Comella's - Coke - Italian Near Me - Winchester, Massachusetts

I had to place a large order for a corporate event. Bobby was responsive, reasonable and the order was just perfect. Everything was fresh and delicious. I can't thank you enough for your help in making this event a success. read more

See all

TL;DR: Pasta's OK, but pizza? That's a hard NO for me, Simon (especially the GLUTEN-FREE GOUGE). Sunday night. Dags? Closed (Rats. I mean, er, *darn*!) A brief bicker, then the kiddos shout "pizza!" Closest? Comella's. Open? Yesss! We've visited now and again for pasta. It's OK (I mean, it's *pasta* man!). Pizza should be fine, right? WRONG!!! Read on to be in on the little JOKE: Daughter B rode shotgun. After some dithering, she orders up a Chicken Parmesan sub for herself and decides on BBQ Chickie pizza for the siblin's. Then, as a spur-of-the-moment s'prise for a gluten-free Momma, adds in a gluten-free cheese pizza. Now, we all know that cheese is the pizza industry's loss leader: Cheap, Big, Good! Comella's seemed no exception: 16" Cheese Pizza for $10.99. Good to go! Order came pretty quick. 40+ bucks seemed a bit pricey, but my math ain't what it useta be; maybe I'd miscalc'ed. B grabs 2x pizzas + Chix Parm and remarks, "feels kinda light." Meh, I'm sure it's fine. Back at the homestead, yummy smells. Open the boxes. BBQ Chicken pizza and... BWAA-HAHAhahahahaha! Baby pizza! Booby-prize pizza! We didn't expect *Joe's* Pizza, but we didn't expect *JOKE* pizza either! See pics. Yessir, in place of a BIG, CHEAP, GOOD cheese pizza  was a teeny-tiny de-glutenized cheese midget. Ha ha, very funny. Maybe they gave us the personal-sized pizza by mistake? Check receipt. Holy SMOKES! Not only was gluten-free pizza not BIG, it was not CHEAP. Did I mention that a 16" cheese pizza is $10.99 (as of 01/23/2022)? Well, guess what: The teensy-weensy (10"!) gluten-free version? **$13.99** Yup, 30% HIGHER price gets you 60% LESS pizza! (Ask your 10th grader to do the math; remember, pie are squared, er..., ℼr²).   Now, was it technically OUR fault? Sure: Daughter makes decision on the fly and -- violà! -- a super-expensive, tiny-tiny pizza. Even says so on the menu (if you were to read it, that is). But still, I mean, *seriously*? Sure, we got a LAUGH out of it, but Comella's? Comella's ain't gettin' another DIME out of us... EVER. For anything. Ix-nay on the asta-pay. Buh-bye. Hey, we're like that. Oh, as for the rest: Dinner WAS light! Again, check the pics. Boxes? Super-Size-Me sized. Pizza? Not so much. (Pro tip: Smaller boxes would at least give the *illusion* of "abbondanza!") To be fair, chick'n pahm was tasty, but it was still relatively small (Darn, you D'agostino's! Darn you to heck!). In a similar vein, the BBQ Chicken on the BBQ Chicken pizza was tasty, but the crust? Well... certainly not the worst (*cough* *cough* Gloria's *cough*), but, hmm... Picture "thick/thin" crust, i.e., hard and crunchy like thin crust but thick like Domino's (but not chewy). Kinda tough on the mouth. At least the offspring didn't complain. Oh, the gluten-free "pizza"? Mixed reviews. Crisp thin crust? Check! Tasty cheese? Check! Tomato sauce? "Ketchup-y" (Wa'h-wa'h-waaaah), or so says the Momma, and what she says, goes. Certainly NOT worth the price (18¢/in² vs. 5.5¢ for regular cheese pizza, i.e., more than 3 TIMES THE PRICE!). So, word to the wise: Don't ass/u/me that all Italian eateries offer the same value and value options. Stick with core competencies (e.g., don't buy PIZZA at your PASTA joint). Embrace my ill fortune so's that the joke ain't on *you*. Two stars for this episode. Pasta's OK (three stars), so, stick with that. read more

Comella's - Seriously, is this a JOKE? Teeny-tiny midget pizza! $13.99 bay-bee! 18¢ per square inch (regular cheese pizza = 5.5¢ per square inch). - Italian Near Me - Winchester, Massachusetts

See all

Quality of the pizza here has really gone downhill. You can tell that the cook just threw the toppings on without much thought. And it's almost like the pizza is not fully cooked. Let the photo speak for itself: read more

Comella's - Bad pizza - Italian Near Me - Winchester, Massachusetts

First, the easy online ordering and quick pick up impressed me. I ordered two messes (ma and nephew) and garlic bread & easily feeds 4! Delicious sauce and love the mix of ziti, spaghetti and linguine. My hub wished there was more eggplant in the nephew mess. But overall totally satisfied our craving for family pasta night. Will only order Messes from now on! read more

Clearly dysfunctional staff! Chef wouldn't talk to the person taking the order. A Guy waited over an hour for his food that never came and finally left. I was told it would take 20 minutes and i's been 40 and still no sign of my order. The girl at the resister is overwhelmed and hyperventilating and there is no one else to help her figure this out. read more

I placed an order online for curbside pickup, and when I got there and called there was no answer. I called 5 more times and no one picked up the phone..... Finally I found a spot to park ( if you know the area you know parking is very difficult) and the girl at the front told me they don't have curbside. Why is it an option online then? And it even says curbside on the receipt attached to my food. So that, combined with the inability to reach someone by phone, means I will not return. Which is a shame, because I enjoy the food. read more

Who the heck makes chicken Ziti and broccoli Alfredo with Mozzarella!!!?????? It's disgusting, I open the container and piles of mozzarella sit atop my pasta. I am so disappointed because I was so hungry, hadn't eaten all day. Wish yelp allowed to give negative stars!!!! read more

Wanted a good salad. Didn't check the reviews and just ordered for DoorDash. First time ordering a Cobb Salad and my add one made it taste amazing! Will definitely be ordering from them again! read more

Comella's - Cobb Salad with Breaded Chicken, Calamari, Feta, Roasted Red Peppers and Oil and Vinegar Dressing - Italian Near Me - Winchester, Massachusetts

Good service, great food, nice music. Definitely best fast food in Winchester, waiter very personable

More then Pleased! Quick catering for dinner parties! Christmas Eve I had last minute family over for an 8 person dinner party. Spinellis was no longer taking orders and in a desperate search for good Italian I came across Comellas, a Christmas miracle! Ordered a full pan of chicken broccoli ziti and sausage eggplant mess 1 hour before guests arrived Christmas Eve and although I was skeptical of my last minute decision the food was delivered piping hot and on time-delicious, AMAZING! The chicken broccoli and zitis even had mozzarella on top ( so delicious, everyone loved it!) Did not even miss spinellis! Thank you Comellas! Ps I'm Italian American and can appreciate your efficient, well priced, large portion, home cooked Italian American food. Forgetaboutit!! You guys get five stars in my book! read more

The food here is delicious, but aside from that it's the people there that make the real difference! The manager of this place is a class act and really cares about each and every customer that comes in. 5 STARS ALL AROUND!!! read more

Wanted pasta and was tired of all the usual places. Saw Comella's on Door Dash and I was intrigued by their menu. Specifically the Messes. Got a Ziti with Mess, Chicken Parm and Ziti, Caesar Salad and some other salad(I forget what kind). Everything was incredible! Large portions! And packaged well. I'm about to make another order now. read more

so I work in Winchester and this is like 1 of 3 places available for lunch. it must be under new management because the service/ menu are different. I used to be able to stop in and get a slice. side note I'm a vegetarian. the new standard has the "chef" making slices with 4 different pizzas. I got the margarita and spit it out because it had BACON on it because the slice next t it has bacon on it. if u have allergies/ dietary restrictions do not go here read more

Should be 0. Had to change my sons diaper on the dining room floor. O infant changing station in either bathroom, and the mens room had urine all around it. Nice to get stars at, even though I preferred not doing it there regardless. General lack of care from employees when asked. Food is 3 stars, but I wouldn't/couldn't go knowing my son would be changed in the middle of the eating area. read more

Good spot for a fast family dinner with little guys. Parm sub was great and pizza was pretty good. Not a huge fan of the machine pressed dough but it was satisfyingly crunchy to bite into. We would go back again... read more

They messed up my order and threw a bunch of raw garlic on top there was no Alfredo sauce they put the wrong pasta

Can I give no stars? Don't order the wings (seemed like they came from the freezer and I'm not sure what the dressing was) or the pizza (sauce was, I think, an unseasoned tomato paste - any other pizza place is a better option). And I was starving - I probably would have given 5 stars to cardboard. Good luck! read more

Fast, friendly, and good food. Perfect for a reasonable family meal. The pizza is thin crust and on the crispy side. They have plenty of options for picky eaters. My daughters love the place. We go about once a week, and have not been disappointed. read more

The service here is always very good, the staff is friendly and helpful. Their sandwiches are great, I always get the chicken parm on the chabata, very good! Nice to be able to get a beer with my sandwich too! Not a big fan of the pizza though, crust looks like it was pre-made and possibly frozen. Good sandwiches though! read more