Amazing food! The milk bread is phenomenal, the scallops, steak, risotto and of course the drinks are unique and delicious. Ambiance is great and romantic for a date night. read more

Made a reservation for our anniversary. Came in at our reserved time and was sat immediately. After sitting for 15-20 mins and not a single waitress / waiter came by to assist us. Tables around us sat after us were helped. We left without any service, thanks for disappointing my wife and I on our anniversary. For the so called fine dining when we are looking to drop $200+ on a dinner what a waste of time. 1838 was a way better experience and very professional staff. read more

Gave this place a second chance after being disappointed when they first opened, and were just as (if not more) disappointed the second time around. First, we loved the restaurant that was at this location previously. It was great food, great service, great all around. When it changed, we were hoping we'd find an equally great place. Upon the first visit, some similar items on the menu were now $10 - $20 more expensive, and no longer included the amazing focaccia bread everyone loved so much. ( They actually kept it for a brief time during the transition, but started charging). The food was not as good, and the menu was transitional (we were told). Previously, there were several vegetarian selections which we also enjoyed. This time we went for happy hour, asked to sit outside as it was a beautiful day, and were taken to a dirty table in direct sunlight. All the patio umbrellas which previously existed have been removed, and all the tables were covered in a pretty thick dust. We asked to be moved to a table with some shade and were seated at a similarly dirty table. This one included bird poop! The table was never cleaned, or wiped, and plates and utensils wrapped in a cloth napkin were brought and placed directly on the dusty table. There are a few food and drink items available for happy hour, but for you wine drinkers, there is no happy hour for a glass of wine, only for an entire bottle of wine. ($13 a glass) I ordered the Coconut Shrimp which was quite good. ($8 for 4 shrimp, normally $14) We also ordered Brussels sprouts which came drenched in so much sauce it was soggy, and un-eatable. The $14 squash salad was mushy, and not very good. The $20 Lobster and Halibut Street tacos, (3) had some sort of pickled vegetable which totally dominated the flavor. It made the Lobster a bit pointless and just tasted like a pickle taco. All other items on the menu came with a steeper price point. ($30 - $65 range - with no sides, or up to $125 Ribeye. Sides are all separate. Average $8 ea.) Perhaps, we would have been happier with the preparation and flavor of the steeper priced selections....?? Overall, not a good dining experience. For 2 people, 1 glass of wine, Brussels sprouts, 3 street Tacos, salad, and Shrimp Appetizer, Our total bill came out to $80 with a 20% tip. (Other suggested tip rates were 25% and 30%) I am not concerned about the price IF the food and service are worth it. I'm just trying to give an idea of what to expect. I will say our server was attentive, but that didn't change the food or the dirty tables. We won't be returning a third time. read more

See all

Fabulous food, lovely upscale interior with patio seating as well. The service was perfect. We will definitely be back!! read more

Always a wonderful experience at Cody's. Looking for a place to enjoy a finer meal with a world class wine selection & a cocktail menu that would impress any cocktail enthusiast, this is the eatery for you! read more

We had higher expectations because my husband enjoyed Cody's in San Marcos. The food was just not good enough for the price. If you pay that much and everything on the menu is so expensive you expect it to be amazing. It was just mediocre. We have other restaurants in New Braunfels that are a bit more reasonable with way better food. Very disappointed. Service was fine. Ambiance nothing amazing. read more

We came in for the first time tonight. the food and service were excellent. Randy treated us so well and had great recommendations. Brussls, Ribeye and lobster tacos all amazing. We will be back. read more

Went on a Saturday at 11:30am when it opened. We were greeted and sat a table with a smile. The place is tiny, but very elegant. Our waitress was very nice and attentive. The food was good. Get the Brussel sprouts appetizer. The salads were ok. The chicken wrap, hamburger, and red fish were tasty. If you are a bourbon drinker, they had Stagg, which was tasty. read more

I've been here a few times since they opened about a month ago. Very nice decor and inviting bar atmosphere. You cannot beat the $7 happy hour drinks. When they first opened the had a larger happy hour food menu now it's just 2 items. My favorite thing I've eaten was the Yellowfin Brie. Best $7 aperol sprits I've ever had. Very friendly and knowledgeable bartenders, especially Jericho. read more

Cody's Restaurant - Happy Hour Aperol Sprits - New American Near Me - New Braunfels, Texas

I thought the some of the food was overpriced a wedge salad was very good but not enough lettuce and it wasn't a true wedge. I also felt the filet was pretty high priced for the size. I got the additional shrimp and for my meal, they were small for the price. Everything had a great flavor, just pricey . read more

Owner and staff are very friendly and can explain all the menu items very well. The tuna appetizer is highly recommended as well as the arancinis. Arguably the most mixologists in town work here! It's also a good spot to catch lunchtime sporting events. read more

Fist time here. Started with Gin Paloma which paired nicely with Tuna Tartare. Followed with Wedge Salad. Main course was scallops which were perfect! The pork belly combination is the best I have ever had. Great Caymus selection to compliment the palate! Skipped dessert, ordered another glass of wine :) read more

Cody's Restaurant - Caymus Cab - New American Near Me - New Braunfels, Texas

See all

Food is stellar whether you go to the San Marcos location or New Braunfels. Friendly atmosphere and good drinks.

Our reservation was at 6:30, we ordered before 7 and food did not arrive until after 8:30 and it came out cold. No manager ever came over to speak to us or apologize. The waitress offered a free dessert after, but by that time we did not want to wait another hour for dessert. Will not be returning. read more

The ambiance was fabulous along with the drinks, and food. Great date night place! Waitress was very helpful!

The food, the service and the ambience was excellent. The bartender knew how to make a great cucumber Mojito. I can't wait to go back and enjoy the whole experience once again thank you for being a New Braunfels. lol read more

Service was bad. Didn't even get our drink order right. Food was way too expensive for what you get. I won't go back.

I'm from the DC area and am always looking for some food options in Texas that are comparable to what I have at home. I spend a lot of time here and was so happy when I found Cody's! Finally a place to get fresh food that is more diverse than most of the other foods in the area and offers more fish and vegetable options that appeal to me. Of note, the heirloom tomato salad and grilled asparagus are some of the best! And the staff, notably Cheyenne, go above and beyond! read more

Waited an hour and a half for our food to arrive tonight, then it came out cold! Notified the waitress and another staff member and nothing was done. Paid full price for cold meals we waited 90 mins for. Extremely disappointed. Food was mediocre, seems like something has changed or gone downhill. read more

They need more items on happy hour menu. Service is friendly. Drinks are good. When we are there at 4:00 for happy hour they have 2 items of food on HH menu. What the heck? read more

absolutely love coming here. the bar snd wait staff are amazing and treat you so well. read more

See all

Updated review: it's been 5 months since the opening and there was a drastic improvement in the menu. We had the coconut shrimp, burrata, halibut and the rib eye and everything was perfectly cooked and very flavorful. Cody has definitely stepped up his his game. Our waiter Eric also provided the best service! P.S. We hear he is adding a very cool infused drink menu - so check it out! read more

The menu has great items and I haven't been disappointed by any of my choices. Service is on point. My wife and I are now frequent customers

Wen there last night and the food was better than average, but not as good as the prices would suggest. I used a credit card that I rarely use. Within minutes after leaving the restaurant, I received notifications that my card was being used in Austin and Plugerville. I won't be going back. read more

My new favorite restaurant in town! The Brussels sprouts are to die for and the overall menu options are very interesting! Can't wait to be back to try more. read more

We went around 2:30 or 3:00 and the restaurant was thankfully not busy. Service was good and the food was top notch. We are looking forward to trying the new Cody's in New Braunfels. Definitely recommend. read more

Now that fall weather has kicked in such a lovely spot to dine on the patio.I had one of their seasonal cocktails to start Autumn and it was perfect.The Caesar salad with anchovies ( you either love them or hate them) hit the spot with their duck breast to follow was delicious.Hubs got a Starla and said it was great.Dessert was carrot cheesecake with a bourbon ice cream it was divine. I don't get desert often but this was definitely worth the splurge and I will happily pay for it in the gym the next couple days.Thanks for a lovely fall evening. read more

Food real good. As well as service. Portions small, over priced. For what it is. Hence 3 stars.

My Husband and I enjoyed our first of many dinners at Cody's! The drinks, appetizers, entrees, and dessert were superb!! Our service was also excellent. I recommend you go early or make reservations. Not a lot of table seating inside, smaller bar, and patio seating outside. The Brussel sprouts were AMAZING, the beef Wellington was Fabulous, we both thoroughly enjoyed are drinks, and the carrot cheese cake with pecan ice cream was perfection! When food is this good, the price is worth it! Can't wait to go back and order the same thing and/or trying something new! read more

See all

Cody's is our go-to restaurant for date night. Food is amazing, great atmosphere and drinks! Would recommend Cody's to anyone.

Is it good when you order an item from the menu and then you have to order it again because it never made its way back to you (table of 4)?! I'm glad Cody's has not lost its sense of value for food and drinks. Bartender Nick was amazing , our server was attentive but not overbearing allowing great conversation and Cody came by several times to check on our food and experience. 5 stars and we will be back read more

Great staff, the owner Cody is always there and easily approachable. Really nice guy. Drinks are fantastic but the food is a little underwhelming and a bit pricey. I get that New Braunfels isn't known for fine cuisine but I would have liked to see better quality for the price. I'd still go back, I'd order drinks and I'd eat the appetizers. read more

Food was awful and overpriced. My husband's duck was raw. My halibut was tasteless for $49. Prices are like Myron's without the execution. We won't be going back. read more

Food was excellent. Service was good. But took forever for food to arrive. Kitchen/management did not do their server any favors. He did apologize. Ambiance was fine. Given the price, I would expect the kitchen to get food out in a reasonable amount of time. read more

What a great addition to New Braunfels!! My husband and I ate at Cody's New Braunfels last night. Today, we are talking about the excellent food and service. Our appetizer, the burata, melted in my mouth. My husband's beef wellington was prepared on the rare side of medium, just like he ordered. I loved my tuna. Our server was attentive and made our evening memorable. Our dinner was not inexpensive, but "you get what you pay for" and we did. We usually travel to San Antonio or Austin for "special" dinners. Now, we will not have to go so far! read more

I wish I took a picture of our dinner! It was delicious! We had coconut shrimp appetizer, Beef Wellington, scallops, ribeye and the waygu burger. Everything was top notch!! We'll definitely go back!!! We went for a a holiday dinner with friends. Great atmosphere! Felt very festive! Service was best too! I wish I could remember our waitress's name...tall blonde gal. Super sweet and helpful. read more

We showed up and there weren't reservations. They pulled in a table from outside and found a spot to put a table cloth on. Service was excellent and food/cocktails were great. You get what you pay for and one of the nicer places in town. read more

We ate at Cody's on a Tuesday night on the patio. Food and service were both amazing. Loved my wine and the butternut squash soup! Everything we tried was wonderful. Highly recommend. read more

Casual environment, but excellent food. We had the beef Wellington and tuna Taki again and both were awesome. Highly recommend

Fantastic atmosphere, mediocre food and experiences. After being seated at a high table 2 top with broken dirty chairs we were promptly greeted with sub par fashions. Following came a cold burrata (should be room temperature or warm) with burnt baguette. Watermelon in the burrata appeared to be a nice touch, however executed with failure. We decided to end our experience before tasting main course service. Not the pinnacle experience I expected for my husbands birthday. read more