Cancel

Open app

Search

Claypool Coffee & Ice Cream

4.6 (13 reviews)

Claypool Coffee & Ice Cream Photos

Business Info

CLAYPOOL COFFEE & ICE CREAM ATMOSPHERE

What's the vibe?

You might also consider

More like Claypool Coffee & Ice Cream

Recommended Reviews - Claypool Coffee & Ice Cream

Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
Yelp app icon
Browse more easily on the app
Review Feed Illustration

Reviews With Photos

Stephanie D.

Back again and this time I tried their chocolate peanut butter cup ice cream. Once again, delicious. Really wish it wasn't almost $5 for one scoop cause that's a crazy price but since I only go when I'm actually in Indianapolis I guess I'll just call it a treat that I rarely have. Just sucks that I can get a whole pint for that price and have it for more than five minutes. Oh well.

Helene D.

You know it's good ice cream when there a long line! Ordered a strawberry and Oreo ice cream and it was absolutely amazing! Strawberries were very fresh and didn't taste like the frozen ones we get at the store. The cone was still crunchy and not stale. The service was amazing and the staff was always quick!

Ryan D.

I had a craving for ice cream after dinner, fortunately Claypool Coffee & Ice Cream was open late. There was a big crowd there after 8:00. My husband and I got two scoops in a bowl. Note that the sign telling you the flavor of ice cream does not match where the ice cream is located in the freezer. The ice cream is good. They have some new and different flavors. We ate in an eating area just outside the restaurant in the shopping center. I highly recommend Claypool Coffee & Ice Cream!

Ro W.

I was greeted when I walked in. They offer almond milk. They had plenty of ice cream flavors to choose from. I ordere the snickers drink. It was too much chocolate for my liking. The shop was clean. I'd recommend stopping by if you're in the building.

Peter P.

This is a NEW place in Claypool Court, a level above Panera and Weber Grill. I was surprised to see a new business opening in this space as the adjacent indoor mall (Circle Center) is coming down soon. All that aside, this place is a treat. They serve a proper affogato (ice cream topped with espresso).

See all

3 days ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

5 days ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

1 month ago

Helpful 1
Thanks 0
Love this 2
Oh no 0

2 months ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 1
Oh no 0

4 months ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 1
Oh no 0

6 months ago

Helpful 11
Thanks 2
Love this 7
Oh no 0
Photo of Ro W.
52
704
2402

7 months ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 1
Oh no 0
Photo of Peter P.
257
2381
5744

1 year ago

Helpful 2
Thanks 0
Love this 1
Oh no 1

1 year ago

Helpful 1
Thanks 1
Love this 2
Oh no 0
Photo of Terri C.
159
53
27

2 months ago

Great ice cream! They were very busy to be so hidden in their location. I had Michigan Pot Hole.

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0
Photo of William K.
9
617
1680

6 months ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

6 months ago

Nice but out of the favors I really wanted but not to bad. I didn't like that the server did change his gloves after handling the money.

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 1
Oh no 0

4 months ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

Ask the Community - Claypool Coffee & Ice Cream

You might also consider

Verify this business for free

People searched for Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt 2,222 times last month within 10 miles of this business.

Verify this business

Bovaconti Coffee - Strawberry Lavender Lemonade

Bovaconti Coffee

4.7(356 reviews)
1.4 mi•Fountain Square
•$$

Dear reader,…read more Bovaconti Coffee in Fountain Square remains one of my favourite coffee shops, and we stop there whenever we come to town. It is the sort of place that feels special the moment you walk in. A lot of people rave about the beautiful space, and quite right too. The shop has a gorgeous, old-world feel in a historic Fountain Square building, plenty of seating, and a lovely outdoor area that is very dog friendly. The staff always boast a delightful disposition that makes you want to smile and enjoy the rest of your day as well. As for the coffee, I love the iced Mayan Mocha. It is like a mocha with a kick and extra flavour depth, and it is absolutely delicious. The dark chocolate, honey, cinnamon, and cayenne give it a little warmth and complexity without losing the joy of a proper iced coffee treat. They also have some really high-end pastries to choose from. I love the lemon loaf, and some of the more complex, unique pastries make it feel a bit more elevated than the average coffee stop. Overall, it is clean, beautiful, welcoming, and always worth the return visit.

The staff here is so awesome. Can't believe I haven't reviewed this place yet! It's definitely one…read moreof my favorite spots to stop by when I'm in Fountain Square. There's plenty of natural light, but also several cozier, dark areas perfect for coworking. When the weather's nice, the patio is unbeatable - they offer ample patio seating as well as chairs along the sidewalk. I usually choose something from their seasonal menu, and recently I tried the iced blueberry brown sugar matcha and it was amazing. *Free parking directly outside the building on Woodlawn Ave

Photos
Bovaconti Coffee - Chocolate  crossiant

Chocolate crossiant

Bovaconti Coffee - Inside

Inside

Bovaconti Coffee - Interior

See all

Interior

Good Vibes Cafe Indy - Strawberry Matcha with strawberry popping boba

Good Vibes Cafe Indy

4.7(50 reviews)
0.2 mi•Mile Square, Wholesale District
•$$

SO. GOOD. Good Vibes Cafe in downtown Indy was my next stop on the Indianapolis Coffee Passport…read morejourney, and honestly, with the parking shenanigans, I'm not sure I would've ever made my way here without it. BUT I'm SO glad I did! Usually, I'm going on and on about the coffee, but can we talk about the CROFFLES?! Croissant waffles are apparently my new obsession, and the Avocado Bacon Croffle was SO savory and delicious that I'm still thinking about it. Then there was the French Toast Iced Latte topped with CHEESECAKE COLD FOAM?! The menu was absolutely drool-worthy, with so many yummy concoctions that I already know I need to go back and try more! The service was amazing, too. Shoutout to the girly who stamped my coffee passport because her nails were EVERYTHING! The vibes are cozy, comfy, and fun, making it such a cute spot to hang out and enjoy a treat. Now, let's talk parking... I circled around 3-4 times before finally giving in and paying $10 to park. Not ideal, but honestly? Finding this little gem was WORTH IT. If you're visiting Indianapolis or exploring downtown around Monument Circle, I highly recommend adding Good Vibes Cafe to your list! Trust me, the croffles alone are worth the visit.

A small cafe for quick bites. The cafe is on the top floor with another fastfood restaurant on the…read morelower level. Prices are a little on the higher side. Both the beverage and food was okay! Parking is hard to find.

Photos
Good Vibes Cafe Indy - Mango Matcha with mango popping boba

Mango Matcha with mango popping boba

Good Vibes Cafe Indy - Good Vibes Cafe Indy

Good Vibes Cafe Indy

Good Vibes Cafe Indy - Seating Area at Good Vibes Cafe Indy

See all

Seating Area at Good Vibes Cafe Indy

Tinker Coffee - The Firehouse - Hot 5 spice latte

Tinker Coffee - The Firehouse

4.6(48 reviews)
6.0 mi•Butler-Tarkington
•$$

When I think about coffee in Indy, I think of Tinker Coffee. They have been a staple and have their…read moreown roasting facility. I love that they make their own syrups and always have fun speciality drinks. The quality and consistency is something I really appreciate and helps them stand out. I love that they gave new life to this old historic building. It was so busy, and full of happy customers.

I love Tinker Coffee and this spot is no exception to their overall brand. I love that they have…read moretaken an old building and re-purposed it but also calling it The Firehouse as a nod to its history. It is a bit challenging to find parking but there are a few spots in front. I parked down the street and walked which is always an option. There are a few stairs to get in but also a ramp, and the set up has a nice aisle like space for the line and plenty of tables and chairs. It can be quite loud so keep that in mind if you want a quieter reflection time, and maybe take it to go or sit outside. They have various food items but I absolutely LOVE their peanut butter energy balls! In fact that is why I came to this location as this is where the magic happens. They make them here and send them to other Tinker locations! They are the perfect blend of savory and a tad sweet and go super well with their coffee and/or London Fog tea. Yum! I will freely admit to buying all they had on hand, and now can enjoy them at home. Yay! It is a very busy spot so not the friendliest of staff, but assumed they were already hassled from the morning. It was a great spot to meet a friend and enjoy the patio and some tea/coffee. I would for sure go back and even bring a friend! In fact I've already mentioned it to several people as a potential meet up spot! Definitely something to enjoy!

Photos
Tinker Coffee - The Firehouse - Seating

Seating

Tinker Coffee - The Firehouse - Cappuccino and blueberry muffin

Cappuccino and blueberry muffin

Tinker Coffee - The Firehouse - Counter

See all

Counter

Claypool Coffee & Ice Cream - icecream - Updated October 2026

Loading...
Loading...
Loading...