I like the classics: butter pecan, pistachio... But because of how inexpensive square scoop is I add a second scoop of another kind to expand my pallet. I was shocked at how much I liked Graham Central Station! I can see why it is so popular now. I like that they have fun flavors like Dubai chocolate, although it has been sold out the two times I visited recently. read more

Such yummy flavors! Love when a place has unique flavors. This place is hidden and i wouldn't have known it was there if it wasn't for my maps. It's a small hole in the wall and I never saw anyone come in for the 20 min I was there. I got the lemon poppy seed muffin which tasted exactly like that and the famed graham central station. 2 very diff flavors but good. It's a big scoop. You can try the flavors as well. 1 flavor not listed was the caramel mocha brownie, this looked really good as well. I didn't want to confuse myself further so I opted for the 2 flavors I tasted and liked. read more

See all

As my son and husband sat in the car I ran in here to get everyone some delicious ice cream. Service was good and it was a cute place the 5 minutes I was in there. Won't be disappointed! read more

We hit this place multiple times during our recent stay in the city and we're pleased each time. Service was terrific and there was a great variety of flavors. We didn't have anything bad at any time. Well worth a visit if you were in the Fountain Square area. read more

Square Scoop - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

Cute ice cream shop/candy store. We were greeted when we walked in. They just ran out of my flavor before we came so I had to improvise. read more

Square Scoop - Cookies and cream - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

What a fun find. We were driving through the city and wanted a sweet treat. I loved how everything was easy to see to help choose what we wanted. There were some delicious flavors and I loved that there was space to sit inside and eat. Can't wait to come back our next time through the city. read more

Square Scoop - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

With an under the radar exterior, you could easily pass up a hidden gem in the FSQ neighborhood. They have tons of ice cream flavors there which can make it impossible to choose. Luckily, they have an ice cream flight sampler for $6, which comes with 4 kid sized scoops of ice cream - what a deal! This is honestly enough ice cream for two people, too. My flavors were Lemoreo, Elvis has left the building, Brookie dough, and graham central station. read more

See all

Was looking for an afternoon pick me up and Square Scoop delivered! Our party of 10 crammed ourselves in front of the two cases of ice cream flavors and the two employees didn't bat an eye. They were friendly and handled our orders quickly and correctly. They allow you to sample flavors if you can't decide and believe me it's a tough choice! I went with the flight of four for only $6.49 and opted to add 3 peanut butter malt balls on top for $1 once I noticed them by the register. The ice cream flavors are fun and inventive, but they also carry some of the usual suspects too. Great pieces, great product, and just enough tables available for all of us to sit down and enjoy our treats. They have a few small tables and one large one towards the back. The parking is on the street. read more

See all

it comes to fountain Square all the time, but I didn't realize there was an ice cream shop until a few days ago. I finally went and tried the Lemoreo and blackberry or raspberry cheesecake. both flavors were so good and I was able to sample them before making a decision both workers there were really nice super patient and I'll definitely be back. They also had candy and a few other items around the store so there's limited seating but overall, the whole vibe in there is pretty cool and chill. read more

See all

This quaint little ice cream shop is located in Fountain Square. There is a free parking lot available off to the side of the shop and there is limited street parking within walking distance. Parking is very scare no matter what way you choose to park, so you should take the first spot that you see. The shop has a decent sized dining area, consiting of tables and chairs, where you can eat your delicious frozen treats. The shop has a wide variety of delicious flavors including Cookie Dough, Butter Pecan, mint chocolate, LemonOreo, Key Lime Pie, Chewy Chocolate, Strawberry, Pistachio, Peanut Butter Pie, Graham Cracker, Espresso Chip, Honey Lavender, and Black Raspberry Cheesecake. A good amount of those flavors are gluten free. They usual have a dairy free option or two as well. Like most ice cream shops, they offer free samples of the ice cream. The woman working the counter was very friendly and helpful. I may have missed it, but I did not see the buffet of toppings that you would find at other ice cream shops The shop also sells candy and bottled drinks. I ended up getting an ice cream flight, which consists of 4 small scoops (LemonOreo, Mint Chocolate, Key Lime Pie, and Butter Pecan) of ice cream of your choosing. The only thing is that it is served in a clear plastic container that is not insulated. So, it does not travel very well. The ice cream was good though and I enjoyed trying the 4 flavors, because I was My little guy got a scoop of the chocolate chip cookie dough in a waffle cone. And that was after he sampled it and gave me the thumbs up. He said it was good. My ice cream was good. Tasted fresh. This is a nice option for those looking for some frozen treats. read more

See all

This may be one of the single greatest ice cream shops I've ever been to - and I'm not for one hyperbole. The menu online does not do the flavors justice. It's like they took every ice cream flavor you've ever liked - and then made it BETTER by adding more to it. Not only were the flavors to die for, but the texture of the ice cream and waffle cones was absolute perfection. Again, like I said, maybe the single greatest ice cream shop I've ever been to - and I am not for hyperbole. If you are anywhere within a 20-minute drive, make it. You're welcome. read more

This place was so good. Enjoyed the evening experience. My family and I enjoyed this after church 10/10 must try again!

We had ice cream here after lunch and stroll through the Fountain District. They have SO many great flavors of ice cream to choose from here. They have the obligatory vanilla and strawberry, but their Sticky Chewy Chocolate flavor was over the top. I had pumpkin and a scoop of Turkish Coffee and that proved to be a great combo. Other unusual flavors included carrot cake, honey lavender and honey graham central! Cute names for the different flavors. Also, the scoops are huge! This is a must try when in Indianapolis. Yummmmm read more

Square Scoop - Ice cream - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

Excellent ice cream store in a cool part of town. Within walking distance of a number of restaurants and right next to a bus stop. A ton of different options of ice cream to choose from and the couple we tasted were both excellent. Prices weren't too bad but in general ice cream places aren't necessarily cheap. It's a small place so I'm sure their overhead costs are small. they had a couple very friendly people working behind the counter. It's a little crowded in the place with a few small tables And a couple cool, but otherwise cool place. One cool treatment is a bunch of game boards on the wall, it gave it a kind of a fun, playful touch. read more

See all

Easy to walk to, as they're located in the Fountain square area. They have great ice cream flavors and a variety of shakes, malts, float, and sundae options. Their nostalgic candy offerings were also fun to see. There's about eight tables with chairs, which makes for a nice space to enjoy your ice cream away from the summer outdoor heat. The employees are friendly and get through the line pretty fast. read more

Square Scoop - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

Google thought this place was inside a nearby market for some reason, but it has its own entrance. They housed an appealing variety of flavors. While my banana cream pie delivered appealing bits of pie crust, I was unconvinced that my mint chip would be good because the fake green color looked a bit overdone. It delivered on flavor however, with a more herbal note that I would have guessed. Vegan options were available, and I was also intrigued by some of the niche sodas and candies they had on display. Not much here other than sugar, despite all the variety, but if you're going to treat you'd better do it right. read more

Square Scoop - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

I fell in love with their pineapple ice cream, which tasted like my favorite pineapple sherbet from my childhood. I ordered it as a shake several times. Delicious! Vegan shakes are made with oatmilk and they can make it thicker upon request. I was charged 3 different prices each time I went. That was upsetting and confusing and no one could explain why. read more

See all

I got the banana cream pie and it was scrumdiddly. they had a ton of options which was dope. it was right in the middle of everything so it was easy to get to after we ate lunch. bathroom was clean. would eat here again but I don't actually like ice cream i just came here with my friends. will recommend tho place was cool. lowkey cramped. lowkey felt like I was in an ice cream pint bc of it but the music was chill. the friendly cutie with the glasses and brown ponytail helped me. big shout out to her. really only writing this for her read more

Square scoop doesn't stand out from any other ice cream shop other than it's perfectly in fountain square. They do have a lot of ice cream options and are generous with the tastings which is a plus. read more

See all

This was one of the best ice creams I've ever had. I got the chocolate churro and it was spectacular!!! Rich, creamy, decadent, with a lotta churro. The flavors are unique and delicious. This is definitely a must get. read more

See all

Square scoop is really good and they have good prices. $5 and change for two scoops in a dish. That's good pricing for near downtown. They don't have the most flavors, but honestly every flavor looked really good. Some ice cream places have more flavors, but some of the flavors aren't the best. Not here. It's in a nice little build and the staff was friendly and made my ice cream quick. This is a great option for fountain square for ice cream. Good flavors, low prices, nice staff. read more

Square Scoop - Nuts and bolts coffee ice cream. - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

Great location for a sweet treat in Fountain Square! The interior gives lots of retro game aesthetics and is a fun spot to hang out. I love Sundae's ice cream, which is the supplier for the Square Scoop shop. While you enjoy your cone, you have to walk around Fountain Square and take in the murals, shops and all around art scene! read more

Square Scoop - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

See all

One of my new favorite ice cream flavors is Cereal Bowl! The flavor is a spin off on lucky charms (it's a fruity cereal base with rainbow marshmallows mixed in). The ice cream was so yummy and I know others would agree with me because this place was packed! The line was out the door and down the sidewalk. read more

In town for a night, looking for a nice ice cream place. Found this one on Yelp. Fantastic ice cream. I tried the much ballyhooed lemoreo flavor and it was delicious. Like I will forever seek out lemon and oreo together in an ice cream flavor... and I'm worried I will never find it anywhere but Indianapolis.. and I just can't justify a four hour drive for ice cream every day... waaaaa. So good. Highly recommend 5 stars. Also kudos from teens with us: Cookie dough is lit Chocolate was the sigma read more

Square Scoop - Points for the personality on the tip jar - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

We walked into Square Scoop on this Saturday afternoon with 7 kiddos, all under 5 yo. The ice cream attendant was super kind, patient, and efficient. Prices are right, ice cream is great, atmosphere is fun, and service was exceptional! read more

Was amazing! Truly one of the best vegan ice creams I've had in a long time. Big scoops too, and plenty of flavors to choose from. The staff was kind and offered samples Loved the decor of all the board games and just a chill atmosphere. Highly recommend. read more

See all

Omg-this might the best pistachio ice cream I've ever had! The cone was tasty but that ice cream!! Whoa!!! Had little bits of pistachios throughout, the entire thing was YUMMY!! Can't wait to try other flavors. read more

Square Scoop - Pistachio ice cream - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

Best ice cream downtown! I love the lemon Oreo. Great taste (doesn't taste like fake ice cream with a ton of additives like some places). Will be back! read more

Square Scoop - Lemon Oreo - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

How cute is this shop? Board games cover the wall. Love that! From what I read online the room can be rented out for parties. Sign me up! Such a fun party idea. I thought Square Scoop was a locally owned ice cream shop so I was super confused when the glass cases had Sundae's stickers all over it. Turns out Square Scoop does not make ice cream in house but they sell Sundae's ice cream. Sundae's is locally owned and operated! Obviously I wanted to try all the flavors because they looked so.good but went with their two most unique options which I learned were the top sellers - lemoreo and graham central station. Um. I am going to be dreaming about the lemoreo ice cream. Yes, you read that correctly and yes it is lemon meets oreo and it is life changing. I may just have a new favorite flavor of ice cream. It doesn't pack a tart punch but just a nice, refreshing lemon. The graham central station was also a real treat! These are 2 giant scoops for less than $5. I will be making many a trips to Square Scoop this summer. If I bike down from So Bro, that is called balance, right? read more

See all

Such a great ice cream spot! I got the raspberry cheesecake in a waffle cone and it was so so perfect for a super hot day. They had tons of flavors that were both unique, like lemon Oreo, and of course the classics too. There are tables inside so you can sit down to eat. The girls at the counter were super helpful & provided us multiple samples! read more

Square Scoop - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

Easily the best ice cream in Indy. I am in love with the Lemoreo ice cream here, which sounds like a mistake of a flavor at first (lemon + Oreo?!), but it's actually divine. Lemoreo is now my favorite flavor of ice cream. My husband got the peanut butter pie flavor, and he said it was the best. He said that usually, peanut butter ice cream is a bit too much of something (like too much peanut butter, or too much chocolate), but this ice cream got it right and the peanut butter and chocolate was well balanced. My kids got chocolate ice cream and cookies & cream ice cream, and both loved them. The cookies & cream had big chunks of cookies, as it should. Because I visited during the pandemic, I'm adding in my review that both people behind the counter were wearing masks as they were serving. There are a few indoor tables here, but not much seating, so it's probably best to get your ice cream to go. read more

So, I went to Square Scoop ice cream shop Friday night at 8pm April 22nd, and I took my niece along with me since she wanted to try a different ice cream shop. Ice cream shop is in the heart of Fountain Square, local ice cream shop, small, and it smells so good inside. I noticed ice cream shop has a lot of the old school candies I grew up on, Jones pop different flavors, as well as Root beer. I ordered one scoop in a dish of cookies - n- cream & my niece had half and half of honey lavender along with vanilla. We, ate our ice cream inside of the shop. I'll definitely go back to try more delicious items. Oh, the cookies-n cream ice cream had plenty of oreos so delicious read more

See all

Really love visiting here! The staff (I think including the owner) is always so friendly. Ice cream flavors are great, and they have a lot of combinations. It's also fun how they have hard-to-find candy. Very casual environment with a decent amount of seating. read more

Square Scoop - a variety of food items in a store - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

Love Square Scoop! I'm kind of an ice cream snob. If I'm going to get it it better be good. I hadn't stopped in here because I'd been stuck on Sundae's ice cream- driving all the way to Geist to get it (after having it at Livery with my dessert). I was walking by on a hot day and decided to give it a try. To my surprise, I saw "Graham Central Station" on a sign and thought it was a coincidence- then I realized they served Sundae's! Needless to say I've been back many times and have added a new favorite to my list- banana cream pie- wow. It did not disappoint. So Square Scoop serves the best ice cream, has a cute shop and great location in fountain square. Parking can be a challenge but it's worth it. Make sure you check it out! read more

Square Scoop - Next to City Dogs - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

See all

There is a reason this place has 5 stars. Friendly service, reasonable prices, and delicious ice cream. We love getting a tasty dessert after eating dinner in the area. It's the perfect location and a perfect treat! read more

See all

If you blink you might miss Square Scoop, but this place is one ice cream lovers won't want to miss. They serve more traditional ice cream and you can get sundaes and milkshakes. I opted for a single scoop sundae today with black raspberry cheesecake flavor as the base and raspberry syrup, whipped cream and a cherry for my toppings. The prices are pretty reasonable and they have a gluten feee list handy. They also have treats from the cheesecake lady that melt in your mouth! The ambiance is fun for all occasions with board games on hand to extend your visit. This was my third time visiting and they are always happy to give samples to help you decide. The hardest part is choosing a flavor, but I promised you won't be disappointed. Street parking and free parking lots are located within a short walk. While I tend to prefer custards, I'm an ice cream lover in general and have always been pleased with my experience. read more

Square Scoop - Sundae - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

Definitely a must-try ice cream shop in Indy! Square Scoop has so many unique and delicious flavors (I got the Key Lime Pie ice cream and it was to die for!). The Indy cultural trail is right across the street, so it's a perfect spot to grab some ice cream and go for a stroll around Fountain Square when the weather's nice. Usually Square Scoop is pretty crowded in the evenings, and there isn't too much seating inside, so make sure to plan accordingly. read more

Square Scoop - Key Lime Pie Ice Cream - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

We finally got around to visiting Square Scoop for a late night treat in the car. We'd heard great things and were craving something sweet. A few bullets ok this locally owned ice cream shop: -ice cream is homemade by Sundae's - also Indiana based business -pup cup graciously provided for our pup while she waited outside the door with my husband -very friendly and helpful staff- the gentleman who was working made the quick experience all the more fun -interesting flavors like peanut butter and jelly -delicious peanut butter milkshake- not overly thick like some you'll find -conveniently located across the street from the Cultural Trail and a block from the heart of Fountain Square read more

Theres a lot wrong with this place 1. Ice cream is melted in the display cases (should of left immediately) 2. Not kid friendly(stroller barley fit and felt like I was an inconvenience to others) and no high chairs 3.when I brought my concerns to the worker who helped me she went to charge me for an other scoop said "we don't do refunds" 4. I believe I was over charged $4+ I asked for a 2scoops and was given two different cups and was charged a total of $9+ I left extremely upset and disappointed it was my first time there and will be the last Will be posting this experience on Google,fb local foodies and anywhere else I can find them I don't want anyone to go in with high hopes read more

Really enjoy this place overall. They have some different flavors of ice cream that you don't see at other places without being too over too the top. Last night I have a single with Graham Cracker something and it was great... tasted with a Golden Graham Cereal with that honey sweetness and a ton of flavor... they also let you do half and half... so i went with tried and true cookie dough for the other half of my single. Kids got cereal something, lime sorbet (half and half) and a cookie dough... 3 single scoops for less than $12? pretty good deal! Usually not more than 1 or 2 people working, so if you're in a hurry it may not be a quick trip on a busy/hot/summer day... But its worth it!! read more