I want to give a huge shoutout to Mandy's Ice Cream! They truly went above and beyond to accommodate a last-minute cake order. I was supposed to be in the Bahamas this week, but unfortunately, due to my health, I had to cancel. At the last minute, I decided I still wanted to make my son's 21st birthday special with an ice cream cake. After seeing so many recommendations in Town Chatter, I reached out to Mandy's Ice Cream. She responded quickly, explained the ordering process, and made everything so easy. There were so many amazing flavors to choose from! We finally decided on banana cream pie ice cream, strawberry cheesecake ice cream, vanilla cake, and whipped icing--and it was absolutely divine! My son said it was his favorite birthday cake he's ever had, and we all agreed it was absolutely delicious. Not only was the cake amazing, but the presentation and packaging were beautiful. Mandy even included a birthday card for my son, which was such a thoughtful and personal touch. It's little gestures like that that show how much she genuinely cares about her customers and her small business. Thank you, Mandy, for helping make my son's birthday so special despite everything that has happened. You have earned a customer for life, and I will gladly support your business by ordering our family's birthday cakes from you for years to come. I highly recommend Mandy's Ice Cream to anyone looking for an incredible ice cream cake! read more

Mandy's Ice Cream - She wrote what I asked. 21yr Birthday Cake - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Brownsburg, Indiana

See all

When I'm in the area, I love stopping here! This place is so good, and flavors change periodically. One of my favorite flavors is the Coconut Almond Bliss, it's so good it's amazing! They have several different cone options, or you can get your ice cream in a cup. I also love that they offer different sizes, especially the Junior size. It's the perfect portion for me without being too much or make a mess with the cone. The inside is cute and has a nice local flair. There's seating inside, along with a couple of benches outside. It can get pretty busy here at times, so just be prepared for a wait when it's crowded. Restrooms are located inside, which is always a plus. They also offer taste testers, so you can try a flavor before committing. Service is always great, and I usually see teens working when I visit. Prices are fair for the quality and the homemade ice cream. Definitely a spot I'll keep coming back to when I'm in the area! read more

See all

I love Mandy's. Small family business with great service. They even catered our wedding dessert! Great selection of flavors that change some with seasons and availability. It is our new go to spot! Can't go wrong with this one! read more

This is a fun spot in Brownsburg! I loved the variety of flavors and I appreciate that they allow you to sample them. My favorite was the smores ice cream! Fast service and friendly staff! read more

Mandy's Ice Cream - Smores - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Brownsburg, Indiana

This was my first visit. It seems like a family business. There was a small wait as only two people were working. They didn't seem stressed or overwhelmed and both were very patient. They didn't have my flavor ice cream but I was able to make it work by adding toppings. It wasn't bad. There are also benches outside as well to sit. There wasn't a trash outside so you had to go back in to throw away the garbage. read more

Mandy's Ice Cream - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Brownsburg, Indiana

See all

It's ice cream! Can you really go wrong? Amazing customer service and the ice cream is always tasty! Mandy's has a nice variety of flavors. Highly recommend! read more

Ice cream is fine, if you like the chocolate shoppe brand they sell. However, this place is in desperate need of a deep cleaning. The ice cream cases are filthy. I didn't end up getting ice cream at all, you can go and get the chocolate shoppe at other businesses. They do have a variety of options from shakes, floats, malts, and even boba. Ordering is straight ahead when you walk in so I'd recommend ordering there first and then walk around to pick your flavor and meet back at the register. read more

You ever have one of those days where you know you want ice cream, but you have absolutely no idea what kind? This was one of those days. I was an indecisive, hormonal, hot mess, and the worker behind the counter was an absolute gem. We talked through my mood, my general indecisiveness, and my very strong dislike of chocolate (yes, I know, I'm weird). When nothing on display seemed just right, she casually mentioned they had an additional flavor in the back--without the chocolate chunks. After much deliberation (and multiple reassurances that she really didn't mind scooping into the reserves), I finally went for it. Do you believe she had the audacity to apologize to me for taking "a long time" to bring me my ice cream? As if she wasn't already my hero of the day. The ice cream, the conversation, the kindness--everything was exactly what I needed. Some heroes wear capes. Others scoop ice cream. read more

Mandy's Ice Cream - Coffee ice cream - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Brownsburg, Indiana

While my husband and I were out shopping we got a craving for something sweet and decided to find a little spot that was family run. I feel like the larger corporations are taking over and the smaller family businesses need as much help as they can get. We found this little spot in Brownsburg called Mandy's ice cream which we had never tried and it was really really good. I'm not one to try the normal flavors you can buy from kroger because what's the point of that? So I went with the kitty kitty bang bang. It had vanilla, raspberry, chocolate chips, chocolate cookies, and raspberry sauce is believe. It was very good and the raspberry flavor gave it a good punch with each bite. My husband got a sprinkle cone dipped and had a double chocolate type brownie. It was really good. read more

See all

The staff was friendly made me feel welcome on my first visit. I had strawberry ice cream in a waffle cone and it was perfection! There is a freezer of little take-home pints and I got one called Exhausted Parent that was AMAZING. So happy I got out of the line at DQ and stopped in here instead. read more

Always friendly staff and love supporting a local business. Super good ice cream! Been there a few times now and never disappointed!

I've not been to Mandy's before and I'm so happy finally made the visit! We went on a Friday afternoon and that place was filled to the brim with happy customers eating their ice cream! Even though there was a line, the two employees handled it was grace and exceptional customer service! Bravo! Now to the yummy ice cream ! There were so many different ice cream flavors, which was wonderful! We ordered lemon meringue, mint chocolate chip, and kitty kitty (which was a cheesecake-ish flavor). We ordered junior cups (smallest size) and it was still plenty! We ate every single drop. The ice cream was creamy, full of flavor, and overall delicious! read more

See all

I loved, loved, loved this place. It is a neat little hand scooped ice cream shop located just outside of downtown Brownsburg. It is the epitome of a small business and I was glad that I was able to come there, check them out and review them. The owner, Amanda (Mandy) Johnson, was actually working the shop during my visit. She was very welcoming, friendly, up-beat, helpful and personable. She greeted me as soon as I walked in, with a handful of sample sticks. She calls her shop the Burger King of ice cream shops, where you can have it your way. She is definitely all Brownsburg, through and through and is proud of and supports her town. They also operate an ice cream truck, which you will probably see in the parking lot. There is tons of parking available in the lot that it shares with the other businesses in the strip mall that it is located. The shop is very tiddy and if you are wondering what the pictures on the back wall are about, they are part of a school project from two local elementary classes that is funded by The Brownsburg Education Foundation, They serve some signature sundaes, make your own sundaes, ice cream scoops (cone or cup), banana splits and boba teas. They have all your standard toppings to go on your ice cream like sprinkles, caramel, fudge, strawberry, peanuts, marshmallow fluff, pineapple, whipped cream, M&Ms and gummy bears to name a few. Mandy asked me what my taste were and then personally suggested ice cream samples based off my taste. I sampled (they were decent sized samples) a few of their ice creams and I was hooked. This $&%! Just Got Serious was my favorite, but I really liked all of them. The shop is pet friendly and has a decent sized dining area if you want to eat your savory treat right on the spot. After a long deliberation, I decided to go with a Banana Royal (a banana split in a cup). Of course I got it with a scoop of This $&%! Just Got Serious and I got a scoop of Coconut Almond Bliss for my second scoop. It took about 5 minutes for her to prepare and I was getting it to go. Mandy packaged it up very nice to travel. It did make it all the way home. It was very delicious. The ice cream and ingredients were fresh and had a good flavor. I almost ate the spoon. This shop is amazing, the owner is amazing, and the ice cream is amazing. I give this spot one of my highest recommendations. I enjoyed my delicious treat from this family run shop, with deep Brownsburg roots. Trust me, you will not be disappointed. read more

So so nice!!! And the ice cream was so yummy! They told us about every thing there let the kids try why they wanted and all had smiles on their faces as they helped us read more

Excellent Ice Cream & always pleasant folks to deal with! The kids are always very nice!

Great ice cream and fun servers. My favorite is Zoreo (sp?), I also really like their strawberry. My wife likes the chocolate/caramel. My grandkids like their cookie dough. Everything I've tried is very good. They do not scrimp on the flavorings. read more

Ok this place is a core childhood memory for me. Everyone is super nice, the ice cream is amazing and they rotate flavors all the time. It's got fun decorations and they're always advertising local events and artwork. Love it. Would definitely recommend. read more

Nothing says summer like a scoop or three of ice cream. I enjoy trying smaller local shops and was happy when i discovered this shop. It seems to be pretty popular as they were consistently busy but there was minimal wait. The employees were all pretty friendly and very helpful with providing recommendations. I had salted carmel and another salty popular scoop that were both tasty and i will be back to try some of the other flavors. The interior is fairly small but indoor dining is available and there is also a bench in front of the store to dine on while basking in the sunlight. read more

Mandy's Ice Cream - the outside of the store - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Brownsburg, Indiana

See all

Mandy's has the best flavors and amazing service! Love Kitty, Kitty Bang Bang, Superman and Butter Pecan

When I say this is some of the best ice cream I've had, I am not joking. First time being here, and I love to be able to come back! I got a double scoop with cotton candy and raspberry rhapsody. It was delicious! Cotton candy had hints of bubble gum as well which was a delight. Would highly recommend them if you're ever near by and want ice cream. read more

Mandy's Ice Cream - Cotton candy and black raspberry - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Brownsburg, Indiana

Great ice cream with a multitude of flavors. Located in a nice area. Just be patient with the young staff they are doing their best. Enjoy your ice cream. read more

60+ degrees in February? Better get to Mandy's for ice cream! Great local business in Brownsburg. We took a 4 year old and Mandy was so good to him recommending Superman Ice cream and a special spoon. He was thrilled! We also tried the bubble tea which is sweet but good on a warm day. The shop is adorable with lots of artwork by local school kids. Skip the chains and check out Mandy's in BBurg or Pittsboro. You'll be glad you did. read more

Mandy's Ice Cream - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Brownsburg, Indiana

See all

This place is great. They have a variety of flavors and dessert dishes and even have kid cones! They have seating inside and kind staff. They also display local art. read more

Mandy's Ice Cream - A small one scoop ice cream cup. - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Brownsburg, Indiana

The staff overlooked the people who were next in line, tried to humiliate patrons, and threw items at a child. Not worth the ice cream. I like the Owner but she needs to find better staff. read more

Quick post my son loved the vanilla ice cream , loved the atmosphere when we walked in , we were treated amazing when we walked in we were greeted and treated amazing. I have to go again to try all the flavors that they offered also they are known for their amazing ice cream cakes. Defiantly a stop in Brownsburg that you must try . read more

See all

My wife and I love coming here. She always orders a Double scoop of ice cream of munchie Madness flavor (m&ms and peanut butter cups) and kitty kitty bang bang flavor (cherry chocolate) and I order a one scoop bowl of Espresso Oreo flavor. We liked seeing the new addition of art work displayed from the local schools and the Elvis music playing on the radio. I wonder if the art work displayed will ever be available for sale as many of these young artists are very talented. My wife liked one painting a lot the one titled "Be You" with the yellow background and flowers. We will be back. read more

Mandy's Ice Cream - Double scoop - munchie Madness and kitty kitty bang bang (cherry) and a bowl of espresso Oreo - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Brownsburg, Indiana

See all

Amazing as always. I come here all the time to get boba. Great environment and great customer service. I would recommend to everyone!

Ed my and the service. Y'all r very welcoming and generous I'm gonna keep coming here everytime I need a reward

Mandy's is a fantastic find in Brownsburg. The ice cream is fantastic and the sundaes are amazing. If you are in a mood to indulge your sweet tooth, you can't go wrong with Mandy's. I will want you, the pricing is higher than you'll see at Culver's or DQ, but the real ice cream you can get at Mandy's is well over and above the sad soft serve/custard you can get at the fast food joints. The only complaint I have is the lack of the current rotation of flavors available online (Facebook or where ever) and that's really only an issue for me during COVID since I'm getting ice cream for the family and end up with a long back and forth when I get there letting everyone know what flavors are available. read more

See all

My two kiddos & I have made the drive from Carmel to Brownsburg JUST for the ice cream here at Mandy's haha. I'm sure there are other places closed to home but the service & yummy options are worth the trip. My daughter usually wants to try something new, which the younger staff are always very accommodating about (samples are allowed!) and once she's decided, my son always gets his usual chocolate scoops. I can only have non-dairy options, which I will say are sometimes lacking in variety, but as any parent can attest: when the kids are smiling, the day is good. We usually sit outside in the summer time and, if you're lucky, the local fire department might even swing in and say hello. Just an all around great local spot. Thanks Mandy's! read more

I'm in Chicago for the weekend from Dallas and decided to drive the three hours to come see my niece and goddaughters for the day. We came for an after school treat and it did not disappoint! I'm an ice cream connoisseur and this is some of the best! Great service was a bonus! read more

Mandy's is great. I have been there a lot of times and they never have disappointed me. The ice cream is always impressing me. The boba is fantastic. The service is helpful and very nice. The building is great for a small ice cream shop. read more

For ice cream fans who like to try something new, I recommend stopping by Mandy's in the Main Street Shoppes in Brownsburg. Mandy's is a locally owned ice cream shop that has a new name and location just a few shops down from its previous incarnation as Wylie's. After parking in the shared lot, we entered the brightly lit shop. Small tables for guests run along the left side of the shop. The L-shaped order counter has a nice variety of ice cream on display through glass cases. Samples are available to try before purchase which comes in handy since the names don't always give an immediate idea of the taste. Fortunately, the shop has fuller descriptions underneath each title. (Yeah!) We found out the young man working was the son of the owner, who used to work at Wyliepalooza when it was in Brownsburg, then bought the franchise and renamed it Wylie's. When the opportunity opened up for the shop closer to US 136/Main St, she decided to change the name to her own when she moved. My wife and grandson both got small servings of "This $&@! Just Got Serious" ice cream which is a salted caramel with fudge and cashews. Both really liked their selection. There are five sizes of cups available to choose from and I went with the middle size (called Single) for my Raspberry Rhapsody which comes with Moose Tracks chocolate chunks inside. Wow! Excellent flavor. They do have cones available, but I didn't check them out for options. My wife kept commenting at how unique the flavor combinations were compared to other ice cream shops she has been to. She normally just goes to the local DQ near our house, but I agreed the number of unique flavor combos was comparable to most of the larger ice cream shops in Central Indiana. If you are looking for a delicious treat, don't wait until summer to start thinking of ice cream from Mandy's! Review #3738 read more

Mandy's Ice Cream - exterior - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Brownsburg, Indiana

See all

Yum! the stories on the flavor selection quality and friendly service are true! The best part is the easy direct access from the Avon Brownsburg B&O bike trails. Just open the Yelp directions feature on the trail to see the street closest to cut through from the trail and you can hike or ride directly to ice cream (we used the cut through at Airport road). As yummy as the 2 scoops on waffle cone were it wasn't so rich that we couldn't continue our bike ride. read more

Mandy's Ice Cream - More tables n chairs have been added outside since this photo was taken - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Brownsburg, Indiana

"Life's too short for boring flavors". On my very first trip to Mandy's I was blown away by the number of unique and delicious flavors that Mandy's offered. Mandy was there when we arrived and insisted that we try as many flavors as our hearts desired. And we certainly took her up on her offer! From fruity, to chocolatey, to every flavor pallet in between, you'll find a fun and unique treat to enjoy. Perhaps what I loved most about this spot is how warm and welcoming Mandy was and how every customer felt like an old friend. I'll be back soon and will be bringing my family along for the ride next time! read more

Mandy's Ice Cream - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Brownsburg, Indiana

Big selection of ice cream flavors. The waffle cone was fresh which I appreciate. Even though they were pretty busy I was in and out quickly. They also have bubble tea which I will try next time I come. Is you're in the area it's def worth the stop. read more

Mandy's Ice Cream - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Brownsburg, Indiana

See all

Great service. Great ice cream. Little bummed they didn't have any dairy free at the time.

The staff is friendly, offers samples, and gives generous scoops. Flavors change. Great hometown business!

It was an amazing experience, great customer service and awesome ice cream. The best I had in awhile! FYI: The county just lifted the mask wearing/optional. The staff was welcoming and offered samples as they had a nice selection. I enjoyed the Mackinaw Island fudge and my 12 years old thought Zoreo flavor was amazing!!! read more

Mandy's Ice Cream - Mandy's also has a truck, good photo op - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Brownsburg, Indiana

Delicious ice cream. 2/3 of the staff not wearing masks. Table were together. No social distances. No markings on the floor for social distancing. Take customer orders Willy nilly. No masks required signs. No cleaning of the tables. As far as covid precautions, they are getting a big zero. I'm vaccinated so I felt better about ordering a scoop of ice cream. Friday night and a bit busy. Mine was Zanzibar or something like that. Very delicious, very healthy scoop. My husband had salted caramel. It was tasty too. I just wish it was a bit covid aware. read more