4.20.26 I haven't written a review here in a while (?!) but tonight the hubs & I were both craving something sweet & we stopped in after a mediocre dinner elsewhere downtown. I was going to go with my favorite - gooey sticky chocolate - but the chocolate raspberry in the case looked so tempting, and the staff told me that was a more limited edition than my go-to, so it won out! I get the baby cone, which is a perfect amount. SO GOOD! Nice way to end the evening. #yum #ReviewsByRL read more

After many visits there has never been a flavor I did not love. It is extremely hard to make a choice though, so I love getting the flight to have a little of more flavors. Whenever they have Chocolate Amaretto Cheesecake I make sure to get a pint to take home! If you have your heart set on a flavor check their social media as they keep it updated. Plenty of indoor seating and easy parking. read more

Scoop Shack - Ice cream flight - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

We went to this spot after having dinner. This was our first time in but the ladies were really helpful with making some choices. My son enjoyed his shake and I had the flight sorbet/ice cream. My favorite was the Turkish coffee... YUM! It's a must try. We had a 40 min drive back home so it being packed in plastic was a little inconvenient. I went back in to see if they had something like styrofoam to keep the ice cream from melting as opposed to plastic but they didn't have anything. Overall the pricing was decent and next time we will just eat our treats there. It was late so we decided to head home. My son really enjoyed his shake. He gives it a 9 out of 10. Definitely try the Turkish Coffee, I'm still thinking about it. read more

See all

We were in the area and brought up yelp to see ice cream shops near us. We landed at Scoop Shack. When we walked in the lady at the register was talking across the room to a party sitting at a table. There was a young man who just stood behind the counter looking at us. When we said we were ready to order he just looked at us so we went ahead and said our order. We had questions and as we were asking them, they were very vaguely answered. I always like trying new places but the welcoming mat was not out and unfortunately the ice cream was just ice cream. Nothing to write home about as they say. We both got the ice cream nachos. It is parts of waffle cone, broken up with a scoop of ice cream put on top. We even had to ask if we can get a topping on it... I would give a five star for presentation read more

Scoop Shack - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

This is a cute little ice cream spot. Stopped in here and ended up playing some board games at one of their tables for a bit with my family. I was interested to see that they do crafting events sometimes as well! read more

The ice cream was delicious and there was a great smell and vibe! The staff were kind and fast. read more

Ice cream is not my favorite dessert, but my children love ice cream, so we visited Scoop Shack. Good news: They're open year-round! Even during the winter. Some ice cream joints in the Midwest close during the colder months, but this one doesn't. Good! I believe that ice cream should be an all-seasons treat for those that partake, if you ask me. (And I know you didn't ask me, but I'm telling you.) Scoop Shack is women-owned and locally owned, and they support the community by offering their space to small businesses and vendors to sell their goods. The ice cream is also made with local ingredients. Best of all: The ice cream is delicious! We got a flight of ice cream -- six different mini scoops of any of their 24 flavors. Each one was great in its own way, but we really loved the double chocolate and Lemoreo. You'll also find things like ice cream nachos, made with waffle cone "chips" and toppings. Other popular items include their ice cream tacos, cookie and waffle sandwiches, cake bites, drumsticks and lots more. The service was super friendly, and I love that they offer special events, like family bingo hours, trivia night, and paint-your-pet parties. This is a fun and cozy place to hang out, eat great ice cream, and have fun. read more

We had an amazing birthday party for our mini histed by @scoopshackindy! Here's what we loved: Affordable packages: a group of 8 costs $115 plus tax, with bigger party options available! Staff provides activities! When you reserve your party, you'll be asked what theme you want. We picked Princess and the coloring sheets with Belle holding ice cream and making edible crowns were adorable! Watch the reel to see even more activities! Ice cream! Need we say more! Party package comes with goody bags! The birthday person gets an additional Scoop Shack bag of goodies Stress free planning for parents read more

See all

I love the rotating flavors and variety of treat offered. The ice cream cookies are so good! read more

Scoop Shack - Sampler - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

I have found my new guilty pleasure! Creamy, flavorful, and unique ice cream options made it hard to decide; we loved everything we got. I couldn't help it but had to try the "ice cream nachos" (the nachos are pieces of waffle cone!). Very reasonably priced, too. I'm sure you'll see me there if you go, because I won't be able to stay away. read more

Scoop Shack - Ice cream nachos with Wild Mountain Blackberry scoop and Lemon Oreo scoop, with hot fudge and Oreo bits - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

I went here on a whim, as I'm normally not in this area of town. It was a delightful surprise! It's locally owned and they make their own ice cream. You can have regular ice cream, sundaes, cookie sandwiches, ice cream cakes, etc. even just a scoop of ice cream you can pay for toppings. I only tried the buckeye option but I really liked it. Adding peanut butter syrup on top was a very tasty idea. Comfy seating and they have games you can play as you enjoy ice cream. read more

See all

This is my favorite spot to get ice cream! The service is always top notch, and the employees are always very friendly. They have so many unique flavors that are ever changing. I try something new every time. I love that you can order a single scoop and get 2 different flavors. The shop has tons of seating and is always clean. read more

Scoop Shack - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

Super tasty and some unique flavors. I had Peanut butter pie, but my friend's sugar cream pie was super tasty, too. Service was friendly. And there was local merch from all around Indy on some shelves, which was a nice touch. I think we'll be back. read more

Scoop Shack - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

If you haven't tried Scoop Shack yet, you're really missing out! The staff is great! They're very welcoming and accommodating. The atmosphere is relaxed, and there are more flavors available than most other ice cream shops I've been to. On top of that, the flavors are unique. There are shakes, cones, ice cream cakes, etc.; also, there are ice cream cookie sandwiches that are DELICIOUS. There are so many things to choose from! I ordered a single scoop of Turkish coffee ice cream, and I think it was the best coffee ice cream I've had. I feel most coffee ice creams are too much or too little when it comes to coffee, but this one is just right. The creaminess is excellent! I am not a dessert person, and this is the only ice cream shop I actively seek out. read more

Scoop Shack - Turkish coffee ice cream - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

For some reason I was craving ice cream after work, and noticed this location off of binford as I was driving home. I decided to stop and check them out. The inside location is very cute and colorful, and the service was great! I had a hard time choosing since all of the flavors sounded so good! I decided on 2 scoops of key lime ice cream; it was tasty and delicious! It even had bits of crust in it like a true pie! So good! I'll be back to check out more awesome flavors! Check this place out if you are in the area! read more

Scoop Shack - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

If you want to enjoy some tasty ice cream while chillaxing on couches (or seated tables...this is the place to go! The scenery A very modern and cozy vibe greets you when you walk in the door...there's even hutches like you would see in a dining room setting adorning local goods for deals. The Staff We were able to have great service and a wonderful conversation with the owner of the place. She shared with us about her journey on how she got there and how she came to serve locally made ice cream....pretty cool to get this info.:) The food We'll, they serve my fave local ice cream (Sundae's) and put it together beautifully with broken up waffle cone pieces, topped with delicious hot fudge (if hot fudge isn't your thing...they have plenty of other toppings to choose from!)...this creation is called Ice Cream Nachos and I highly recommend! They also have other standard ice cream creations ... if you aren't feeling the nachos vibe! Great experience and great food! We will be back! read more

Scoop Shack - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

Scoop Shack rocks!! They served Sundae's Icecream and have a great menu of options. The icecream nachos are a great creation. It's icecream of your choice on broken up waffle cones with whatever topping you like. This is a great stop along Binford either on your way downtown or on your way home from work. read more

Scoop Shack - Ice cream nachos - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

I'd been eyeballing this spot for quite some time and was more than a little excited when I saw that the former location of Twisted Sisters was soon to become a badly needed ice cream shop here on the Northeast side of Indy. Yes, you can badly need ice cream. Don't argue with me. I'm willing to fight over this one. Seriously, "Scoop Shack" is a neat little place in the small strip center closest to Binford Boulevard at 71st and Binford. It's in the same strip with Great Clips, Jimmy John's, and a brand new Domino's that's going in where another pizza shop used to be. This strip center has accessible parking at the South end of the strip with a curb cut also only on the South end. The front door is a one-sided glass door. You enter and there's a fairly decent-sized dining area to the right and the ordering counter slightly to the left. It's pretty much an open concept. Scoop Shack does also have 2-3 benches right outside their door. According to their website, Scoop Shack was started by two women - Sonja and Nicole. A lot of the locally owned shops in this area are owned by folks who live relatively close. It sounds like the same is true here. They make a point of noting that their ice cream is local and homemade. The interior is still a work in process, though it's already warm and inviting. The employees were super friendly and helpful. They have 24 rotating flavors of ice cream - I can't imagine you can't find one that resonates. They note that they use social media to let folks know flavors. They also have around 17 toppings. You can get ice cream in a cup or cone - including waffle cones. Prices range from a mini/kid size at $2.50 to a triple at $7.00. I ordered a single at $3.50. You can also take home pints at $6.25 or quarts at $9.75. A really cool feature - they have "flights" of ice cream. A 4 flavor flight is $6 and a 6 flavor flight is $8. They call their scoops "mini scoops" with the flights. They also offer sundaes, ice cream nachos (waffle chips with choice of ice cream and topping), walkabouts, chocogattos, a handful of extras, and a handful of beverage options. They have tables and one more relaxing area. The interior feels warm and intimate, though it's clear they're still getting things together. There's a unisex bathroom that looks accessible. I'm super excited to have Scoop Shack relatively close to my house. Other than the chains, it's definitely the closest place and I'll always go local first. Business seemed to be pretty steady and it's clear that they're already building positive relationships in the area. This area truly didn't have anything like this and I'm really hoping this does well here. With a great product, friendly employees, and fair prices Scoop Shack is definitely off to a good start. I'll definitely be back. read more

See all

5 stars. I'm a Sundae's fan and I was pleasantly surprised to see their flavors in this new shop. Kudos for supporting a hometown business! I sampled a few flavors (kudos for offering samples even during this pandemic) and settled on Cherry Almond! It was phenomenal! But I love almond flavoring, so it was right up my alley. For others, it may be overpowering to the palate. I enjoyed the waffle cone, too! It was kinda "chewy", in a good way. I liked being able to bite and chew it along with my ice cream. Reasonably priced. Lots of options. Very clean. read more

Scoop Shack - Cherry Almond - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

We used to go here a lot. Their product and service were good. My wife's friend gave us a gift card. They refused to accept it twice so we just quit going. read more

I ordered scoop shack for the first time to go and was impressed . I tried the home made ice cream sandwich and the cookies were soft and warm and the ice cream was super rich ! I love that they took their time and it tastes like everything was made with love . Such a warm feeling in the establishment that carried over into my home ! I highly recommend Scoop Shack read more

I ordered a pint of LemOreo via Doordash last week. The ice cream was refreshing and enjoyable until I found a long strand of hair in the ice cream. Afterwards, I threw up and contacted doordash for a full refund. I was disappointed but do understand that accidents do happen. Hopefully in the near future, there will be stricter food safety measures that will be taken place. read more

Scoop Shack - Hair found in LemOreo ice cream - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

Absolutely delicious ice cream. The service was wonderful they helped us pick flavors we wouldn't normally and the ambiance was super cute. Will return read more

The staff was friendly and very patient with my husband and I as we read over the menu. They did not help with explaining any items but the menu is easy enough to figure out. The shop was clean and there was plenty of space to sit and eat. We ordered the ice cream nachos and although good they were not what was expected. It was more of ice cream scooped onto of a crumbled up waffle bowl. The ice cream sections were not very large for those who do not like chocolate. Everything was mixed with a flavor and chocolate. Overall, not a bad place to stop for a late night snack. read more

Our order came fine but after drinking it the kitkat shake the kitkat bits at the bottom tasted odd. Not long after we started to feel sick. The kitkats were stale. read more

Ice cream was delicious, I had a scoop of graham cracker crust with a special name! Service was great, they let us taste as many flavors as we wanted with no eye rolling read more

I've spotted this ice cream spot a couple of times and while we were in the area, I suggested it to my husband. Very easy to get too and had plenty of parking. We walked in kind of surprised to see a line formed, wrapping around the tables. What I enjoyed about this place right off the bat was that they had a very large menu board that included flavors. Which was great because with the large line, we weren't able to see the flavors in the case and the large menu helped us know what to order before getting to the cashier, which in return helped the line move quickly. They had a variety of interesting flavors, one being Lemoreo (Lemon/Oreo), which was REALLY good! I was craving the melted Peanut Butter topping so I got the sundae with Oreo, peanut butter and Heath. We really enjoyed our trip and we will definitely return! read more

See all

Adorable, friendly, super duper tasty. What a neighborhood asset, it should be packed all the time! They have the coolest handheld ice cream treats they craft in-house, and they support other local businesses too. read more

See all

Delicious flavors! I had the Turkish coffee, my grandson had the sticky chewy chocolate! This is how much he loved it... read more

Scoop Shack - My grandson enjoying his sticky chewy chocolate ice cream!!! - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

Tried this place out for the first time and I will be back. The flavors were on the IG page and my family enjoyed pralines and cream, strawberry and raspberry sorbet. All were tasty, fresh and flavorful We also got waffle bowls that were fresh, light and a perfect accompaniment to our ice cream. Service was friendly and great. read more

This is the best ice cream place! Always friendly and inviting. Very much like having ice cream in your own kitchen!

We eat A LOT of ice cream and this is definitely the best overall in Indy. They have delicious flavors with lots of variety, yummy fresh toppings including chocolate hard shell (!!), the staff are really attentive and friendly, and their sundaes are unique and satisfying. And as of that's not enough, they make homemade cones, brownies and cookies to go with your ice cream. We have been here multiple times and are always happy, and they even did my sons 5th birthday party and did a fantastic job for so cheap. Love love love this place! read more

Great ice cream but what sold me were the homemade ice cream cookie sandwiches. We had the M&M with salted caramel ice cream and it was perfection! The cookie wasn't too hard which always is a win in my book for ice cream sandwiches. I also like that the kids cup was truly a kids cup. So often that size is still too big for my littles and I end up finishing it off (good and bad). Next time you want ice cream in the area, definitely try Scoop Shack!! read more

We had dinner nearby and noticed this new ice cream shop and gave it a try. The inside is very cute with comfy seating areas. I got back-raspberry cheesecake and my friend got mint Oreo. I tasted it and it had a great mint flavor and huge chunks of cookie. The cheesecake was very creamy and delicious. It was a wonderful treat. read more

Scoop Shack - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

Delicious ice cream! Very soft and creamy. I highly recommend the Turkish coffee and graham central station! Also great prices! It is worth coming here! Will for sure be coming back! read more

This place is sooooo good. The ice cream sandwiches are to die for...just get multiple and bring them home. Then cut a quarter at a time. Wow. Everything is excellent here and a great addition to the area! read more

Awesome ice cream! I ordered a flight and wasn't disappointed at all. I've found my new local do-to ice cream shop. Service was good and the atmosphere was welcoming and warm. read more

With rotating, unique flavors and good prices, this is our new favorite spot! After two visits, we've tried the Twix, Chocolate Raspberry Truffle and the Cinnamon Churro Chocolate. All delicious!They have fun options with ice cream nachos. If you live in the Devonshire area, it is a easy walk over. With a few benches outside, you can bring your pup. read more

Delicious ice cream, freshly made cones, great service. Very clean environment with a nice seating area, complete with comfy chairs! We will be back to try an ice cream sandwich! read more

I had the ice cream cookie sandwich with two huge homemade peanut butter cookies with the sticky chewy chocolate ice cream in the middle: HEAVEN! I've been dreaming of it ever since and cannot wait to get back there! read more