Very tiny place on mass ave! It was empty when i went and the service was good. I got the cheesecake of the day milkshake which was delicious!!! It's a little pricey for a shake but so worth it as a sweet treat. read more

See all

The milkshakes we got here were downright delicious. It wasn't just your stereotypical "standard flavored milkshake with unique toppings". Each one of our milkshakes themselves tasted different. The Oreo one had a very strong cookies and cream flavor while the S'mores one had an impressive smoky taste to it that I've never had before in ice cream. Really, the attention to detail here is fantastic.My s'mores milkshake came with a literal s'mores treat on top of it. It wasn't just a from-the-box s'mores treat. It was actual graham cracker and marshmallow that they took into the back to use a torch on and give that extra-smokey, warm gooey feel to it. It did take awhile to get our milkshakes. One older woman was working her butt off but clearly getting frustrated at the mounting line and the fact that things kept falling. (Good to see: if something fell on the floor, she took it into the back to, presumably, toss it into the cleaning area) At one point, she asked for someone in the back to come help her, but that young teen seemed to be doing the bare minimum. I'm not sure if it's because they're untrained or not allowed to operate some of the machinery, but while this woman is frantically trying to keep up with things, he'd do what he was told to do, relatively slowly, and then stand around and wait for a new command. It was frustrating ME to watch. I can't imagine how that feels as a co-worker. All-in-all, we had about a 15-20 minute to receive our milkshakes. Definitely worth it in the end, but it's just something to note before popping in. I'd say it was definitely worth it for the unique flavor and quality when it was all done. The place looks a little "hole in the wall" with a few tables and chairs in an older building with the single, for-customers restroom in it. If you like the older, diner-esque style building that's been around for a long time, it has that vibe. Both of our milkshakes included a to-go lid right on them that we could snap on. Unlike some "crazy milkshake" establishments, the lids could actually go on both of the milkshakes after a few sips. The toppings were large but not insurmountable. read more

See all

Come here regularly. They have the best, deluxe Milkshakes in Indy. I usually get their demise strawberry & banana which is "to die for." My 13 year olds got a Birthday Cake milkshake with a slice of birthday cake on top (!) while the other got a chocolate-ish with a handful of Oreo cookies in it and a slice of cheese cake on top (don't recall the name). Be sure to ask to see their booklet with picture of their shakes inside - better than just the reading the ingredients on the board, we believe. We'll be back! read more

I personally was very underwhelmed by my peanut butter milkshake because there was no peanut butter taste. My partner got the vegan cookies and cream milkshake, and he enjoyed it, but even with trying his, there was not much of a cookie taste. I think he just enjoyed it because, most vegan options are pretty bland. I really wanted to like this place because it is black owned, but the service was very subpar, we were barely greeted upon walking in, and even when asking questions, the worker was not helpful in answering questions. For the price of these milkshakes, I'm not sure I will be returning for another try or not because they are on the more expensive side It is a nice location since it is directly on mass Avenue and near a lot of other places like the garage, but if you do go, you will have to pay for street parking in order to visit read more

Gordon’s Milkshake Bar - Peanut butter milk shake - Desserts Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

I have loved Gordon's since they opened! Whenever I'm having dinner in the area, I will stop in and grab dessert at Gordon's. I'm kind of sad that they took away the brownies and beignets, but I love a good milkshake so I can't complain too much! The service can be a bit slow, but I think it's worth the wait. My favorite milkshake of all time is the buttery whipple. It's a seasonal drink that only comes around for the Butter Art Fair season, but I think about it all year around! read more

Gordon’s Milkshake Bar - Desserts Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

My partner and I love milkshakes so we were excited to check this one out! Not our favorite so far, but they weren't bad! I wish my peanut butter brownie shake tasted more like peanut butter brownie - it more just tasted like a chocolate shake with some peanuts in it. My boyfriend got a custom milkshake with vanilla and peaches in it which he liked. I do appreciate that they allow you to make your own, because he doesn't like chocolate, so that gave him more choices than just the specialty shakes read more

See all

I've walked by this spot so many times over the past year and finally decided to stop in now that it's summer. I really wanted to like this place, but it just didn't do it for me. The milkshake tasted very artificial and was way too sweet (and this is coming from someone who has a BIG sweet tooth). I ordered the red velvet love and the cake blended into the milkshake tasted old/stale. I tried to power through given that the specialty shakes are $13, but I couldn't even finish the whole thing because it made my stomach hurt. It's a shame because the shakes look so delicious but the taste just isn't right. I wonder if I just ordered the wrong thing or came in on an off day. Service was okay. The man working the register was nice but the other two workers making the shakes were not as friendly. read more

Gordon’s Milkshake Bar - red velvet love - Desserts Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

I don't think this is "Gordon's" anymore. It now just says, "Milkshake bar." Our shakes were watery and actually lacked flavor. No prices were listed and I was shocked to spend $29 on 2 shakes that we ended up throwing away. I used to love Gordon's but this new owner has let the place go. Even the whipped cream has changed. It was also watery and lacked taste. Sigh. read more

Pretty but not really tasty. The flavor that I ordered was supposed to include chocolate ice cream but instead there was chocolate powder used and it left a weird after taste. I'm thinking that if they just used chocolate ice cream the taste would match the look. read more

Super friendly service! I showed them a picture of a milkshake I saw that was on a review and not the menu and they kindly made it for me. Super good milkshakes! read more

Gordon’s Milkshake Bar - Cookie Monster Milkshake - Desserts Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

I was walking with a friend on a very hot day along Mass Ave and was craving something cold. Stumbled upon this place during my walk and SO GLAD that I did! I quickly walked in and was happy to see how spacious it actually was compared to the outside! Plenty of seating which I always appreciate. The cashier behind the counter was very patient with me as I looked over the menu. I quickly ordered a chocolate milkshake and sat down. When I received it, the milkshake was very creamy and rich. Overall good experience and I will be back to try the ice-cream cause they have that too! read more

Gordon’s Milkshake Bar - Desserts Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

Closed at 7:15 on a Wednesday night. No note on the door. Kid in the back saw us knocking and finally came to the door to say "we weren't busy so we're closed." A group of about ten people had come up behind us saying they were in town and had been looking forward to coming back tonight. read more

This is not Gordon's milkshake anymore, it has been bought out by someone else. It doesn't have its nice, clean, and fun vibe anymore. Definitely needs remodeling! Still great shakes! They just removed the Gordon and have new workers. But I wish the owner the best of luck! read more

Gordon’s Milkshake Bar - Desserts Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

One of the best milkshakes I've ever had. While in town, I had to stop by for one of their handspun, beautifully crafted milkshakes topped with delicious sweet treats. I got the butter cream cake shake and it didnt disappoint. To top it off, the service was impeccable, quick and attentive and the shop was colorful with quirky decor. If you're in the area, stop in and treat yourself! read more

What is this?! If I could give no stars I would. I'm visiting from out of town and this place was highly recommended. Why? Not sure. I always want to support Black Owned businesses so I was happy to visit. However, from the moment my friends and I stepped in, it was a lackluster experience. The employees and manager were not knowledgeable and they claim to have vegan and dairy free options but they only have vanilla soft serve that comes out of a pouch and the manager brought it out of the back to show us the powdered mix. The employees also mentioned that they buy the other ice cream from a store?? against our judgement we ordered and it was not good, and the brownie sundae we got was covered in lukewarm hot fudge and served over a hard thick brownie..to top it off, they served it in a foil pan. The dairy free ice cream had no flavor. This place is awful. Highly DO not recommend. read more

Gordon’s Milkshake Bar - Desserts Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

We hang out on Mass Ave, but haven't tried here before. I have to give them credit for some pretty epic milkshakes. That said, the space was cramped and unkempt. And the shakes were running over the sides and not quite up to my standards presentation wise for a $13 shake. There were also a lot of gnats. The staff were friendly, and I think with a little care, this place could be a nice treat. read more

See all

This has been my favorite milkshake place in Indy since 2020. If you are visiting indy or have always lived here, you MUST try this place. The milkshakes are absolutely amazing and being someone who can't have dairy they can make almost any shake dairy free or vegan. Don't sleep on the other desserts they have available like the beignets, they are good too! The milkshakes/desserts are made to order, so depending on the time of the year, the wait can be long, but it's definitely WORTH it! I have not seen this place available for pickup or doordash, so you have to go there to order it. They have cute lighting and a few seats inside, so you can either take it to go or enjoy it inside! read more

Gordon’s Milkshake Bar - Strawberry & Banana - Desserts Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

See all

This is a great spot in near Northeast Indy in the Mass Ave. area. It's located in an interesting commercial strip with several eateries, specialty shops and boutiques. Our future son-in-law found this spot for us to get a treat after our visit to the Zoo Lights display. The location was easy to find and street parking was adequate when we visited at around 9 PM on a Saturday. It is a small shop with only three or four tables plus a counter that could seat another three or four persons. The guy working that night was hilarious. It was relatively busy and he was by himself. Most people would be frazzled, but he was remarkably cool and calm. When we got to the front, he told us he just had two more shakes to make and he'd be with us. Five shakes later, he told us just one more. Three shakes after that, he finally got to us. I was not at the counter when the order was placed, but our daughter said she asked him how he was doing and his markedly mellow reply was "I'm doing good, it's all good". Hmmm....Nonetheless, he was certainly a very pleasant fellow. Putting aside the bonus people-watching entertainment, however, the ice cream creations were truly noteworthy. Our future son-in-law got the Midnight Cookies and Cream Shake and seemed quite happy with it. But it was a normal serving as opposed to the other two things we got. Our daughter got the ice cream nachos, which was an impressive amount of ice cream over flaky cinnamon sugar chips topped with whipped cream, chocolate chips and chocolate and caramel sauces. It was great. My wife and I split a Bread Pudding covered with Banana Bread Ice Cream. It was also a massive serving that really was meant to share. The Bread Pudding was served warm putting the perfect edge on this delightful creation. It was not cheap, as the final bill was well over $30 for the ice cream, tax and tip. But let's face it...it was well worth it. It was one of the most enjoyable ice cream treats I've had in a while and the ambiance of the area made it even more agreeable. We'll look forward to trying this establishment again. read more

See all

Love this place! I remember when it first opened like before Covid. The quality of the ingredients is great and love the flavor combinations. Every time I'm back in Indianapolis, i always take my friends here! read more

I've been wanting to come here since they opened! So excited to have a milkshake that's dairy free and VEGAN whipped cream! Staff was really helpful about all of my non dairy options. They have plenty to choose from. I'll come back to try the others this summer for sure. Side note though they should consider selling chocolate cake as individual slices. read more

Gordon’s Milkshake Bar - Cookies and Cream Vegan Milkshake - Desserts Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

See all

Following our dinner, we decided to grab a milkshake from Gordon's. The line was kind of crazy and there were only two very overwhelmed people working their hardest to make everyone's orders without getting behind. It probably took 30 minutes from the time we got in to the time we ordered and then to the time we got our shakes. I was kind of underwhelmed by mine and so was my husband. I really wanted ice cream and pie and was told they didn't have it. So that was disappointing. I did like that they put real cake in the shake! That gave it something extra and they have some unique options. I just didn't think it was worth a long line or good enough for what I purchased. read more

Gordon’s Milkshake Bar - Birthday Cake milkshake - Desserts Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

If you're looking for a sweet treat, this is the place! I ordered the midnight cookies and cream milkshake. It is a chocolate lovers dream! It is a chocolate shake with cookies and cream, hot fudge, and then topped with whipped cream, cookie crumbles, and chocolate chips. It was so good!! Their menu says you can add alcohol to any milkshake for only $3. The service was very quick. I didn't notice any seating inside. It seemed like more of a grab and go kind of place. I will definitely be back to try more items on their menu! read more

See all

The service is really slow but the milkshakes are delicious and worth the wait! Cute little interior! read more

See all

Grabbed two shakes here.. they were poppin'. The three workers seemed to have a system though. I thought my shake was 4/5 mostly because it was peanut butter brownie but i kept getting another flavor that I couldn't place My husband went with vanilla and his flavor was good but to him it was too thick. The workers were friendly - 5/5 read more

This place is awful! Milkshakes have no flavor, it's literally milk with toppings, like are you even using ice cream? And the staff is so unfriendly, barely uttered a word to us. Don't waste your money. read more

Yum! While I have never been to their actual location, they had a booth at the Wanamaker Old Settler's Days festival and I couldn't pass it up. I had a cone with the Cookie Monster ice cream and I was as happy as a little kid with my lips turning blue and ice cream all over the place (no picture cuz I devoured it as it was dripping down my arm). My brother had the French toast sundae, and it is exactly that...a slice of hot French toast covered in whatever flavor ice cream you want and toppings. My birthday is around the corner and I was struggling to think of somewhere to celebrate, Gordon's is 100% where I'm going now. Who needs cake? read more

Well, after you wait 20 minutes for your $15 shake, hopefully the contents aren't stale. I hope the person making your shake changes gloves after they dig out dog treats for the pup cup. And I hope your cookie dough milkshake actually has cookie dough in it. What a waste of $30. 0 personality in this place and their product is not remotely worth the price tag. read more

This is a wonderful mural painted on a signal box in front of Gordon's Milkshakes, the business that commissioned the mural. It is the work of an up-and-coming artist Ashley Robinson AKA (artistically known as) Ashley Nora. She completed the work in 2021 and it wraps around the entire box. It is done in her 3D style, that has become to be her signature. I always find her work very impressive and she is becoming one of my favorite artists. Prior to Nora painting the mural, the box was just plain and unattractive. It is interesting to note that Nora did not pursue art full-time until about 3 years ago. One side of the box has the work "JOY" in 3D writing. The opposite side has her tag of sorts "@ASHLEYNORA_ART". The main part of the box, which faces the sidewalk, has a young boy, with a shirt that says "MILKSHAKE", sitting criss-cross applesauce and enjoying a milkshake. The boy is also looking at a pink butterfly that is flying by his face. It is very vibrant. I love how she uses colors in the piece. Laid upon that black background really makes it pop. It demanded my attention and was very impressive. The reverse side, which faces the street, has a colorful butterfly. This is a very nice piece and is a must see. It is right off of the cultural trail and easy to get to. There is a lot of metered street parking available in front of and near the box. You will even find a couple of free short-term spots as well. In addition to the mural, Nora created a milkshake that was available for a limited time at Gordon's that paid homage to her home state of Mississippi. She donated 100% of the proceeds from her "Big Mama's Banana Pudding" milkshake to creating hygiene and toiletry kits for the homeless. Murals with a purpose....that's whats up. Anyway, as with most murals that I have visited and reviewed, this is not a very long stop. I was there less than 5 minutes. You may want to consider planning out additional stops at many of the other murals and attractions in the area, or making this stop part of a larger itinerary to maximize your time and trip. You can walk the cultural trail, get a milkshake or visit the nearby Pattern Magazine mural. read more

This place is just OK. I had heard all the hype and there was a line to get in Saturday night. My milkshake was fine. It was creamy and tasty, but it wasn't really any better than a milkshake from Steak and Shake or Baskin-Robbins. And they're not cheap either. Mine was $9. I know you can add alcohol to any milkshake for $3, but it was unclear what was available. (I saw cans of Guinness and Truly, but that surely can't be what they add.) read more

Gordon’s Milkshake Bar - Outdoor seating - Desserts Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

See all

Pro tip- do not share the milkshakes! They're so good you'll want your own! We walk here often and love sipping our shake as we stroll Mass Ave! read more

Gordon’s Milkshake Bar - Desserts Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

When I want a good milk shake, I go to Gordon's. They have the best handcrafted milkshakes in town! They switch up their menu seasonally, to give a variety of options and flavors. They always have a line, because all good things take time. The staff is always very friendly and inviting. I always have a good experience when I visit! read more

Gordon’s Milkshake Bar - Cheesecake Milk Shake of the Day - Desserts Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

Love Gordon's! Sometimes the line and resulting wait can get long, but it's worth it. Wonderful milkshakes of course, but lots of other options too. Our fave thing to get is probably the coffee frappe. read more

Gordon’s Milkshake Bar - Milkyway coffee frappe - Desserts Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

Great place to stop by for dessert. I love how this area has gotten a lifeline with the Bottleworks hotel and the Garage right across the street from Gordon's. There aren't too many dessert options inside The Garage and Gordon's definitely fills the void. It's a cute milkshake shop with an amazing variety of flavors that will keep You coming back for more. On our visit, my children and I tried the Midnight mocha, cookie dough and strawberry cheesecake shakes. Let me tell you-every last one was just as delicious as the next. It'll depend on your taste buds-but I promise, there's something for everyone. The baristas (I know it's not coffee but they should have a name too)-anyway the team make the shakes right in front of you--using fresh, real ingredients. The cookie dough pieces were so good. They put real strawberries in the cheesecake shake and it's also donned with a delicious piece of original cheesecake right in top! I mean! That's two desserts in ONE! It's a small shop so seating fills up quickly especially with Covid- they try to spread everything out. But there is seating right outside in the little alley next to the shop so you'll have plenty of room to sit and enjoy your treats. Reasonably priced a little bit more expensive than DQ but not outrageous. So definitely worth it for the family without breaking the bank. I also love that it is a black-owned business-a bonus for me. It's clean and professional and a very good vibe when you walk in and throughout your transaction. I would definitely recommend Gordon's. read more

Gordon’s Milkshake Bar - Cookie Dough shake - Desserts Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

See all

Not sure if this place is still open. Went by on a Saturday around 3 and they were closed. We've had problems the last few times we've swing by (over months) where they either weren't open, the milkshake machines were all down, or they didn't have their vegan product available. Too bad since we used to love their milkshakes and would go out of our way to visit. read more

This place lives up to the hype! On any given summer day, you'll find lines of people out the door waiting to get their hands on these shakes. The shakes are decadent and creamy, with homemade whipped cream and fun toppings. I ordered the cookies & cream and loved it - it was one of the best shakes I've ever had. I tried a bit of the peanut butter brownie from my husband and it was a little rich for my taste with a lot of heavy flavors. In my experience, the staff do a great job handling the line of customers, but unfortunately it's not uncommon to have to wait 30+ minutes on a busy day. If you're a sweets lover like me it is definitely worth it, but come prepared for a wait. Pro tip: they offer free pup cups for your dog. This was so sweet and it was a generous size! read more

Gordon’s Milkshake Bar - Cookies & Cream - Desserts Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

See all

Only reason I am giving them a 4 is for the service. This is a delicious joint and haven't had a bad item from here but the service....I gotta say I've maybe had one good experience. The milkshakes are delicious, my favorite is the brownie sundae and they had amazing ice cream selections!! Always several on hand and also have vegan and dairy free options for ice cream (can also be made in a shake). They also offer various dessert items like bread pudding and pies as well as hot dogs! Anytime I have gone there is usually one person working so if there is anyone else ordering expect to wait at least 10-15 mins if not more especially if they order shakes. Last time I was there the only girl working wouldn't even give us a sample she said "well it taste like chocolate and Oreo do you really want a sample." Was very thrown off, I asked for another sample and she told me she needed to go to the back to get it and do I really want to try it. It was very uncomfortable and yes if I'm asking for a sample then yes I want a sample. A few other times I've been it's been slow moving, once a guy working rang me up and rang up everything I ordered wrong and had to walk him through the order again and tried overcharging and adding more items, it was weird. He did the same thing to the man in front of me. Off nights happen, but if you're in customer service especially an ice cream shop, expect people to ask for samples and don't deny them or drag your feet if people are asking. Like I said, haven't had anything bad just bad customer service. read more

Gordon’s Milkshake Bar - Ice cream portion - Desserts Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

See all

Delicious milkshakes and dessert! I got the bread pudding with vanilla ice cream and it really hit the spot! The midnight cookies and cream gourmet milkshake was also delicious and I love crunch in my milkshakes. Perfect sharing size! Definitely recommend if you're in the area. read more

Gordon’s Milkshake Bar - Bread pudding with ice cream - Desserts Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

See all

Milkshake establishment with a milkshake advertisement by the roadside and said their machine was down wow... guess I won't ever try there again for a milkshake read more

On an unseasonably warm January day, my friend and I resolved to get milkshakes and drink them outside Bottleworks. I'd been to Gordon's before, but these just tasted better given the free pass from the snow and sleet. I got the classic chocolate shake and my friend got cookies and cream. They offer more elaborate concoctions, but simplicity tastes so sweet! The milkshakes were very large and reasonably priced :) read more

Gordon’s Milkshake Bar - chocolate and cookies n cream - Desserts Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

I love the fact this place has options for everyone. Vegan, dairy free, etc. My milkshake was one of the best I have ever had in Indy. Initial impression was disappointing, I am not sure if they are renovating but the place seemed run down to almost near closing down. Only 2 of the 3 menu boards had items on them. Ice cream in the freezer wasn't labeled. Just lacked presentation of products or offerings. I asked if they had and vegan specialties and the lady said, "the exact thing I just told her. You have to pick your toppings." Sorry I wasn't paying attention to another persons conversation. It would be nice to have a couple of vegan or dairy free "specialty shake" options. Over all service and lack of environment were disappointing. Hoping this visit was just an off day, because the shake was REALLY good. read more