Cancel

Open app

Search

Natalie's Candy Jar

3.3 (13 reviews)
Open • 5:00 am - 8:00 pm

Natalie's Candy Jar Photos

Business Info

You might also consider

Recommended Reviews - Natalie's Candy Jar

Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
Yelp app icon
Browse more easily on the app
Review Feed Illustration

Reviews With Photos

Maya T.

This is the first time I've been able to go into Natalie's bc we simply never have the time and this time our flight was delayed so time was on our side. I LOVE going into candy stores bc I love seeing all of the weird and crazy candy. Natalie's definitely had some to show. I don't usually get Jelly Bellies but when I do I get the delicious ones like buttered popcorn or s'mores. Also we were going to see my sister and she loves gummies so I got her some of those too. Natalie's thank you be being you bc like the ice cream shops that try to open, not many candy stores are still around either and the online stuff is just way too outrageously expensive.

a display of candy in a store
Reen K.

Face masks and social distancing is a must. Natalie's candy jar has everything you would think of, for your sweet candy tooth. :-) Chocolates, sour candy, sugar candy, sweet tarts, lollipops, and more. You will not be disappointed.

a bag of gummy bears
Jeremy M.

This place is extremely over priced. Very disappointing they charge so much for a little bit random Albanese's candy.

people shopping in a store
Sigrid W.

So I saw some candy on sale... figured I'll get some of that. Well cashier tried to charge me full price, even after I showed her the clearly marked clearance price... I was told that's what it rings up doesn't matter what is marked. Yeah I left the candy there

Candy for days!
Daphne C.

Fast, friendly service. And close to the Southwest gates. Or any gate near the end of terminal B

a view of a waiting area at an airport

See all

6 months ago

Helpful 16
Thanks 3
Love this 15
Oh no 0

11 months ago

Helpful 2
Thanks 0
Love this 3
Oh no 0
Photo of K F.
0
1
0

4 months ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

2 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 1
Oh no 0

11 months ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

6 years ago

Helpful 6
Thanks 0
Love this 5
Oh no 0

3 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

5 years ago

Helpful 3
Thanks 0
Love this 1
Oh no 0

3 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 1
Oh no 0

4 years ago

Helpful 1
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

5 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 1
Oh no 0

3 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

4 years ago

Helpful 1
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

Ask the Community - Natalie's Candy Jar

You might also consider

Verify this business for free

People searched for Candy Stores 585 times last month within 10 miles of this business.

Verify this business

Rocket Fizz - Indianapolis - Jones cane sugar soda // flavor: cream soda

Rocket Fizz - Indianapolis

4.4(125 reviews)
8.3 mi•Mile Square
•$$

wow wow WOW! this was such a cute blast into the past…read more First, you hear that iconic storefront bell ring when you walk in. Then, you see rows, islands, and walls of candies and sodas. You can find classics like Necco, or new things like spicy gummy bears and ranch-flavored pop.. I was most impressed with the *treasure chest* full of cotton candy. From chamoy pineapple to Dr. Pepper (I do not recommend) -- there were so many options!! Out of everything I tried, the gummy sushi platters were my all-time favorite! But I highly recommend picking up something new to go along with it... just make sure it isn't the Chocolate Bacon soda or Salted Black Licorice. I'd only wish those on my enemy :)

Whenever my lil buddy comes to spend time with me, we have to explore things together. It's a must…read more Rocket fizz and I have a wonderful relationship as it always carries some of my old school favorite candies and when my grandbaby mentioned he wanted to try rock candy, I knew exactly where to take him too. Rocket fizz has 2 locations that I am familiar with. One in Plainfiekd and one in Downtown Indy. I love both locations but downtown on the circle was our choice. When the monument isn't under construction I love walking the steps. We parked a block away and walked back. And once inside we were in candy heaven. We spent alot of time perusing. Because their were so many choices it was hard for my grandson to decide until the store clerk mentioned she just made some grab bags. Excited he was. They were pricey but it was for the fun of it all for him. It has been a while since we've gone but he still talks about our visit. And for me, the memories are worth every dollar spent.

Photos
Rocket Fizz - Indianapolis - Unique variety. Also, has an unusual amount of sour options than I typically see in a candy store!

Unique variety. Also, has an unusual amount of sour options than I typically see in a candy store!

Rocket Fizz - Indianapolis - So many pops

So many pops

Rocket Fizz - Indianapolis - Display when you enter

See all

Display when you enter

Sugar Rush

Sugar Rush

4.1(7 reviews)
28.4 mi

We tried four different cupcakes, and split each in quarters so we could try them all. I don't know…read moreif I could pick a favorite, but the lemon blueberry stood out. All the cupcakes were moist, and a great flavor; too often when you visit bakeries they have frozen the cupcakes and I can always taste that. These were fresh! I love that they chose a downtown location in a historic building and left the safe in the wall. They store the cake boxes in the old safe and it is visible behind the counter which lends character to the atmosphere. This is a candy lovers dream store. Lots of candy gifts ideas.

The cupcakes are impressively tall. Frosting towers so high that it makes more sense to eat them…read morewith a fork, so be sure to grab one before you leave if you get yours to go. We got a German chocolate cupcake, which is chocolate cupcake with caramel and coconut-pecan frosting. It was big enough for two people, for sure. The Cookie Monster cupcakes were cute, and there were also cupcakes that looked like sundaes, plus a lot of other flavors, like strawberry cream, pina colada, cherry, M&M and others. Along with cupcakes, you'll also find ice cream, pie and cake slices, cookies, bulk candy, and a whole two walls full of packaged candy, including old fashioned candy like Pez, Chuckles, wax lips and other novelty sweets. This is a sweet and charming little store for all things sweet, located in a vintage-looking building. Parking is on the street or in the small free parking lot a short ways away.

Photos
Sugar Rush - Cookies & cream cupcakes

Cookies & cream cupcakes

Sugar Rush
Sugar Rush - Cookies

See all

Cookies

Uranus Fudge Factory – Anderson - Uranus Fudge Factory

Uranus Fudge Factory – Anderson

4.4(119 reviews)
39.5 mi
•$$

First thing to get out of the way - the atmosphere. Yes, There is mild potty humor related to the…read moremispronunciation of the planet Uranus. It's all a very third grade level. If you can get past that, you will enjoy the excellent ice cream and family-friendly facility. A lot of the gift store items are potty humor related but if you have the slightest sense of humor you'll be able to enjoy yourself. There are lots of fun attractions like putting your hand in the aliens mouth, Putt-Putt golf, and other fun stuff. They have a newsletter and many different types of fudge. The potty humor for the fudge amps up to 5th or 6th grade humor. If you survived Elementary School, you should be able to handle this. Visit their website to see the level of humor expected. Again, the ice cream was excellent and served by a staff of teens. The facility was clean and I like the use of graffitied vintage chairs and furniture in the ice cream eatery. Keep an open mind when you visit and remember that off color jokes don't injure or change the taste of really good ice cream!

I stopped here thinking it was the one I was at six months ago. Turns out this is another location…read more I think the one in Richmond is much better insofar as the customer service, plus is much bigger. My spouse bought a pound of their hand dipped chocolates that the girl behind the counter put in a bag. We were going to be traveling several hundred miles so I asked if she could please put them in a candy box. She said sure, I'll just dump them in the box. Before I could say anything she did exactly that, Dumped them in the box straight out of the bag instead of placing each one in there individually. Seriously??? Then at the check out the clerk was rude when I asked her to put the various boxes of chocolate we were buying in the bag in size order so they wouldn't be tipping all over. I said we had several hundred miles to travel. She didn't seem to care, but did what I asked with a bit of a huff. Guess what Uranus, your fudge and chocolates aren't cheap. They're very good, but pricy. That's okay, I'm willing to pay it. People buy for themselves and for gifts. I don't think it's too much to ask your employees to handle them property whether putting them in a box or bagging them up at checkout. Please, re-educate your employees on courtesy and professionalism. If it weren't for the quality of the candy you'd get a one star review. Needless to say I won't return to this location again. The Richmond location will get my business in the future.

Photos
Uranus Fudge Factory – Anderson
Uranus Fudge Factory – Anderson - Business sign

Business sign

Uranus Fudge Factory – Anderson - Dubai Chocolate

See all

Dubai Chocolate

Martinsville Candy Kitchen - Christmas Decorations

Martinsville Candy Kitchen

4.4(32 reviews)
21.3 mi
•$

It was crowded the day before Thanksgiving but we managed to browse around and find some…read more"treasures." We always love coming here and struggling with what candy to get, they have so much variety to choose from. I found a new favorite, Malted Milk Balls. They are so much bigger than the kind found in a movie theater box. My old favorite, Milk Chocolate Cherry Cordials, turned out to be one of granddaughter's faves too. I should have bought more, much more. She tried a Mud Ball for the first time and loved it. Of course we had to pick up some milk chocolate and dark chocolate caramels as well. Martinsville Candy Kitchen is a popular destination when in the downtown area. Right now you can watch the new addition being built onto the old courthouse and see the renovations taking place. The entire city block is undergoing a dramatic change from what it used to be right across the street from the Candy Kitchen.

We couldn't have been more pleased with our special order of 100 Buckeye candies. This was for a…read moreCelebration of Life where the person being honored had been known for her quality and delicious Buckeyes. The staff was so friendly and helpful on the phone. The candies came beautifully wrapped and divided in boxes, everyone was so complimentary, delicious delicate chocolate and airy and light peanut butter was just perfection. Thank you for being a part of this most important event in such a sentimental way.

Photos
Martinsville Candy Kitchen
Martinsville Candy Kitchen - Buckeyes. Expertly made and oh so delicious.

Buckeyes. Expertly made and oh so delicious.

Martinsville Candy Kitchen

See all

Schakolad Chocolate Factory - In Boone Village

Schakolad Chocolate Factory

4.8(58 reviews)
16.2 mi
•$$

I had delicious chocolate for breakfast, today. Schakolad is a local chocolatier run by husband and…read morewife team, Mindy and Todd Polizotto. Todd helped us out this morning. He is friendly and engaging. The gorgeous chocolates are made on site. The shop is filled with cases of truffles and small bites. Gift boxes throughout the store, showcase everything from chocolate dinosaurs to the state of Indiana. My mind was exploding just seeing all the chocolate. A display of shamrock and other St. Patrick's Day themed chocolates stood in the middle of the store. Todd told us that they custom make just about any shape of chocolate. They will cover wine bottles or other bottles with chocolate for perfect gifts. My brain was calculating what gifts that I need to pick up. I picked out several assorted dark chocolate truffles for an afternoon treat and a large dark bar for evening dessert. (It is important to get chocolate after every meal.) The truffles were divine. The raspberry truffles are the best I've had. My husband liked the amaretto truffle. They also serve a handful of flavors of gelato. I'll return later in the day and report back. I thought prices were reasonable. A small cafe table is inside the store if you want to eat your treats there. There is plenty of parking in the strip mall lot.

New in town and stopped in after a trip to the grocery. Nice small little shop with a nice…read moreselection of treats. The buckeyes were definitely an eye catcher and the Dubai treat was too. The customer service was very friendly and patient while making my selections.

Photos
Schakolad Chocolate Factory
Schakolad Chocolate Factory - St. Patrick's Day chocolates

St. Patrick's Day chocolates

Schakolad Chocolate Factory - A dinosaur!

See all

A dinosaur!

Natalie's Candy Jar - candy - Updated October 2026

Loading...
Loading...
Loading...