Stopped by with 2 other couples for trivia night. My husband was hesitant at first because the food used to be very bad. Since the restaurant took new ownership my husband said the food is 10 times better. Everything was delicious. I loved the $5 margaritas for happy hour. The trivia was a lot of fun!! Our waitress was super friendly. Overall great experience! read more

Love this place, the food is delicious and the people are even better. I love the shredded beef tacos and nachos. My 5 year old is obsessed with their chicken tenders. read more

Tried this place for take out on Friday. The service was friendly and my order was out quickly. The chicken taquitos were hefty with wonderfully stewed meat. Four taquitos is more than enough for a full meal. I also ordered the steak fajitas. While there is plenty for two to share the meal the meat was overcooked and dry but did have good flavor and the veggies were on point! The beans and rice that came with it were adequate for the meal. The full slice of a beefsteak tomato wasn't necessary and really didn't need to be on the plate, but not a deal breaker. As for the tortilla chips, half were overcooked and the flavor was so-so. All in all good service with friendly staff, quick turnaround on food delivery and the taquitos were totally worth it. Probably wouldn't do the fajitas again but I will definitely come again. read more

See all

Horrible, my service was nice and friendly but the food was completely wrong.My brother had quesadilla without lettuce only cheese and chicken but they replaced the cheese with lettuce.My moms mahi mahi was fries and she specifically said grilled. read more

We visit for a margarita, a beer, and we split a California burrito and it's great every time. Chips are excellent, salsa is a little sweet for me but everyone has their own preference. Overall, very consistent and good service too. read more

Desde que el restaurante Cinco de mayo murabella abrio he side cliente. Los meseros son excelentes, muy amables me encanta el servicio y amabilidad. La comida siempre muy buena y buen sabor y a muy accesible. Me Encanta sentarme en la barra donde siempre hay buena musica y mucha conversacion con todos. Si tienen la oportunidad de visitar el restaurante la en la fecha cinco de mayo ¡no se van a arrepentir! Buenas promociones y buen ambiente. read more

Cinco De Mayo - Mexican Near Me - Saint Augustine, Florida

See all

Zero stars if I could. Came in quickly on my 45min lunch. Was seated, my waitress took 10min to "check on me", asked for water was ready to order, she walked away got lost. Came back 10min later I ordered a quick lunch the Speedy Gonzalez I asked if I could have a corn tortilla instead of flour she seemed annoyed by that. Food came out a nice gentleman brought it out. I wanted to place a to -go order of churros but since my waitress felt like her text messages were more important I ran out of time. (I watched her as she was at a table in the corner, texting, drinking her drink, having not a care in the world.) Very unprofessional, not friendly, food is not good. I'm from CA and our Mexican food out there is great this place, met zero expectations. Definitely did not tip. Tips are earned and the lady that was not present during my visit did not earn my hard earned money. read more

Cinco De Mayo - Mexican Near Me - Saint Augustine, Florida

Food was trash. Served me what looked like homemade ground beef tacos o a mission tortilla

The food was decent. Flavorful. Fresh. Large portions. Service could have been better. We were a party of 5. Both hostesses seated us swiftly without any conversation. Attitude of the wait staff was similar. There was a language barrier. I ordered corn tortillas with the pollo loco. They brought flour tortillas. No biggie. I tried to the attention of three seperate servers to have it changed. No luck. We were unsuccessful. We had to get up and go towards the kitchen to get their attention. They brought in fresh corn tortillas that were delicious and freshly made They were not full or busy. Same story when we tried to order desert or get boxes. It was hard to get anyone's attention. We had to get up and go to them to ask. I would do a takeaway next time. Food was decent. read more

Cinco De Mayo - Mexican Near Me - Saint Augustine, Florida

See all

The food was decent and you get ALOT to eat for the price, but I was very thrown off by the terrible, nasty smell in the restroom near the kitchen. The chips were sub par, however......if you like spicy, ask for their jalapeño salsa and you're in for a kick! I wish they had a small bites menu (similar to the lunch menu) that was always available because the portions were so large. The service was pretty good when the food was brought out. There was only a slight issue with languages, but we all managed perfectly. I would have liked to try a frozen margarita, but they use a premade sour mix that is too strong and they were $9.99 for one (not sure of the size). Compared to the other locations, this one is the best. If it weren't for the sour water, sulfur smell in the restroom and lack of ambiance, I would give them four stars. We probably will not be back, but for the price, the food was substantial and tasted fine. read more

Cinco De Mayo - Combination #1 w/ Chicken - Mexican Near Me - Saint Augustine, Florida

See all

Dined in last night (5/20) and had the worst experience at Cinco de Mayo. We have eaten there on many occasions but last night's experience will be our last. The waitress was inattentive and the food was well below par. We sat at the table waiting for our bill and I noticed our waitress outside making videos with another co-worker. I had to get a hostess to close out our bill. Regarding the entrees, my wife ordered a taco salad and it was basically a meat and refried bean soup within the taco shell. It was disgusting. read more

Love the food! (Especially the new wings on the menu!) The staff are the best!! They treat everyone like family!! Make you a favor and stop by cinco de Mayo murabella!! read more

Interesting decor that is more nuanced than it first appears. The salsa served with the chips is very good. Our burritos were very large, we each took half home. Service was great! Cinco de Mayo is our new go-to for Mexican food. read more

Seated right away at our 500pm arrival. The atmosphere is good with the decor and music. The chips and salsa are the perfect start. The salsa has more flavor and kick than the usual. We got the Burrito California and Burrito Mayo. Both large, tasty and worth it. Above average amount of meat as other restaurants fill burritos with rice and lettuce. Will be a frequent customer. read more

recently had the pleasure of dining at Cinco de Mayo Mexican Restaurant in St. Augustine, and it was very good! The menu offered a wide range of authentic Mexican dishes. The excellent flavors and the portions were generous too! The service and staff were attentive and eager to ensure a delightful dining experience. Overall, Cinco de Mayo exceeded my expectations, and I can't wait to visit again. If you're a fan of Mexican cuisine and find yourself in St. Augustine, make sure to stop by this restaurant. read more

The worst Mexican food! DO NOT WASTE YOUR MONEY OR TIME. I'll never return to this restaurant. I will say our waitress was good. Tipped her accordingly. Not her issue on food quality. read more

My wife and I have been enjoying Cinco De Mayo in World Golf Village for over 8 years and this is the first time I had POLO ALA CREMA. I Loved it!! Every bite I was like mmm, mmm, until my wife was like stop! Let me try some she loved it too! Great Friendly Service Always, Cold beer and you get a lot of food on the plate. Tomorrow I will be having POLO ALA CREMA for lunch unless I get hungry tonight The picture does not do the dish justice, it was full of delicious Chicken, Mushrooms, Grilled Onions, Peppers and unbelievable cream sauce. YUMMY It only got better as I was eating it because the cream sauce was mixing with the rice and beans. The Owner is always there to make sure the food comes out hot and fresh, but don't tell anyone how nice Cinco De Mayo is in WGV, don't want it to get too crowded I will say one thing I noticed that was different, the music is not as authentic as it used to be, but I love when someone is having a Birthday Party, it's just a fun place to eat. And if you have little kids, you can buy just one taco for a few bucks. read more

Cinco De Mayo - Pollo A La Crema - Mexican Near Me - Saint Augustine, Florida

The food can be hit or miss depending on what time you go. The cheese dip is watery and not my favorite. I like their homemade hot sauces & margaritas. Some of the staff are super friendly and helpful, while others are very rushed. They had a big Cinco de Mayo celebration and it was a lot of fun. read more

Great flavors! Full bar! I love this restaurant! I loved my chicken taco salad and carnitas stuffed poblano pepper. My wife's taco salad with shredded Chicken wasn't quite as tasty as my grilled Chicken. The pineapple margarita was very good too read more

Cinco De Mayo - Carnitas Poblano - Mexican Near Me - Saint Augustine, Florida

See all

Well I haven't been back to Cinco De Mayo in a year, hoping it had gotten better. Well it didn't, it worse. I ordered carne asada last night take out and it ranks up there with the top 5 worst Mexican dinners I have ever had. When I moved here 6+ years ago I was so happy to see that restaurant near my neighborhood. But over the past couple of years their food has become increasingly worse. Toughest steak that couldn't be cut with knife, the chips were stale and tasted like old grease, they tried to give me fries instead of rice, the steak was smothered in refried beans and onions, then I got brown lettuce with a teaspoon of guacamole. Horrible meal! Taco Bell is much better. I'm totally done with that place. read more

The margaritas are potent! And yummy! Overall, everything was just what you would expect from strip plaza Mexican food. Everything we got was delicious. Fajitas, queso, burritos - all yummy. read more

This place used to be just decent but as of late the quality is absolutely terrible. Watery salsa that tastes like tomato water. Fajitas that come with stale shells and mostly veggies. The rice and beans were very bland. The food in general lacked flavor. Do yourself a favor and avoid at all cost. read more

It was loud inside so we opted to sit outside, but there wasn't any privacy and we were very close to parked cars. It felt as though we were eating in the parking lot. That was ok though. The hostess and waiter were nice, so that was a plus. However, the waiter forgot to bring the sour cream I ordered (extra charge). I It was charged to me, and when I told the waiter I never received it, he took the charge off the bill. I think the sour cream should be included in a taco dinner set up instead of having to pay extra for it. Our Food was brought out hot. We both ordered the two taco dinner. The tacos were tasty but not out of this world. I ordered a new drink that was on the menu, but the bartender was unsure how to make it. read more

Brutally bad food. The worst "Mexican food" I've ever had. We live 5 minutes away and would love for this place to be decent. Btw, Please don't believe any of the positive reviews of this place. They have to be plants. STAY AWAY. read more

My Chili Relleno was awful. The service was less than mediocre. That was our first time there but we will not go back

The food is less than average. I wouldn't recommend eating here. The restaurant needs to be revamped as a lot of the seats are ripped/tattered. Wasn't too busy while we were there for lunch but the service was still slow. Floor was dirty from prior business. read more

Let's start with....it is not Mexican food!! The food was awful! Ordered shredded Beef....got ground beef, asked for crispy tacos, got hard shells from a box that fell apart before I could even eat them. Rice is under cooked and the chips didn't have a grain of salt. I could have gotten more flavorful "Mexican" food at Taco Bell!! Service was ehhhh....and the place was sooooo dirty! They were washing bar glasses and setting them to dry on a dry pad with dirty glasses. Do not recommend!!!!!!! read more

This isn't the greatest Mexican food around. I was craving tacos and should have stopped at a taco truck. The restaurant is very clean and the staff is very friendly. The food is sort of bland and not much flavor. Plus they serve Pepsi which basically is the final nail in the box for me. Someone else may appreciate this place more than me. read more

Great food. Great service. The quantity of the food great. We went to a Thursday night around 6:30pm and most of the drinks were out. I'm thinking it was because of happy hour 4-7pm. It's a nice local Mexican restaurant. Ambience is nice, but it was extremely loud with babies crying. We had fun anyways. read more

Cinco De Mayo - Carne asada - Mexican Near Me - Saint Augustine, Florida

See all

I've never written a Yelp review before but I had to for this. Me and my brother are new to town and wanted to try this place. The food was so disgusting. My brother only took 2 bites before pushing away his food. I even took one bite of my food and spit it out. No flavor, and tasted terrible. Our service wasn't the best either. Waitress barely came to our table. We both didn't touch our food after the first initial bites and immediately asked for the check. First time and LAST time we will ever be back. Avoid this place if you don't want a stomach ache on the ride home as well. read more

Came here on a weds night about 1900, was seated very quickly. Waitress came over quickly and gave us our chips And salsa, which is is my weakness, they were very generous in refilling the bowl prob one to many times lol. Drinks i ordered a frozen margarita my co worker had a margarita on the rocks, mine came out in the fancy glass and hers in a what i call a "water" plastic cup. I figured it was because she looked like a child and they were scared if someone came in they would know she was drinking lol jk! She ended asking them to put it in a tradition margarita glass which they did( presentation is everything) Now on to the food! I had the combo plate enchilada and chulpa it was so good. My coworker had the steak carne a la tampiqena which she said was good but could've used a bit more flavor. Again I must say the margaritas were on point which made everything else so much better! So I do recommend this restaurant! read more

See all

Best Mexican food we have found outside of San Diego. The biggest adjustment moving from California to Florida is that it is almost impossible to find authentic Mexican food here. Search no more! The Carnitas here are incredible. They are even more flavorful than our favorite restaurant in San Diego. We had Alan as a server and he was awesome!! The drinks may seem a little weak so you might want to add a double shot. One of the most important things you need to know here is that they have high-quality tequilas including Cabo Wabo, Don Julio etc. The guacamole is as authentic as it is in California and even Baja California which is Mexico. read more

Cinco De Mayo - Cover of Menu - Mexican Near Me - Saint Augustine, Florida

See all

We've been here a few times and the food is always good. However my most recent experience was pretty awful. Our server, Joe was too busy talking with other staff to refill our drinks. At one point I waved down the hostess he was talking too but they continued to chat. He checked in on us once after we got our food and when we were finished he asked if we were good. I got a to go drink since I had waited so long for a refill and just asked for our check. Pay more attention to your customers and don't leave them at the table while you chit chat with the hosts. read more

Walked in, very dirty and horrible service immediately. Tables that came after us received service first. When I say our food was done in less than 5 minutes, I am not exaggerating. Food came to us before chips and salsa and drinks. The kids meal came out cold, ordered a chicken quesadilla but it was just a taco with cold, dry, flavorless chicken in it. The bean burritos were cold and smothered in very what I assume to be weird tasting queso sauce. My birria came out soggy and I could see that fat pieces in the tacos. AWFUL EXPERIENCE. read more

I won't be returning. Prices are now outrageous, new menu which has eliminated the combo dinners. Per management, house margaritas only come in one size which is a very small cocktail glass. They don't honor the happy hour prices that are plastered on the windows. Staff says they are old prices. read more

Cinco De Mayo - Mexican Near Me - Saint Augustine, Florida

Conveniently located near a Publix and many other shops, this restaurant is a go to for the locals. The food is plenty and tasty too. The cheese enchiladas are filled with white cheese and not yellow. 3 of us ate for less than $25.00. Quick and friendly food service in a clean restaurant. read more

Cinco De Mayo - Two beef enchiladas with queso on top - Mexican Near Me - Saint Augustine, Florida

Where do I start. This place is horrible!!!!! First time dining and will be the last for sure. Ordered Nachos. Came with so-called cheese at bottom. Tasted horrible. Asked another worker to see the Server (did not come around till about 10 minutes later. Told him about and didn't care. Asked to speak with Manager who also didn't care. Had to ask first more chips which arrived with no more sauce. Manager has such an attitude that it is almost the worst place to ever dine. You can tell that workers are not trained. Ask the Host how she likes working for this place? Yes, she does not like it! Bottom line, this place is horrible and will not recommend to anyone!!!! Can only imagine if the food is horrible and service is horrible, what is the state of health with the kitchen ...? Perhaps the Health Department should stop by. read more

Firstly we have tried this place numerous times since moving to the neighborhood. And every time we are so underwhelmed. The service is sub-par. It's as tho no one is even trying. They are not speedy with greeting us at our table and we got there for an early dinner. So i think there was only a couple other tables. We ordered our food. Server had little to no personality. And then they brought out our food. The balding man with a short beard set the food down. He must really hate his job because he looks so angry at every single table he delivers food to. Such a bad experience. Maybe if everyone who worked there actually put in a little effort, including the cooks....my cheese enchilada was not even cooked all the way through. This place might stand a Chance. The food is not tasty. It's not plated nicely and it's giving Mexican food a bad name. We will not be back. read more

Lousy. Not clean. Poor quality food. Tacos arrived cold. Quesadillas arrived soggy and doughy. One of our party had a food allergy and given inaccurate information on prep. Restrooms we're filthy. Floors were slippery from not being cleaned well. Service was very slow and inattentive. If you are looking for Mexican food, look elsewhere. Would not recommend. read more

Cinco De Mayo - Picture of floors under our table. - Mexican Near Me - Saint Augustine, Florida

i love our regular servers they always know what we like and what sides we get. it has a great vibe as well. the decor is colorful and vibrant read more