I went to Cedar Performance for over two years. In the beginning, Matt was friendly and helpful. He influenced me to buy a number of performance parts for my car. "Now you just need this..." and "Now you just need that and it'll work better" and eventually over time, my car got to the point where few people in town could work on it and I became dependent on him as a mechanic and tuner. Over time, it started taking him longer and longer to finish work on my car when I would bring it to him, especially if I paid him up front, to the point where it was in his shop for weeks, sometimes months at a time. I noticed other people were complaining about that as well. He even mentioned to me once that there was talk of him being sued for this. It was certainly the case for me that my car was there for very long periods at a time.
My motor failed, and had to be replaced. My original thought was to buy one from a company, but Matt said he could do it and quicker. It took around 8 months for him to build the motor and get it in my car. Unfortunately, I made the mistake of paying him "up-front" for almost everything. Matt became more and more rude and unprofessional to me over time, often making comments such as he was "sick of my car". I'm attaching some text messages he sent me. To me, this behavior was unacceptable. When I picked it up, however, it had issues and was not running right. I asked him if, this time, he could let me know when I could drop it off on a day he would actually be able to work on it, as opposed it sitting around the shop while he worked on "higher paying jobs" as he put it to me at one point. After dropping it off, it was there almost two months. When I picked it up, it still had many of the the same issues.
At this point, I had enough. I searched around for a place I could take my car, and finally found a great place. After taking my business elsewhere, it was revealed that Matt's work was sub-par. For example, the air filter was literally half way off the intake pipe (see attached air filter photo). There were cables laid on top of the engine. The catch can wasn't even hooked up, and a few other things too. We also found out that the spark plugs were bad, something I asked him to check when he was trying to figure out why my car was missing, at which point he became insulted that I even asked such a basic question. Those spark plugs are why the motor was missing. Photos do not lie, as to two other mechanics who witnessed and can back up what is in the phots below; one of them was an air filter not even hooked up all the way, cables laying across the motor, large plastic pieces not even connected and simply unattached on top of the engine etc. He claimed my car made good power on his dyno and didn't miss however that is simply not true at all, as proven by the spark plugs pulled by the other shop right after taking it to them.
Matt once made the comment "Unfortunately the n54 engine has a host of natural issues" and my car was "plagued" with them. This simply is not the case - the reality is, he didn't even check basic mechanic issue such as spark plugs, and whether he installed port injection correctly and literally spent weeks trying to figure out why my car was missing and going into limp mode. However, another shop was able to quickly resolve these issues within a few hours.
The ONLY reason I stopped taking my car to Matt and Cedar Performance, is due to the very long wait times (two mechanics told me someone came to them after having their cat at Matts for AN ENTIRE YEAR); any claims by Matt of personal problems on my end are simply lies and completely untrue.
I do not recommend Cedar Performance, based not only on what, in my experience, was poor quality work, but also very long times that mine and other customers cars were in his shop as he worked on other cars and I waited and waited patiently. I won't be returning to that shop, and won't recommend anyone else go there either. read more