Casey's (Huntington, Bluffton, Decatur, Waterloo, etc.) - for gas station pizza
I confess that Casey's is the only gas station pizza I have ever eaten. I really avoid prepared food at gas stations. However...I tried Casey's pizza (including breakfast pizza) and really liked their offering. Note: I think most Casey's do not have a place to sit down and eat the pizza - home or to your car you go.
The picture has a slice of "jumbo" pepperoni and sausage pizza. I paid $3 per slice with my Casey's membership. It's probably $4+ without the card. At $3 a slice...that's $24 for a whole pizza, perhaps not a good value.
Casey's crust is on the thin side of hand tossed. It is soft with a slightly crunchy outside. Slightly brown bottom. Has a flour taste - no seasoning, butter or oil flavors added.
The sauce has a mild tomato flavor. Not sweet nor thick. It is a bit difficult to detect as they don't use a lot of sauce.
There seems to be an appropriate amount of meat on the two slices. The meat comes off a bit greasy - in case you don't like that. It also doesn't have a strong/forward meat or spicy flavor - just kinda there like most "plain" pizzas. I personally like the flavor that the meat "sauces" add. The pizza is thick with mozzarella cheese. In fact you could say that the mozzarella dominates the taste - cheese lovers will like!
I've been to several different Casey's across Indiana. The pizza has a very consistent taste.
Cold Pizza Test - sorry, it didn't make it out of the parking lot. read more