Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Goodfella's Pizza

    4.6 (20 reviews)
    ModerateItalian, Pizza
    Closed 11:00 am - 8:00 pm

    Goodfella's Pizza Photos

    GOODFELLA'S PIZZA ATMOSPHERE

    What's the vibe?
    Quiet
    Outdoor seating
    Dogs allowed
    Good for groups

    You might also consider

    More like Goodfella's Pizza

    Recommended Reviews - Goodfella's Pizza

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    Reviews With Photos

    Just as classy as this girl.. Goodfellas are "GOOD FELLAS!" :)
    Trever B.

    Goodfellas will be to your house/tiny-apartment, or whatever you got in the allotted time and it pretty good. got a real thick bistro type smell and taste to it. i will eat there now and then for sure. And the service always speedy NICE!

    18" hand tossed pepperoni, mushroom, onion.
    Nicole K.

    I'm going to be honest, after reading the previous bad reviews and noting that the parking lot was empty on a Sunday evening we almost chose a different dining option. These two things that led me to believe we were in for sub-par pizza. But with two small starving kids we decided to forge ahead. I am so glad we did. Wow. This pizza was great. We ordered breadsticks (hot and buttery), a small pizza with no sauce for our picky child, and an 18" hand tossed pepperoni, mushroom and onion. The crust was soft and tasty on its own plus great sauce and plenty of toppings. It was even good microwaved for breakfast (shhh...) the next morning. I can't speak for the others who were unhappy with their experience but, to me, Goodfellas lived up to the hype I always hear from Monte "The Music Man" Sieberns. My only suggestions: music in the dining area and real utensils for people that like to eat the middle pizza pieces with a fork.

    The Don

    See all

    2 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 2
    Love this 1
    Oh no 0

    7 months ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    4 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 1
    Love this 1
    Oh no 0
    Photo of Lyn K.
    0
    15
    0

    1 year ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    3 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    3 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 1
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0
    Photo of Nicole K.
    40
    42
    194

    7 years ago

    Helpful 3
    Thanks 1
    Love this 3
    Oh no 0

    2 years ago

    Awesome customer service. Always great food. We love coming here for something a little different

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0
    Photo of Brooke V.
    0
    70
    220

    6 years ago

    Helpful 2
    Thanks 1
    Love this 1
    Oh no 0

    9 years ago

    Helpful 3
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    7 years ago

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    4 years ago

    Simply put, the best pizza ever! Delivery service was speedy and the people are wonderful.

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 1
    Love this 1
    Oh no 0

    7 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 1
    Oh no 0

    11 years ago

    Helpful 2
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    8 years ago

    I absolutely love Goodfella's pizza. They are very generous with toppings and cheese. Yum!

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    9 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    7 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    7 years ago

    After traveling all day didn't feel like cooking. The best Pizza in town! We ordered the all meat and it was loaded.

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    12 years ago

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    11 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    Ask the Community - Goodfella's Pizza

    Is bone in wings bread?

    The bone in wings are similar to chicken nuggets.. but are baked and not fried

    View All 2 Questions

    You might also consider

    Verify this business for free

    Get access to customer & competitor insights.

    Verify this business

    Paynes Restaurant - Fish & Chips

    Paynes Restaurant

    4.5(522 reviews)
    26.9 mi
    $$

    For years I have wanted to try Payne's since I have driven by the sign on the interstate so many…read moretimes. So glad I finally did. The restaurant was a lot more kitschy than I was expecting, which I loved. Our waitress had a wonderful energy. She was very knowledgeable about the menu. The menu had several unique items. I ordered a Scottish soda called IRN BRU. I love trying food and drinks from around the world. It tasted like an Orange Crush soda. Our waitress said they were known for their Cauliflower soup. It was cold outside so soup sounded perfect. I also got a pepper jack grilled cheese. The soup came in a huge bowl. The combo of the soup and grilled cheese was very filling. My friends ordered the sticky pudding. I had a bite and it was delicious. I cant believe it's taken me so long to eat here. I throughly enjoyed it and cant wait for my next road trip.

    On our drives from Carmel to Michigan this wonderful, amazing, restaurant makes our long journey so…read moremuch easier. We love Payne's and have told everyone about it. In fact it is my favorite restaurant of all time. Sunday we stopped again. I had the British chicken curry and the fatoush. It was amazing as usual. That fatoush is so refreshing! My wife had the pork chop which comes with these amazing mashed potatoes with mustard seasoning that will blow your mind. She can never finish because it's so much food, which is OK with me because I help her out some. My favorite way to eat this is to mix a little mashed potato, mustard and pork chop together into one delicious bite. We were too full for dessert, but the times that we had the dessert here were spectacular as well. Thank you to all the people that work at Paynes, please don't change anything, you are the best!

    Photos
    Paynes Restaurant - Whimsical Stonehenge

    Whimsical Stonehenge

    Paynes Restaurant - Toffee Sticky Pudding

    Toffee Sticky Pudding

    Paynes Restaurant

    See all

    Catello's Italian Art Cuisine - Pasta

    Catello's Italian Art Cuisine

    4.5(190 reviews)
    55.5 mi
    $$

    As I was coming home from Ft Wayne I was detoured through Pendleton…read more I remembered I had an Italian place marked on my bucket list on Yelp- WOW- honestly this was the best Italian meal I have had in Indy! It is worth the drive!!! All pastas are made fresh. The staff was so friendly and accommodating! They have a piano player as well...what a treat! I sat in the back corner and took it all in! The food was outstanding, I ordered Linguine Frutti di Mare- homemade linguine ( delicious) served with clams, mussels, scallops? Shrimp, cherry tomatoes, evoo, garluc, parsley cooked in a white wine sauce!!! As you can see I absolutely hated it... lol! I has an expression and lava cake for dessert. The lava cake was a little overcooked- that is the only complaint.... Other than the lady sitting across the table from me that talked loud enough for the whole restaurant to hear her conversation. I wish people would be more observant and realize they don't have to talk so loud when they're sitting at their table it made it difficult to hear the piano player and it went from a relaxing stress free feeling to an annoyance. I was so happy when her food arrived. This place is very special. It's very small. I got in because it was very early in the evening. I believe their doors open at 5 o'clock. I would highly recommend reservations, but if you have a special occasion that you're celebrating, and it appeared that several people did this is worth the drive!

    Ambience and service superb. Food not so much…read more Not a lot of choices and all very rich.

    Photos
    Catello's Italian Art Cuisine
    Catello's Italian Art Cuisine - Rita's Ragu

    Rita's Ragu

    Catello's Italian Art Cuisine

    See all

    Goodfella's Pizza - italian - Updated May 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...