Pizza is great, along with the delivery people. Could use better phone etiquette but overall great staff!

By a mile the greatest pizza place I've ever eaten that my entire life. This pizza was so good that it makes me addicted. I eat at Michael's Pizza every single day now because of how amazing the pizza and breadsticks are. Ever since those bombs over at brunos disappointed me, I started coming here. The workers are so nice and the service is so excellent. Other pizza places should take notes and try to be exactly like Michael's. read more

Breadsticks, garlic cheese bread, and bacon cheese fries are AMAZING. This is about the only place i order from every couple days, and it works out because my dad wants one of their pizzas almost every night. 10/10 my favorite local pizza joint. read more

This pizza rates right up there with Bruno's, in my opinion. The crust is perfect thickness, spices are great, and it's just a great pizza.

Love the pizza! Very tasty and cheesy. Has great flavor and my family likes the hot wings. I didn't care for the bread sticks and sauce, but others do. read more

Went to Michaels Pizza last night with my family. It's a small pizza place with great food and a nice menu. I had a sub and thought it was delicious while everyone else in my family also enjoyed their meals. We've been coming here for several years and would recommend it to anyone whos hungry or just driving through! read more

As a small business owner, I avoid writing negative reviews on sites like these. However, after my awful experience at Michael's and my unsucceful attempt to reason with the management, I felt like I had no other recourse. So here goes... I chose Michaels because all of the great reviews I read online. I'm not exaggerating when I say it was the worst pizza I've ever bought. The employees also seemed indifferent to us; failing to greet my sister and I when we entered and neglecting to thank us before we left. On the way to the car I looked at the pizza and commented that it looked horrible. We later ate one small corner piece and confirmed that it was. We contemplated whether we should call and complain or just accept that we made a bad decision. My sister did call and asked if we could return it, to which an employee said we could. I assumed that meant we could return it for a full refund. I drove back and walked in with 99.99% of the pizza in hand. The employee saw me and fetched the owner. The owner (Mike) came out and was immediately combative with me. He said it was "craziest thing he ever heard" and asked what was wrong with the pizza. I told him it tasted bad and we were just dissatisfied. I told him we called and were told we could return it and I just wanted my money back. He begrudgingly walked to his register and told me he would only return half my money. I told him that was not acceptable and I expected a full refund. He replied "this isn't Walmart" and alluded to the "buyer beware" policy. He was hostile and unreasonable. I told him I'd rather avoid writing a bad review and I would prefer the refund that I was promised on the phone. He then told me that he didn't care If I wrote a bad review. He said he's been there for fifteen years and bad reviews don't affect him at all. I became agitated and tossed the pizza on the counter. I told him to keep his crappy, over-priced pizza. He then accused me of "throwing the pizza at him". He said he could have me arrested for assault. He said he had video evidence to prove it. I told him I didn't "throw the pizza at him" and I encouraged him to call the police. I waited in my car for the police to arrive. While we waited, my more cool-headed sister also went in and tried to talk to him. She said he was a total jerk to her too. The police came. They were nice and took statements from both of us. I then left and went to Papa Johns. I guess they weren't very convinced or compelled by his footage of my alleged assault on him. My sister and I are professional people. She is a teacher and I am a fellow restaurant owner in another state. That is why I am uneasy about posting this review. But If my customers ever complain about their food or service in my restaurant I make every effort to satisfy their grievance. I travel through this area a lot and try to support local restaurants whenever possible. I will not make the mistake of going to Michael's Pizza again. I could've overlooked the sub-standard food, apathetic service, dirty environment, and expensive prices without writing a negative review but the rude, irrational and hostile behavior of the owner and his disregard for customer service are indefensible. I wish I could give them 3 negative stars. read more

Great pizzas! Who returns a pizza partially eaten and asks for their money back?!?! Lol! Real professionals. (Sarcasm) I think you should have stuck to not writing reviews. You make yourself sound ridiculous. I would assume that the owner chose not to have you arrested but it's your story. Smh read more

Great Pizza, very good customer service. Pizza seems a lot more real and less greasy then Bruno's! Definitely will come back

I've always loved Michael's Pizza. I lived North of town, and it is delicious, convenient, and always friendly service. So many opinions, for whatever you're feeling. read more

I have a card that has special offers from different business's in Logansport. The card is good until 3/31/18. Michael's has a bogo lg. pizza on the card. I called tonight 3/19/18 to get the deal and was told they quit doing the deal as of last night. You pay for a card that has these deals on them, so the store owners should honor them. I've never had a problem using them anywhere else. I will not be going back to Michael's Pizza. I just think that is bad business. Bruno's also has an offer on this same card and they've honored it every time I've used it. Guess where I'm going tonight?? read more

LOVE this pizza! My favorite place in Logansport by far. Highly recommend the spicy ground pepperoni! Reasonably priced and friendly service. We are definitely regulars! read more